John J. Perona

Type II restriction endonucleases

Type II restriction endonucleases have emerged as important paradigms for the study of protein-nucleic acid interactions. This is due to their ability to catalyse phosphodiester bond cleavage with very large rate enhancements while also maintaining exquisite sequence selectivities. The principles and methods developed to analyze site-specific binding and catalysis for restriction endonucleases can be applied to other enzymes which also operate on nucleic acids. This paper reviews biochemical and structural approaches to characterization of these enzymes, with particular attention to the multiple crucial roles of divalent metal ions, the possibilities for use of alternative substrates in binding and catalytic experiments, the strategies for exploring the detailed chemistry of phosphoryl transfer, and the use of X-ray crystallography to provide descriptions of conformational pathways at specific, nonspecific, and noncognate DNA sites.

tRNA-dependent Aminoacyl-adenylate Hydrolysis by a Nonediting Class I Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetase

Glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase generates Gln-tRNAGln 107-fold more efficiently than Glu-tRNAGln and requires tRNA to synthesize the activated aminoacyl adenylate in the first step of the reaction. To examine the role of tRNA in amino acid activation more closely, several assays employing a tRNA analog in which the 2′-OH group at the 3′-terminal A76 nucleotide is replaced with hydrogen (\batchmode \documentclass[fleqn,10pt,legalpaper]{article} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amsmath} \pagestyle{empty} \begin{document} \(\mathrm{tRN}\mathrm{A}_{2^{{^\prime}}\mathrm{H}}^{\mathrm{Gln}}\) \end{document}) were developed. These experiments revealed a 104-fold reduction in kcat/Km in the presence of the analog, suggesting a direct catalytic role for tRNA in the activation reaction. The catalytic importance of the A76 2′-OH group in aminoacylation mirrors a similar role for this moiety that has recently been demonstrated during peptidyl transfer on the ribosome. Unexpectedly, tracking of Gln-AMP formation utilizing an α-32P-labeled ATP substrate in the presence of \batchmode \documentclass[fleqn,10pt,legalpaper]{article} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amsmath} \pagestyle{empty} \begin{document} \(\mathrm{tRN}\mathrm{A}_{2^{{^\prime}}\mathrm{H}}^{\mathrm{Gln}}\) \end{document} showed that AMP accumulates 5-fold more rapidly than Gln-AMP. A cold-trapping experiment revealed that the nonenzymatic rate of Gln-AMP hydrolysis is too slow to account for the rapid AMP formation; hence, the hydrolysis of Gln-AMP to form glutamine and AMP must be directly catalyzed by the \batchmode \documentclass[fleqn,10pt,legalpaper]{article} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amsmath} \pagestyle{empty} \begin{document} \(\mathrm{GlnRS}{\cdot}\mathrm{tRN}\mathrm{A}_{2^{{^\prime}}\mathrm{H}}^{\mathrm{Gln}}\) \end{document} complex. This hydrolysis of glutaminyl adenylate represents a novel reaction that is directly analogous to the pre-transfer editing hydrolysis of noncognate aminoacyl adenylates by editing synthetases such as isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase. Because glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase does not possess a spatially separate editing domain, these data demonstrate that a pre-transfer editing-like reaction can occur within the synthetic site of a class I tRNA synthetase.

Amino Acid Discrimination by a class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase specified by negative determinants

The 2.5 A crystal structure of Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase in a quaternary complex with tRNA(Gln), an ATP analog and glutamate reveals that the non-cognate amino acid adopts a distinct binding mode within the active site cleft. In contrast to the binding of cognate glutamine, one oxygen of the charged glutamate carboxylate group makes a direct ion-pair interaction with the strictly conserved Arg30 residue located in the first half of the dinucleotide fold domain. The nucleophilic alpha-carboxylate moiety of glutamate is mispositioned with respect to both the ATP alpha-phosphate and terminal tRNA ribose groups, suggesting that a component of amino acid discrimination resides at the catalytic step of the reaction. Further, the other side-chain carboxylate oxygen of glutamate is found in a position identical to that previously proposed to be occupied by the NH(2) group of the cognate glutamine substrate. At this position, the glutamate oxygen accepts hydrogen bonds from the hydroxyl moiety of Tyr211 and a water molecule. These findings demonstrate that amino acid specificity by GlnRS cannot arise from hydrogen bonds donated by the cognate glutamine amide to these same moieties, as previously suggested. Instead, Arg30 functions as a negative determinant to drive binding of non-cognate glutamate into a non-productive orientation. The poorly differentiated cognate amino acid-binding site in GlnRS may be a consequence of the late emergence of this enzyme from the eukaryotic lineage of glutamyl-tRNA synthetases.

