Karel H. M. van Wely

Centromere-localized breaks indicate the generation of DNA damage by the mitotic spindle

Most carcinomas present some form of chromosome instability in combination with spindle defects. Numerical instability is likely caused by spindle aberrations, but the origin of breaks and translocations remains elusive. To determine whether one mechanism can bring about both types of instability, we studied the relationship between DNA damage and spindle defects. Although lacking apparent repair defects, primary Dido mutant cells formed micronuclei containing damaged DNA. The presence of centromeres showed that micronuclei were caused by spindle defects, and cell cycle markers showed that DNA damage was generated during mitosis. Although the micronuclei themselves persisted, the DNA damage within was repaired during S and G2 phases. DNA breaks in Dido mutant cells regularly colocalized with centromeres, which were occasionally distorted. Comparable defects were found in APC mutant cell lines, an independent system for spindle defects. On the basis of these results, we propose a model for break formation in which spindle defects lead to centromere shearing.

Dido disruption leads to centrosome amplification and mitotic checkpoint defects compromising chromosome stability

Numerical and/or structural centrosome abnormalities have been correlated with most solid tumors and hematological malignancies. Tumorigenesis also is linked to defects in the mitotic or spindle assembly checkpoint, a key control mechanism that ensures accurate segregation of chromosomes during mitosis. We have reported that targeted disruption of the Dido gene causes a transplantable myelodysplastic/myeloproliferative disease in mice. Here, we report that Dido3, the largest splice variant of the Dido gene, is a centrosome-associated protein whose disruption leads to supernumerary centrosomes, failure to maintain cellular mitotic arrest, and early degradation of the mitotic checkpoint protein BubR1. These aberrations result in enhanced aneuploidy in the Dido mutant cells. Dido gene malfunction thus is reported to be part of an impaired signaling cascade that results in a defective mitotic checkpoint, leading to chromosome instability.

Centromere fission, not telomere erosion, triggers chromosomal instability in human carcinomas

The majority of sporadic carcinomas suffer from a kind of genetic instability in which chromosome number changes occur together with segmental defects. This means that changes involving intact chromosomes accompany breakage-induced alterations. Whereas the causes of aneuploidy are described in detail, the origins of chromosome breakage in sporadic carcinomas remain disputed. The three main pathways of chromosomal instability (CIN) proposed until now (random breakage, telomere fusion and centromere fission) are largely based on animal models and in vitro experiments, and recent studies revealed several discrepancies between animal models and human cancer. Here, we discuss how the experimental systems translate to human carcinomas and compare the theoretical breakage products to data from patient material and cancer cell lines. The majority of chromosomal defects in human carcinomas comprises pericentromeric breaks that are captured by healthy telomeres, and only a minor proportion of chromosome fusions can be attributed to telomere erosion or random breakage. Centromere fission, not telomere erosion, is therefore the most probably trigger of CIN and early carcinogenesis. Similar centromere–telomere fusions might drive a subset of congenital defects and evolutionary chromosome changes.

Are aneuploidy and chromosome breakage caused by a CINgle mechanism

Genetic instability is a hallmark of cancer. Most tumors show complex patterns of translocations, amplifications, and deletions, which have occupied scientists for decades. A specific problem arises in carcinomas with a genetic defect termed chromosomal instability; these solid tumors undergo gains and losses of entire chromosomes, as well as segmental defects caused by chromosome breaks. To date, the apparent inconsistency between intact and broken chromosomes has precluded identification of an underlying mechanism. The recent identification of centromeric breaks alongside aneuploidy in cells with spindle defects indicates that a single mechanism could account for all genetic alterations characteristic of chromosomal instability. Since a poorly controlled spindle can cause merotelic attachments, kinetochore distortion, and subsequent chromosome breakage, spindle defects can generate the sticky ends necessary to start a breakage-fusion-bridge cycle. The characteristic breakpoint of spindle-generated damage, adjacent to the centromere, also explains the losses and gains of whole chromosome arms, which are especially prominent in low-grade tumors. The recent data indicate that spindle defects are an early event in tumor formation, and an important initiator of carcinogenesis.

SPOC: a widely distributed domain associated with cancer, apoptosis and transcription.

BackgroundThe Split ends (Spen) family are large proteins characterised by N-terminal RNA recognition motifs (RRMs) and a conserved SPOC (Spen paralog and ortholog C-terminal) domain. The aim of this study is to characterize the family at the sequence level.ResultsWe describe undetected members of the Spen family in other lineages (Plasmodium and Plants) and localise SPOC in a new domain context, in a family that is common to all eukaryotes using profile-based sequence searches and structural prediction methods.ConclusionsThe widely distributed DIO (Death inducer-obliterator) family is related to cancer and apoptosis and offers new clues about SPOC domain functionality.

Chromothripsis: breakage-fusion-bridge over and over again.

