John K. Neubert

Genetic influence on variability in human acute experimental pain sensitivity associated with gender, ethnicity and psychological temperament

&NA; While a variety of cultural, psychological and physiological factors contribute to variability in both clinical and experimental contexts, the role of genetic factors in human pain sensitivity is increasingly recognized as an important element. This study was performed to evaluate genetic influences on variability in human pain sensitivity associated with gender, ethnicity and temperament. Pain sensitivity in response to experimental painful thermal and cold stimuli was measured with visual analogue scale ratings and temperament dimensions of personality were evaluated. Loci in the vanilloid receptor subtype 1 gene (TRPV1), &dgr; opioid receptor subtype 1 gene (OPRD1) and catechol O‐methyltransferase gene (COMT) were genotyped using 5′ nuclease assays. A total of 500 normal participants (306 females and 194 males) were evaluated. The sample composition was 62.0% European American, 17.4% African American, 9.0% Asian American, and 8.6% Hispanic, and 3.0% individuals with mixed racial parentage. Female European Americans with the TRPV1 Val585 Val allele and males with low harm avoidance showed longer cold withdrawal times based on the classification and regression tree (CART) analysis. CART identified gender, an OPRD1 polymorphism and temperament dimensions of personality as the primary determinants of heat pain sensitivity at 49 °C. Our observations demonstrate that gender, ethnicity and temperament contribute to individual variation in thermal and cold pain sensitivity by interactions with TRPV1 and OPRD1 single nucleotide polymorphisms.

Deletion of vanilloid receptor 1-expressing primary afferent neurons for pain control

Control of cancer, neuropathic, and postoperative pain is frequently inadequate or compromised by debilitating side effects. Inhibition or removal of certain nociceptive neurons, while retaining all other sensory modalities and motor function, would represent a new therapeutic approach to control severe pain. The enriched expression of transient receptor potential cation channel, subfamily V, member 1 (TRPV1; also known as the vanilloid receptor, VR1) in nociceptive neurons of the dorsal root and trigeminal ganglia allowed us to test this concept. Administration of the potent TRPV1 agonist resiniferatoxin (RTX) to neuronal perikarya induces calcium cytotoxicity by opening the TRPV1 ion channel and selectively ablates nociceptive neurons. This treatment blocks experimental inflammatory hyperalgesia and neurogenic inflammation in rats and naturally occurring cancer and debilitating arthritic pain in dogs. Sensations of touch, proprioception, and high-threshold mechanosensitive nociception, as well as locomotor function, remained intact in both species. In separate experiments directed at postoperative pain control, subcutaneous administration of RTX transiently disrupted nociceptive nerve endings, yielding reversible analgesia. In human dorsal root ganglion cultures, RTX induced a prolonged increase in intracellular calcium in vanilloid-sensitive neurons, while leaving other, adjacent neurons unaffected. The results suggest that nociceptive neuronal or nerve terminal deletion will be effective and broadly applicable as strategies for pain management.

Concurrent release of ATP and substance P within guinea pig trigeminal ganglia in vivo.

Neurons within sensory ganglia have been proposed to communicate via non-synaptic release of a diffusible chemical messenger, but the identity of the chemical mediator(s) remains unknown [J. Neurosci. 16 (1996) 4733-4741]. The present study addressed the possibility of co-released ATP and substance P (SP) within sensory ganglia to further advance the hypothesis of non-synaptic communication between sensory neurons. Microdialysis probes inserted into trigeminal ganglia (TRGs) of anesthetized guinea pigs were perfused with artificial cerebrospinal fluid and the collected perfusate analyzed for ATP and SP content using the firefly luciferin-luciferase (L/L) assay and radioimmunoassay, respectively. Significant reversible increases in ATP and SP levels were observed after infusion of 100 mM KCl or 1 mM capsaicin. Ca(2+)-free ACSF produced an eightfold increase in ATP levels, interpreted as a decrease in activity of Ca(2+)-dependent ecto-nucleotidases that degrade ATP. In contrast, KCl-induced release of ATP in the presence of normal Ca(2+) was blocked by Cd(2+), a voltage-gated Ca(2+) channel blocker, illustrating Ca(2+)-dependence of evoked ATP release. Since ganglionic release of ATP could arise from several neuronal and non-neuronal sources we directly tested acutely dissociated TRG neuron somata for ATP release. Neuron-enriched dissociated TRG cells were plated onto glass tubes and tested for ATP release using the L/L assay. Robust ATP release was evoked with 5 microM capsaicin. These data suggest that ATP is released concurrently with SP from the somata of neurons within sensory ganglia.

