John P. Clark

The Application of Flow Control to an Aft-Loaded Low Pressure Turbine Cascade With Unsteady Wakes

The synchronous application of flow control in the presence of unsteady wakes was studied on a highly loaded low pressure turbine blade. At low Reynolds numbers, the blade exhibits a nonreattaching separation bubble under steady flow conditions without upstream wakes. Unsteady wakes from an upstream vane row are simulated with a moving row of bars. The separation zone is modified substantially by the presence of unsteady wakes, producing a smaller separation zone and reducing the area-averaged wake total pressure loss by more than 50%. The wake disturbance accelerates transition in the separated shear layer but stops short of reattaching the flow. Rather, a new time-averaged equilibrium location is established for the separated shear layer. The focus of this study was the application of pulsed flow control using two spanwise rows of discrete vortex generator jets. The jets were located at 59% Cx, approximately the peak cp location, and at 72% Cx. The most effective separation control was achieved at the upstream location. The wake total pressure loss decreased 60% from the wake-only level and the cp distribution fully recovered its high Reynolds number shape. The jet disturbance dominates the dynamics of the separated shear layer, with the wake disturbance assuming a secondary role only. When the pulsed jet actuation was initiated at the downstream location, synchronizing the jet to actuate between wake events was key to producing the most effective separation control. Evidence suggests that flow control using vortex generator jets (VGJs) will be effective in the highly unsteady low pressure turbine environment of an operating gas turbine, provided the VGJ location and amplitude are adapted for the specific blade profile.

Unsteady Interaction Between a Transonic Turbine Stage and Downstream Components

Results from a numerical simulation of the unsteady flow through one quarter of the circumference of a transonic high-pressure turbine stage, transition duct, and low-pressure turbine first vane are presented and compared with experimental data. Analysis of the unsteady pressure field resulting from the simulation shows the effects of not only the rotor/stator interaction of the high-pressure turbine stage but also new details of the interaction between the blade and the downstream transition duct and low-pressure turbine vane. Blade trailing edge shocks propagate downstream, strike, and reflect off of the transition duct hub and/or downstream vane leading to high unsteady pressure on these downstreamcomponents. The reflection of these shocks from the downstream components back into the blade itself has also been found to increase the level of unsteady pressure fluctuations on the uncovered portion of the blade suction surface. In addition, the blade tip vortex has been found to have a moderately strong interaction with the downstream vane even with the considerable axial spacing between the two blade-rows. Fourier decomposition of the unsteady surface pressure of the blade and downstream low-pressure turbine vane shows the magnitude of the various frequencies contributing to the unsteady loads. Detailed comparisons between the computed unsteady surface pressure spectrum and the experimental data are shown along with a discussion of the various interaction mechanisms between the blade, transition duct, and downstream vane. These comparisons show-overall good agreement between the simulation and experimental data and identify areas where further improvements in modeling are needed.

Designing Low-Pressure Turbine Blades With Integrated Flow Control

A low pressure turbine blade was designed to produce a 17% increase in blade loading over an industry-standard airfoil using integrated flow control to prevent separation. The design was accomplished using two-dimensional CFD predictions of blade performance coupled with insight gleaned from recently published work in transition modeling and from previous experiments with flow control using vortex generator jets (VGJs). In order to mitigate the Reynolds number lapse in efficiency associated with LPT airfoils, a mid-loaded blade was selected. Also, separation predictions from the computations were used to guide the placement of control actuators on the blade suction surface. Three blades were fabricated using the new design and installed in a two-passage linear cascade facility. Flow velocity and surface pressure measurements taken without activating the VGJs indicate a large separation bubble centered at 68% axial chord on the suction surface. The size of the separation and its growth with decreasing Reynolds number agree well with CFD predictions. The separation bubble reattaches to the blade over a wide range of inlet Reynolds numbers from 150,000 down to below 20,000. This represents a marked improvement in separation resistance compared to the original blade profile which separates without reattachment below a Reynolds number of 40,000. This enhanced performance is achieved by increasing the blade spacing while simultaneously adjusting the blade shape to make it less aft-loaded but with a higher peak cp . This reduces the severity of the adverse pressure gradient in the uncovered portion of the modified blade passage. With the use of pulsed VGJs, the design blade loading was achieved while providing attached flow over the entire range of Re. Detailed phase-locked flow measurements using three-component PIV show the trajectory of the jet and its interaction with the unsteady separation bubble. Results illustrate the importance of integrating flow control into the turbine blade design process and the potential for enhanced turbine performance.Copyright