Methods for kinetic and thermodynamic analysis of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The accuracy of protein synthesis relies on the ability of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) to discriminate among true and near cognate substrates. To date, analysis of aaRSs function, including identification of residues of aaRS participating in amino acid and tRNA discrimination, has largely relied on the steady state kinetic pyrophosphate exchange and aminoacylation assays. Pre-steady state kinetic studies investigating a more limited set of aaRS systems have also been undertaken to assess the energetic contributions of individual enzyme-substrate interactions, particularly in the adenylation half reaction. More recently, a renewed interest in the use of rapid kinetics approaches for aaRSs has led to their application to several new aaRS systems, resulting in the identification of mechanistic differences that distinguish the two structurally distinct aaRS classes. Here, we review the techniques for thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of aaRS function. Following a brief survey of methods for the preparation of materials and for steady state kinetic analysis, this review will describe pre-steady state kinetic methods employing rapid quench and stopped-flow fluorescence for analysis of the activation and aminoacyl transfer reactions. Application of these methods to any aaRS system allows the investigator to derive detailed kinetic mechanisms for the activation and aminoacyl transfer reactions, permitting issues of substrate specificity, stereochemical mechanism, and inhibitor interaction to be addressed in a rigorous and quantitative fashion.

Shape-selective RNA recognition by cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase (CysRS) bound to tRNACys at a resolution of 2.3 Å reveals base-specific and shape-selective interactions across an extensive protein-RNA recognition interface. The complex contains a mixed α/β C-terminal domain, which is disordered in the unliganded enzyme. This domain makes specific hydrogen bonding interactions with all three bases of the GCA anticodon. The tRNA anticodon stem is bent sharply toward the enzyme as compared with its conformation when bound to elongation factor Tu, providing an essential basis for shape-selective recognition. The CysRS structure also reveals interactions of conserved enzyme groups with the sugar-phosphate backbone in the D loop, adjacent to an unusual G15·G48 tertiary base pair previously implicated in tRNA aminoacylation. A combined mutational analysis of enzyme and tRNA groups at G15·G48 supports the notion that contacts between CysRS and the sugar-phosphate backbone contribute to recognition by indirect readout.

Structural origins of amino acid selection without editing by cysteinyl‐tRNA synthetase

Cysteinyl‐tRNA synthetase (CysRS) is highly specific for synthesis of cysteinyl adenylate, yet does not possess the amino acid editing activity characteristic of many other tRNA synthetases. To elucidate how CysRS is able to distinguish cysteine from non‐cognate amino acids, crystal structures of the Escherichia coli enzyme were determined in apo and cysteine‐bound states. The structures reveal that the substrate cysteine thiolate forms a single direct interaction with a zinc ion bound at the base of the active site cleft, in a trigonal bipyramidal geometry together with four highly conserved protein side chains. Cysteine binding induces movement of the zinc ion towards substrate, as well as flipping of the conserved Trp205 indole ring to pack on the thiol side chain. The imidazole groups of five conserved histidines lie adjacent to the zinc ion, forming a unique arrangement suggestive of functional significance. Thus, amino acid discrimination without editing arises most directly from the favorable zinc–thiolate interaction, which is not possible for non‐cognate substrates. Additional selectivity may be generated during the induced‐fit conformational changes that help assemble the active site.

