Jesús Delgado-Calle

Genome‐wide profiling of bone reveals differentially methylated regions in osteoporosis and osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE To determine genome-wide methylation profiles of bone from patients with hip osteoarthritis (OA) and those with osteoporotic (OP) hip fractures. METHODS Trabecular bone pieces were obtained from the central part of the femoral head of 27 patients with hip fractures and 26 patients with hip OA. DNA was isolated, and methylation was explored with Illumina methylation arrays. RNA was extracted, pooled, and deep-sequenced to obtain the whole transcriptome. Differentially methylated regions were identified, and connections between genes with differentially methylated regions were explored by pathway and text-mining analyses. RESULTS After quality control, methylation of 23,367 CpG sites (13,463 genes) was analyzed. There was a genome-wide inverse relationship between methylation and gene expression in both patient groups. Comparison of OP and OA bones revealed 241 CpG sites, located in 228 genes, with significant differences in methylation (false discovery rate<0.05). Of them, 217 were less methylated in OP than in OA. The absolute methylation differences were >5% in 128 CpG sites and >10% in 45 CpG sites. The differentially methylated genes were enriched for association with bone traits in the genome-wide association study catalog. Pathway analysis and text-mining analysis with Gene Relationships Across Implicated Loci software revealed enrichment in genes participating in glycoprotein metabolism or cell differentiation, and particularly in the homeobox superfamily of transcription factors. CONCLUSION Genome-wide methylation profiling of bone samples revealed differentially methylated regions in OP and OA. These regions were enriched in genes associated with cell differentiation and skeletal embryogenesis, such as those in the homeobox superfamily, suggesting the existence of a developmental component in the predisposition to these disorders.

DNA methylation contributes to the regulation of sclerostin expression in human osteocytes

Sclerostin, encoded by the SOST gene, is a potent inhibitor of bone formation, produced by osteocytes, not by osteoblasts, but little is known about the molecular mechanisms controlling its expression. We aimed to test the hypothesis that epigenetic mechanisms, specifically DNA methylation, modulate SOST expression. We found two CpG‐rich regions in SOST: region 1, located in the proximal promoter, and region 2, around exon 1. qMSP and pyrosequencing analysis of DNA methylation showed that region 2 was largely methylated in all samples analyzed. In contrast, marked differences were observed in region 1. Whereas the CpG‐rich region 1 was hypermethylated in osteoblasts, this region was largely hypomethylated in microdissected human osteocytes. Bone lining cells showed a methylation profile between primary osteoblasts and osteocytes. Whereas SOST expression was detected at very low level or not at all by RT‐qPCR in several human osteoblastic and nonosteoblastic cell lines, and human primary osteoblasts under basal conditions, it was dramatically upregulated (up to 1300‐fold) by the demethylating agent AzadC. Experiments using reporter vectors demonstrated the functional importance of the region −581/+30 of the SOST gene, which contains the CpG‐rich region 1. In vitro methylation of this CpG‐island impaired nuclear protein binding and led to a 75 ± 12% inhibition of promoter activity. In addition, BMP‐2‐induced expression of SOST was markedly enhanced in cells demethylated by AzadC. Overall, these results strongly suggest that DNA methylation is involved in the regulation of SOST expression during osteoblast–osteocyte transition, presumably by preventing the binding of transcription factors to the proximal promoter. To our knowledge, our data provide first ever evidence of the involvement of DNA methylation in the regulation of SOST expression and may help to establish convenient experimental models for further studies of human sclerostin.

Role of DNA methylation in the regulation of the RANKL-OPG system in human bone

Osteoblasts are specialized cells that form new bone and also indirectly influence bone resorption by producing factors that modulate osteoclast differentiation. Although the methylation of CpG islands plays an important role in the regulation of gene expression, there is still scanty information about its role in human bone. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of CpG methylation on the transcriptional levels of two osteoblast-derived critical factors in the regulation of osteoclastogenesis: the receptor activator of nuclear factor NF-κB ligand (RANKL) and its soluble decoy receptor osteoprotegerin (OPG). Quantitative methylation specific PCR (qMSP) and pyrosequencing analysis in various cell types showed that the methylation of regulatory regions of these genes, in the vicinity of the transcription start sites, repressed gene transcription, whereas an active transcription was associated with low levels of methylation. In addition, treatment with the DNA demethylating agent 5-azadeoxycitidine promoted a 170-fold induction of RANKL and a 20-fold induction of OPG mRNA expression in HEK-293 cells, which showed hypermethylation of the CpG islands and barely expressed RANKL and OPG transcripts at baseline. Transcriptional levels of both genes were also explored in bone tissue samples from patients with hip fractures and hip osteoarthritis. Although RANKL transcript abundance and the RANKL:OPG transcript ratio were significantly higher in patients with fractures than in those with osteoarthritis (RANKL: 0.76 ± 0.23 vs. 0.24 ± 0.08, p = 0.012; RANKL/OPG: 7.66 ± 2.49 vs. 0.92 ± 0.21, p = 0.002), there was no evidence for differential methylation across patient groups. In conclusion, the association between DNA methylation and the repression of RANKL and OPG expression strongly suggests that methylation-dependent mechanisms influence the transcription of these genes, which play a critical role in osteoclastogenesis. However, other mechanisms appear to be involved in the increased RANKL/OPG ratio of patients with osteoporotic fractures.

