Judith Reid Graves

Out-of-hospital ventricular fibrillation in children and adolescents : causes and outcomes

STUDY OBJECTIVE To compare causes and outcomes of patients younger than 20 years with an initial rhythm of ventricular fibrillation versus asystole and pulseless electrical activity. DESIGN Retrospective cohort study. SETTING Urban/suburban prehospital system. PARTICIPANTS Pulseless, nonbreathing patients less than 20 years who underwent out-of-hospital resuscitation. Patients with lividity or rigor mortis or who were less than 6 months old and died of sudden infant death syndrome were excluded. RESULTS Ventricular fibrillation was the initial rhythm in 19% (29 of 157) of the cardiac arrests. Rhythm assessment was performed by the first responder in only 44% (69 of 157) of patients. All three rhythm groups were similar in age distribution, frequency of intubation (96%), and vascular access (92%); 93% of ventricular fibrillation patients were defibrillated. The causes of ventricular fibrillation were distributed evenly among medical illnesses, overdoses, drownings, and trauma, only two patients had congenital heart defects. Seventeen percent were discharged with no or mild disability, compared with 2% of asystole/pulseless electrical activity patients (P = .003). CONCLUSION Ventricular fibrillation is not rare in child and adolescent prehospital cardiac arrest, and these patients have a better outcome than those with asystole or pulseless electrical activity. Earlier recognition and treatment of ventricular fibrillation might improve pediatric cardiac arrest survival rates.

Incidence of agonal respirations in sudden cardiac arrest

STUDY OBJECTIVE To discover the frequency of agonal respirations in cardiac arrest calls, the ways callers describe them, and discharge rates associated with agonal respirations. DESIGN We reviewed taped recordings of calls reporting cardiac arrests and emergency medical technician and paramedic incident reports for 1991. Arrests after arrival of emergency medical services were excluded. SETTING King County, Washington, excluding the city of Seattle. PARTICIPANTS Four hundred forty-five persons with out-of-hospital cardiac arrests receiving emergency medical services. INTERVENTIONS Telephone CPR, emergency medical technicians-defibrillation, and advanced life support by paramedics. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS Any attempts at breathing described by callers were identified, as well as whether agonal respirations could be heard by dispatcher, emergency medical technicians, or paramedics. Agonal respirations occurred in 40% of 445 out-of-hospital cardiac arrests. Callers described agonal breathing in a variety of ways. Agonal respirations were present in 46% of arrests caused by cardiac etiology compared with 32% in other etiologies (P < .01). Fifty-five percent of witnessed arrests had agonal activity compared with 16% of unwitnessed arrests (P < .001). Agonal respirations occurred in 56% of arrests with a rhythm of ventricular fibrillation compared with 34% of cases with a nonventricular fibrillation rhythm (P < .001). Twenty-seven percent of patients with agonal respirations were discharged alive compared with 9% without them (P < .001). CONCLUSION There is a high incidence of agonal activity associated with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. Presence of agonal respirations is associated with increased survival. These findings have implications for public CPR training programs and emergency dispatcher telephone CPR programs.

Out-of-Hospital Transcutaneous Pacing by Emergency Medical Technicians in Patients with Asystolic Cardiac Arrest

