John Radke

Determining a Relationship Between Applied Occlusal Load and Articulating Paper Mark Area

Articulating paper mark size has been widely accepted in the dental community to be descriptive of occlusal load. The objective of this study is to determine if any direct relationship exists between articulating paper mark area and applied occlusal load. A uniaxial testing machine repeatedly applied a compressive load, beginning at 25N and incrementally continuing up to 450N, to a pair of epoxy dental casts with articulating paper interposed. The resultant paper markings (n = 600) were photographed, and analyzed the mark area using a photographic image analysis and sketching program. A two-tailed Student’s t-test for unequal variances compared the measured size of the mark area between twelve different teeth (p < 0.05). Graphical interpretation of the data indicated that the mark area increased non-linearly with increasing load. When the data was grouped to compare consistency of the mark area between teeth, a high variability of mark area was observed between different teeth at the same applied load. The Student’s t-test found significant differences in the size of the mark area approximately 80% of the time. No direct relationship between paper mark area and applied load could be found, although the trend showed increasing mark area with elevating load. When selecting teeth to adjust, an operator should not assume the size of paper markings, accurately describing the markings’ occlusal contact force content.

A Force Reproduction Analysis of Two Recording Sensors of a Computerized Occlusal Analysis System

Abstract The purpose of this study was to measure the performance of a new design of occlusal sensor, the high definition (HD) sensor, and directly compare this sensor to the previous design. This new HD sensor design has increased active recording area by 33%, and decreased inactive recording area by 50% as compared to the previous design (G3). This was accomplished by determining the force reproduction variability for repeated occlusal closures on the same sensor for a sampling of sensors from both designs. Thirty (30) G3 and 30 HD sensors were consistently positioned and loaded 24 times between articulated epoxy casts by a Pneumatic Occlusal Force Simulator. Their force reproduction consistency was measured as an electronic voltage drop across six occlusal contacts that were consistently located on all sensors. The force variability of the two sensor designs was determined by comparing the consistency of the voltage drops across the six occlusal contacts. An analysis of variance was employed to determine the variability of force reproduction over multiple closures across six occlusal contact regions. For five of the six contacts, the G3 sensor mean variances, were significantly larger (p<0.05) than those of the HD sensor. The within sensor variability of the HD sensor was significantly less than that of the G3 sensor. Within the limitations of this study, the HD sensor exhibited less variable force reproduction than the G3 sensor for at least 20 in-laboratory loading cycles.

The Effect of Disclusion Time Reduction on Maximal Clench Muscle Activity Levels

Abstract Simultaneous recording of excursive function and muscle activity on 62 MPDS patients demonstrated that reducing prolonged disclusion time (1.4 seconds per excursion) to short disclusion time (0.41 seconds per excursion) created a therapeutic effect such that within one month’s time following treatment, there was an observed increase in the maximal clenching capacity of the masseter and temporalis muscles. This clinical treatment effect appears to be the result of decreased ischemia in these same muscles resultant from minimizing the time posterior teeth compress their periodontal ligament mechanoreceptors as these teeth are engaged and disengaged during excursive function.

Clinician accuracy when subjectively interpreting articulating paper markings

Abstract Aims: The aim of this study was to determine whether Subjective Interpretation of paper markings is a reliable method for identifying the relative occlusal force content of tooth contacts. Methodology: 295 clinicians selected the “Most Forceful” and “Least Forceful” occlusal contacts in six occlusal-view photographs of articulating paper marks that were later compared against computerized occlusal analysis relative occlusal force measurements of the same tooth contacts. Means and standard deviations were calculated by years in clinical practice and by number of occlusion courses taken. A Chi-square analysis was also performed. Results: The mean correct for 295 participant dentists was 1·53 (±1·234). There were no significant differences found for years in practice (P>0·16) or number of occlusion courses taken (P>0·75). The Chi-square analysis showed a sensitivity of 12·6%, a specificity of 12·4%, a positive predictive value of 12·58%, and a negative predictive value of 12·42%. Chance was calculated at 12·5% correct. Conclusions: Subjective Interpretation is an ineffective clinical method for determining the relative occlusal force content of tooth contacts. The reported low scores obtained from a large group of participant dentists suggest clinicians are unable to reliably differentiate high and low occlusal force from looking at articulating paper marks. This longstanding method of visually observing articulating paper marks for occlusal contact force content should be replaced with a measurement-based, objective method.

