John P. Wourms

1 The Maternal-Embryonic Relationship in Viviparous Fishes

Publisher Summary This chapter discusses the maternal–embryonic relationship in viviparous fishes. Viviparity is a highly successful mode of reproduction that has evolved independently many times and with many variations in widely separated taxonomic groups. It occurs in all classes of vertebrates, except birds, and among many different groups of invertebrates. Initial steps in the evolution of viviparity involved a shift from external to internal fertilization and the retention of fertilized eggs in the female reproductive system. The osmoregulation of early embryos can be accomplished more efficiently and with less expenditure of embryonic energy in a maternally controlled uterine environment, but as development progresses to term, the embryos presumably acquire an increasing degree of osmoregulatory independence. Available evidence suggests that maternal regulation of the osmotic and chemical environment of the embryo also confers a selective advantage on viviparous teleosts. The uterine wall of most viviparous elasmobranchs and the coelocanth both delimits and defines the embryonic environment. The most spectacular maternal specializations for uterine gestation involve the uterine wall and involve (1) the amplification of the surface area in the form of folds, villi, or trophonemata; (2) the production of histotrophe or uterine milk’ (3) the compartmentalization of embryos; and (4) the development of placental attachment sites.

The reproduction and development of sharks, skates, rays and ratfishes: introduction, history, overview, and future prospects

ReferencesThis volume had its origin in aSymposium on the Reproduction and Development of Cartilaginous Fishes that was held at the annual meetings of the American Elasmobranch Society and the American Society of Ichthyologists and Herpetologists in Charleston, South Carolina in June 1990. The aim of this symposium was to bring together many of those scientists interested in chondrichthyan reproduction and development in order to assess the current state of knowledge in these fields.The chondrichthyan fishes occupy a pivotal position in comparative and evolutionary studies of vertebrate reproduction and development. They are the oldest surviving group of jawed vertebrates and they possess both the adult vertebrate Bauplan and the vertebrate program of embryonic development. The major features of the female reproductive system, including its embryonic origin, structure, physiological function, and biochemistry, apparently were established early in vertebrate evolution and are fully developed in chondrichthyan fishes. These features of the female reproductive system have been retained during the evolution of the other classes of vertebrates. Much the same can be said for the male reproductive system. Moreover, viviparity, placental nourishment of developing embryos, and the hormonal regulation of these events made an initial appearance in this group.The twenty-two articles contained in this volume bring together a wide variety of complementary research by investigators from seven countries. It is hoped that presentation of this disparate body of research and thought in one place will provide perspective on current research activity, call attention to those areas in which the research endeavour is deficient, and identify opportunities for future study. The appearance at this time of a volume on the reproduction and development of cartilaginous fishes is quite opportune. The continued existence of these fishes, which survived the great extinction events of Earths history, is now threatened by over-exploitation unless immediate steps for their conservation are undertaken. Knowledge of their reproduction and development not only is an end in itself, but is of critical importance in devising successful conservation and resource management strategies.

Reproduction and development ofSebastes in the context of the evolution of piscine viviparity

SynopsisSelected aspects of the reproduction and development ofSebastes and other rockfishes are reviewed in the context of piscine viviparity. Among the eight subfamilies of the Scorpaenidae, viviparity is confined to the subfamily Sebastinae; gestation is lumenal and the embryos usually develop to term within the egg envelope. Transitional states from oviparity to viviparity are evident in different species within the family. A scenario for the evolutionary origin of viviparity in rockfishes is derived from an analysis of scorpaeniform reproductive biology. Although viviparity is best developed in the genusSebastes, it is still in a primitive, unspecialized state. Rockfish viviparity is essentially lecithotrophic, i.e. embryonic nutrition is dependent on the energy reserves laid down during oogenesis. In other groups of viviparous fishes, lecithotrophy has been shown to be better suited energetically to seasonally unpredictable habitats, whereas matrotrophy requires a predictable food supply. During the evolution of an essentially primitive form of lecithotrophic viviparity in rockfishes, the advantages of high fecundity associated with oviparity were retained while an enormous increase in the survival rate of the developing embryos was acquired. The basic lecithotrophic pattern of oviparous development was not changed since it offered selective advantages both in terms of energetics and as a basis for retaining a large brood size.

