Józef R. Lewandowski

Proton assisted recoupling and protein structure determination.

We introduce a homonuclear version of third spin assisted recoupling, a second-order mechanism that can be used for polarization transfer between (13)C or (15)N spins in magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR experiments, particularly at high spinning frequencies employed in contemporary high field MAS experiments. The resulting sequence, which we refer to as proton assisted recoupling (PAR), relies on a cross-term between (1)H-(13)C (or (1)H-(15)N) couplings to mediate zero quantum (13)C-(13)C (or (15)N-(15)N recoupling). In particular, using average Hamiltonian theory we derive an effective Hamiltonian for PAR and show that the transfer is mediated by trilinear terms of the form C(1) (+/-)C(2) (-/+)H(Z) for (13)C-(13)C recoupling experiments (or N(1) (+/-)N(2) (-/+)H(Z) for (15)N-(15)N). We use analytical and numerical simulations to explain the structure of the PAR optimization maps and to delineate the PAR matching conditions. We also detail the PAR polarization transfer dependence with respect to the local molecular geometry and explain the observed reduction in dipolar truncation. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of PAR in structural studies of proteins with (13)C-(13)C spectra of uniformly (13)C, (15)N labeled microcrystalline Crh, a 85 amino acid model protein that forms a domain swapped dimer (MW=2 x 10.4 kDa). The spectra, which were acquired at high MAS frequencies (omega(r)2pi>20 kHz) and magnetic fields (750-900 MHz (1)H frequencies) using moderate rf fields, exhibit numerous cross peaks corresponding to long (up to 6-7 A) (13)C-(13)C distances which are particularly useful in protein structure determination. Using results from PAR spectra we calculate the structure of the Crh protein.

High-resolution solid-state NMR structure of a 17.6 kDa protein.

The use of pseudocontact shifts arising from paramagnetic metal ions in a microcrystalline protein sample is proposed as a strategy to obtain unambiguous signal assignments in solid-state NMR spectra enabling distance extraction for protein structure calculation. With this strategy, 777 unambiguous (281 sequential, 217 medium-range, and 279 long-range) distance restraints could be obtained from PDSD, DARR, CHHC, and the recently introduced PAR and PAIN-CP solid-state experiments for the cobalt(II)-substituted catalytic domain of matrix metalloproteinase 12 (159 amino acids, 17.6 kDa). The obtained structure is a high resolution one, with backbone rmsd of 1.0 +/- 0.2 A, and is in good agreement with the X-ray structure (rmsd to X-ray 1.3 A). The proposed strategy, which may be generalized for nonmetalloproteins with the use of paramagnetic tags, represents a significant step ahead in protein structure determination using solid-state NMR.

Direct observation of hierarchical protein dynamics

A hierarchy of protein motions Functioning proteins are not static but explore complex conformational energy landscapes. Lewandowski et al. used multinuclear solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance experiments to measure protein motion over a broad range of temperatures and time scales. Above 160 K there was a strong coupling between solvent and protein motion. The hierarchy of motions as the temperature increased revealed the dynamic modes that relate solvent, sidechain, and backbone motion. Science, this issue p. 578 The dynamic modes that relate solvent, side-chain, and backbone motions in a protein are determined from nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation. One of the fundamental challenges of physical biology is to understand the relationship between protein dynamics and function. At physiological temperatures, functional motions arise from the complex interplay of thermal motions of proteins and their environments. Here, we determine the hierarchy in the protein conformational energy landscape that underlies these motions, based on a series of temperature-dependent magic-angle spinning multinuclear nuclear-magnetic-resonance relaxation measurements in a hydrated nanocrystalline protein. The results support strong coupling between protein and solvent dynamics above 160 kelvin, with fast solvent motions, slow protein side-chain motions, and fast protein backbone motions being activated consecutively. Low activation energy, small-amplitude local motions dominate at low temperatures, with larger-amplitude, anisotropic, and functionally relevant motions involving entire peptide units becoming dominant at temperatures above 220 kelvin.

Site-specific measurement of slow motions in proteins

We demonstrate that a quantitative measure of slow molecular motions in solid proteins can be accessed by measuring site-specific (15)N rotating-frame relaxation rates at high magic-angle-spinning frequencies.

Advances in solid-state relaxation methodology for probing site-specific protein dynamics.

