K. Gulabivala

Tooth survival following non-surgical root canal treatment: a systematic review of the literature

AIMS To investigate (i) the effect of study characteristics on reported tooth survival after root canal treatment (RCTx) and (ii) the effect of clinical factors on the proportion of root filled teeth surviving after RCTx. METHODOLOGY Longitudinal human clinical studies investigating tooth survival after RCTx which were published up to the end of 2007 were identified electronically (MEDLINE and Cochrane database 1966-2007 December, week 4). In addition, four journals (Dental Traumatology, International Endodontic Journal, Journal of Endodontics, Oral Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology Oral Radiology & Endodontics), bibliographies of all relevant articles and review articles were hand searched. Two reviewers (Y-LN, KG) assessed and selected the studies based on specified inclusion criteria and extracted the data onto a pre-designed proforma, independently. The criteria were as follows: (i) clinical study on RCTx; (ii) stratified analysis of primary and secondary RCTx available; (iii) sample size given and larger than 10; (iv) at least 6-month postoperative review; (v) success based on survival of tooth; and (vi) proportion of teeth surviving after treatment given or could be calculated from the raw data. Three strands of evidence or analyses were used to triangulate a consensus view. The reported findings from individual studies, including those excluded for quantitative analysis, were utilized for the intuitive synthesis, which constituted the first strand of evidence. Secondly, the pooled weighted proportion of teeth surviving and thirdly the combined effects of potential prognostic factors were estimated using the fixed and random effects meta-analyses on studies fulfilling all the inclusion criteria. RESULTS Of the 31 articles identified, 14 studies published between 1993 and 2007 were included. The majority of studies were retrospective (n = 10) and only four prospective. The pooled percentages of reported tooth survival over 2-3, 4-5 and 8-10 years following RCTx were 86% (95% CI: 75%, 98%), 93% (95% CI: 92%, 94%) and 87% (95% CI: 82%, 92%), respectively. Substantial differences in study characteristics were found to hinder effective direct comparison of findings. Evidence for the effect of prognostic factors on tooth survival was weak. Based on the data available for meta-analyses, four conditions were found to significantly improve tooth survival. In descending order of influence, the conditions increasing observed proportion of survival were as follows: (i) a crown restoration after RCTx; (ii) tooth having both mesial and distal proximal contacts; (iii) tooth not functioning as an abutment for removable or fixed prosthesis; and (iv) tooth type or specifically non-molar teeth. Statistical heterogeneity was substantial in some cases but its source could not be investigated because of insufficient available information. CONCLUSIONS The pooled proportion of teeth surviving over 2-10 years following RCTx ranged between 86% and 93%. Four factors (listed above) were identified as significant prognostic factors with concurrence between all three strands of evidence.

A prospective study of the factors affecting outcomes of non‐surgical root canal treatment: part 2: tooth survival

AIM To investigate the probability of and factors influencing tooth survival following primary (1°RCTx) or secondary (2°RCTx) root canal treatment. METHODOLOGY This prospective study involved annual follow-up of 2 (100%) to 4 years (50%) of 1°RCTx (759 teeth, 572 patients) and 2°RCTx (858 teeth, 642 patients) carried out by Endodontic postgraduate students. Pre-, intra- and post-operative data were collected prospectively from consented patients. Information about extraction of the root filled tooth was sought from the patient, the referring dentist or derived from the patients records and included the timing and reasons for extraction. Tooth survival was estimated and prognostic factors were investigated using Cox regression. Clustering effects within patients were adjusted in all models using robust standard error. RESULTS The 4-year cumulative tooth survival following 1°RCTx [95.4% (93.6%, 96.8%)] or 2°RCTx [95.3% (93.6%, 96.5%)] was similar. Thirteen prognostic factors were identified. Significant patient factors included history of diabetes and systemic steroid therapy. Significant pre-operative factors included narrow but deep periodontal probing depth; pain; discharging sinus; and iatrogenic perforation (for 2°RCTx cases only). Significant intra-operative factors included iatrogenic perforation; patency at apical terminus; and extrusion of root fillings. Significant post-operative restorative factors included presence of cast restoration versus temporary restoration; presence of cast post and core; proximal contacts with both mesial and distal adjacent teeth; and terminal location of the tooth. The presence of pre-operative pain had a profound effect on tooth loss within the first 22 months after treatment [hazard ratio (HR) = 3.1; P = 0.001] with a lesser effect beyond 22 months (HR = 2.4; P = 0.01). Patency at the apical terminus reduced tooth loss (HR = 0.3; P < 0.01) within the first 22 months after treatment but had no significant effect on tooth survival beyond 22 months. Extrusion of gutta-percha root filling did not have any effect on tooth survival (HR = 1.1; P = 0.2) within the first 22 months but significantly increased the hazard of tooth loss beyond 22 months (HR = 3.0; P = 0.003). CONCLUSIONS The 4-year tooth survival following primary or secondary root canal treatment was 95%, with thirteen prognostic factors common to both.

