Jeffrey S. Iwig

H-Ras forms dimers on membrane surfaces via a protein–protein interface

Significance Ras is a key signaling molecule in living cells, and mutations in Ras are involved in 30% of human cancers. It is becoming progressively more clear that the spatial arrangement of proteins within a cell, not just their chemical structure, is an important aspect of their function. In this work, we use a series of quantitative physical techniques to map out the tendency of two Ras molecules to bind together to form a dimer on membrane surfaces. Insights from this work, as well as the technical assays developed, may help to discover new therapeutic drugs capable of modulating the errant behavior of Ras in cancer. The lipid-anchored small GTPase Ras is an important signaling node in mammalian cells. A number of observations suggest that Ras is laterally organized within the cell membrane, and this may play a regulatory role in its activation. Lipid anchors composed of palmitoyl and farnesyl moieties in H-, N-, and K-Ras are widely suspected to be responsible for guiding protein organization in membranes. Here, we report that H-Ras forms a dimer on membrane surfaces through a protein–protein binding interface. A Y64A point mutation in the switch II region, known to prevent Son of sevenless and PI3K effector interactions, abolishes dimer formation. This suggests that the switch II region, near the nucleotide binding cleft, is either part of, or allosterically coupled to, the dimer interface. By tethering H-Ras to bilayers via a membrane-miscible lipid tail, we show that dimer formation is mediated by protein interactions and does not require lipid anchor clustering. We quantitatively characterize H-Ras dimerization in supported membranes using a combination of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, photon counting histogram analysis, time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy, single-molecule tracking, and step photobleaching analysis. The 2D dimerization Kd is measured to be ∼1 × 103 molecules/µm2, and no higher-order oligomers were observed. Dimerization only occurs on the membrane surface; H-Ras is strictly monomeric at comparable densities in solution. Analysis of a number of H-Ras constructs, including key changes to the lipidation pattern of the hypervariable region, suggest that dimerization is a general property of native H-Ras on membrane surfaces.

Ras activation by SOS: Allosteric regulation by altered fluctuation dynamics

Outliers dominate signaling at cell membrane SOS enzymes act at cell membranes to activate Ras, a regulatory protein often overactive in cancer cells. Iversen et al. devised a system where they could observe the activity of individual enzymes at work. The single SOS molecules occupied stable states that varied greatly in their catalytic activity. Regulation appeared to occur by altering the time spent in active states. The overall activity of SOS was determined by just a few molecules that achieved the highest catalytic activity. The methods described should allow further detailed kinetic analysis of this and other signaling events that occur at the cell membrane — properties that it is not possible to discern from bulk biochemical measurements. Science, this issue p. 50 Single-molecule measurements reveal insights into regulation of the small GTPase Ras. Activation of the small guanosine triphosphatase H-Ras by the exchange factor Son of Sevenless (SOS) is an important hub for signal transduction. Multiple layers of regulation, through protein and membrane interactions, govern activity of SOS. We characterized the specific activity of individual SOS molecules catalyzing nucleotide exchange in H-Ras. Single-molecule kinetic traces revealed that SOS samples a broad distribution of turnover rates through stochastic fluctuations between distinct, long-lived (more than 100 seconds), functional states. The expected allosteric activation of SOS by Ras–guanosine triphosphate (GTP) was conspicuously absent in the mean rate. However, fluctuations into highly active states were modulated by Ras-GTP. This reveals a mechanism in which functional output may be determined by the dynamical spectrum of rates sampled by a small number of enzymes, rather than the ensemble average.

Structural analysis of autoinhibition in the Ras-specific exchange factor RasGRP1

RasGRP1 and SOS are Ras-specific nucleotide exchange factors that have distinct roles in lymphocyte development. RasGRP1 is important in some cancers and autoimmune diseases but, in contrast to SOS, its regulatory mechanisms are poorly understood. Activating signals lead to the membrane recruitment of RasGRP1 and Ras engagement, but it is unclear how interactions between RasGRP1 and Ras are suppressed in the absence of such signals. We present a crystal structure of a fragment of RasGRP1 in which the Ras-binding site is blocked by an interdomain linker and the membrane-interaction surface of RasGRP1 is hidden within a dimerization interface that may be stabilized by the C-terminal oligomerization domain. NMR data demonstrate that calcium binding to the regulatory module generates substantial conformational changes that are incompatible with the inactive assembly. These features allow RasGRP1 to be maintained in an inactive state that is poised for activation by calcium and membrane-localization signals. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.00813.001

