John T. Sessions

Crohn's disease: does race matter?

OBJECTIVE:The severity of Crohns disease (CD) has been reported to be greater in blacks than in whites. This possible disparity may be due, in part, to differences between these groups in health care utilization and accessibility. To explore these issues, we conducted a multicenter survey of patients with CD.METHODS:One-hundred and forty-five blacks with CD, recruited from four teaching hospitals and five private practices, and identified by medical record review or ICD-9 code, were enrolled and matched to 407 whites with CD (by age, gender, and practice type [teaching vs private practice setting]). Participants were interviewed regarding medical history, health status, personal health care practices during the preceding 5 yr, and beliefs regarding health care in the general population.RESULTS:Blacks and whites were similar with respect to age of CD onset, lag in time to diagnosis, and number of gastrointestinal (GI)-related hospitalizations and surgeries. Medication usage patterns were also similar in the two groups. Quality of life, measured by SF-36, was lower in all categories for blacks, compared with whites. Blacks were more likely to have had to stop work (p < 0.01) and have lost more work days (p < 0.01) than were whites. Whites were more likely to have health insurance and be able to identify a regular provider than were blacks. Blacks were more likely to report the following: receiving Medicaid; difficulty affording health care; delaying appointments due to financial concerns; difficulty traveling to their providers office; and experiencing unreasonable delays at their providers office. After adjusting for potential confounding variables, we found no differences between the groups, except for the number of days of work lost because of CD.CONCLUSIONS:These data suggest that black and white patients have similar reported disease presentations and course, and contrast with prior reports suggesting a more severe disease course among black patients. Although the disease itself appears similar, there were numerous reported differences between the races in health care utilization practices and in disease impact upon daily activities. We suggest that apparent disparities in CD according to race are actually due to social and economic factors, and not to the disease itself.

Crohn's disease: does race matter? The Mid-Atlantic Crohn's Disease Study Group.

OBJECTIVE:The severity of Crohns disease (CD) has been reported to be greater in blacks than in whites. This possible disparity may be due, in part, to differences between these groups in health care utilization and accessibility. To explore these issues, we conducted a multicenter survey of patients with CD.METHODS:One-hundred and forty-five blacks with CD, recruited from four teaching hospitals and five private practices, and identified by medical record review or ICD-9 code, were enrolled and matched to 407 whites with CD (by age, gender, and practice type [teaching vs private practice setting]). Participants were interviewed regarding medical history, health status, personal health care practices during the preceding 5 yr, and beliefs regarding health care in the general population.RESULTS:Blacks and whites were similar with respect to age of CD onset, lag in time to diagnosis, and number of gastrointestinal (GI)-related hospitalizations and surgeries. Medication usage patterns were also similar in the two groups. Quality of life, measured by SF-36, was lower in all categories for blacks, compared with whites. Blacks were more likely to have had to stop work (p < 0.01) and have lost more work days (p < 0.01) than were whites. Whites were more likely to have health insurance and be able to identify a regular provider than were blacks. Blacks were more likely to report the following: receiving Medicaid; difficulty affording health care; delaying appointments due to financial concerns; difficulty traveling to their providers office; and experiencing unreasonable delays at their providers office. After adjusting for potential confounding variables, we found no differences between the groups, except for the number of days of work lost because of CD.CONCLUSIONS:These data suggest that black and white patients have similar reported disease presentations and course, and contrast with prior reports suggesting a more severe disease course among black patients. Although the disease itself appears similar, there were numerous reported differences between the races in health care utilization practices and in disease impact upon daily activities. We suggest that apparent disparities in CD according to race are actually due to social and economic factors, and not to the disease itself.

Potential economic impact of applying DRG-based prospective payment categories to inflammatory bowel disease patients

New incentives regarding delivery of inpatient care by physicians and administrators have resulted from Medicares DRG-based prospective reimbursement system. As these payment systems become widely adopted by other third-party payors, implications for adequate hospital reimbursement and quality inpatient care will intensify. This study of inflammatory bowel disease inpatients examines discharge data for 300 patients comprising 507 admissions from 1983 to 1987 at a large tertiary center hospital. While only 10.8% of these discharges were Medicare patients, all discharges were assigned a diagnosis-related-group reimbursement to derive a theoretical monetary loss or gain for the hospital. Overall hospital losses averaged

Crohn's disease: does race matter|[quest]|

127.24 per case for this patient population, in which the medical and pediatric cases were adequately reimbursed, and the surgical admissions represented greater losses. The average length of stay for all patients decreased from 11.9 to 7.4 days over the study period, mostly a result of reductions in surgical hospital stays. We conclude that reimbursement for medical and pediatric discharges under DRG 179 appear adequate for this hospital, while surgical inflammatory bowel disease reimbursement is not. These data will be useful for comparison of future trends of inpatient utilization for inflammatory bowel disease patients as prospective reimbursement practices become more widespread.

National Cooperative Crohn's Disease Study: Results of Drug Treatment

OBJECTIVE:The severity of Crohns disease (CD) has been reported to be greater in blacks than in whites. This possible disparity may be due, in part, to differences between these groups in health care utilization and accessibility. To explore these issues, we conducted a multicenter survey of patients with CD.METHODS:One-hundred and forty-five blacks with CD, recruited from four teaching hospitals and five private practices, and identified by medical record review or ICD-9 code, were enrolled and matched to 407 whites with CD (by age, gender, and practice type [teaching vs private practice setting]). Participants were interviewed regarding medical history, health status, personal health care practices during the preceding 5 yr, and beliefs regarding health care in the general population.RESULTS:Blacks and whites were similar with respect to age of CD onset, lag in time to diagnosis, and number of gastrointestinal (GI)-related hospitalizations and surgeries. Medication usage patterns were also similar in the two groups. Quality of life, measured by SF-36, was lower in all categories for blacks, compared with whites. Blacks were more likely to have had to stop work (p < 0.01) and have lost more work days (p < 0.01) than were whites. Whites were more likely to have health insurance and be able to identify a regular provider than were blacks. Blacks were more likely to report the following: receiving Medicaid; difficulty affording health care; delaying appointments due to financial concerns; difficulty traveling to their providers office; and experiencing unreasonable delays at their providers office. After adjusting for potential confounding variables, we found no differences between the groups, except for the number of days of work lost because of CD.CONCLUSIONS:These data suggest that black and white patients have similar reported disease presentations and course, and contrast with prior reports suggesting a more severe disease course among black patients. Although the disease itself appears similar, there were numerous reported differences between the races in health care utilization practices and in disease impact upon daily activities. We suggest that apparent disparities in CD according to race are actually due to social and economic factors, and not to the disease itself.