Contemporary Root Canal Irrigants Are Able to Disrupt and Eradicate Single- and Dual-Species Biofilms

INTRODUCTION Clinical/microbiological studies have consistently revealed the persistence of some bacteria after conventional root canal debridement. Although this was originally attributed to the complexity of the root canal anatomy and the difficulty of delivering antibacterial agents effectively, it has emerged that the biofilm encasement of bacterial cells may confer a further mechanism of resistance. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relative disruption and bactericidal effects of root canal irrigants on single- and dual-species biofilms of root canal isolates. METHODS Biofilms of Streptococcus sanguinis, Enterococcus faecalis, Fusobacterium nucleatum, and Porphyromonas gingivalis were grown on nitrocellulose membranes for 72 hours and immersed in NaOCl, EDTA, chlorhexidine, and iodine for 1, 5, or 10 minutes. The number of viable and nonviable bacteria disrupted from the biofilm and those remaining adherent were determined by using a viability stain in conjunction with fluorescence microscopy. RESULTS Gram-negative obligate anaerobe species were more susceptible to cell removal than gram-positive facultative anaerobes. The majority of cells were disrupted after the first minute of exposure; however, the extent varied according to the agent and species. The most effective agent at disrupting biofilms was NaOCl. Iodine was generally effective at bacterial killing but not disruption. CONCLUSIONS Biofilm disruption and cell viability were influenced by the species, their coassociation in dual-species biofilms, the test agent, and the duration of exposure. The effectiveness of NaOCl as an endodontic irrigant was reinforced.

Evaluation of Protocols for Field Decontamination Before Bacterial Sampling of Root Canals for Contemporary Microbiology Techniques

The effectiveness of sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) (2.5%) or iodine (10%) for decontamination of the operation field (tooth, rubber dam, and gasket [Oraseal]) was compared by using bacterial cultivation. In addition, the final samples were also assessed for bacteria by using polymerase chain reaction. Teeth (n = 63) receiving root canal treatment were polished with pumice, isolated with rubber dam, and their margins sealed with Oraseal. The operation field was disinfected with hydrogen peroxide (30%), followed by iodine (n = 31) or NaOCl (n = 32), before and after access cavity preparation. The operation field was sampled before and after each decontamination, giving four samples per field. After the final decontamination, there was no significant difference (p = 0.602, 0.113, 0.204) in recovery of cultivable bacteria from various sites in either group. However, bacterial DNA could be detected significantly (p = 0.010) more frequently from the tooth surfaces after iodine (45%) compared with NaOCl (13%) decontamination, although on the rubber dam or Oraseal surfaces there was no difference. Root canal sampling for polymerase chain reaction might be better preceded by NaOCl decontamination than by iodine, based on the findings.

