K.Y. Lim

The Ups and Downs of Genome Size Evolution in Polyploid Species of Nicotiana (Solanaceae)

BACKGROUND In studies looking at individual polyploid species, the most common patterns of genomic change are that either genome size in the polyploid is additive (i.e. the sum of parental genome donors) or there is evidence of genome downsizing. Reports showing an increase in genome size are rare. In a large-scale analysis of 3008 species, genome downsizing was shown to be a widespread biological response to polyploidy. Polyploidy in the genus Nicotiana (Solanaceae) is common with approx. 40 % of the approx. 75 species being allotetraploid. Recent advances in understanding phylogenetic relationships of Nicotiana species and dating polyploid formation enable a temporal dimension to be added to the analysis of genome size evolution in these polyploids. METHODS Genome sizes were measured in 18 species of Nicotiana (nine diploids and nine polyploids) ranging in age from <200,000 years to approx. 4.5 Myr old, to determine the direction and extent of genome size change following polyploidy. These data were combined with data from genomic in situ hybridization and increasing amounts of information on sequence composition in Nicotiana to provide insights into the molecular basis of genome size changes. KEY RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS By comparing the expected genome size of the polyploid (based on summing the genome size of species identified as either a parent or most closely related to the diploid progenitors) with the observed genome size, four polyploids showed genome downsizing and five showed increases. There was no discernable pattern in the direction of genome size change with age of polyploids, although with increasing age the amount of genome size change increased. In older polyploids (approx. 4.5 million years old) the increase in genome size was associated with loss of detectable genomic in situ hybridization signal, whereas some hybridization signal was still detected in species exhibiting genome downsizing. The possible significance of these results is discussed.

Mobilization of retrotransposons in synthetic allotetraploid tobacco

Allopolyploidy is a major driving force in plant evolution and can induce rapid structural changes in the hybrid genome. As major components of plant genomes, transposable elements are involved in these changes. In a previous work, we observed turnover of retrotransposon insertions in natural allotretraploid tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum). Here, we studied the early stages of allopolyploid formation by monitoring changes at retrotransposon insertion sites in the Th37 synthetic tobacco. We used sequence-specific amplification polymorphism (SSAP) to study insertion patterns of two populations of the Tnt1 retrotransposon in Th37 S4 generation plants, and characterized the nature of polymorphic insertion sites. We observed significant amplification of young Tnt1 populations. Newly transposed copies were amplified from maternal elements and were highly similar to Tnt1A tobacco copies amplified in response to microbial factors. A high proportion of paternal SSAP bands were not transmitted to the hybrid, corresponding to various rearrangements at paternal insertion sites, including indels or the complete loss of the Tnt1/flanking junction. These data indicate that major changes, such as retrotransposon amplification and molecular restructuring in or around insertion sites, occur rapidly in response to allopolyploidy.

Telomere variability in the monocotyledonous plant order Asparagales

A group of monocotyledonous plants within the order Asparagales, forming a distinct clade in phylogenetic analyses, was reported previously to lack the ‘typical’ Arabidopsis–type telomere (TTTAGGG)n. This stimulated us to determine what has replaced these sequences. Using slot–blot and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) to species within this clade, our results indicate the following. 1. The typical Arabidopsis–type telomeric sequence has been partly or fully replaced by the human–type telomeric sequence (TTAGGG)n. Species in Allium lack the human–type variant. 2. In most cases the human variant occurs along with a lower abundance of two or more variants of the minisatellite sequences (of seven types evaluated), usually these being the consensus telomeric sequence of Arabidopsis, Bombyx (TTAGG)n and Tetrahymena (TTGGGGn. FISH shows that the variants can occur mixed together at the telomere. 3. Telomerases generate products with a 6 base pair periodicity and when sequenced they reveal predominantly a reiterated human–type motif. These motifs probably form the ‘true telomere’ but the error rate of motif synthesis is higher compared with ‘typical’ plant telomerases. The data indicate that the Asparagales clade is unified by a mutation resulting in a switch from synthesis of Arabidopsis–like telomeres to a low–fidelity synthesis of human–like telomeres.

Loss and recovery of Arabidopsis–type telomere repeat sequences 5′–(TTTAGGG)n–3′ in the evolution of a major radiation of flowering plants

Fluorescent in situ hybridization and Southern blotting were used for showing the predominant absence of the Arabidopsis–type telomere repeat sequence (TRS) 5′–(TTTAGGG)n–3′ (the ‘typical’ telomere) in a monocot clade which comprises up to 6300 species within Asparagales. Initially, two apparently disparate genera that lacked the typical telomere were identified. Here, we used the new angiosperm phylogenetic classification for predicting in which other related families such telomeres might have been lost. Our data revealed that 16 species in 12 families of Asparagales lacked typical telomeres. Phylogenetically, these were clustered in a derived clade, thereby enabling us to predict that the typical telomere was lost, probably as a single evolutionary event, following the divergence of Doryanthaceae ca. 80–90 million years ago. This result illustrates the predictive value of the new phylogeny, as the pattern of species lacking the typical telomere would be considered randomly placed against many previous angiosperm taxonomies. Possible mechanisms by which chromosome end maintenance could have evolved in this group of plants are discussed. Surprisingly, one genus, Ornithogalum (Hyacinthaceae), which is central to the group of plants that have lost the typical telomere, appears to have regained the sequences. The mechanism(s) by which such recovery may have occurred is unknown, but possibilities include horizontal gene transfer and sequence reamplification.

