Joohyun Rhee

Consolidating behavioral and neurophysiologic findings to explain the influence of contextual interference during motor sequence learning

Motor sequence learning under high levels of contextual interference (CI) disrupts initial performance but supports delayed test and transfer performance when compared to learning under low CI. Integrating findings from early behavioral work and more recent experimental efforts that incorporated neurophysiologic measures led to a novel account of the role of CI during motor sequence learning. This account focuses on important contributions from two neural regions—the dorsal premotor area and the SMA complex—that are recruited earlier and more extensively during the planning of a motor sequence in a high CI context. It is proposed that activation of these regions is critical to early adaptation of sequence structure amenable to long-term storage. Moreover, greater CI enhances access to newly acquired motor sequence knowledge through (1) the emergence of temporary functional connectivity between neural sites previously described as crucial to successful long-term performance of sequential behaviors, and (2) heightened excitability of M1—a key constituent of the temporary coupled neural circuits, and the primary candidate for storage of motor memory.

Offline Improvement during Motor Sequence Learning Is Not Restricted to Developing Motor Chunks

ABSTRACT Robust offline performance gains, beyond those that would be anticipated by being exposed to additional physical practice, have been reported during procedural learning and have been attributed to enhancement consolidation, a process by which memory is transformed in such a way that it is not only more resistant to forgetting but may also involve a reorganization of information that supports superior task execution. The authors assessed the impact of increasing within-session practice extent on the emergence of offline performance gains. Practice-dependent improvements occurred across 12 and 24 30-s practice trials of a 5-element motor sequencing task. Offline improvements were observed following both 12 and 24 trials. The improvement following 12 trials was associated with the formation of motor chunks important for establishing movement sequence structure. In contrast, the offline improvement after 24 trials was not related to further changes in movement structure beyond those that had emerged during practice. These data suggest that additional memory operations, beyond those needed to amalgamate subsequences of the SRT task, are susceptible to enhancement consolidation.

Rhythmical bimanual force production: homologous and non-homologous muscles

Abstract The experiment was designed to determine participants’ ability to coordinate a bimanual multifrequency pattern of isometric forces using homologous or non-homologous muscles. Lissajous feedback was provided to reduce perceptual and attentional constraints. The primary purpose was to determine whether the activation of homologous and non-homologous muscles resulted in different patterns of distortions in the left limb forces that are related to the forces produced by the right limb. The task was to rhythmically produce a 1:2 pattern of isometric forces by exerting isometric forces on the left side force transducer with the left arm that was coordinated with the pattern of isometric forces produced on the right side force transducer with the right arm. The results indicated that participants were able to ‘tune-in’ a 1:2 coordination patterns using homologous (triceps muscles of the left and right limbs) and using non-homologous muscles (biceps left limb and triceps right limb) when provided Lissajous feedback. However, distinct but consistent and identifiable distortions in the left limb force traces were observed for both the homologous and non-homologous tasks. For the homologous task, the interference occurred in the left limb when the right limb was initiating and releasing force. For the non-homologous task, the interference in the left limb force occurred only when the right limb was releasing force. In both conditions, the interference appeared to continue from the point of force initiation and/or release to peak force velocity. The overall results are consistent with the notion that neural crosstalk manifests differently during the coordination of the limbs depending upon whether homologous or non-homologous muscles are activated.

The Structural Relationship Between Two Motor Sequences Practiced Close in Time Impacts Offline Facilitation

ABSTRACT Robust offline gains occur during explicit motor sequence learning. However practice of a motor sequence, other than the target sequence, within 4–6 hr after initial practice interferes with these gains. This work assessed if experiencing supplemental practice of spatially or motorically similar sequences influenced the extent of offline gain. A contemporary model of sequence learning assumes that exposure to a spatially but not motor-related sequence would not compromise stabilization of the memory for the target sequence, thus, would have minimal impact on the resultant offline gain and possibly amplify overnight gains. As anticipated, a reliable offline improvement was observed for the target motor sequence in the absence of practice with an alternative motor sequence. This gain was significantly reduced when the learner experienced additional practice with either a novel or motorically similar sequence. There was no evidence of heightened overnight gain for the target sequence from intervening practice with a spatially similar sequence. Thus, the expression of offline improvement is not necessarily eliminated if practice of an alternative motor sequence is encountered shortly after a target sequence. However, the structure of the motor sequence faced during intervening practice can impact the resultant postpractice consolidation processes reflected in the eventual expression of offline facilitation.

Allowing time to consolidate knowledge gained through random practice facilitates later novel motor sequence acquisition.