BACKGROUND Transcutaneous cardiac pacemakers generate electrical stimuli that pace the heart through external electrodes that adhere to the chest wall. Transcutaneous pacing has been useful in some patients with bradycardia, but its efficacy in patients with asystole and full cardiac arrest has been limited, possibly because of delays in the initiation of pacing. We studied the efficacy of early transcutaneous pacing in patients with out-of-hospital asystolic cardiac arrest. METHODS For three years we provided transcutaneous pacemakers to about half the fire districts in a large emergency-medical-services system (the intervention group). In these districts, we authorized emergency medical technicians (EMTs) to begin transcutaneous pacing in patients with cardiac arrest and primary asystole or post-defibrillation asystole. Pacing was done as early as possible, before endotracheal intubation or intravenous medication. EMTs in the other fire districts (the control group) treated similar patients with basic cardiopulmonary resuscitation but without transcutaneous pacing. RESULTS The EMTs in the intervention group initiated transcutaneous pacing in 112 of the 278 patients with primary asystole. Of these patients, 22 (8 percent) were admitted to the hospital, and 11 (4 percent) were discharged. Among the 259 patients treated by the EMTs in the control group, 21 (8 percent) were admitted to the hospital, and 5 (2 percent) were discharged. The two groups did not differ significantly with respect to the rate of hospital admission or survival. Survival after early pacing for post-defibrillation asystole was no better than survival after pacing for primary asystole. CONCLUSIONS Transcutaneous pacing appears to offer no benefit in patients with asystolic cardiac arrest, even when it is performed as early as possible by EMTs in the field. Our data suggest that the widespread implementation of early transcutaneous pacing for out-of-hospital asystolic cardiac arrest would be ineffective.

Ventilation skills of emergency medical technicians: A teaching challenge for emergency medicine

We assessed the ability of 64 emergency medical technicians (EMTs) to ventilate a resuscitation manikin with a bag valve mask and with a pocket face mask to determine if their skill levels met the American Heart Association standard of 12 ventilations per minute, each with a tidal volume of 800 mL or more. All ventilation attempts were made during ongoing chest compressions (60 per minute). A successful ventilation was defined as a tidal volume of 800 mL +/- 40 mL. In a preliminary skills assessment, EMTs averaged 4.8 attempts with the bag valve mask and 2.9 attempts with the pocket face mask before a successful ventilation (P less than .01). In a formal skills assessment that lasted two minutes, successful ventilations per minute averaged 8.3 with the bag value mask and 9.9 with the pocket face mask (P less than 0.1). EMTs passed if they averaged ten or more successful ventilations per minute; 67% passed with the bag valve mask and 77% with the pocket face mask (NS). During a ten-minute extended skill assessment the EMTs averaged 9.6 ventilations per minute with the bag valve mask and 9.5 with the pocket face mask (NS). EMTs achieved initial success and maintained continued success better with the pocket face mask, but a reasonably high percentage (67%) met an objective standard when using the bag valve mask. We propose that objective standards be used to test the skills of EMTs for any ventilatory adjunct that they are permitted to use.

Expected death and unwanted resuscitation in the prehospital setting

STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine the outcome, location, preexisting conditions, and resuscitation wishes of prehospital cardiac arrest patients. DESIGN Retrospective review of paramedic and emergency medical technician run reports. SETTING Urban area with a two-tiered emergency medical services response system covering an area of 2,128 square miles and serving a population of 1,413,900 (in 1988). PARTICIPANTS All prehospital cardiac arrest patients to which the King County, Washington, Emergency Medical Services (KCEMS) system responded to during a 12-month period. Unless decapitation, decomposition, or dependent lividity existed, all cardiac arrest patients in the KCEMS system received full resuscitative efforts. MEASUREMENTS We analyzed run reports from 694 cardiac arrest patients, excluding all cardiac arrests from trauma, overdose, or drowning, or obvious signs of extended downtime such as decomposition or dependent lividity. We defined an unwanted resuscitation as a resuscitation attempt despite written or verbal requests by the patient, family, or private physician. We defined a patient as having severe, chronic disease if the run report listed one or more conditions associated with poor survival rates after inpatient CPR. These included cancer, cerebral vascular accident, dementia, renal failure, dialysis, AIDS, thoracic or abdominal aneurysms, cirrhosis, or if the patient was bedridden or was receiving chronic home nursing care. MAIN RESULTS Overall 16% (103 of 633) of all cardiac arrest patients survived to hospital discharge. Seven percent (47 of 633) of all cardiac arrest patients fit the unwanted resuscitation definition; 2% (one of 47) survived to hospital discharge. Twenty-five percent (158 of 633) of cardiac arrest patients fit the definition of severe chronic disease; 8% (12 of 158) survived to hospital discharge. CONCLUSION Severe chronic disease and unwanted resuscitation patients comprised one-third of all resuscitation attempts by KCEMS during a 12-month period. Both groups had lower survival rates compared to cardiac arrest patients who did not have severe chronic disease or indications of unwanted resuscitation.