Artificial Neural Network Learns to Differentiate Normal TMJs and Nonreducing Displaced Disks after Training on Incisor-Point Chewing Movements

ABSTRACT Previous authors have described four frontal gum-chewing patterns associated with normal and abnormal TMJ disk-condyle relationships. The objective of this study was to create an automatic detection capability (expert system) by training an artificial neural network to recognize nonreducing displaced disks from frontal chewing data. Sixty-eight (68) subjects, 29 with normal joints, 18 with unilateral nonreducing displaced disks and 21 with bilateral nonreducing displaced disks were selected from a continuous series of patients seeking treatment for TMD. Right-sided gum chewing was recorded from all patients. Left-sided chewing was also recorded from the right unilateral patients. 50% of the vertical, lateral and timing values at 10%, 65% and 100% of opening and at 30%, 70% and 90% of closing were used to train an artificial neural network. The remaining 50% were used for testing. All normal subjects were detected as normal (specificity = 100%). Two bilateral and two unilateral patients were not detected (sensitivity = 91.8%). Four (4) patients received the wrong classification (unilateral vs. bilateral) and one patient received both (undecided) for an overall accuracy = 86.8%. The artificial neural network detected, at an acceptable level of error, the presence and type of nonreducing disk displacement from frontal plane jaw recordings of gum chewing in a group of real patients seeking treatment for TMD. Since it is very inexpensive to conduct, mastication analysis appears to have the potential of an excellent cost/benefit ratio.

Distribution of Temporomandibular Joint Vibration Transfer to the Opposite Side

Abstract A vibration produced when a displaced temporomandibular disc reduces during opening can transfer some of its energy from the ipsilateral joint to the contralateral joint. The objective of this study was to measure what percentage of the ipsilateral vibration is transferred to the contralateral joint. The study included the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) vibrations of 144 (informed consent) subjects, (113 F, 31 M), with reducing displaced discs (DDR). Vibrations from 165 joints were recorded bilaterally with BioJVA (BioResearch Associates, Inc. Milwaukee, WI). In each case, any contralateral vibration was analyzed to verify that it was caused by the ipsilateral joint. The contralateral amplitude was divided by the ipsilateral amplitude and multiplied by 100 to produce a percentage of transfer. The percentage values (0-100%) were used to create a Relative Frequency Histogram with 20 classes (1-5%, 6-10%, 11-15%, etc.). The Relative Frequency Histogram graph revealed a three-mounded distribution of the percentage of transfer. One mound fell between 5 and 34 percent, one between 35 and 69 percent and the third between 70 and 98 percent. The appearance of a three-mounded distribution suggests that there may be three different failure modes leading to TMJ internal derangements. Alternatively, it may be that failure of the disc’s stabilizing ligaments leads to three different internal derangement conditions that are in some way distinct. The evidence of apparent tri-modality in this vibration data distribution suggests that there may be three different failure modes of disc displacement with reduction (e.g., anterior, anteromedial, and medio-lateral disc displacement). If so, identifying them could allow for a more detailed description of DDR. Therefore, further investigation of this ‘tri-modal’ distribution should be undertaken.

Chewing movements altered in the presence of temporomandibular joint internal derangements

Abstract Aims: The objectives were to find specific factors that are mathematically distinct between the chewing timings, movement pattern shapes, variability, and movement velocities of: (1) normal asymptomatic subjects and (2) a group of subjects with verified temporomandibular joint (TMJ) internal derangements. Methodology: Left- and right-sided chewing movement recordings of 28 subjects (34·5±14·0 years) were randomly selected from a large database of patients exhibiting verified unilateral or bilateral TMJ internal derangements. The chewing movements of an age- and gender-matched control group of 20 asymptomatic subjects (32·5±11·6 years, P>0·60) with verified normal TMJ function were also recorded. Means and standard deviations of the opening, closing, turning point, terminal chewing position, and velocity patterns were calculated. A two-tailed Student’s t-test with unequal variances was used to compare the parameters between the two groups (alpha = 0·05). Results: The dysfunctional group functioned significantly slower and with greater variability than the control group. The vertical dimension was consistently smaller in the dysfunctional group (P<0·00001). The terminal chewing position was significantly less precise in the dysfunctional group (vertical: P<0·002 and lateral: P<0·037). The maximum lateral width was significantly less (P<0·0071), and the peak and the average velocities were significantly lower (P<0·00001 for both) in the dysfunctional group. Conclusions: This group of dysfunctional subjects exhibited significantly slower, smaller, and more variable chewing patterns than the control group. The functional pattern of mastication appears to be significantly altered in the presence of an internal derangement of the TMJ.