Dynamics are intimately linked to protein stability and play a crucial role in important biological processes, such as ligand binding, allosteric regulation, protein folding, signaling, and enzymatic catalysis. Solid-state NMR relaxation measurements allow researchers to determine the amplitudes, time scales, and under favorable conditions, directionality of motions at atomic resolution over the entire range of dynamic processes from picoseconds to milliseconds. Because this method allows researchers to examine both the amplitudes and time scales of motions in this range, they can link different tiers of protein motions in protein energy landscapes. As a result, scientists can better understand the relationships between protein motions and functions. Such studies are possible both with the primary targets of solid-state NMR studies, such as amyloid fibrils, membrane proteins, or other heterogeneous systems, and others that researchers typically study by solution NMR and X-ray crystallography. In addition, solid-state NMR, with the absence of tumbling in solution, eliminates the intrinsic size limitation imposed by slow tumbling of large proteins. Thus, this technique allows researchers to characterize interdomain and intermolecular interactions in large complexes at the atomic scale. In this Account, we discuss recent advances in solid-state relaxation methodology for studying widespread site-specific protein dynamics. We focus on applications involving magic angle spinning, one of the primary methods used in high-resolution solid-state NMR. We give an overview of challenges and solutions for measuring (15)N and (13)C spin-lattice relaxation (R1) to characterize fast picosecond-nanosecond motions, spin-lattice in the rotating frame (R1ρ), and other related relaxation rates for characterization of picosecond-millisecond protein motions. In particular, we discuss the problem of separating incoherent effects caused by random motions from coherent effects arising from incomplete averaging of orientation-dependent NMR interactions. We mention a number of quantitative studies of protein dynamics based on solid-state relaxation measurements. Finally, we discuss the potential use of relaxation measurements for extracting the directionality of motions. Using the (15)N and (13)C R1 and R1ρ measurements, we illustrate the backbone and side-chain dynamics in the protein GB1 and comment on this emerging dynamic picture within the context of data from solution NMR measurements and simulations.

Huntingtin exon 1 fibrils feature an interdigitated β-hairpin-based polyglutamine core.

Significance Huntington’s disease is a devastating and incurable inherited neurodegenerative disease. Like at least eight other diseases, its primary genetic cause is the CAG repeat expansion in a specific gene. Mutant huntingtin protein undergoes misfolding and aggregation, causing degeneration of neurons through as-yet poorly understood mechanisms. Attempts to characterize the implicated protein deposits have until now had limited success. We present our structural studies of mutant huntingtin-derived protein deposits by advanced solid-state NMR spectroscopy. We determine the essential structural features of the fibrils’ rigid core, which is shown to feature intramolecular β-hairpins tied together via interdigitating extended side chains. These structural insights have direct implications for the mechanism by which the mutant protein misfolds and self-assembles. Polyglutamine expansion within the exon1 of huntingtin leads to protein misfolding, aggregation, and cytotoxicity in Huntington’s disease. This incurable neurodegenerative disease is the most prevalent member of a family of CAG repeat expansion disorders. Although mature exon1 fibrils are viable candidates for the toxic species, their molecular structure and how they form have remained poorly understood. Using advanced magic angle spinning solid-state NMR, we directly probe the structure of the rigid core that is at the heart of huntingtin exon1 fibrils and other polyglutamine aggregates, via measurements of long-range intramolecular and intermolecular contacts, backbone and side-chain torsion angles, relaxation measurements, and calculations of chemical shifts. These experiments reveal the presence of β-hairpin–containing β-sheets that are connected through interdigitating extended side chains. Despite dramatic differences in aggregation behavior, huntingtin exon1 fibrils and other polyglutamine-based aggregates contain identical β-strand–based cores. Prior structural models, derived from X-ray fiber diffraction and computational analyses, are shown to be inconsistent with the solid-state NMR results. Internally, the polyglutamine amyloid fibrils are coassembled from differently structured monomers, which we describe as a type of “intrinsic” polymorphism. A stochastic polyglutamine-specific aggregation mechanism is introduced to explain this phenomenon. We show that the aggregation of mutant huntingtin exon1 proceeds via an intramolecular collapse of the expanded polyglutamine domain and discuss the implications of this observation for our understanding of its misfolding and aggregation mechanisms.

Conformational dynamics of a seven transmembrane helical protein Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin probed by solid-state NMR.

