John C. Saliken

A randomized trial of external beam radiotherapy versus cryoablation in patients with localized prostate cancer

Localized prostate cancer can be treated several different ways, but head‐to‐head comparisons of treatments are infrequent. The authors of this report conducted a randomized, unblinded, noninferiority trial to compare cryoablation with external beam radiotherapy in these patients.

A model for the time dependent three-dimensional thermal distribution within iceballs surrounding multiple cryoprobes

A time dependent three-dimensional finite difference model of iceball formation about multiple cryoprobes has been developed and compared to experimental data. Realistic three-dimensional probe geometry is specified and the number of cryoprobes, the cryoprobe cooling rates, and the locations of the probes are arbitrary inputs by the user. The simulation accounts for observed longitudinal thermal gradients along the cryoprobe tips. Thermal histories for several points around commercially available cryoprobes have been predicted within experimental error for one, three, and five probe configurations. The simulation can be used to generate isotherms within the iceball at arbitrary times. Volumes enclosed by the iceball and any isotherms may also be computed to give the ablative ratio, a measure of the iceballs killing efficiency. This ratio was calculated as the volume enclosed by a critical isotherm divided by the total volume of the iceball for assumed critical temperatures of -20 and -40 degrees C. The ablative ratio for a single probe is a continuously decreasing function of time but when multiple probe configurations are used the ablative ratio increases to a maximum and then essentially plateaus. Maximum values of 0.44 and 0.55 were observed for three and five probe configurations, respectively, with an assumed critical temperature of -20 degrees C. Assuming a critical temperature of -40 degrees C, maximum ablative ratios of 0.21 and 0.3 for three and five probe configurations, respectively, were observed.

The evolution and state of modern technology for prostate cryosurgery

Cryosurgery is the in situ ablation of a target tissue by application of extreme cold temperature. The ability of cryosurgery to ablate tissue is unquestioned. It is the controlled application of a cryoinjury in a manner to minimize morbidity that is problematic. Prostate cryosurgery is complicated by the proximity of the prostate to adjacent structures that are sensitive to a freeze injury, namely the urethra, rectal wall, and neurovascular bundles. Several recent technological advances have led to the development of an effective treatment protocol with acceptable morbidity. These include the advent of real-time transrectal ultrasound, cryomachines with almost instant freeze-thaw control through the use of the Joule-Thompson effect, and warming catheters to effectively preserve the integrity of the urethra and external sphincter. Further, temperature monitoring at the posterior margin of the prostate sometimes combined with an injection of saline solution into Denonvilliers fascia has reduced the occurrence of urethrorectal fistula formation to 0% to 0.5% in modern series. We review the key innovations of prostate cryosurgery that differentiate this state-of-the-art procedure from that used by early investigators to even that of the early 1990s. Potential future innovations, specifically related to image guidance of the procedure, are also addressed.

X-ray CT monitoring of iceball growth and thermal distribution during cryosurgery

X-ray CT is able to image the internal architecture of frozen tissue. Phantoms of distilled water, a saline-gelatin mixture, lard and a calf liver-gelatin suspension cooled by a plastic tube acting as a long liquid nitrogen cryoprobe were used to study the relationship between Hounsfield unit (HU) values and temperature. There is a signature change in HU value from unfrozen to completely frozen tissue. No discernible relation exists between temperature in a completely frozen tissue and its HU value for the temperature range achieved with commercial cryoprobes. However, such a relation does exist in the typically narrow region of phase change and it is this change in HU value that is the parameter of concern for quantitative monitoring of the freezing process. Calibration of temperature against change in HU value allows a limited set of isotherms to be generated in the phase change region for direct monitoring of iceball growth. The phase change temperature range, mid-phase change temperature and the absolute value of HU change from completely frozen to unfrozen tissue are shown to be sensitive to the medium. Modelling of the temperature distribution within the region of completely frozen phantom using the infinite cylinder solution to the Fourier heat equation allows the temperature history of the phantom to be predicted. A set of isotherms, generated using a combination of thermal modelling and calibrated HU values demonstrates the feasibility of routine x-ray CT assisted cryotherapy. Isotherm overlay will be a major aid to the cryosurgeon who adopts a fixed target temperature as the temperature below which there is a certainty of ablation of the diseased tissue.

