Jonathan Barratt

The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: rationale, clinicopathological correlations, and classification

IgA nephropathy is the most common glomerular disease worldwide, yet there is no international consensus for its pathological or clinical classification. Here a new classification for IgA nephropathy is presented by an international consensus working group. The goal of this new system was to identify specific pathological features that more accurately predict risk of progression of renal disease in IgA nephropathy, thus enabling both clinicians and pathologists to improve individual patient prognostication. In a retrospective analysis, sequential clinical data were obtained on 265 adults and children with IgA nephropathy who were followed for a median of 5 years. Renal biopsies from all patients were scored by pathologists blinded to the clinical data for pathological variables identified as reproducible by an iterative process. Four of these variables: (1) the mesangial hypercellularity score, (2) segmental glomerulosclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, and (4) tubular atrophy/interstitial fibrosis were subsequently shown to have independent value in predicting renal outcome. These specific pathological features withstood rigorous statistical analysis even after taking into account all clinical indicators available at the time of biopsy as well as during follow-up. The features have prognostic significance and we recommended they be taken into account for predicting outcome independent of the clinical features both at the time of presentation and during follow-up. The value of crescents was not addressed due to their low prevalence in the enrolled cohort.

The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility

Pathological classifications in current use for the assessment of glomerular disease have been typically opinion-based and built on the expert assumptions of renal pathologists about lesions historically thought to be relevant to prognosis. Here we develop a unique approach for the pathological classification of a glomerular disease, IgA nephropathy, in which renal pathologists first undertook extensive iterative work to define pathologic variables with acceptable inter-observer reproducibility. Where groups of such features closely correlated, variables were further selected on the basis of least susceptibility to sampling error and ease of scoring in routine practice. This process identified six pathologic variables that could then be used to interrogate prognostic significance independent of the clinical data in IgA nephropathy (described in the accompanying article). These variables were (1) mesangial cellularity score; percentage of glomeruli showing (2) segmental sclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, or (4) cellular/fibrocellular crescents; (5) percentage of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy; and finally (6) arteriosclerosis score. Results for interobserver reproducibility of individual pathological features are likely applicable to other glomerulonephritides, but it is not known if the correlations between variables depend on the specific type of glomerular pathobiology. Variables identified in this study withstood rigorous pathology review and statistical testing and we recommend that they become a necessary part of pathology reports for IgA nephropathy. Our methodology, translating a strong evidence-based dataset into a working format, is a model for developing classifications of other types of renal disease.

Discovery of new risk loci for IgA nephropathy implicates genes involved in immunity against intestinal pathogens

We performed a genome-wide association study (GWAS) of IgA nephropathy (IgAN), the most common form of glomerulonephritis, with discovery and follow-up in 20,612 individuals of European and East Asian ancestry. We identified six new genome-wide significant associations, four in ITGAM-ITGAX, VAV3 and CARD9 and two new independent signals at HLA-DQB1 and DEFA. We replicated the nine previously reported signals, including known SNPs in the HLA-DQB1 and DEFA loci. The cumulative burden of risk alleles is strongly associated with age at disease onset. Most loci are either directly associated with risk of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) or maintenance of the intestinal epithelial barrier and response to mucosal pathogens. The geospatial distribution of risk alleles is highly suggestive of multi-locus adaptation, and genetic risk correlates strongly with variation in local pathogens, particularly helminth diversity, suggesting a possible role for host–intestinal pathogen interactions in shaping the genetic landscape of IgAN.

Validation of the Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy in cohorts with different presentations and treatments

The Oxford Classification of IgA Nephropathy (IgAN) identified mesangial hypercellularity (M), endocapillary proliferation (E), segmental glomerulosclerosis (S), and tubular atrophy/interstitial fibrosis (T) as independent predictors of outcome. Whether it applies to individuals excluded from the original study and how therapy influences the predictive value of pathology remain uncertain. The VALIGA study examined 1147 patients from 13 European countries that encompassed the whole spectrum of IgAN. Over a median follow-up of 4.7 years, 86% received renin–angiotensin system blockade and 42% glucocorticoid/immunosuppressive drugs. M, S, and T lesions independently predicted the loss of estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and a lower renal survival. Their value was also assessed in patients not represented in the Oxford cohort. In individuals with eGFR less than 30 ml/min per 1.73 m2, the M and T lesions independently predicted a poor survival. In those with proteinuria under 0.5 g/day, both M and E lesions were associated with a rise in proteinuria to 1 or 2 g/day or more. The addition of M, S, and T lesions to clinical variables significantly enhanced the ability to predict progression only in those who did not receive immunosuppression (net reclassification index 11.5%). The VALIGA study provides a validation of the Oxford classification in a large European cohort of IgAN patients across the whole spectrum of the disease. The independent predictive value of pathology MEST score is reduced by glucocorticoid/immunosuppressive therapy.

