Jeremy H. Toyn

Discovery and Evaluation of BMS-708163, a Potent, Selective and Orally Bioavailable γ-Secretase Inhibitor

During the course of our research efforts to develop a potent and selective γ-secretase inhibitor for the treatment of Alzheimers disease, we investigated a series of carboxamide-substituted sulfonamides. Optimization based on potency, Notch/amyloid-β precursor protein selectivity, and brain efficacy after oral dosing led to the discovery of 4 (BMS-708163). Compound 4 is a potent inhibitor of γ-secretase (Aβ40 IC50 = 0.30 nM), demonstrating a 193-fold selectivity against Notch. Oral administration of 4 significantly reduced Aβ40 levels for sustained periods in brain, plasma, and cerebrospinal fluid in rats and dogs.

The Amyloid-β Rise and γ-Secretase Inhibitor Potency Depend on the Level of Substrate Expression

The amyloid-β (Aβ) peptide, which likely plays a key role in Alzheimer disease, is derived from the amyloid-β precursor protein (APP) through consecutive proteolytic cleavages by β-site APP-cleaving enzyme and γ-secretase. Unexpectedly γ-secretase inhibitors can increase the secretion of Aβ peptides under some circumstances. This “Aβ rise” phenomenon, the same inhibitor causing an increase in Aβ at low concentrations but inhibition at higher concentrations, has been widely observed. Here we show that the Aβ rise depends on the β-secretase-derived C-terminal fragment of APP (βCTF) or C99 levels with low levels causing rises. In contrast, the N-terminally truncated form of Aβ, known as “p3,” formed by α-secretase cleavage, did not exhibit a rise. In addition to the Aβ rise, low βCTF or C99 expression decreased γ-secretase inhibitor potency. This “potency shift” may be explained by the relatively high enzyme to substrate ratio under conditions of low substrate because increased concentrations of inhibitor would be necessary to affect substrate turnover. Consistent with this hypothesis, γ-secretase inhibitor radioligand occupancy studies showed that a high level of occupancy was correlated with inhibition of Aβ under conditions of low substrate expression. The Aβ rise was also observed in rat brain after dosing with the γ-secretase inhibitor BMS-299897. The Aβ rise and potency shift are therefore relevant factors in the development of γ-secretase inhibitors and can be evaluated using appropriate choices of animal and cell culture models. Hypothetical mechanisms for the Aβ rise, including the “incomplete processing” and endocytic models, are discussed.

Pharmacodynamics of Selective Inhibition of γ -Secretase by Avagacestat

A hallmark of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) pathology is the accumulation of brain amyloid β-peptide (Aβ), generated by γ-secretase-mediated cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein (APP). Therefore, γ-secretase inhibitors (GSIs) may lower brain Aβ and offer a potential new approach to treat AD. As γ-secretase also cleaves Notch proteins, GSIs can have undesirable effects due to interference with Notch signaling. Avagacestat (BMS-708163) is a GSI developed for selective inhibition of APP over Notch cleavage. Avagacestat inhibition of APP and Notch cleavage was evaluated in cell culture by measuring levels of Aβ and human Notch proteins. In rats, dogs, and humans, selectivity was evaluated by measuring plasma blood concentrations in relation to effects on cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) Aβ levels and Notch-related toxicities. Measurements of Notch-related toxicity included goblet cell metaplasia in the gut, marginal-zone depletion in the spleen, reductions in B cells, and changes in expression of the Notch-regulated hairy and enhancer of split homolog-1 from blood cells. In rats and dogs, acute administration of avagacestat robustly reduced CSF Aβ40 and Aβ42 levels similarly. Chronic administration in rats and dogs, and 28-day, single- and multiple-ascending–dose administration in healthy human subjects caused similar exposure-dependent reductions in CSF Aβ40. Consistent with the 137-fold selectivity measured in cell culture, we identified doses of avagacestat that reduce CSF Aβ levels without causing Notch-related toxicities. Our results demonstrate the selectivity of avagacestat for APP over Notch cleavage, supporting further evaluation of avagacestat for AD therapy.