The follicular placenta of the viviparous fish, Heterandria formosa. I, Ultrastructure and development of the embryonic absorptive surface

Embryos of the poeciliid Heterandria formosa develop to term in the ovarian follicle in which they establish a placental association with the follicle wall (follicular placenta) and undergo a 3,900% increase in embryonic dry weight. This study does not confirm the belief that the embryonic component of the follicular placenta is formed only by the surfaces of the pericardial and yolk sacs; early in development the entire embryonic surface functions in absorption. The pericardial sac expands to form a hood‐like structure that covers the head of the embryo and together with the yolk sac is extensively vascularized by a portal plexus derived from the vitelline circulation. The hood‐like pericardial sac is considered to be a pericardial amnion‐serosa. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy reveal that during the early and middle phases of development (Tavolgas stages 10–18 for Xiphophorus maculatus) the entire embryo is covered by a bilaminar epithelium whose apical surface is characterized by numerous, elongate microvilli and coated pits and vesicles. Electron‐lucent vesicles in the apical cytoplasm appear to be endosomes while a heterogeneous group of dense‐staining vesicles display many features characteristic of lysosomes. As in the larvae of other teleosts, cells resembling chloride cells are also present in the surface epithelium. Endothelial cells of the portal plexus lie directly beneath the surface epithelium of the pericardial and yolk sacs and possess numerous transcytotic vesicles. The microvillous surface epithelium becomes restricted to the pericardial and yolk sacs late in development when elsewhere on the embryo the non‐absorptive epidermis differentiates. We postulate that before the definitive epidermis differentiates, the entire embryonic surface constitutes the embryonic component of the follicular placenta. The absorptive surface epithelium appears to be the principle embryonic adaptation for maternal‐embryonic nutrient uptake in H. formosa, suggesting that a change in the normal differentiation of the surface epithelium was of primary importance to the acquisition of matrotrophy in this species. In other species of viviparous poeciliid fishes in which there is little or no transfer of maternal nutrients, the embryonic surface epithelium is of the non‐absorptive type.

Ultrastructure of the pre-implantation shark yolk sac placenta

During ontogeny, the yolk sac of viviparous sharks differentiates into a yolk sac placenta which functions in gas exchange and hematrophic nutrient transport. The pre-implantation yolk sac functions in respiration and yolk absorption. In a 10.0 cm embryo, the yolk sac consists of six layers, viz. (1) somatic ectoderm; (2) somatic mesoderm; (3) extraembryonic coelom; (4) capillaries; (5) endoderm; and (6) yolk syncytium. The epithelial ectoderm is a simple cuboidal epithelium possessing the normal complement of cytoplasmic organelles. The endoplasmic cisternae are dilated and vesicular. The epithelium rests upon a basal lamina below which is a collagenous stroma that contains dense bodies of varying diameter. They have a dense marginal zone, a less dense core, and a dense center. The squamous mesoderm has many pinocytotic caveolae. The capillary endothelium is adjacent to the mesoderm and is delimited by a basal lamina. The endoderm contains yolk degradation vesicles whose contents range from pale to dense. The yolk syncytium contains many morphologically diverse yolk granules in all phases of degradation. Concentric membrane lamellae form around yolk bodies as the main yolk granules begin to be degraded. During degradation, yolk platelets exhibit a vesicular configuration.

