Jean-Pierre Bonin

The Experience of Seclusion and Restraint in Psychiatric Settings: Perspectives of Patients

Many studies report that the use of seclusion and restraint (SR) is experienced negatively by patients who experience feelings of shame, helplessness, and humiliation, and may relive previous trauma events. Since 2000, in Québec, exceptional measures like SR have been framed by a protocol. This protocol provides health care teams with guidelines for relieving, containing, and reducing the suffering caused by SR. We have no knowledge, however, about the views of patients regarding application of the protocol. This study aims to understand the perception of patients regarding application of the SR protocol. For this purpose, a questionnaire was presented to patients (n = 50) who experienced an episode of SR in a psychiatric hospital in Canada. Results show that patients had a nuanced perception of SR: Some felt that SR was a helpful measure, while others felt that SR was not a helpful measure. Patients tended to agree with statements related to the comfort and safety of seclusion rooms and the meeting of their physical needs. Regarding support, they suggested relational, drug, and environmental interventions to prevent seclusion. Finally, nearly all patients perceived that the health care team did not follow-up with the patients after the experience; such follow-up is essential for reconstructing a sometimes confusing event.

Contribution of the psychosocial work environment to psychological distress among health care professionals before and during a major organizational change.

The aim of this study was to investigate the relationships between 4 dimensions of the psychosocial work environment (psychological demands, decision latitude, social support, and effort-reward) among health care professionals as well as their psychological distress during a reorganization process. A correlational descriptive design was used for this quantitative study. A total of 159 health care professionals completed the questionnaire at T1, and 141 at T2. First, before the work reorganization, effort-reward imbalance was the sole variable of the psychological work environment that significantly predicted psychological distress. Second, the high overall level of psychological distress increased during the process of organizational change (from T1 to T2). Finally, effort-reward imbalance, high psychological demands, and low decision latitude were all significant predictors of psychological distress at T2, during the organizational change. In conclusion, to reduce the expected negative outcomes of restructuring on health care practitioners, managers could increase the number of opportunities for rewards, carefully explain the demands, and clarify the tasks to be performed by each of the employees to reduce their psychological burden and increase their perceptions of autonomy.

Empirical Verification of a Theoretical Model Derived From the Roy Adaptation Model: Findings From Five Studies

This article presents a theoretical model derived from the Roy adaptation model and the findings of an empirical verification of this model from five studies. Four groups of subjects were included in the studies: informal caregivers of demented relatives at home, informal caregivers of psychiatrically ill relatives at home, professional caregivers of elderly institutionalized patients, and aged spouses in the community. In at least three studies, a number of theoretical propositions derived from the Roy adaptation model were supported using LISREL VIII, thus adding credence to some tenets of Roys model. Particularly, the focal stimulus of perceived stress, the contextual stimulus of conflicts in the exchange of social support, and one component of the coping mechanisms (the passive/avoidance coping strategies) were positively linked directly or indirectly with psychological distress, which is an indicator of adaptation in the self-concept mode. Given their importance, these elements should be considered in the development of a middle-range theory of psychological adaptation derived from the Roy adaptation model.

Families' and Decision Makers' Experiences With Mental Health Care Reform: The Challenge of Collaboration

Family-driven collaboration is fundamental to developing a new model of health care and eliminating fragmented services in mental health. The province of Québec (Canada) recently undertook major transformations of its mental health care system. These transformations represent an opportunity to improve collaboration between families and health care practitioners and to understand which factors facilitate this collaboration. This article describes how families and decision makers perceive collaboration in the context of a major transformation of mental health services and identifies the factors that facilitate and hinder family collaboration.

Health and Mental Health Care Utilization by Clients of Resources for Homeless Persons in Quebec City and Montreal, Canada: A 5-Year Follow-Up Study

The objective of this cohort study is to describe the service utilization by clients of homeless resources in Quebec and Montreal (Canada) over a 5-year period. Participants (N = 426) were recruited from a survey conducted in 1999 about clients’ utilization of resources intended for homeless people in Montreal and Quebec. Data analyzed in this study were also drawn from three administrative databanks managed by the Quebec health care system. Results revealed that: (1) in general, mental health services are less used than physical health services; (2) generally, women, older persons, nonhomeless persons, and persons with mental health problems utilized proportionately more health services; and (3) participants involved in this study tend to continue using services over years in a system where health services are free. These findings are discussed in terms of long-term service utilization by clients of homeless resources.