Epigenetic regulation of alkaline phosphatase in human cells of the osteoblastic lineage

Epigenetic mechanisms play an important role in the tissue-specific regulation of gene expression. This study analyzed the relationship between tissue non-specific alkaline phosphatase (ALPL) gene expression and the methylation of a CpG island located in its proximal region. Gene expression was analyzed by real time RT-qPCR in primary human osteoblasts (hOBs), the osteoblastic cell line MG-63, the mammary cell line MCF-7, and bone tissue. DNA methylation was analyzed by qMSP in those cells and also in lining osteoblasts and in osteocytes obtained from human bone samples by laser-assisted capture. hOBs expressed much more ALPL mRNA than MG-63 cells (7.3±3.2 vs. 0.2±0.1 arbitrary units, respectively). hOBs showed a very weak DNA methylation (<10%), whereas MG-63 had a higher degree of methylation (58±6%). Likewise, MCF-7 cells, which scarcely expressed ALPL, had a hypermethylated CpG island. Thus, the degree of methylation in the CpG island was inversely associated with the transcriptional levels of ALPL in the studied cells. Furthermore, treatment with the DNA demethylating agent AzadC induced a 30-fold increase in ALPL expression, in MG-63 cells, accompanied by a parallel increase in alkaline phosphatase activity. However, AzadC did not affect ALPL levels in the already hypomethylated hOBs. In addition, in microdissected osteocytes, which do not express alkaline phosphatase, the CpG island was highly methylated (>90%), whereas lining osteoblasts showed an intermediate degree of methylation (58±13%). These results suggest an important role of DNA methylation in the regulation of ALPL expression through the osteoblast-osteocyte transition.

H3K4me1 marks DNA regions hypomethylated during aging in human stem and differentiated cells

In differentiated cells, aging is associated with hypermethylation of DNA regions enriched in repressive histone post-translational modifications. However, the chromatin marks associated with changes in DNA methylation in adult stem cells during lifetime are still largely unknown. Here, DNA methylation profiling of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) obtained from individuals aged 2 to 92 yr identified 18,735 hypermethylated and 45,407 hypomethylated CpG sites associated with aging. As in differentiated cells, hypermethylated sequences were enriched in chromatin repressive marks. Most importantly, hypomethylated CpG sites were strongly enriched in the active chromatin mark H3K4me1 in stem and differentiated cells, suggesting this is a cell type-independent chromatin signature of DNA hypomethylation during aging. Analysis of scedasticity showed that interindividual variability of DNA methylation increased during aging in MSCs and differentiated cells, providing a new avenue for the identification of DNA methylation changes over time. DNA methylation profiling of genetically identical individuals showed that both the tendency of DNA methylation changes and scedasticity depended on nongenetic as well as genetic factors. Our results indicate that the dynamics of DNA methylation during aging depend on a complex mixture of factors that include the DNA sequence, cell type, and chromatin context involved and that, depending on the locus, the changes can be modulated by genetic and/or external factors.

Role of BMPs in the regulation of sclerostin as revealed by an epigenetic modifier of human bone cells

Sclerostin, encoded by the SOST gene, is specifically expressed by osteocytes. However osteoblasts bear a heavily methylated SOST promoter and therefore do not express SOST. Thus, studying the regulation of human SOST is challenged by the absence of human osteocytic cell lines. Herein, we explore the feasibility of using the induction of SOST expression in osteoblasts by a demethylating agent to study the mechanisms underlying SOST transcription, and specifically, the influence of bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). Microarray analysis and quantitative PCR showed that AzadC up-regulated the expression of several BMPs, including BMP-2, BMP-4 and BMP-6, as well as several BMP downstream targets. Recombinant BMP-2 increased the transcriptional activity of the SOST promoter cloned into a reporter vector. Likewise, exposing cells transfected with the vector to AzadC also resulted in increased transcription. On the other hand, inhibition of the canonical BMP signaling blunted the effect of AzadC on SOST. These results show that the AzadC-induced demethylation of the SOST promoter in human osteoblastic cells may be a valuable tool to study the regulation of SOST expression. As a proof of concept, it allowed us to demonstrate that BMPs stimulate SOST expression by a mechanism involving BMPR1A receptors and downstream Smad-dependent pathways.

Contribution of genetic and epigenetic mechanisms to Wnt pathway activity in prevalent skeletal disorders.