P-Glycoprotein Efflux and Other Factors Limit Brain Amyloid β Reduction by β-Site Amyloid Precursor Protein-Cleaving Enzyme 1 Inhibitors in Mice

Alzheimers disease (AD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease. Amyloid β (Aβ) peptides are hypothesized to cause the initiation and progression of AD based on pathologic data from AD patients, genetic analysis of mutations that cause early onset forms of AD, and preclinical studies. Based on this hypothesis, β-site amyloid precursor protein (APP)-cleaving enzyme 1 (BACE1) inhibitors are an attractive therapeutic approach for AD because cleavage of the APP by BACE1 is required to form Aβ. In this study, three potent BACE1 inhibitors are characterized. All three inhibitors decrease Aβ formation in cultured cells with IC50 values less than 10 nM. Analysis of APP C-terminal fragments by immunoblotting and Aβ peptides by mass spectrometry showed that these inhibitors decreased Aβ by inhibiting BACE1. An assay for Aβ1–40 in mice was developed and used to show that these BACE1 inhibitors decreased plasma Aβ1–40, but not brain Aβ1–40, in wild-type mice. Because these BACE1 inhibitors were substrates for P-glycoprotein (P-gp), a member of the ATP-binding cassette superfamily of efflux transporters, these inhibitors were administered to P-gp knockout (KO) mice. These studies showed that all three BACE1 inhibitors decreased brain Aβ1–40 in P-gp KO mice, demonstrating that P-gp is a major limitation for development of BACE1 inhibitors to test the amyloid hypothesis. A comparison of plasma Aβ1–40 and brain Aβ1–40 dose responses for these three compounds revealed differences in relative ED50 values, indicating that factors other than P-gp can also contribute to poor brain activity by BACE1 inhibitors.

Signal Peptide Peptidase and γ-Secretase Share Equivalent Inhibitor Binding Pharmacology

The enzyme γ-secretase has long been considered a potential pharmaceutical target for Alzheimer disease. Presenilin (the catalytic subunit of γ-secretase) and signal peptide peptidase (SPP) are related transmembrane aspartyl proteases that cleave transmembrane substrates. SPP and γ-secretase are pharmacologically similar in that they are targeted by many of the same small molecules, including transition state analogs, non-transition state inhibitors, and amyloid β-peptide modulators. One difference between presenilin and SPP is that the proteolytic activity of presenilin functions only within a multisubunit complex, whereas SPP requires no additional protein cofactors for activity. In this study, γ-secretase inhibitor radioligands were used to evaluate SPP and γ-secretase inhibitor binding pharmacology. We found that the SPP enzyme exhibited distinct binding sites for transition state analogs, non-transition state inhibitors, and the nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug sulindac sulfide, analogous to those reported previously for γ-secretase. In the course of this study, cultured cells were found to contain an abundance of SPP binding activity, most likely contributed by several of the SPP family proteins. The number of SPP binding sites was in excess of γ-secretase binding sites, making it essential to use selective radioligands for evaluation of γ-secretase binding under these conditions. This study provides further support for the idea that SPP is a useful model of inhibitory mechanisms and structure in the SPP/presenilin protein family.

Synthesis and SAR of indole-and 7-azaindole-1,3-dicarboxamide hydroxyethylamine inhibitors of BACE-1.

Heterocyclic replacement of the isophthalamide phenyl ring in hydroxyethylamine (HEA) BACE-1 inhibitors was explored. A variety of indole-1,3-dicarboxamide HEAs exhibited potent BACE-1 enzyme inhibition, but displayed poor cellular activity. Improvements in cellular activity and aspartic protease selectivity were observed for 7-azaindole-1,3-dicarboxamide HEAs. A methylprolinol-bearing derivative (10n) demonstrated robust reductions in rat plasma Aβ levels, but did not lower rat brain Aβ due to poor central exposure. The same analog exhibited a high efflux ratio in a bidirectional Caco-2 assay and was likely a substrate of the efflux transporter P-glycoprotein. X-ray crystal structures are reported for two indole HEAs in complex with BACE-1.

Acyl guanidine inhibitors of β-secretase (BACE-1): optimization of a micromolar hit to a nanomolar lead via iterative solid- and solution-phase library synthesis.