Reproduction, placentation, and embryonic development of the Atlantic sharpnose shark, Rhizoprionodon terraenovae

The Atlantic sharpnose shark Rhizoprionodon terraenovae (Richardson) is a small carcharhinid that is a common year‐round resident along the southeast coast of the United States. It is viviparous and its embryos develop an epithelio‐vitelline placenta. Females enter shallow water to give birth in late May and early June. Mating occurs shortly after parturition, and four to seven eggs are ovulated. Fertilized eggs attain the blastoderm stage in early June to early July. Separate compartments for each egg are formed in the uterus when the embryos reach 3–30 mm. Embryos depend on yolk for the first 8 weeks of development. When embryos reach 72 mm their yolk supply is nearly depleted and they shift to matrotrophic nutrition. When the embryos reach 40–55 mm, placental development begins with the vascularization of the yolk sac where it contacts the uterine wall. Implantation occurs at an age of 8–10 weeks by which time the embryos reach 70–85 mm. The expanding yolk sac engulfs the maternal placental villi, and its surface interdigitates with the villi to form the placenta. The rest of the lumenal surface of the uterus is covered by non‐placental villi that appear shortly after implantation. Histotrophe production by the non‐placental villi begins just after their formation. The placenta grows continuously during gestation. The egg envelope is present throughout gestation, separating maternal and fetal tissues. Embryos develop numerous appendiculae on the umbilical cord. Young sharks are born at 290–320 mm after a gestation period of 11 to 12 months.

Ultrastructure of the full-term shark yolk sac placenta. I. Morphology and cellular transport at the fetal attachment site.

During ontogeny, the yolk sac of some viviparous sharks differentiates into a yolk sac placenta that persists to term. The placenta is non-invasive and non-deciduate. Hematrophic transport is the major route of nutrient transfer from mother to fetus. The placental unit consists of: (1) an umbilical stalk; (2) the smooth, proximal portion of the placenta; (3) the distal, rugose portion; (4) the egg envelope; and (5) the maternal uterine tissues. Exchange of metabolites is effected through the intervening egg envelope. The distal rugose portion of the placenta is the fetal attachment site. It consists of: (1) surface epithelial cells; (2) a collagenous stroma with vitelline capillaries; and (3) an innermost boundary cell layer. The columnar surface epithelial cells are closely apposed to the inner surface of the egg envelope. Wide spaces occur between the lateral margins of adjacent cells. Surface epithelial cells contain an extensive apical canalicular-tubular system and many whorl-like inclusions in their basal cytoplasm. Capillaries of the vitelline circulation are closely situated to these cells. A well-developed collagenous stroma separates the surface epithelium from an innermost boundary cell layer. In vitro exposure of full-term placentae to solutions of trypan blue and horseradish peroxidase (HRP) reveals little uptake by the smooth portion of the placenta but rapid absorption by the surface epithelial cells of the distal, rugose portion. HRP enters these cells by an extensive apical system of smooth-walled membranous anastomosing canaliculi and tubules. Prominent whorl-like inclusions that occupy the basal cytoplasm of the surface cells, adjacent to the pinocytotically active endothelium of the vitelline capillaries, are hypothesized to be yolk proteins that are transferred from the mother to embryo throughout gestation.

Follicular placenta of the viviparous fish, Heterandria formosa: II. Ultrastructure and development of the follicular epithelium

Embryos of the viviparous poeciliid fish, Heterandria formosa, develop to term in the ovarian follicle where they undergo a 3,900% increase in embryonic dry weight. Maternal‐embryonic nutrient transfer occurs across a follicular placenta that is formed by close apposition of the embryonic surface (i.e., the entire body surface during early gestation and the pericardial amnionserosa during mid‐late gestation) to the follicular epithelium. To complement our recent study of the embryonic component of the follicular placenta, we now describe the development and fine structure of the maternal component of the follicular placenta. Transmission electron microscopy reveals that the ultrastructure of the egg envelope and the follicular epithelium that invests vitellogenic oocytes is typical of that described for teleosts. The egg envelope is a dense matrix, penetrated by microvilli of the oocyte. The follicular epithelium consists of a single layer of cuboidal cells that lack apical microvilli, basal surface specializations, and junctional complexes. Follicle cells investing the youngest embryonic stage examined (Tavolgas and Rughs stage 5–7 for Xiphophorus maculatus) also lack apical microvilli and basal specializations, but possess junctional complexes. In contrast, follicle cells that invest embryos at stage 10 and later display ultrastructural features characteristic of transporting epithelial cells. Apical microvilli and surface invaginations are present. The basal surface is extensively folded. Apical and basal coated pits are present. The cytoplasm contains a rough endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi complexes, and dense staining vesicles that appear to be lysosomes. The presence of numerous apically located electron‐lucent vesicles that appear to be derived from the apical surface further suggests that these follicle cells may absorb and process follicular fluid. The egg envelope, which remains intact throughout gestation and lacks perforations, becomes progressively thinner and less dense as gestation proceeds. We postulate that these ultrastructural features, which are not present in the follicles of the lecithotrophic poeciliid, Poecilia reticulata, are specializations for maternal‐embryonic nutrient transfer and that the egg envelope, follicular epithelium, and underlying capillary network form the maternal component of the follicular placenta.