Acute Ischemic Sinus Node Dysfunctions in Dogs

The effects of the occlusion of the two main atrial arteries irrigating the sinus node on sinus rhythm and postpacing sinus recovery were studied in 12 anesthetized dogs. Records of spontaneous rhythm and of postpacing sinus recovery were taken at control and hourly for 6 hours after the occlusion. The spontaneous cycle length (AA interval) was 335 ± 11 ms at control and 416 ± 17 ms (mean ± SE) (p < 0.005) one hour after the occlusion. It remained nearly unchanged during the following 5 hours of observation. The occlusion also shortened atrioventricular conduction time [AV interval] and reduced P‐wave amplitude in EGG lead II in 9 of these dogs. While the control postpacing sinus recovery time was 397 ± 13 ms, the 3‐hour value was 715 ± 165 ms. This prolongation persisted during the first four postocclusion hours but was Jess marked during the last two hours of observation. Moreover, the postpacing mode of return of the AA intervals to their prepacing value (sinus recovery pattern) became characteristically slow and progressive after occlusion, complete post‐pacing recovery often occurring only after 100 or more beats. Sequences of escape atrial and/or AV functional rhythms were frequently seen during this recovery. Atrial extrasystoles and short sequences of atrial tachycardias were observed in most dogs after occlusion. Conversely, none of these changes occurred during a 6‐hour experimental time in 5 control dogs in which the same protocol, occlusion excepted, was repeated. These observations show that the sinus node function in the dog is consistently affected by impairing its blood supply. Ischemic dysfunctions include sinus slowing, pacemaker shift, prolonged sinus recovery time, delayed post‐pacing recovery and supraventricular tachyarrhythmias.

Attempted suicide among students and young adults in Montreal, Quebec, Canada: a retrospective cross-sectional study of hospitalized and nonhospitalized suicide attempts based on chart review

OBJECTIVE We conducted a chart review to identify postsecondary students and nonstudents in the same age range who presented to the emergency department following a suicide attempt to (1) compare demographic characteristics and suicide risk factors and (2) determine factors associated with more serious attempts requiring hospitalizations. METHOD The study was conducted in 1 tertiary trauma hospital and 1 community hospital affiliated with McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, between January 1, 2009, and March 31, 2010. Charts of patients with potential suicide attempts were identified from medical records using ICD-10 codes that indicated traumatic injury, intentional self-harm, poisoning, and psychiatric or perception/cognition disorders and from the emergency department triage file using keywords that indicated suicidality or self-harm at presentation. RESULTS In multivariable logistic regression models (odds ratio, 95% CI), students were younger (per 5-year increase: 0.22, 0.12-0.41), less likely to be born in Canada (0.17, 0.06-0.44), and more likely to use less violent methods (laceration, poisoning, other, multiple methods) versus more violent methods (collision, jump, fire burns, firearm, hanging) in their attempt. Fewer students had a history of substance abuse (0.12, 0.02-0.94) but were not different from nonstudents on history of other mental disorders. Less students attempted suicide in the winter/spring (January-April) versus fall (September-December) semester (0.32, 0.11-0.91). Students who attempted suicide were more likely to have family/social support. Those who attempted suicide in the previous year were more likely to require hospitalization for their current suicide attempt. CONCLUSIONS Knowledge of specific factors associated with suicide attempts in young people can help inform and guide suicide prevention efforts in both academic and community settings. Specific to the findings of this study regarding the method of suicide attempt used, for example, limiting access to dangerous substances or large quantities of medications may help prevent or reduce suicide attempts in this population.

Relevance of a subjective quality of life questionnaire for long-term homeless persons with schizophrenia.