This report describes the discovery and optimization of a BACE-1 inhibitor series containing an unusual acyl guanidine chemotype that was originally synthesized as part of a 6041-membered solid-phase library. The synthesis of multiple follow-up solid- and solution-phase libraries facilitated the optimization of the original micromolar hit into a single-digit nanomolar BACE-1 inhibitor in both radioligand binding and cell-based functional assay formats. The X-ray structure of representative inhibitors bound to BACE-1 revealed a number of key ligand:protein interactions, including a hydrogen bond between the side chain amide of flap residue Gln73 and the acyl guanidine carbonyl group, and a cation-π interaction between Arg235 and the isothiazole 4-methoxyphenyl substituent. Following subcutaneous administration in rats, an acyl guanidine inhibitor with single-digit nanomolar activity in cells afforded good plasma exposures and a dose-dependent reduction in plasma Aβ levels, but poor brain exposure was observed (likely due to Pgp-mediated efflux), and significant reductions in brain Aβ levels were not obtained.

Interpreting Alzheimer’s disease clinical trials in light of the effects on amyloid-β

The failure of several potential Alzheimer’s disease therapeutics in mid- to late-stage clinical development has provoked significant discussion regarding the validity of the amyloid hypothesis. In this review, we propose a minimum criterion of 25% for amyloid-β (Aβ) lowering to achieve clinically meaningful slowing of disease progression. This criterion is based on genetic, risk factor, clinical and preclinical studies. We then compare this minimum criterion with the degree of Aβ lowering produced by the potential therapies that have failed in clinical trials. If the proposed minimum Aβ lowering criterion is used, then the amyloid hypothesis has yet to be adequately tested in the clinic. Therefore, we believe that the amyloid hypothesis remains valid and remains to be confirmed or refuted in future clinical trials.

Soluble Aβ and cognitive function in aged F-344 rats and Tg2576 mice

Recent findings suggest that Alzheimers dementia may be mediated by soluble beta amyloid (Abeta) more than the deposits of aggregated, insoluble Abeta, and vulnerability to cognitive deficits after scopolamine challenge may help identify AD even in patients that are still pre-symptomatic. The objectives of the present experiments were to determine if vulnerability to cognitive deficits after scopolamine challenge is related to levels of soluble Abeta, and if levels of soluble Abeta are more closely related to cognitive deficits than levels of insoluble Abeta, even in aged, transgenic mice, after they have developed very high levels of insoluble Abeta. Aged F-344 rats and young mice over-expressing the Swedish mutation in the human amyloid precursor protein (APPsw; Tg2576+) had elevated levels of soluble Abeta, and were more vulnerable to scopolamine challenge in the Morris water maze (MWM), relative to young rats and Tg2576- mice; but, among individual animals, higher levels of soluble Abeta were not correlated with vulnerability to scopolamine. On the other hand, in aged Tg2576+ mice, cognitive deficits were related to levels of soluble Abeta, not insoluble Abeta, despite the fact that the levels of insoluble Abeta were thousands of times higher than the levels of soluble Abeta. The results of the present experiments suggest that vulnerability to cognitive deficits after scopolamine challenge is not related to elevated levels of soluble Abeta, but that high levels of soluble Abeta are more closely correlated with cognitive deficits than the amount insoluble Abeta, even after large amounts of aggregated, insoluble Abeta have been deposited.

Monosubstituted γ-lactam and conformationally constrained 1,3-diaminopropan-2-ol transition-state isostere inhibitors of β-secretase (BACE)

The synthesis, evaluation, and structure-activity relationships of a class of γ-lactam 1,3-diaminopropan-2-ol transition-state isostere inhibitors of BACE are discussed. Two strategies for optimizing lead compound 1a are presented. Reducing the overall size of the inhibitors resulted in the identification of γ-lactam 1i, whereas the introduction of conformational constraint on the prime-side of the inhibitor generated compounds such as the 3-hydroxypyrrolidine inhibitor 28n. The full in vivo profile of 1i in rats and 28n in Tg 2576 mice is presented.