One-way membrane trafficking of SOS in receptor-triggered Ras activation

SOS is a key activator of the small GTPase Ras. In cells, SOS-Ras signaling is thought to be initiated predominantly by membrane recruitment of SOS via the adaptor Grb2 and balanced by rapidly reversible Grb2-SOS binding kinetics. However, SOS has multiple protein and lipid interactions that provide linkage to the membrane. In reconstituted-membrane experiments, these Grb2-independent interactions were sufficient to retain human SOS on the membrane for many minutes, during which a single SOS molecule could processively activate thousands of Ras molecules. These observations raised questions concerning how receptors maintain control of SOS in cells and how membrane-recruited SOS is ultimately released. We addressed these questions in quantitative assays of reconstituted SOS-deficient chicken B-cell signaling systems combined with single-molecule measurements in supported membranes. These studies revealed an essentially one-way trafficking process in which membrane-recruited SOS remains trapped on the membrane and continuously activates Ras until being actively removed via endocytosis.

Monitoring the Waiting Time Sequence of Single Ras GTPase Activation Events Using Liposome Functionalized Zero-Mode Waveguides

Activation of small GTPases of the Ras superfamily by guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) is a key step in numerous cell signaling processes. Unveiling the detailed molecular mechanisms of GEF-GTPase signaling interactions is of great importance due to their central roles in cell biology, including critical disease states, and their potential as therapeutic targets. Here we present an assay to monitor individual Ras activation events catalyzed by single molecules of the GEF Son of Sevenless (SOS) in the natural membrane environment. The assay employs zero-mode waveguide (ZMW) nanostructures containing a single Ras-functionalized liposome. The ZMWs facilitate highly localized excitation of fluorophores in the vicinity of the liposome membrane, allowing direct observation of individual Ras activation events as single SOS enzymes catalyze exchange of unlabeled nucleotides bound to Ras with fluorescently labeled nucleotides from solution. The system is compatible with continuous recording of long sequences of individual enzymatic turnover events over hour-long time scales. The single turnover waiting time sequence is a molecular footprint that details the temporal characteristics of the system. Data reported here reveal long-lived activity states that correspond to well-defined conformers of SOS at the membrane. Liposome functionalized ZMWs allow for studies of nucleotide exchange reactions at single GTPase resolution, providing a platform to gauge the mechanisms of these processes.

Fixing a Hole Where the Ras Gets In

A clinically efficacious Ras inhibitor has eluded drug-discovery efforts for decades. In a paper in Nature, Zimmermann and et al. show that blocking a hole in PDEδ that normally engages the lipid tail of Ras disrupts downstream signaling, pointing to a potentially promising route to develop Ras inhibitors for cancer treatment.

A histidine pH sensor regulates activation of the Ras-specific guanine nucleotide exchange factor RasGRP1.

RasGRPs are guanine nucleotide exchange factors that are specific for Ras or Rap, and are important regulators of cellular signaling. Aberrant expression or mutation of RasGRPs results in disease. An analysis of RasGRP1 SNP variants led to the conclusion that the charge of His 212 in RasGRP1 alters signaling activity and plasma membrane recruitment, indicating that His 212 is a pH sensor that alters the balance between the inactive and active forms of RasGRP1. To understand the structural basis for this effect we compared the structure of autoinhibited RasGRP1, determined previously, to those of active RasGRP4:H-Ras and RasGRP2:Rap1b complexes. The transition from the autoinhibited to the active form of RasGRP1 involves the rearrangement of an inter-domain linker that displaces inhibitory inter-domain interactions. His 212 is located at the fulcrum of these conformational changes, and structural features in its vicinity are consistent with its function as a pH-dependent switch.

The Residence Time and Processivity Study of the Ras/Sos Interaction

Ras is a membrane-bound small GTPase protein that plays a central role in the signal transduction pathways that control cell proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis. Its deregulation is a hallmark of many cancers and developmental defects. Son of Sevenless (SOS) is a guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) enzyme that activates Ras by catalyzing the conversion of Ras from the GDP- to the GTP-bound state.SOS has two binding sites for Ras, a catalytic site and an allosteric site, which can both be occupied simultaneously by membrane-bound Ras. Previous studies have shown that binding to the allosteric site by Ras-GTP will localize SOS to the membrane and therefore stimulate the nucleotide exchange activity of the catalytic site (positive-feedback), raising the question of whether SOS is processive, capable of remaining surface bound while catalyzing the nucleotide exchange of multiple Ras. In this study we employ fluorescence microscopy on Ras functionalized supported lipid bilayers to demonstrate that the catalytic core of SOS (SOScat) is processive. In the absence of GTP, SOScat remains surface bound via Ras in a non-processive state for ∼hours. Addition of GTP triggers processive turnover of multiple Ras by surface bound SOScat. Using single molecule TIRF microscopy, the result indicates that most of the initial surface bound SOScat rapidly desorbs when GTP is added, and that most of the Ras turnover is catalyzed by a small but processive fraction of the initial SOScat population.