The Effect of Airfoil Scaling on the Predicted Unsteady Loading on the Blade of a 1 and 1/2 Stage Transonic Turbine and a Comparison With Experimental Results

In this study, two time-accurate Navier-Stokes analyses were obtained to predict the first-vane/first-blade interaction in a 1 and 1/2-stage turbine rig for comparison with measurements. In the first computation, airfoil scaling was applied to the turbine blade to achieve periodicity in the circumferential direction while modeling 1/18 of the annulus. In the second, 1/4 of the wheel was modeled without the use of airfoil scaling. For both simulations the predicted unsteady pressures on the blade were similar in terms of time-averaged pressure distributions and peak-peak unsteady pressure envelopes. However, closer inspection of the predictions in the frequency domain revealed significant differences in the magnitudes of unsteadiness at twice vane-passing frequency (and the vane-passing frequency itself, to a lesser extent). The results of both computations were compared to measurements of the vane-blade interaction in a full-scale turbine rig representative of an early design iteration of the PW6000 engine. These measurements were made in the short-duration turbine-test facility at The Ohio State University Gas Turbine Laboratory. The experimentally determined, time-resolved pressures were in good agreement with those predicted with the 1/4-wheel simulation.© 2000 ASME

Migration of Combustor Exit Profiles Through High Pressure Turbine Vanes

The high pressure turbine stage within gas turbine engines is exposed to combustor exit flows that are nonuniform in both stagnation pressure and temperature. These highly turbulent flows typically enter the first stage vanes with significant spatial gradients near the inner and outer diameter endwalls. These gradients can result in secondary flow development within the vane passage that is different than what classical secondary flow models predict. The heat transfer between the working fluid and the turbine vane surface and endwalls is directly related to the secondary flows. The goal of the current study was to examine the migration of different inlet radial temperature and pressure profiles through the high turbine vane of a modern turbine engine. The tests were performed using an inlet profile generator located in the Turbine Research Facility at the Air Force Research Laboratory. Comparisons of area-averaged radial exit profiles are reported as well as profiles at three vane pitch locations to document the circumferential variation in the profiles. The results show that the shape of the total pressure profile near the endwalls at the inlet of the vane can alter the redistribution of stagnation enthalpy through the airfoil passage significantly. Total pressure loss and exit flow angle variations are also examined for the different inlet profiles.

Validation of Heat-Flux Predictions on the Outer Air Seal of a Transonic Turbine Blade

It is desirable to accurately predict the heat load on turbine hot section components within the design cycle of the engine. Thus, a set of predictions of the heat flux on the blade outer air seal of a transonic turbine is here validated with time-resolved measurements obtained in a single-stage high-pressure turbine rig. Surface pressure measurements were also obtained along the blade outer air seal, and these are also compared to three-dimensional, Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes predictions. A region of very high heat flux was predicted as the pressure side of the blade passed a fixed location on the blade outer air seal, but this was not measured in the experiment. The region of high heat flux was associated both with very high harmonics of the blade-passing event and a discrepancy between predicted and measured time-mean heat-flux levels. Further analysis of the predicted heat flux in light of the experimental technique employed in the test revealed that the elevated heat flux associated with passage of the pressure side might be physical. Improvements in the experimental technique are suggested for future efforts.