Evolution and structure of 5S rDNA loci in allotetraploid Nicotiana tabacum and its putative parental species

Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) is an allotetraploid derived from ancestors of the modern diploids, N. sylvestris and N. tomentosiformis. We identified and characterized two distinct families of 5S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) in N. tabacum; one family had an average 431 bp unit length and the other a 646 bp unit length. In the diploid species, N. sylvestris and N. tomentosiformis, the 5S rDNA unit lengths are 431 bp and 644 bp respectively. The non-coding spacer sequence of the short unit in tobacco had high sequence homology to the spacer of N. sylvestris 5S rDNA, while the longer spacer of tobacco had high homology with the 5S spacer of N. tomentosiformis. This suggests that the two 5S families in tobacco have their origin in the diploid ancestors. The longer spacer sequence had a GC rich sub-region (called the T-genome sub-region) that was absent in the short spacer. Pulsed field gel analysis and fluorescent in situ hybridization to tobacco metaphase chromosomes showed that the two families of 5S rDNA units are spatially separate at two chromosomal loci, on chromosomes S8 (short family) and T8 (long family). The repeat copy number at each chromosomal locus showed heterogeneity between different tobacco cultivars, with a tendency for a decrease in the copy number of one family to be compensated by an increase in the copy number of the second family. Sequence analysis reveals there is as much diversity in 5S family units within the diploid species as there is within the T and S-genome 5S family units respectively, suggesting 5S diversification within each family had occurred before tobacco speciation. There is no evidence of interlocus homogenization of the two 5S families in tobacco. This is therefore substantially different to 18–26S rDNA where interlocus gene conversion has substantially influenced most sequences of S and T genome origin; possible reasons are discussed.

Evolutionary implications of permanent odd polyploidy in the stable sexual, pentaploid of Rosa canina L

In Rosa canina (2n=5x=35), the pollen and ovular parents contribute, respectively, seven and 28 chromosomes to the zygote. At meiosis I, 14 chromosomes form seven bivalents and 21 chromosomes remain as univalents. Fluorescent in situ hybridization to mitotic and pollen mother cells (PMC) of R. canina showed that 10 chromosomes (two per genome) carry ribosomal DNA (rDNA) loci. Five chromosomes carry terminal 18S–5.8S–26S rDNA loci; three of these also carry paracentric 5S rDNA loci and were designated as marker chromosomes 1. Five chromosomes carry only 5S rDNA loci and three of these were designated as marker chromosomes 2. The remaining four of the 10 chromosomes with rDNA loci were individually identifiable by the type and relative sizes of their rDNA loci and were numbered separately. At PMC meiosis, two marker chromosomes 1 and two marker chromosomes 2 formed bivalents, whereas the others were unpaired. In a gynogenetic haploid of R. canina (n=4x=28), obtained after pollination with γ-irradiated pollen, chromosomes at meiosis I in PMC remained predominantly unpaired. The data indicate only one pair of truly homologous genomes in R. canina. The 21 unpaired chromosomes probably remain as univalents through multiple generations and do not recombine. The long-term evolutionary consequence for the univalents is likely to be genetic degradation through accumulated mutational change as in the mammalian Y chromosome and chromosomes of asexual species. But there is no indication that univalents carry degenerate 5S rDNA families. This may point to a recent evolution of the R. canina meiotic system.

Genomic characterisation and the detection of raspberry chromatin in polyploid Rubus

Abstract This paper reports genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) data for chromosomes of raspberry (Rubus idaeus 2n=2x=14), blackberry (Rubus aggregate, subgenus Eubatus. 2n=2–12x=14–84) and their allopolyploid derivatives used in fruit breeding programmes. GISH was used to discriminate labelled chromosomes of raspberry origin from those of blackberry origin in allopolyploid hybrid plants. The raspberry chromosomes were labelled by GISH at their centromeres, and 1 chromosome was also labelled over the short arm. In one allopentaploid plant a chromosome carried a terminal signal. Karyotype analysis indicated that this is a blackberry chromosome carrying a raspberry translocation. GISH analysis of an aneuoctaploid blackberry cv ‘Aurora’ (2n=8x=58) showed that both whole and translocated raspberry chromosomes were present. The basic Rubus genome has one ribosomal DNA (rDNA) locus, and in all but one case all levels of ploidy had the expected multiples of rDNA loci. Interestingly, in the blackberry cv ‘Aurora’, there were only six sites, two less than might be predicted from its aneuoctaploid chromosome number. Our results highlight the potential of GISH and FISH for genomic designation, physical mapping and introgression studies in Rosaceous fruit crops.