The fluid mechanics of root canal irrigation

Root canal treatment is a common dental operation aimed at removing the contents of the geometrically complex canal chambers within teeth; its purpose is to remove diseased or infected tissue. The complex chamber is first enlarged and shaped by instruments to a size sufficient to deliver antibacterial fluids. These irrigants help to dissolve dying tissue, disinfect the canal walls and space and flush out debris. The effectiveness of the procedure is limited by access to the canal terminus. Endodontic research is focused on finding the instruments and clinical procedures that might improve success rates by more effectively reaching the apical anatomy. The individual factors affecting treatment outcome have not been unequivocally deciphered, partly because of the difficulty in isolating them and in making the link between simplified, general experimental models and the complex biological objects that are teeth. Explicitly considering the physical processes within the root canal can contribute to the resolution of these problems. The central problem is one of fluid motion in a confined geometry, which makes the dispersion and mixing of irrigant more difficult because of the absence of turbulence over much of the canal volume. The effects of treatments can be understood through the use of scale models, mathematical modelling and numerical computations. A particular concern in treatment is that caustic irrigant may penetrate beyond the root canal, causing chemical damage to the jawbone. In fact, a stagnation plane exists beyond the needle tip, which the irrigant cannot penetrate. The goal is therefore to shift the stagnation plane apically to be coincident with the canal terminus without extending beyond it. Needle design may solve some of the problems but the best design for irrigant penetration conflicts with that for optimal removal of the bacterial biofilm from the canal wall. Both irrigant penetration and biofilm removal may be improved through canal fluid agitation using a closely fitting instrument or by sonic or ultrasonic activation. This review highlights a way forward by understanding the physical processes involved through physical models, mathematical modelling and numerical computations.

An in vivo evaluation of the ENDEX and RCM Mark II electronic apex locators in root canals with different contents

The accuracy of many apex locators is affected by electrolytes including sodium hypochlorite. According to the manufacturer a new device, the ENDEX, overcomes this problem. The purpose of this study was to assess the accuracy of the ENDEX in comparison with a traditional device, the RCM Mark II. The lengths of 61 canals with various contents (vital pulp, necrotic pulp, pus/exudate, sodium hypochlorite, and water) were determined in vivo. Files were cemented within the canals at lengths determined by the ENDEX. The teeth were then radiographed and extracted, and the distance between the file tip and apical foramen was recorded. Derived readings for the RCM Mark II were compared with the actual ENDEX reading and corresponding radiograph. The results indicated that most of the file tips that were at the radiographic apex actually extended through the apical foramen, and canal content had a varying effect on each device. The overall accuracy of the ENDEX (71.7%) was higher than that of the RCM Mark II (43.5%) within 0.5 mm of the apical foramen. The ENDEX, unlike the RCM Mark II, proved accurate in the presence of sodium hypochlorite.

Microflora in teeth associated with apical periodontitis: a methodological observational study comparing two protocols and three microscopy techniques.

AIM The aim of this study was to compare two protocols to examine bacterial colonization in teeth associated with chronic apical periodontitis with acute episodes (ap), using light microscopy (LM), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). METHODOLOGY Nine root samples (seven teeth) were processed using either Eastman Dental Institute (EDI) (n = 4 teeth/4 roots) or Zurich (n = 3 teeth/5 roots) protocols. The roots were sectioned longitudinally; one root portion was viewed with SEM, descriptively dividing its length into apical, middle and coronal; semi-thin and ultra-thin transverse sections were viewed under LM and TEM from each third of the other root portion. Each root was therefore examined using all microscopy techniques. Observations of bacterial presence, description and distribution within the root canal lumen and root dentine were systematically recorded using pre-determined criteria. RESULTS The Zurich technique gave a more predictable division of the root, but the surface was slightly smeared and demineralization was incomplete. The Eastman Dental Institute (EDI) approach appeared to provide better ultrastructural detail. Bacteria were detected in eight of the nine roots. Bacterial biofilms were commonly seen adhering to the root canal surface, containing various cellular morphotypes: rods, cocci, filaments and spirochaetes. Bacteria were more evident apically than coronally, associated with the canal wall but were more commonly evident coronally than apically within the dentinal tubules. Polymorphs (PMNs) were found in all the root thirds, especially apically, often numerous and walling off the bacterial biofilm from the remaining canal lumen. CONCLUSIONS Both protocols had merits and de-merits. The combination of microscopy techniques offered complementary views of intra-radicular bacterial colonization. The perception of confinement of the host/microbial interface at the apical foramen is not entirely correct; PMNs may be found even in the coronal third of root canals containing necrotic pulp tissue.