Flexible Non-Intrusive Heat Flux Instrumentation for the AFRL Research Turbine

This paper describes a large scale heat flux instrumentation effort for the AFRL HIT Research Turbine. The work provides a unique amount of high frequency instrumentation to acquire fast response unsteady heat flux in a fully rotational, cooled turbine rig along with unsteady pressure data to investigate thermal loading and unsteady aerodynamic airfoil interactions. Over 1200 dynamic sensors are installed on the 1 & 1/2 stage turbine rig. Airfoils include 658 double-sided thin film gauges for heat flux, 289 fast-response Kulite pressure sensors for unsteady aerodynamic measurements, and over 40 thermocouples. An overview of the instrumentation is given with in-depth focus on the non-commercial thin film heat transfer sensors designed and produced in the Heat Flux Instrumentation Laboratory at WPAFB. The paper further describes the necessary upgrade of data acquisition systems and signal conditioning electronics to handle the increased channel requirements of the HIT Research Turbine. More modern, reliable, and efficient data processing and analysis code provides better handling of large data sets and allows easy integration with the turbine design and analysis system under development at AFRL. Example data from cooled transient blowdown tests in the TRF are included along with measurement uncertainty.Copyright

Geometry-Grid Generation for Three-Dimensional Multidisciplinary Simulations in Multistage Turbomachinery

A procedure is presented for automated and fast geometry-grid generation of three-dimensional, multistage, axial turbomachinery for multidisciplinary simulations involving fluid–thermal, fluid–structural, or fluid–thermal–structural interaction. The procedure rapidly generates geometry for solid airfoils and endwalls, thermal barrier coatings, heat transfer pedestals, cooling plenums, cooling flow control tubes, and interblade row endwall leakage slots as well as the computational grids for these components automatically based on prescribed input parameters. The computational grids that are generated in general consist of multiblock, point-matched structured grids. For the cooling flow control tubes, heat transfer pedestals, and interblade row leakage slots, the computational grids are embedded, multiblock, overset grids to allow for arbitrary placement to allow optimization without the need for regridding the entire domain. The techniques used to construct the geometry and various computational grids are...

A Review of the AFRL Turbine Research Facility

The Air Force Research Laboratory Turbine Research Facility is a transient blowdown facility that allows simultaneous measurement of unsteady heat transfer and aerodynamics on full scale engine hardware. It is unique for its size and consequent blowdown duration. Compared to engine validation testing, full scale, short duration turbine-rig testing is able to provide very large amounts of rotating turbine flowfield information using far less energy, orders of magnitude lower cost, and greater instrumentation selection.This paper provides an updated review of the facility’s history, operation, and enhancements since its initial construction over two decades ago. Historical connections to pioneering work in short-duration turbine heat transfer testing are highlighted, and an overview of past developments, features, and capabilities is given. More recent experimental and computational integration is described using a suite of in-house developed CFD design and analysis tools. Example test programs include a non-proprietary 1+ 1/2 stage research turbine rig, which is the most heavily instrumented high pressure turbine tested in the facility to date.. Recent data illustrates the character of unsteady airfoil shock interactions that may lead to large levels of resonant stress or turbine high cycle fatigue. The paper ends with a brief discussion of future work.© 2013 ASME

Comparison of Predictions From Conjugate Heat Transfer Analysis of a Film-Cooled Turbine Vane to Experimental Data

Conjugate heat transfer analysis was conducted on a 648 hole film cooled turbine vane using Code Leo and compared to experimental results obtained at the Air Force Research Laboratory Turbine Research Facility. An unstructured mesh with fully resolved film holes for both fluid and solid domains was used to conduct the conjugate heat transfer simulation on a desktop PC with eight cores. Initial heat flux and surface metal temperature predictions showed reasonable agreement with heat flux measurements but under prediction of surface metal temperature values. Root cause analysis was performed, leading to two refinements. First, a thermal barrier coating layer was introduced into the analysis to account for the insulating properties of the Kapton layer used for the heat flux gauges. Second, inlet boundary conditions were updated to more accurately reflect rig measurement conditions. The resulting surface metal temperature predictions showed excellent agreement relative to measured results (+/− 5 degrees K).Copyright