Two experiments were conducted to examine the efficacy of random (RP) and blocked practice (BP) for enhancing later motor learning. Each experiment involved practicing three unique seven key serial reaction time (SRT) tasks in either a blocked or random format followed by practice of a novel SRT task either 2-min (Experiment 1) or 24-h (Experiment 2) later. While the expected benefit of RP for retention was present in both experiments, in Experiment 1 there was no advantage from prior RP for new learning. Experiment 2 explored the possibility that increasing the interval, from 2-min to 24-h, between BP or RP and practice of the novel motor task might allow consolidation of sequence knowledge acquired during BP or RP which in turn might facilitate new learning. As a result of the additional time between training bouts RP facilitated the rate at which the novel motor task was acquired. Interestingly, when this additional time was provided, both BP and RP supported (a) a performance saving for the first trial with the novel task, and (b) an offline improvement in performance across a 24-h interval not present when only the novel motor task was practiced. The latter benefits for new learning may have resulted from exposure to prior physical practice per se. or practice variability. These data are discussed with respect to (a) future learning benefits from prior experience training with greater CI, and (b) the importance of memory consolidation for motor learning.

The influence of asymmetric force requirements on a multi-frequency bimanual coordination task

An experiment was designed to determine the impact of the force requirements on the production of bimanual 1:2 coordination patterns requiring the same (symmetric) or different (asymmetric) forces when Lissajous displays and goal templates are provided. The Lissajous displays have been shown to minimize the influence of attentional and perceptual constraints allowing constraints related to neural crosstalk to be more clearly observed. Participants (N=20) were randomly assigned to a force condition in which the left or right limb was required to produce more force than the contralateral limb. In each condition participants were required to rhythmically coordinate the pattern of isometric forces in a 1:2 coordination pattern. Participant performed 13 practice trials and 1 test trial per force level. The results indicated that participants were able to effectively coordinate the 1:2 multi-frequency goal patterns under both symmetric and asymmetric force requirements. However, consistent distortions in the force and force velocity time series were observed for one limb that appeared to be associated with the production of force in the contralateral limb. Distortions in the force produced by the left limb occurred regardless of the force requirements of the task (symmetric, asymmetric) or whether the left or right limb had to produce more force than the contralateral limb. However, distinct distortions in the right limb occurred only when the left limb was required to produce 5 times more force than the right limb. These results are consistent with the notion that neural crosstalk can influence both limbs, but may manifest differently for each limb depending on the force requirements of the task.

Neuromuscular Control and Performance Differences Associated With Gender and Obesity in Fatiguing Tasks Performed by Older Adults

Obesity rates in the geriatric population have emerged as a serious health concern in recent decades. Yet, obesity-related differences in neuromuscular performance and motor control during fatiguing tasks, and how they are modified by gender, specifically among older adults, are still largely unexplored. The first aim of this study was to understand obesity and gender-related differences in endurance time among older adults. Motor variability has been linked with inter-individual differences in the rate of fatigue development, and as potentially revealing underlying mechanisms of neuromuscular control. Hence, the second and third aims of this study were to investigate to what extent motor variability at baseline could predict inter-individual differences in endurance time, and whether systematic obesity and gender differences exist in motor variability among older adults. Fifty-nine older adults (65 years or older) were recruited into four groups: obese male, obese female, non-obese male, and non-obese female. Participants performed submaximal intermittent isometric knee extensions until exhaustion. Knee extension force and muscle activation signals (surface electromyography) of a primary agonist muscle, the Vastus Lateralis (VL), were collected. Endurance time and metrics quantifying both the size and structure of variability were computed for the force and EMG signals, using coefficient of variation (within cycles and between cycles) and sample entropy measures. While group differences in endurance time were primarily associated with gender, adding individual motor variability measures as predictor variables explained significantly more variance in endurance time, thus highlighting the relevance of motor variability in understanding neuromotor control strategies. Males exhibited longer endurance times, higher EMG CV, lower EMG SaEn, lower force CV, and higher force SaEn than females. These findings are interpreted to indicate males as using a motor strategy involving better “distribution” of the neural efforts across synergists and antagonists to achieve better performance during the knee extension task. No obesity-related changes in endurance time were found. However, obese individuals exhibited a greater cycle-to-cycle variability in muscle activation, indicating a larger alteration in the recruitment of motor units across successive contractions and potentially increased neural costs, which may have contributed to comparable endurance time and performance as non-obese older adults.

