Jonathan Glover

Should the child live? Doctors, families and conflict

It is a terrible thing to let a child die against the deeply held and clearly expressed view of the childs parents. Yet it could be claimed that there are some conditions so burdensome that it may also be a terrible thing to deny a child the escape of death. The focus of this piece is on three ethical issues relating to withholding and withdrawal of treatment in a neonatal and paediatric context. The first is whether there are other interests that should be considered as well as those of the child. The second is how we should think about the interests of the child. The third is a set of issues raised by cases where the medical team and the family reach different conclusions about what it is best to do. Reference is made to the recent cases of Charlotte Wyatt and Luke Winston-Jones.

The Idea of Progress in Medical Ethics

All current discussions of medical ethics take place against a background shaped by two factors, one of which is obvious and one of which is not.