Use of a novel thermal operant behavioral assay for characterization of orofacial pain sensitivity

&NA; Orofacial pain has been well‐characterized clinically, but evaluation of orofacial pain in animals has not kept pace. The objective of this study was to describe behavioral responses to facial thermal stimulation and inflammation with/without an analgesic using a novel operant paradigm. Animals were trained to voluntarily place their face against a stimulus thermode (37.7–57.2 °C) providing access to positive reinforcement. These contingencies present a conflict between positive reward and tolerance for nociceptive stimulation. Inflammation was induced and morphine was provided as an analgesic in a subset of animals. Six outcome measures were determined: reward intake, reward licking contacts, stimulus facial contacts, facial contact duration, ratio of reward/stimulus contacts, and ratio of facial contact duration/event. Animals displayed aversive behaviors to the higher temperatures, denoted by a significant decrease in reward intake, total facial contact duration, and reward licking events. The number of facial contacts increased with increasing temperature, replacing long drinking bouts with more frequent short drinks, as reflected by a low ratio of facial contact duration/event. The number of reward licking/facial contact events was significantly decreased as the thermal stimulus intensity increased, providing another pain index derived from this operant method. These outcomes were significantly affected in the direction of increased nociception following inflammation, and these indices of hyperalgesia were reversed with morphine administration. These data reflect an orofacial pain behavior profile that was based on an animals responses in an operant escape paradigm. This technique allows evaluation of nociceptive processing and modulation throughout the neuraxis.

Inflammation-induced changes in primary afferent-evoked release of substance P within trigeminal ganglia in vivo

Substance P (SP) is synthesized in a subset of nociceptive sensory neurons and is released from their peripheral and central terminals. Here we demonstrate with the use of in vivo microdialysis and radioimmunoassay techniques that SP is also released within trigeminal ganglia following intraganglionic application of KCl, veratridine or capsaicin, and after electrical stimulation of peripheral afferent fibers. Both the basal and KCl-evoked release of SP are shown to be dependent on extracellular calcium. Using the turpentine-induced model of unilateral orofacial inflammation we also show that both the basal and KCl-evoked release of SP within trigeminal ganglia are greatly increased on the inflamed side 48 h after induction of inflammation. Coupled with previous demonstrations of excitatory effects of SP on sensory neurons, these results suggest that SP fulfils the role of a non-synaptically released diffusible chemical messenger that may modulate the somatic excitability of neurons within sensory ganglia in inflammatory pain states.

Peripherally induced resiniferatoxin analgesia.

&NA; Selective blockade of nociceptive pathways represents a mechanism‐based approach that has attracted a large variety of pharmacological and molecular investigations. A potential site for selective intervention is the primary afferent nociceptive nerve terminal. Binding of resiniferatoxin (RTX) to the vanilloid‐1 receptor (VR1) stimulates and then inactivates heat and vanilloid‐responsive nerve endings involved in heat and inflammatory pain signaling which can progress to localized degeneration of the peripheral ending followed by regeneration. Application of RTX directly to peripheral nerve endings produces a long term, reversible attenuation of nociceptive transmission. Heat hyperalgesia and mechanical allodynia were assessed prior to injection of RTX into the hindpaw (baseline) and at acute (minutes–hours) and more chronic (days–weeks) times after injection. Acutely, an inverse dose‐to‐pain response (guarding, licking) for RTX (0.0625–2.0 &mgr;g) occurs, followed by selective attenuation of peripheral pain transmission. Thermal nociception was decreased in a concentration‐dependent fashion and lasted up to 21 days, without impairing motor function. Administration of RTX blocked both inflammation‐induced hyperalgesia and spinal c‐Fos induction. The results demonstrate the efficacy and therapeutic potential of reversible, peripheral C‐fiber ‘inactivation’ for intermediate duration pain control.

Pain sensitivity and vasopressin analgesia are mediated by a gene-sex-environment interaction

Quantitative trait locus mapping of chemical/inflammatory pain in the mouse identified the Avpr1a gene, which encodes the vasopressin-1A receptor (V1AR), as being responsible for strain-dependent pain sensitivity to formalin and capsaicin. A genetic association study in humans revealed the influence of a single nucleotide polymorphism (rs10877969) in AVPR1A on capsaicin pain levels, but only in male subjects reporting stress at the time of testing. The analgesic efficacy of the vasopressin analog desmopressin revealed a similar interaction between the drug and acute stress, as desmopressin inhibition of capsaicin pain was only observed in nonstressed subjects. Additional experiments in mice confirmed the male-specific interaction of V1AR and stress, leading to the conclusion that vasopressin activates endogenous analgesia mechanisms unless they have already been activated by stress. These findings represent, to the best of our knowledge, the first explicit demonstration of analgesic efficacy depending on the emotional state of the recipient, and illustrate the heuristic power of a bench-to-bedside-to-bench translational strategy.