Comparative analysis of DNA methylation in tobacco heterochromatic sequences

Cytosine methylation levels and susceptibility to drug-induced hypomethylation have been studied in several Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) DNA repetitive sequences. It has been shown using HapII, MspI, BamHI and Sau3AI methylation-sensitive restriction enzymes that the degree of 5′-mCmCG-3′ methylation varied significantly between different repeats. There were almost saturation levels of 5-methylcytosine at the inner (3′) cytosine position and variable degrees of methylation at the outer (5′) cytosine at the enzyme recognition sites. The non-transcribed high copy satellite sequences (HRS60, GRS) displayed significant heterogeneity in methylation of their basic units while middle repetitive sequences (R8.1, GRD5, 5S rDNA) were more uniformly modified at both cytosine residues. Dihydroxypropyladenine (DHPA) treatment, which is thought to reduce DNA methyltransferase activity by increasing S-adenosylhomocysteine levels, resulted in extensive demethylation of the outer cytosine in all repeats, and the partial hypomethylation of cytosines at the inner positions in less densely methylated repeats such as HRS60 and GRS. The results suggest that hypomethylation of 5′-mCmCG-3′ sites with DHPA is a gradual non-random process proceeding in the direction mCmCG→CmCG→CCG. The 18S-5.8S-25S rDNA was remarkably hypomethylated relative to the 5S rDNA at all restriction sites studied. Fluorescence in-situ hybridization showed that DNA decondensation within and between the 18S-5.8S-25S and 5S rDNA loci was variable in different nuclei. All nuclei had condensed and decondensed sequence. The chromatin of 18S-5.8S-25S rDNA was more readily digested with micrococcal nuclease than the 5S rDNA suggesting that the overall levels of decondensation were higher for 18S-5.8S-25S rDNA. Variable decondensation patterns within and between loci were also observed for GRS and HRS60. Cytosine methylation of the tobacco repeats is discussed with respect to transcription, overall levels of condensation and overall structure.

Ribosomal DNA evolution and gene conversion in Nicotiana rustica

Genomic in situ hybridisation was used to confirm that Nicotiana rustica (2n=4x=48) is an allotetraploid between N. paniculata (2n=2x=24, maternal P- genome donor) and N. undulata (2n=2x=24, paternal U-genome donor), their progenitors or species closely related to them. Fluorescent in situ hybridisation showed that N. paniculata has one 5S and two 18-5.8-26S rDNA loci whereas N. undulata has an additional 18-5.8-26S rDNA locus. N. rustica has the sum of the loci found in these putative parents. The sizes of the 18-5.8-26S rDNA loci indicate that the number of rDNA units on the U-genome chromosomes has amplified; perhaps this is associated with a concomitant reduction in the number of units on P-genome chromosomes. Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of the intergenic spacer (IGS) of the 18-5.8-26S rDNA units in N. rustica and the two progenitor diploids revealed that about 80% of IGS sequences in N. rustica are of an N. undulata type and 20% of N. paniculata type. These data indicate that interlocus sequence homogenisation has caused the replacement of many N. paniculata-type IGSs in N. rustica with an N. undulata-type of sequence. It is probable that subsequent to this replacement there has been sequence divergence at the 5′ end of the IGS. As in tobacco, an allotetraploid between N. sylvestris and N. tomentosiformis, the direction of the IGS interlocus conversion is towards the paternal genome donor.

Molecular cytogenetics and tandem repeat sequence evolution in the allopolyploid Nicotiana rustica compared with diploid progenitors N. paniculata and N. undulata

Nicotiana rustica (2n = 4x = 48) is a natural allotetraploid composed of P and U genomes which are closely related to genomes of diploid species N. paniculata and N. undulata. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) also confirms that the diploid parents, or close relatives, are the ancestors of N. rustica. In order to study genetic interactions between ancestral genomes in the allotetraploid, we isolated three families of repetitive sequences, two from N. paniculata (NPAMBE and NPAMBO) and one from N. undulata (NUNSSP). Southern blot hybridization revealed that the sequences are digested with a range of restriction enzymes into regular ladder patterns indicating a tandem arrangement of high copy repeats possessing monomeric units of about 180 bp. The three-tandem sequences belong to a larger Nicotiana tandem repeat family called here the HRS-60 family. Members of this family are found in all Nicotiana species studied. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis localized the satellite repeats to subtelomeric regions of most chromosomes of N. paniculata and N. undulata. The pattern of sequence distribution on the P- and U-genomes of N. rustica was similar to the putative parents N. paniculata and N. undulata respectively. However, NPAMBO repeats appear to be reduced and rearranged in N. rustica that may suggest evolution within the P genome. GISH and FISH with the tandem repeat probes failed to reveal intergenomic translocations as might be predicted from the nucleocytoplasmic interaction hypothesis.