Task and sex differences in muscle oxygenation during handgrip fatigue development

Abstract The purpose of this study was to examine task and sex differences in forearm muscle oxygenation, measured using near infrared spectroscopy, during sustained submaximal handgrip exercises. Forty-eight adults (50% males) performed fatiguing handgrip exercises at 20, 40, 60 and 80% of their maximum handgrip strength. While males and females exhibited similar levels of relative fatigability, forearm oxygenation was found to be task (i.e. contraction intensity and phase of fatigue development) and sex dependent. Higher contraction intensities were associated with greater desaturation over time. Compared to females, males exhibited greater desaturation as fatigue progressed and this was augmented at higher contraction intensities. These may be likely affected by sex differences in muscle mass, morphology and strength differences during exercises at relative intensities. Future work that explores sex differences in muscle oxygenation during absolute force intensities are needed, which may have implications for muscle fatigue development and potential fatigue mitigation strategies. Practitioner Summary: Muscle oxygenation impacts fatigue development that can in turn affect worker health and productivity. Males exhibit greater forearm desaturation than females at higher relative work intensities, despite similar fatigue levels. Females may be predisposed to greater muscle delivery and oxygenation challenges that can increase their fatigability during work at absolute load levels.

Effect of Social Stress on Motor Function in Older Adults: an fNIRS Investigation

Stress has adverse impacts on mental and physical health and quality of life, especially in older adults. Stress can impair cognitive function including short and long-term memory, and this functional declines can further be associated with decreased neuromuscular performance (Mehta & Parasuraman, 2014) and increased fatigability (Keller-Ross et al., 2014). Since older adults are more susceptible to the effect of stress because their limited mobility caused by aging can worsen under stress (Noven at al., 2014), it is important to examine the effect of acute stress on neuromuscular function in older adults. In the present study, we tested the effect of social stress on neuromuscular function of both upper and lower extremity in older adults before and after a short bout of social stress. Thirty participants (15 males, 15 females, mean age: 73.3 (5.6) yrs) performed ten trials of submaximal voluntary contraction at 30% of their maximum voluntary contraction force level before and after the Trier Social Stress Test (TSST) session. Handgrip and knee extension motor performance was measured on separate days. TSST consisted of five minutes speech and five minutes serial arithmetic subtraction tasks. We measured force steadiness and electromyography (EMG) of working muscles to evaluate motor function. Additionally, electrocardiogram (ECG), the Visual Analogue Scale of Stress (VAS), and salivary cortisol were collected to evaluate the effect of the TSST. Neural activation pattern changes of prefrontal and sensorimotor area during exercise and TSST sessions was recorded using functional Near Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS). To confirm whether the TSST session increased stress level in our participants, we first analysed the stress metrics. Heart rate increased during the TSST and returned to prestress level instantly after the TSST session. Perceived stress level using the VAS increased after TSST. While not significant, salivary cortisol level increased after the TSST session. Findings indicate that handgrip force steadiness improved after the TSST session, whereas knee extension force steadiness remained unchanged. On the other hand, handgrip EMG root mean square (RMS) did not change after stress while knee extension EMG RMS was found to increase. Neural activation during handgrip exercise increased at the left motor area, and neural activation during knee extension increased at the left sensory area after the TSST session. Change of heart rate and VAS indicates that participants’ stress level was increased after stress and the improved motor performance during handgrip exercise after the stress is consistent with a previous study that reported increased memory function after stress in older adults (Pulopulos et al., 2015). However, the differential effects of stress based on upper or lower extremity indicates increased sensitivity of certain motor tasks to social stress than other. While social stress is known to affect response time but not memory function (Guez et al., 2016), different spatial activation pattern between handgrip and knee extension exercises observed in the present study suggest that different neural strategies were adapted to compensate for the effects of acute social stress to maintain motor performance.

Muscle Oxygenation Correlates of Handgrip Fatigue with Obesity

The aims of this study were to determine obesity-related muscle oxygenation correlates of submaximal fatigue, across 20, 40, 60, and 80% of maximum voluntary contractions (MVC). 72 normal weight, overweight and obese adults, matched by gender, performed the four endurance tests on different days. Muscle oxygenation of the flexor and extensor carpi radialis were measured by near infrared spectroscopy and endurance time was recorded for each test. The findings indicated that obesity-related reduction in handgrip endurance was evident at low force contraction levels. Obesity was associated with impaired muscle oxygenation; however, the changes were independent of force contraction levels. Muscle oxygenation did not directly limit the time to failure for endurance tests at higher force levels. Thus, it is likely that factors other than local metabolic and hemodynamic changes impede fatigue resistance at higher force contraction levels.