Relationship between capsaicin-evoked substance p release and neurokinin 1 receptor internalization in the rat spinal cord

The relationship between substance P release and the activation of its receptor in the spinal cord remains unclear. Substance P release is usually measured by radioimmunoassay, whereas the internalization of the neurokinin 1 (NK1) receptor has been used to assess its activation by noxious stimuli. Our objective was to compare substance P release and NK1 receptor internalization produced by capsaicin in rat spinal cord slices. Superfusion of the slices with capsaicin for 3 min produced a gradual increase in substance P release that peaked 3-7 min afterward, and then decreased to baseline levels. The concentration-response curve for capsaicin was biphasic, with concentrations above 10 microM producing significantly less release. The effective concentration for 50% of response (EC(50)) for capsaicin, calculated from its stimulatory phase, was 2.3 microM. However, the potency of capsaicin to elicit NK1 receptor internalization in the same slices was one order of magnitude higher (EC(50)=0.37 microM) in lamina I, probably because NK1 receptors become saturated at relatively low concentrations of substance P. The potency of capsaicin to produce internalization was progressively lower in lamina III (EC(50)=1.9 microM) and lamina IV (EC(50)=14.5 microM), suggesting that neurokinins released in laminae I-II become diluted as they diffuse to the inner dorsal horn. To study the correlation between these two measures, we plotted substance P release against NK1 receptor internalization and fitted a saturation binding function to the points. The correlation was good for laminae I (R(2)=0.82) and III (R(2)=0.78), but it was poor (R(2)=0.35) for lamina IV because NK1 receptor internalization kept on increasing at high concentrations of capsaicin, whereas substance P release decreased. In conclusion, amounts of substance P able to activate NK1 receptors may fall under the threshold of detection of radioimmunoassay. Conversely, radioimmunoassay often detects levels of substance P release well over those required to saturate NK1 receptors in the superficial dorsal horn, but that may be able to activate these receptors in nearby regions of the spinal cord.

Placebo-induced analgesia in an operant pain model in rats.

Summary Rats show canonical features of human placebo‐induced analgesia in an assay designed to evaluate pain affect. ABSTRACT Analgesia is particularly susceptible to placebo responses. Recent studies in humans have provided important insights into the neurobiology underlying placebo‐induced analgesia. However, human studies provide incomplete mechanistic explanations of placebo analgesia because of limited capacity to use cellular, molecular, and genetic manipulations. To address this shortcoming, this article describes the development of a rat model of conditioned analgesia in an operant pain assay. Specifically, rats were conditioned to associate a placebo manipulation with the analgesic effect of 1 mg/kg morphine (subcutaneously) on facial thermal pain. We found that conditioned (placebo) responding bore 3 of the hallmarks of placebo‐induced analgesia: (1) strong interanimal variability in the response, (2) suppression by the opiate antagonist naloxone (5 mg/kg subcutaneously), and (3) a positive predictive relationship between the unconditioned analgesic effect and the conditioned (placebo) effect. Because of the operant nature of the assay and the use of only a mild noxious thermal stimulus, we suggest that these results provide evidence of placebo‐induced analgesia in a preclinical model that utilizes an affective behavioral end point. This finding may provide opportunities for invasive preclinical studies allowing greater understanding of placebo‐induced analgesia, thus paving the way for avenues to harness its benefits.

Sex Differences in Thermal Pain Sensitivity and Sympathetic Reactivity for Two Strains of Rat

UNLABELLED Human females are more sensitive than males to brief nociceptive stimuli such as heat and cold. However, a more pronounced peripheral vasoconstriction by females than by males during prolonged nociceptive stimulation predicts that females would be more sensitive to prolonged cold but not heat stimulation. We tested this possibility with reflex (lick/guard) and operant escape and preference tests of sensitivity to prolonged stimulation of Long-Evans and Sprague-Dawley rats. Escape responses to cold stimulation revealed a greater sensitivity of females. In contrast, males were more sensitive to nociceptive heat stimulation. An operant preference test of relative sensitivity to cold or heat stimulation confirmed these results. Cold was more aversive than heat for females, but heat was more aversive than cold for males. Recordings of skin temperature during nociceptive heat stimulation were consistent with the results of operant testing. A reduction in skin temperature (peripheral vasoconstriction) during nociceptive stimulation should increase cold sensitivity as observed for females relative to males. Lick/guard testing did not confirm the results of operant testing. Lick/guard (L/G) responding to nociceptive heat stimulation was greater for females than for males. Female escape responses to heat were more variable than males, but L/G responding of males to the same stimulus was more variable than for females. PERSPECTIVE A variety of chronic pain conditions are more prevalent for females, and psychological stress (with attendant sympathetic activation) is implicated in development and maintenance of these conditions. Therefore, understanding relationships between gender differences in pain sensitivity and sympathetic activation could shed light on mechanisms for some varieties of chronic pain.