Near-fatal yew berry intoxication treated with external cardiac pacing and digoxin-specific FAB antibody fragments

The case of a 5-year-old girl who survived a near-fatal ingestion of yew plant leaves after treatment with CPR, transcutaneous pacing, and digoxin-specific FAB antibody fragments is presented. Multiple rhythm disturbances, including profound bradycardia, occurred. She required endotracheal intubation, external chest compressions, and application of a transcutaneous pacemaker. Paced cardiac contractions produced a dramatic improvement in her blood pressure and clinical condition. Two empiric injections of digoxin-specific FAB antibody fragments were administered, after which cardiac function and rhythm gradually improved. She was discharged in her normal state of health three days later. Yew leaves and berries contain several alkaloids that can produce fatal conduction disturbances. Transcutaneous cardiac pacemakers may be lifesaving for patients with transient cardiac toxicity from drug or toxin ingestions. In addition, cross-reactivity between digoxin-specific FAB antibodies and the alkaloids in the yew plant may exist and may have therapeutic importance, although this mechanism was unlikely to have helped our patient.

Transcutaneous cardiac pacing in the treatment of out-of-hospital pediatric cardiac arrests

Study objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of transcutaneous cardiac pacing in out-of-hospital treatment of cardiac arrests in pediatric patients. Design: We describe the outcome of patients treated during a prospective trial of transcutaneous cardiac pacing in the field. We compare their outcome with that of out-of-hospital arrests in submersion patients who were not paced. We identified patients from Seattle and King County Emergency Medical Services reports, hospitals, and medical examiners registries. Measurements and main results: Nine patients in cardiac arrest caused by drowning (six) and sudden infant death syndrome (three) were paced in the field. All were less than 6 years old. The one survivor was severely neurologically impaired and died six months later. Transcutaneous cardiac pacing produced electrical capture in two patients but no detectable pulse or blood pressure. Ten submersion patients less than 6 years old in cardiac arrest were not paced. One survived, with mild neurologic impairment at hospital discharge. Conclusion: Transcutaneous cardiac pacing was not effective and was not associated with improved survival.

Automatic external defibrillators used by emergency medical technicians: A controlled clinical trial

In a randomized controlled clinical trial, the effectiveness of emergency medical technician (EMT) use of automatic external defibrillators (AEDs) was compared with EMT use of standard defibrillators for patients in cardiac arrest. A total of 321 cardiac arrest patients were treated during the study: 116 were treated by EMTs using the AED (AUTO group), 158 were treated by EMTs using the standard defibrillators (standard group), and 47 were treated by EMTs using the standard defibrillator when they were assigned to use the AED. There was no significant differences in hospital admission or discharge rates between the AUTO group (54% admitted, 28% discharged) and the standard group (52% admitted, 23% discharged) for patients in ventricular fibrillation (VF), for patients in non-VF rhythms, or for all patients combined. The only significant difference observed was in the time from power ON to first shock: 1.1 minutes average AUTO group and 2.0 minutes average standard group. The treatment groups did not differ significantly in sensitivity for VF (78% AED, 76% standard), specificity for non-VF rhythms (100% AED, 95% standard), or rates of defibrillation to a non-VF rhythm (62% AED, 57% standard). We conclude that in clinical outcomes and device performance, AEDs are comparable with standard defibrillators and should be considered an acceptable alternative. Automatic external defibrillators appear to have advantages over standard defibrillators in training, skill retention, and faster operation. Such devices can make early defibrillation available for a much larger portion of the population. They are a major innovation for the prehospital care of cardiac arrest patients.