We reported previously that the expression of Wnt-related genes is lower in osteoporotic hip fractures than in osteoarthritis. We aimed to confirm those results by analyzing β-catenin levels and explored potential genetic and epigenetic mechanisms involved. β-Catenin gene expression and nuclear levels were analyzed by real time PCR and confocal immunofluorescence. Increased nuclear β-catenin was found in osteoblasts isolated from patients with osteoarthritis (99 ± 4 units vs. 76 ± 12, p=0.01, n=10), without differences in gene transcription, which is consistent with a post-translational down-regulation of β-catenin and decreased Wnt pathway activity. Twenty four single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of genes showing differential expression between fractures and osteoarthritis (WNT4, WNT10A, WNT16 and SFRP1) were analyzed in DNA isolated from blood of 853 patients. The genotypic frequencies were similar in both groups of patients, with no significant differences. Methylation of Wnt pathway genes was analyzed in bone tissue samples (15 with fractures and 15 with osteoarthritis) by interrogating a CpG-based methylation array. Six genes showed significant methylation differences between both groups of patients: FZD10, TBL1X, CSNK1E, WNT8A, CSNK1A1L and SFRP4. The DNA demethylating agent 5-deoxycytidine up-regulated 8 genes, including FZD10, in an osteoblast-like cell line, whereas it down-regulated other 16 genes. In conclusion, Wnt activity is reduced in patients with hip fractures, in comparison with those with osteoarthritis. It does not appear to be related to differences in the allele frequencies of the Wnt genes studied. On the other hand, methylation differences between both groups could contribute to explain the differences in Wnt activity.

The Role of DNA Methylation in Common Skeletal Disorders

Bone is a complex connective tissue characterized by a calcified extracellular matrix. This mineralized matrix is constantly being formed and resorbed throughout life, allowing the bone to adapt to daily mechanical loads and maintain skeletal properties and composition. The imbalance between bone formation and bone resorption leads to changes in bone mass. This is the case of osteoporosis and osteoarthritis, two common skeletal disorders. While osteoporosis is characterized by a decreased bone mass and, consequently, higher susceptibly to fractures, bone mass tends to be higher in patients with osteoarthritis, especially in the subchondral bone region. It is known that these diseases are influenced by heritable factors. However, the DNA polymorphisms identified so far in GWAS explain less than 10% of the genetic risk, suggesting that other factors, and specifically epigenetic mechanisms, are involved in the pathogenesis of these disorders. This review summarizes current knowledge about the influence of epigenetic marks on bone homeostasis, paying special attention to the role of DNA methylation in the onset and progression of osteoporosis and osteoarthritis.

A Sclerostin Super-Producer Cell Line Derived from the Human Cell Line SaOS-2: A New Tool for the Study of the Molecular Mechanisms Driving Sclerostin Expression

Sclerostin, the product of the SOST gene, is a key regulator of bone homeostasis. Sclerostin interferes with the Wnt signalling pathway and, therefore, has a negative effect on bone formation. Although the importance of sclerostin in bone homeostasis is well established, many aspects of its biology are still unknown. Due to its restricted pattern of expression, in vitro studies of SOST gene regulation are technically challenging. Furthermore, a more profound investigation of the molecular mechanism controlling sclerostin expression has been hampered by the lack of a good human in vitro model. Here, we describe two cell lines derived from the human osteosarcoma cell line SaOS-2 that produce elevated levels of sclerostin. Analysis of the super-producer cell lines showed that sclerostin levels were still reduced in response to parathyroid hormone treatment or in response to mechanical loading, indicating that these regulatory mechanisms were not affected in the presented cell lines. In addition, we did not find differences between the promoter or ECR5 sequences of our clones and the SaOS-2 parental line. However, the methylation of the proximal CpG island located at the SOST promoter was lower in the super-producer clones, in agreement with a higher level of SOST transcription. Although the underlying biological causes of the elevated levels of sclerostin production in this cell line are not yet clear, we believe that it could be an extremely useful tool to study the molecular mechanisms driving sclerostin expression in humans.

Epigenetic Regulation of Sost/sclerostin Expression

Purpose of ReviewSclerostin, encoded by the gene Sost, is a regulatory glycoprotein produced by mature osteocytes in bone. Findings in animals and humans revealed that Sost/sclerostin deficiency results in increased bone density, and neutralizing antibodies to this protein are being investigated for treatment of postmenopausal osteoporosis. While it is clear that sclerostin is a major regulator of skeletal homeostasis, the specific mechanisms that control its expression are not completely understood.Recent FindingsGrowing evidence suggest that epigenetic phenomena such as histone modification, DNA methylation, or microRNAs influence Sost/sclerostin expression under physiologic and pathologic conditions. Furthermore, these epigenetic mechanisms control Sost/sclerostin production in a time- and cell-context manner. Together with previous literature, these new findings indicate that Sost/sclerostin regulation is complex and requires coordination of multiple mechanisms.SummaryThis review summarizes the current knowledge on the epigenetic regulation of Sost/sclerostin expression and discusses future research needed to unravel the mechanisms by which Sost/sclerostin expression is controlled in a cell-, time-, and space-specific manner.