The Oxford IgA nephropathy clinicopathological classification is valid for children as well as adults

To study the predictive value of biopsy lesions in IgA nephropathy in a range of patient ages we retrospectively analyzed the cohort that was used to derive a new classification system for IgA nephropathy. A total of 206 adults and 59 children with proteinuria over 0.5 g/24 h/1.73 m(2) and an eGFR of stage-3 or better were followed for a median of 69 months. At the time of biopsy, compared with adults children had a more frequent history of macroscopic hematuria, lower adjusted blood pressure, and higher eGFR but similar proteinuria. Although their outcome was similar to that of adults, children had received more immunosuppressants and achieved a lower follow-up proteinuria. Renal biopsies were scored for variables identified by an iterative process as reproducible and independent of other lesions. Compared with adults, children had significantly more mesangial and endocapillary hypercellularity, and less segmental glomerulosclerosis and tubulointerstitial damage, the four variables previously identified to predict outcome independent of clinical assessment. Despite these differences, our study found that the cross-sectional correlation between pathology and proteinuria was similar in adults and children. The predictive value of each specific lesion on the rate of decline of renal function or renal survival in IgA nephropathy was not different between children and adults.

An update on the pathogenesis and treatment of IgA nephropathy.

Over the past two decades significant progress has been made in unravelling the complex pathogenesis of immunoglobulin A nephropathy (IgAN). Excess amounts of poorly galactosylated immunoglobulin (Ig)A1 in the serum appear to be the trigger for generation of glycan-specific IgG and IgA autoantibodies, resulting in the formation of circulating IgA immune complexes, which are pivotal to the development of nephritis. It remains unclear why there is an increase in poorly galactosylated IgA1 molecules in the serum in IgAN. One intriguing possibility is that this IgA is derived from displaced mucosal B cells, which have mis-homed from their mucosal induction sites to systemic sites, where they secrete polymeric, poorly galactosylated IgA directly into the circulation rather than onto mucosal surfaces. Lack of a clear appreciation of the origins of poorly galactosylated IgA1 and an incomplete understanding of immune complex formation have hampered development of specific therapeutic strategies to prevent mesangial IgA deposition. Clinicians have therefore been left to manage patients with generic therapies, mainly by control of blood pressure and renin-angiotensin blockade. A paucity of high-quality clinical trials has meant that evaluation of additional therapies, particularly immunosuppressive regimens, has been difficult and there remains a great deal of confusion over the optimum treatment of patients at high risk of progressive chronic kidney disease.

O-Glycosylation of Serum IgA1 Antibodies against Mucosal and Systemic Antigens in IgA Nephropathy

In IgA nephropathy (IgAN), serum IgA1 with abnormal O-glycosylation deposits in the glomerular mesangium. The underlying mechanism of this IgA1 O-glycosylation abnormality is poorly understood, but recent evidence argues against a generic defect in B cell glycosyltransferases, suggesting that only a subpopulation of IgA1-committed B cells are affected. For investigation of whether the site of antigen encounter influences IgA1 O-glycosylation, the O-glycosylation of serum IgA1 antibodies against a systemic antigen, tetanus toxoid (TT), and a mucosal antigen, Helicobacter pylori (HP), was studied in patients with IgAN and control subjects. Serum IgA1 was purified from cohorts of patients with IgAN and control subjects with HP infection and after systemic TT immunization. The IgA1 samples were applied to HP- and TT-coated immunoplates to immobilize specific antibodies, and IgA1 O-glycosylation profiles were assessed by binding of the O-glycan-specific lectin Vicia villosa using a modified ELISA technique. Although total serum IgA1 had raised lectin binding in IgAN, the O-glycosylation of the specific IgA1 antibodies to TT and HP did not differ between patients and control subjects. In both groups, IgA1 anti-HP had higher lectin binding than IgA1 anti-TT. This study demonstrates that IgA1 O-glycosylation normally varies in different immune responses and that patients produce the full spectrum of IgA1 O-glycoforms. IgA1 with high lectin binding was produced in response to mucosal HP infection in all subjects. The raised circulating level of this type of IgA1 in IgAN is likely to be a consequence of abnormal systemic responses to mucosally encountered antigens rather than a fundamental defect in B cell O-glycosylation pathways.