The effect of sodium hypochlorite irrigant concentration on tooth surface strain.

The effect of root-canal irrigation with different concentrations of sodium hypochlorite (3%, 5.1%, 7.3% NaOCI) on the mechanical properties of teeth was investigated in vitro. Root canals of 13 extracted, human premolars, denuded of enamel, were prepared with nickel-titanium rotary instruments (Quantec) to a standard size by using saline irrigation. An electrical strain gauge was bonded to the cervical aspect of each tooth. The 10 experimental teeth were subjected to 5 successive, 30-minute periods of irrigation. The irrigants were used in the following order: (a) saline; (b) 3.0% NaOCI; (c) 5.1% NaOCI; (d) 7.3% NaOCI; (e) saline. Three control teeth were irrigated with saline only for all five periods. After each irrigation, the teeth were cyclically loaded to 110N while the surface strain was measured. Changes in strain of the test teeth after each irrigation regimen followed broadly similar patterns that were different from the control teeth. There was no difference, however, in the strain recorded after irrigation by the different irrigants within the experimental group.

The effect of sodium hypochlorite and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid irrigation, individually and in alternation, on tooth surface strain

AIM To evaluate the effect of irrigation regimens on tooth surface strain using saline, sodium hypochlorite (3% and 5% NaOCl) and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (17% EDTA), individually and in alternating combinations. METHODOLOGY Single-rooted premolar teeth with single canals prepared to standardized dimensions were grouped by anatomical features and randomly distributed amongst six experimental groups (n = 12 each). The six groups were: (1) saline; (2) 5% NaOCl; (3) 3% NaOCl; (4) 17% EDTA; (5) 3% NaOCl and 17% EDTA; (6) 5% NaOCl and 17% EDTA. All groups underwent four (group 1) or five (groups 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) sequential 30-min irrigation periods following each of which the tooth was subjected to a standard regime of cyclic, nondestructive, occlusal loading. Tooth surface strain was measured during each loading cycle using electrical strain gauges mounted cervico-proximally. The data were analysed by Hierarchical anova and post hoc multiple comparisons. RESULTS Irrigation with 5% NaOCl alone or alternating with 17% EDTA significantly (P < 0.001) increased the peak strain values for each of the irrigation periods compared with that of saline (group 1). The data for the other groups revealed no significant differences compared with those of saline. The strain increase after the fourth irrigation cycle was significantly higher for group 6 than for group 2. The measured canal morphology and dentine thickness parameters did not prove to have a significant effect on tooth surface strain. CONCLUSIONS Irrigation with 5% NaOCl acting alone or alternated with 17% EDTA (used in 30 min cycles), significantly increased tooth surface strain. The alternated regimen showed significantly greater changes in tooth surface strain than NaOCl alone. Irrigation with 3% NaOCl and 17% EDTA individually or in combination did not significantly alter the tooth surface strain.

3D Computer aided treatment planning in endodontics

OBJECTIVES Obliteration of the root canal system due to accelerated dentinogenesis and dystrophic calcification can challenge the achievement of root canal treatment goals. This paper describes the application of 3D digital mapping technology for predictable navigation of obliterated canal systems during root canal treatment to avoid iatrogenic damage of the root. METHODS Digital endodontic treatment planning for anterior teeth with severely obliterated root canal systems was accomplished with the aid of computer software, based on cone beam computer tomography (CBCT) scans and intra-oral scans of the dentition. On the basis of these scans, endodontic guides were created for the planned treatment through digital designing and rapid prototyping fabrication. RESULTS The custom-made guides allowed for an uncomplicated and predictable canal location and management. CONCLUSION The method of digital designing and rapid prototyping of endodontic guides allows for reliable and predictable location of root canals of teeth with calcifically metamorphosed root canal systems. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE The endodontic directional guide facilitates difficult endodontic treatments at little additional cost.