Wavelet transforms of TM joint vibrations: a feature extraction tool for detecting reducing displaced disks.

ABSTRACT The objective of this study was to determine if wavelet transforms (WTs) of vibrations recorded from temporomandibular joints (TMJs) with reducing displaced disks could be visually separated from WTs of vibrations recorded from normal TM joints by blinded observers. From a continuous series of 124 diagnosed TMD patients, 28 were confirmed with at least one reducing displaced disk. Vibrations were recorded from each affected joint, together with incisal point movements, using BioPAK (BioResearch, Inc., Milwaukee, Wl) during opening, closing, and lateral excursions. Identical recordings were taken from 28 patients who were determined to have normal “nondisplacing, nondisplaced” joints. A 3x7 Biorthogonal Spline Wavelet Transform was used to create three-dimensional time-frequency graphs of the vibration events for each subject. Printed copies of the graphs were then shown sequentially to seven blinded observers who were asked to separate them into two groups without any knowledge of their significance. Each observer was independently able to separate the two groups without committing more than one error. We conclude that the vibrations generated by reducing displaced disks are sufficiently different from the vibrations of normal joints to be separable by visual inspection of their respective wavelet transforms.

Gender Differences in Low and High Pain Palpation Thresholds in the TMJ and Neck Areas

Abstract The null hypothesis was that pain pressure thresholds are the same for young healthy males and females and do not differ between the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) and muscle sites. The aim of the current study was to compare pain pressure threshold levels using an algometer with a convex-formed contact piece and pressure increase rates similar to those in conventional finger palpation, making the conditions more like clinical examination of painful spots with commonly used physiotherapeutic methods. Healthy subjects, 12 male, mean age 22.5±1.62 (SD), and 12 female, 22.4±2.19 (SD), were enrolled. A transducer with a calibrated load range, 0 to 25 pounds, was used to measure pressure threshold levels for low (T1), VAS ~ 2, and high (T2), VAS ~ 8, pain levels bilaterally in the occipital (OC), sternocleidomastoid (SCM), upper trapezius (TU), transverse process of first vertebra (C1), and lateral temporomandibular joint (TMJ) areas. The null hypothesis was rejected. Levels T1 and T2 were significantly lower in the females in all tested areas. The range of the mean for T1 levels was 4.9 - 8.0 pounds for males and 3.2 - 5.1 pounds for females. For T2 levels, the range was 8.9 - 15.6 pounds for males and 6.2 - 10.3 pounds for females. Significant differences were found between muscle sites. These results support the use of different threshold levels: a) for males and females; and b) for different muscle areas.

Average chewing pattern improvements following Disclusion Time reduction.

Objectives: Studies involving electrognathographic (EGN) recordings of chewing improvements obtained following occlusal adjustment therapy are rare, as most studies lack ‘chewing’ within the research. The objectives of this study were to determine if reducing long Disclusion Time to short Disclusion Time with the immediate complete anterior guidance development (ICAGD) coronoplasty in symptomatic subjects altered their average chewing pattern (ACP) and their muscle function. Methods: Twenty-nine muscularly symptomatic subjects underwent simultaneous EMG and EGN recordings of right and left gum chewing, before and after the ICAGD coronoplasty. Statistical differences in the mean Disclusion Time, the mean muscle contraction cycle, and the mean ACP resultant from ICAGD underwent the Student’s paired t-test (α = 0.05). Results: Disclusion Time reductions from ICAGD were significant (2.11–0.45 s. p = 0.0000). Post-ICAGD muscle changes were significant in the mean area (p = 0.000001), the peak amplitude (p = 0.00005), the time to peak contraction (p < 0.000004), the time to 50% peak contraction (p < 0.00001), and in the decreased number of silent periods per side (right p < 0.0000002; left p < 0.0000006). Post-ICAGD ACP changes were also significant; the terminal chewing position became closer to centric occlusion (p < 0.002), the maximum and average chewing velocities increased (p < 0.002; p < 0.00005), the opening and closing times, the cycle time, and the occlusal contact time all decreased (p < 0.004–0.0001). Conclusion: The average chewing pattern (ACP) shape, speed, consistency, muscular coordination, and vertical opening improvements can be significantly improved in muscularly dysfunctional TMD patients within one week’s time of undergoing the ICAGD enameloplasty. Computer-measured and guided occlusal adjustments quickly and physiologically improved chewing, without requiring the patients to wear pre- or post-treatment appliances.