BackgroundIncreasing numbers of programs are addressing the specific needs of homeless people with schizophrenia in terms of access to housing, healthcare, basic human rights and other domains. Although quality of life scales are being used to evaluate such programs, few instruments have been validated for people with schizophrenia and none for people with schizophrenia who experience major social problems such as homelessness. The aim of the present study was to validate the French version of the S-QoL a self-administered, subjective quality of life questionnaire specific to schizophrenia for people with schizophrenia who are homeless.MethodsIn a two-step process, the S-QoL was first administered to two independent convenience samples of long-term homeless people with schizophrenia in Marseille, France. The objective of the first step was to analyse the psychometric properties of the S-QoL. The objective of the second step was to examine, through qualitative interviews with members of the population in question, the relevance and acceptability of the principle quality of life indicators used in the S-QoL instrument.ResultsAlthough the psychometric characteristics of the S-QoL were found to be globally satisfactory, from the point of view of the people being interviewed, acceptability was poor. Respondents frequently interrupted participation complaining that questionnaire items did not take into account the specific context of life on the streets.ConclusionsLess intrusive questions, more readily understandable vocabulary and greater relevance to subjects’ living conditions are needed to improve the S-QoL questionnaire for this population. A modular questionnaire with context specific sections or specific quality of life instruments for socially excluded populations may well be the way forward.

Correlates of Attempted Suicide from the Emergency Room of 2 General Hospitals in Montreal, Canada

Introduction: The epidemiology of attempted suicide has not been well characterized because of lack of national data or an International Classification of Diseases (ICD) code for suicide attempts. We conducted a retrospective chart review in 2 adult general hospitals (tertiary and community) in Montreal, Canada, in 2009-2010 to 1) describe the characteristics of men and women who presented to the emergency department (ED) and/or were hospitalized following a suicide attempt, 2) identify factors associated with attempts requiring hospitalizations, and 3) validate the use of International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision (ICD-10) codes for “intentional self-harm” as a method to detect suicide attempts from hospital abstract summary records. Method: All potential suicide attempts were identified from hospital abstract summary records and ED nursing triage file using ICD-10 codes and keywords suggestive of suicide attempts. All identified charts were examined, and those with confirmed suicide attempts were fully reviewed. Results: Of the 5746 identified charts, 369 were fully reviewed. Of these, 176 were for suicide attempters treated in the ED and 193 for hospitalized attempters, of whom 46% had an ICD-10 code for intentional self-harm. Poisoning (46%) was the most frequent method of suicide used. Half of attempters were younger than 34 years, 53% were female, and 75% had a history of mental disorders. Conclusion: About half of individuals who seek medical care for attempted suicide are admitted to hospital. About half of attempters use poisoning as a method of suicide, and a quarter do not have a history of mental disorders. Intentional self-harm codes capture only about half of hospitalized attempters.

When patients train doctors: feasibility and acceptability of patient partnership to improve primary care providers' awareness of communication barriers in family medicine for persons with serious mental illness

Introduction: Excess mortality from physical chronic disease in patients with serious mental illness (SMI) is such that their life expectancy could be lessened by up to 20 years. This paper reports the results of a pilot study aimed at raising awareness among Primary Care Providers (PCPs) about communication barriers that stand in the way of the better integration of mental and physical health promotion and integration in Primary Care. Methods: We developed a small group learning script of medical training to be delivered by a health promotion nurse and a patient to address the diagnostic overshadowing phenomenon and positively change PCPs’ health promotion knowledge and attitudes. PCPs were asked to fill a series of questionnaires before and after the training. Results: 21 PCPs participated in the 60 minutes patient-centered training. Data shows a statistically significant change (p?.05) between baseline and follow up for 4 out of the 7 dimensions covered by the questionnaires: Health promotion capacity – Resources (p=.001), Psychological Medicine Inventory (p=.002), Efficacy of lifestyle counselling (p=.006), and Perception of skills at lifestyle counselling (p=.000). Discussion: Results suggest that it is possible to raise awareness about the diagnostic overshadowing phenomenon and change PCPs’ knowledge and attitudes by directly exposing them to the personal history of a person with SMI who acts as an auxiliary of medical education. Conclusions: Our script of medical training proved to be more effective than traditional simulation-based training, especially in terms of enhanced inter-professional collaboration. Primary Care Providers also learned that they can be supported by other professionals to whom they can refer their patients for health promotion counselling, and they learned how to better communicate from the patient who acted as an auxiliary of medical training.