Structural and energetic origins of indirect readout in site-specific DNA cleavage by a restriction endonuclease

Specific recognition by EcoRV endonuclease of its cognate, sharply bent GATATC site at the center TA step occurs solely via hydrophobic interaction with thymine methyl groups. Mechanistic kinetic analyses of base analog-substituted DNAs at this position reveal that direct readout provides 5 kcal mol–1 toward specificity, with an additional 6–10 kcal mol–1 arising from indirect readout. Crystal structures of several base analog complexes show that the major-groove hydrophobic contacts are crucial to forming required divalent metal-binding sites, and that indirect readout operates in part through the sequence-dependent free-energy cost of unstacking the center base-pair step of the DNA.

Partitioning of tRNA-dependent Editing between Pre- and Post-transfer Pathways in Class I Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases

Hydrolytic editing activities are present in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases possessing reduced amino acid discrimination in the synthetic reactions. Post-transfer hydrolysis of misacylated tRNA in class I editing enzymes occurs in a spatially separate domain inserted into the catalytic Rossmann fold, but the location and mechanisms of pre-transfer hydrolysis of misactivated amino acids have been uncertain. Here, we use novel kinetic approaches to distinguish among three models for pre-transfer editing by Escherichia coli isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase (IleRS). We demonstrate that tRNA-dependent hydrolysis of noncognate valyl-adenylate by IleRS is largely insensitive to mutations in the editing domain of the enzyme and that noncatalytic hydrolysis after release is too slow to account for the observed rate of clearing. Measurements of the microscopic rate constants for amino acid transfer to tRNA in IleRS and the related valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS) further suggest that pre-transfer editing in IleRS is an enzyme-catalyzed activity residing in the synthetic active site. In this model, the balance between pre-transfer and post-transfer editing pathways is controlled by kinetic partitioning of the noncognate aminoacyl-adenylate. Rate constants for hydrolysis and transfer of a noncognate intermediate are roughly equal in IleRS, whereas in ValRS transfer to tRNA is 200-fold faster than hydrolysis. In consequence, editing by ValRS occurs nearly exclusively by post-transfer hydrolysis in the editing domain, whereas in IleRS both pre- and post-transfer editing are important. In both enzymes, the rates of amino acid transfer to tRNA are similar for cognate and noncognate aminoacyl-adenylates, providing a significant contrast with editing DNA polymerases.

Sequence selectivity and degeneracy of a restriction endonuclease mediated by DNA intercalation.

The crystal structure of the HincII restriction endonuclease–DNA complex shows that degenerate specificity for blunt-ended cleavage at GTPyPuAC sequences arises from indirect readout of conformational preferences at the center pyrimidine-purine step. Protein-induced distortion of the DNA is accomplished by intercalation of glutamine side chains into the major groove on either side of the recognition site, generating bending by either tilt or roll at three distinct loci. The intercalated side chains propagate a concerted shift of all six target-site base pairs toward the minor groove, producing an unusual cross-strand purine stacking at the center pyrimidine–purine step. Comparison of the HincII and EcoRV cocrystal structures suggests that sequence-dependent differences in base–stacking free energies are a crucial underlying factor mediating protein recognition by indirect readout.

Amino Acid-dependent Transfer RNA Affinity in a Class I Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetase

Steady-state and transient kinetic analyses of glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) reveal that the enzyme discriminates against noncognate glutamate at multiple steps during the overall aminoacylation reaction. A major portion of the selectivity arises in the amino acid activation portion of the reaction, whereas the discrimination in the overall two-step reaction arises from very weak binding of noncognate glutamate. Further transient kinetics experiments showed that tRNAGln binds to GlnRS ∼60-fold weaker when noncognate glutamate is present and that glutamate reduces the association rate of tRNA with the enzyme by 100-fold. These findings demonstrate that amino acid and tRNA binding are interdependent and reveal an important additional source of specificity in the aminoacylation reaction. Crystal structures of the GlnRS·tRNA complex bound to either amino acid have previously shown that glutamine and glutamate bind in distinct positions in the active site, providing a structural basis for the amino acid-dependent modulation of tRNA affinity. Together with other crystallographic data showing that ligand binding is essential to assembly of the GlnRS active site, these findings suggest a model for specificity generation in which required induced-fit rearrangements are significantly modulated by the identities of the bound substrates.