Viviparity and the maternal-embryonic relationship in the coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae

Embryos of Latimeria chalumnae develop in well-vascularized compartments in the uterine region of the right oviduct. Compartments conform to the shape of their embryos and yolksacs; they represent a stable, gestation-induced oviductal modification. Late-term pups possess large, flaccid, vascular yolksacs almost devoid of yolk. The sac is in close contact with, but does not adhere to, the lumenal uterine surface. A massive vascular plexus occurs in the wall of the compartment at the site of contact with the yolksac ; together they constitute a non-adherent, transposable placenta. The exterior surface of the yolksac is bounded by an attenuated, single-layered, squamous epithelium that surrounds an intercommunicating bed of cortical sinuses. The cortex of the sac is composed mostly of connective tissue stroma. The inner surface is bounded by a layer of yolk-digesting merocytes. Residual yolk occurs as yolk platelets that include yolk crystals. The interior surface of the sac is invested by an uniquely specialized vitelline circulation; no connection seems to exist between the interior of the yolksac and gut. The uterine wall consists of : (1) a lumenal surface composed of an anastomosing network of capillaries with a layer of attenuated, very thin, squamous epithelium, (2) a well-vascularized connective tissue stroma, (3) alternating transverse and longitudinal layers of smooth muscle, also well-vascularized, and (4) an external epithelial layer. Comparison of egg dry weight (184 g) with the estimated dry weights of a late-term pup (171 to 239 g) and a neonate (200 to 280 g) reveals a weight change of − 7 to + 30% and + 9 to + 52%, respectively. This is indicative of matrotrophy. In one female specimen, 19 remarkably large ovulated eggs were found and in another about 30 somewhat smaller ovarian ones. These are many more than ever could be accommodated in the uterine space. During the early and middle phases of development, embryos must be lecithotrophic, using their yolk reserves, with oophagy of fragmented supernumerary eggs as the most probable source of additional nutrients. The well-developed embryonic gut contains brown, amorphous yolk-like material. The limited amount of metachromatic secretory product of the uterine glands can play little or no role in embryonic nutrition.

Ultrastructure of the full-term shark yolk sac placenta: III. The maternal attachment site

During mid- and late gestation, the uterus of sandbar sharks possesses specialized sites for exchange of metabolites between the mother and fetus. Attachment sites are highly vascular, rugose elevations of the maternal uterine lining that interdigitate with the fetal placenta. The maternal epithelium remains intact and there is no erosion. The attachment site consists of a simple, low columnar juxtaluminal epithelium underlain by an extensive vascular network. Juxtaluminal epithelial cells possess branched microvilli, saccular invaginations of the apical surface, and coated pits. They contain numerous coated vesicles, lipid-like inclusions, a prominent rough endoplasmic reticulum, and many free ribosomes. Tight junctions join the luminal aspect of adjacent cells. Lateral cell boundaries are highly folded and interdigitated. Capillaries are closely apposed to the basal cell surfaces. The endothelium is pinocytotically active. Comparison with the uterine epithelium of non-placental sharks, mammalian epitheliochorial placentae, and selected transporting epithelia reveals that the structure of the maternal shark placenta is consistent with its putative multiple functions, viz: (1) nutrient transfer; (2) transport of macromolecules, e.g., immunoglobulins; (3) respiration; and (4) osmotic and ionic regulation.