A model for the time-dependent thermal distribution within an iceball surrounding a cryoprobe

The optimal cooling parameters to maximize cell necrosis in different types of tissue have yet to be determined. However, a critical isotherm is commonly adopted by cryosurgeons as a boundary of lethality for tissue. Locating this isotherm within an iceball is problematic due to the limitations of MRI, ultrasound and CT imaging modalities. This paper describes a time-dependent two-dimensional axisymmetric model of iceball formation about a single cryoprobe and extensively compares it with experimental data. Thermal histories for several points around a CRYOprobe are predicted to high accuracy (5 degrees C maximum discrepancy). A realistic three-dimensional probe geometry is specified and cryoprobe temperature may be arbitrarily set as a function of time in the model. Three-dimensional temperature distributions within the iceball, predicted by the model at different times, are presented. Isotherm locations, as calculated with the infinite cylinder approximation, are compared with those of the model in the most appropriate region of the iceball. Infinite cylinder approximations are shown to be inaccurate when applied to this commercial probe. Adopting the infinite cylinder approximation to locate the critical isotherm is shown to lead the user to an overestimate of the volume of target tissue enclosed by this isotherm which may lead to incomplete tumour ablation.

Considerations during clinical operation of two commercially available cryomachines

Advances in the technology of cryomachines in the last 10 years have led to the development of both liquid nitrogen and argon‐based Joule‐Thompson cryomachines. Theoretical and practical evaluation of the CMS Accuprobe™ and the ENDOcare CRYOcare™ was performed as respective examples of these technologies.

A Randomized Trial of External Beam Radiotherapy Versus Cryoablation in Patients With Localized Prostate Cancer: Quality of Life Outcomes

A recent randomized trial to compare external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) to cryoablation for localized disease showed cryoablation to be noninferior to external beam EBRT in disease progression and overall and disease‐specific survival. We report on the quality of life (QOL) outcomes for this trial.

Outcome and Safety of Transrectal US-guided Percutaneous Cryotherapy for Localized Prostate Cancer☆

OBJECTIVES To assess the effectiveness and safety of ultrasound (US)-guided cryotherapy as a primary treatment for localized prostate cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS A prospective study of percutaneous transrectal US (TRUS)-guided cryotherapy was performed on 71 patients with T1-T3, N0, M0 prostatic cancer: 10 patients underwent two or more procedures. All cases were newly diagnosed and patients had no previous treatment for cancer. For all patients, TRUS biopsies were performed at 5-6 months. Patients were monitored at 6 weeks; 3, 6, 9, and 12 months; and twice yearly thereafter for prostate specific antigen (PSA) levels, complications, and clinical evidence of residual disease. RESULTS Follow-up from 10 to 36 months was available for 70 of 71 patients; one patient died of unrelated disease. Initially, 10 of 69 patients had positive postcryotherapy biopsy results. After repeated treatment, nine of these 10 patients had negative biopsy results and one patient had no follow-up. Overall, 68 of 69 patients had negative biopsy results. At 1 year, 43 of 64 (67%) had an undetectable PSA level. Two patients had proven metastases. Complications include three cases with urethral sloughing requiring transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP). One patient had orchitis. Two patients had persistent incontinence, one as the result of a TURP. There was no death, acute serious morbidity, or fistula formation. Impotence was universal at 6 months, but many patients demonstrated late recovery. CONCLUSION Cryoablation is an imaging-guided percutaneous intervention for prostate cancer that can safely yield disease-free status in a high percentage of patients with localized disease.

Suppression of high-density artefacts in x-ray CT images using temporal digital subtraction with application to cryotherapy

Image guidance in cryotherapy is usually performed using ultrasound. Although not currently in routine clinical use, x-ray CT imaging is an alternative means of guidance that can display the full 3D structure of the iceball, including frozen and unfrozen regions. However, the quality of x-ray CT images is compromised by the presence of high-density streak artefacts. To suppress these artefacts we applied temporal digital subtraction (TDS). This TDS method has the added advantage of improving the grey-scale contrast between frozen and unfrozen tissue in the CT images. Two sets of CT images were taken of a phantom material, cryoprobes and a urethral warmer (UW) before and during the cryoprobe freeze cycle. The high-density artefacts persisted in both image sets. TDS was performed on these two image sets using the corresponding mask image of unfrozen material and the same geometrical configuration of the cryoprobes and the UW. The resultant difference image had a significantly reduced artefact content. Thus TDS can be used to significantly suppress or eliminate high-density CT streak artefacts without reducing the metallic content of the cryoprobes. In vivo study needs to be conducted to establish the utility of this TDS procedure for CT assisted prostate or liver cryotherapy. Applying TDS in x-ray CT guided cryotherapy will facilitate estimation of the number and location of all frozen and unfrozen regions, potentially making cryotherapy safer and less operator dependent.

Use of a moratorium to achieve consistent liquid nitrogen cryoprobe performance

During liver cryosurgical procedures, the authors observed seriously inconsistent rates of iceball growth implying inconsistent probe cooling rates. This inconsistency can lead to several problems, most importantly, loss of precision and reliability in freezing the chosen volume of tissue. The observation led to investigation of the performance of the cryosurgery machine.