O-Glycosylation of Serum IgD in IgA Nephropathy

In IgA nephropathy (IgAN), serum IgA1 with abnormal O-glycosylation preferentially deposits in the glomerular mesangium. The control of O-glycosylation is poorly understood. Among Ig isotypes, only IgD, produced early in B cell development, and IgA1, produced by mature B cells, are O-glycosylated. For investigation of the stage of B cell maturation at which the defect seen in IgAN arises, the O-glycosylation of serum IgA1 and IgD was studied in IgAN and controls. Serum was obtained from 20 patients with IgAN and 20 control subjects. The O-glycosylation profiles of native and desialylated IgA1 and IgD were measured in an ELISA-type system using the lectins Helix aspersa and peanut agglutinin, which bind to alternative forms of O-glycan moieties. The lectin-binding patterns of the two immunoglobulins differed in all participants, with that of IgD suggesting that it is more heavily galactosylated than IgA1. Defective O-glycosylation of IgA1, probably taking the form of reduced galactosylation, was confirmed in IgAN in this study. This undergalactosylation was not shared by IgD; in contrast, IgD carried more galactosylated O-glycans in IgAN than controls. The contrasting lectin-binding patterns of IgA1 and IgD shows that Ig O-glycosylation is differentially controlled during B cell maturation. Compared with controls, O-glycosylation in IgAN is incomplete in IgA1 but more complete in IgD. These observations show that abnormal IgA1 O-glycosylation in IgAN is not due to an inherent defect in glycosylation mechanisms but arises only at a later stage in B cell development and may be secondary to aberrant immunoregulation.

Immunopathogenesis of IgAN

The defining hallmark of IgA nephropathy (IgAN) is deposition of polymeric IgA1 in the glomerular mesangium accompanied by a mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis. The mechanisms involved in mesangial polymeric IgA1 deposition and the initiation of inflammatory glomerular injury remain unclear. This lack of a complete understanding of the pathogenesis of IgAN has meant that there is still no treatment known to modify mesangial deposition of IgA. Increasing evidence, however, supports the importance of IgA-containing immune complex formation as a pivotal factor driving mesangial IgA deposition and triggering of glomerular injury. A number of potentially important changes to the IgA1 molecule have been identified in IgAN, which may contribute to immune complex formation. These changes suggest that the polymeric IgA1 that deposits in IgA nephropathy is derived from mucosally primed plasma cells. The presence of this IgA in the circulation reflects displacement of mucosal B lineage cells to systemic sites and may be the result of mishoming of lymphocytes trafficking along the mucosa–bone marrow axis.

Oxford Classification of IgA nephropathy 2016: an update from the IgA Nephropathy Classification Working Group

Since the Oxford Classification of IgA nephropathy (IgAN) was published in 2009, MEST scores have been increasingly used in clinical practice. Further retrospective cohort studies have confirmed that in biopsy specimens with a minimum of 8 glomeruli, mesangial hypercellularity (M), segmental sclerosis (S), and interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy (T) lesions predict clinical outcome. In a larger, more broadly based cohort than in the original Oxford study, crescents (C) are predictive of outcome, and we now recommend that C be added to the MEST score, and biopsy reporting should provide a MEST-C score. Inconsistencies in the reporting of M and endocapillary cellularity (E) lesions have been reported, so a web-based educational tool to assist pathologists has been developed. A large study showed E lesions are predictive of outcome in children and adults, but only in those without immunosuppression. A review of S lesions suggests there may be clinical utility in the subclassification of segmental sclerosis, identifying those cases with evidence of podocyte damage. It has now been shown that combining the MEST score with clinical data at biopsy provides the same predictive power as monitoring clinical data for 2 years; this requires further evaluation to assess earlier effective treatment intervention. The IgAN Classification Working Group has established a well-characterized dataset from a large cohort of adults and children with IgAN that will provide a substrate for further studies to refine risk prediction and clinical utility, including the MEST-C score and other factors.