Jeanne F. Rosenthal

Menstrual and reproductive factors and risk of breast cancer in Asian-Americans.

We conducted a population-based case-control study of breast cancer among Chinese-, Japanese- and Filipino-American women in Los Angeles County Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA), San Francisco-Oakland MSA and Oahu, Hawaii. One objective of the study was to quantify breast cancer risks in relation to menstrual and reproductive histories in migrant and US-born Asian-Americans and to establish whether the gradient of risk in Asian-Americans can be explained by these factors. Using a common study design and questionnaire in the three study areas, we successfully conducted in-person interviews with 597 Asian-American women diagnosed with incident, primary breast cancer during the period 1983-87 (70% of those eligible) and 966 population-based controls (75% of those eligible). Controls were matched to cases on age, ethnicity and area of residence. In the present analysis, which included 492 cases and 768 controls, we observed a statistically non-significant 4% reduction in risk of breast cancer with each year delay in onset of menstruation. Independent of age at menarche risk of breast cancer was lower (odds ratio; OR=0.77) among women with menstrual cycles greater than 29 days. Parous Asian-American women showed a significantly lower risk of breast cancer then nulliparous women (OR=0.54). An increasing number of livebirths and a decreasing age at first livebirth were both associated with a lower risk of breast cancer, although the effect of number of livebirths was no longer significant after adjustment for age at first livebirth. Women with a pregnancy (spontaneous or induced abortions) but no livebirth had a statistically non-significant increased risk (OR=1.84), but there was no evidence that one type of abortion was particularly harmful. A positive history of breastfeeding was associated with non-significantly lower risk of breast cancer (OR=.78). There are several notable differences in the menstrual and reproductive factors between Asian-Americans in this study and published data on US whites. US-born Asian Americans had an average age at menarche of 12.12 years-no older than has been found in comparable studies of US whites, but 1.4 years earlier than Asian women who migrated to the US. Asian-American women, particularly those born in the US and those who migrated before age 36, also had a later age at first birth and fewer livebirths than US whites. A slightly higher proportion of Asian-American women breastfed, compared with US whites. The duration of breastfeeding was similar in US-born Asians and US whites, but was longer in Asian migrants, especially those who migrated at a later age. Menstrual and reproductive factors in Asian-American women are consistent with their breast cancer rates being at least as high as in US whites, and they are. However, the effects of these menstrual and reproductive factors were small and the ORs for migration variables changed only slightly after adjustment for these menstrual and reproductive factors. These results suggest that the lower rates of breast cancer in Asians must be largely as a result of other environmental/lifestyle factors.

Case-control study of in situ and invasive carcinoma of the vagina

A case-control study of 41 patients with carcinoma in situ (CIS) or invasive cancer of the vagina and 97 community controls was undertaken to identify potential risk factors. Although vaginal and cervical cancers often occur as multiple primaries, only a few common risk factors prevailed. Similar to cervical cancer, low education and family income were risk factors for vaginal CIS and invasive cancer. In addition, history of genital warts was strongly related (RR = 2.9), although other sexual factors were not. Previous genital abnormalities related to subsequent cancer risk, with significant associations seen for vaginal discharge or irritation (RR = 6.1), a previous abnormal Pap smear (RR = 3.8), or an early hysterectomy (RR = 6.7). In addition, there was some evidence that vaginal trauma might be involved, with nonsignificant and independent associations relating to regular douching with preparations other than water or vinegar (RR = 2.7) and frequent washing of the genital area (RR = 2.7). Further studies are needed to determine whether our findings persist among a larger series of cases.