The ability to detect and characterize molecular motions represents one of the unique strengths of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. In this study, we report solid-state NMR site-specific measurements of the dipolar order parameters and (15)N rotating frame spin-lattice (R1ρ) relaxation rates in a seven transmembrane helical protein Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin reconstituted in lipids. The magnitudes of the observed order parameters indicate that both the well-defined transmembrane regions and the less structured intramembrane loops undergo restricted submicrosecond time scale motions. In contrast, the R1ρ rates, which were measured under fast magic angle spinning conditions, vary by an order of magnitude between the TM and exposed regions and suggest the presence of intermediate time scale motions. Using a simple model, which assumes a single exponential autocorrelation function, we estimated the time scales of dominant stochastic motions to be on the order of low tens of nanoseconds for most residues within the TM helices and tens to hundreds of nanoseconds for the extracellular B-C and F-G loops. These relatively slow time scales could be attributed to collective anisotropic motions. We used the 3D Gaussian axial fluctuations model to estimate amplitudes, directions, and time scales of overall motions for helices and the extracellular B-C and F-G loops. Within this model, the TM helices A,B,C,D,E,F undergo rigid body motions on a time scale of tens of nanoseconds, while the time scale for the seventh helix G approaches 100 ns. Similar time scales of roughly 100-200 ns are estimated for the B-C and F-G loops.

Structural Characterization of GNNQQNY Amyloid Fibrils by Magic Angle Spinning NMR

Several human diseases are associated with the formation of amyloid aggregates, but experimental characterization of these amyloid fibrils and their oligomeric precursors has remained challenging. Experimental and computational analysis of simpler model systems has therefore been necessary, for instance, on the peptide fragment GNNQQNY7−13 of yeast prion protein Sup35p. Expanding on a previous publication, we report here a detailed structural characterization of GNNQQNY fibrils using magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR. On the basis of additional chemical shift assignments we confirm the coexistence of three distinct peptide conformations within the fibrillar samples, as reflected in substantial chemical shift differences. Backbone torsion angle measurements indicate that the basic structure of these coexisting conformers is an extended β-sheet. We structurally characterize a previously identified localized distortion of the β-strand backbone specific to one of the conformers. Intermolecular contacts are consistent with each of the conformers being present in its own parallel and in-register sheet. Overall the MAS NMR data indicate a substantial difference between the structure of the fibrillar and crystalline forms of these peptides, with a clearly increased complexity in the GNNQQNY fibril structure. These experimental data can provide guidance for future work, both experimental and theoretical, and provide insights into the distinction between fibril growth and crystal formation.

Proton assisted recoupling at high spinning frequencies.

We demonstrate the successful application of (13)C-(13)C proton assisted recoupling (PAR) on [U-(13)C,(15)N] N-f-MLF-OH and [U-(13)C,(15)N] protein GB1 at high magic angle spinning (MAS) frequencies (omega(r)/2pi = 65 kHz). Specifically, by combining PAR mixing with low power heteronuclear decoupling (omega(1H)/2pi approximately 16 kHz) and high spinning frequencies, we obtain high resolution 2D spectra displaying long-range (13)C-(13)C contacts from which distance estimates can be extracted. These experiments therefore demonstrate the possibility of performing high resolution structural studies in the limit of high spinning frequency and low power (1)H decoupling, a regime which optimizes the resolution of protein samples and preserves their integrity.

Solid-State NMR of a Protein in a Precipitated Complex with a Full-Length Antibody

NMR spectroscopy is a prime technique for characterizing atomic-resolution structures and dynamics of biomolecular complexes but for such systems faces challenges of sensitivity and spectral resolution. We demonstrate that the application of (1)H-detected experiments at magic-angle spinning frequencies of >50 kHz enables the recording, in a matter of minutes to hours, of solid-state NMR spectra suitable for quantitative analysis of protein complexes present in quantities as small as a few nanomoles (tens of micrograms for the observed component). This approach enables direct structure determination and quantitative dynamics measurements in domains of protein complexes with masses of hundreds of kilodaltons. Protein-protein interaction interfaces can be mapped out by comparison of the chemical shifts of proteins within solid-state complexes with those of the same constituent proteins free in solution. We employed this methodology to characterize a >300 kDa complex of GB1 with full-length human immunoglobulin, where we found that sample preparation by simple precipitation yields spectra of exceptional quality, a feature that is likely to be shared with some other precipitating complexes. Finally, we investigated extensions of our methodology to spinning frequencies of up to 100 kHz.