The acquisition of massive but localized chromosome translocations, a phenomenon termed chromothripsis, has received widespread attention since its discovery over a year ago. Until recently, chromothripsis was believed to originate from a single catastrophic event, but the molecular mechanisms leading to this event are yet to be uncovered. Because a thorough interpretation of the data are missing, the phenomenon itself has wrongly acquired the status of a mechanism used to justify many kinds of complex rearrangements. Although the assumption that all translocations in chromothripsis originate from a single event has met with criticism, satisfactory explanations for the intense but localized nature of this phenomenon are still missing. Here, we show why the data used to describe massive catastrophic rearrangements are incompatible with a model comprising a single event only and propose a molecular mechanism in which a combination of known cellular pathways accounts for chromothripsis. Instead of a single traumatic event, the protection of undamaged chromosomes by telomeres can limit repetitive breakage-fusion-bridge events to a single chromosome arm. Ultimately, common properties of chromosomal instability, such as aneuploidy and centromere fission, might establish the complex genetic pattern observed in this genomic state.

Dido3-dependent HDAC6 targeting controls cilium size

Primary cilia are involved in a variety of physiological processes such as sensing of the environment, cell growth and development. Numerous developmental disorders and pathologies arise from defects in these organelles. Multiple proteins that promote formation and disassembly of the primary cilium have been identified, but little is known about the mechanisms that control steady-state cilium size. Here, we show that death inducer obliterator (Dido3)-dependent targeting of histone deacetylase 6 (HDAC6) is a key determinant of cilium size in growth-arrested cells. The amount of either protein negatively correlates with cilium size. Dido3 availability at the centrosome governs ciliary HDAC6 levels, and redistribution of the two proteins controls tubulin acetylation. In turn, basal body localization of Dido3 and HDAC6 depends on the actin network, previously shown to limit cilium size independent of the cell cycle. These results show that not only kinase-dependent activation of a deacetylase but also its subcellular distribution controls substrate selection.

Merotelic attachments and non-homologous end joining are the basis of chromosomal instability

Although the large majority of solid tumors show a combination of mitotic spindle defects and chromosomal instability, little is known about the mechanisms that govern the initial steps in tumorigenesis. The recent report of spindle-induced DNA damage provides evidence for a single mechanism responsible for the most prominent genetic defects in chromosomal instability. Spindle-induced DNA damage is brought about by uncorrected merotelic attachments, which cause kinetochore distortion, chromosome breakage at the centromere, and possible activation of DNA damage repair pathways. Although merotelic attachments are common early in mitosis, some escape detection by the kinetochore pathway. As a consequence, a proportion of merotelic attachments gives rise to chromosome breakage in normal cells and in carcinomas. An intrinsic chromosome segregation defect might thus form the basis of tumor initiation. We propose a hypothesis in which merotelic attachments and chromosome breakage establish a feedback loop that results in relaxation of the spindle checkpoint and suppression of anti-proliferative pathways, thereby promoting carcinogenesis.

Death inducer obliterator protein 1 in the context of DNA regulation. Sequence analyses of distant homologues point to a novel functional role.

Death inducer obliterator protein 1 [DIDO1; also termed DIO‐1 and death‐associated transcription factor 1 (DATF‐1)] is encoded by a gene thus far described only in higher vertebrates. Current gene ontology descriptions for this gene assign its function to an apoptosis‐related process. The protein presents distinct splice variants and is distributed ubiquitously. Exhaustive sequence analyses of all DIDO variants identify distant homologues in yeast and other organisms. These homologues have a role in DNA regulation and chromatin stability, and form part of higher complexes linked to active chromatin. Further domain composition analyses performed in the context of related homologues suggest that DIDO‐induced apoptosis is a secondary effect. Gene‐targeted mice show alterations that include lagging chromosomes, and overexpression of the gene generates asymmetric nuclear divisions. Here we describe the analysis of these eukaryote‐restricted proteins and propose a novel, DNA regulatory function for the DIDO protein in mammals.

Synaptonemal complex assembly and H3K4Me3 demethylation determine DIDO3 localization in meiosis

Synapsis of homologous chromosomes is a key meiotic event, mediated by a large proteinaceous structure termed the synaptonemal complex. Here, we describe a role in meiosis for the murine death-inducer obliterator (Dido) gene. The Dido gene codes for three proteins that recognize trimethylated histone H3 lysine 4 through their amino-terminal plant homeodomain domain. DIDO3, the largest of the three isoforms, localizes to the central region of the synaptonemal complex in germ cells. DIDO3 follows the distribution of the central region protein SYCP1 in Sycp3−/− spermatocytes, which lack the axial elements of the synaptonemal complex. This indicates that synapsis is a requirement for DIDO3 incorporation. Interestingly, DIDO3 is missing from the synaptonemal complex in Atm mutant spermatocytes, which form synapses but show persistent trimethylation of histone H3 lysine 4. In order to further address a role of epigenetic modifications in DIDO3 localization, we made a mutant of the Dido gene that produces a truncated DIDO3 protein. This truncated protein, which lacks the histone-binding domain, is incorporated in the synaptonemal complex irrespective of histone trimethylation status. DIDO3 protein truncation in Dido mutant mice causes mild meiotic defects, visible as gaps in the synaptonemal complex, but allows for normal meiotic progression. Our results indicate that histone H3 lysine 4 demethylation modulates DIDO3 localization in meiosis and suggest epigenetic regulation of the synaptonemal complex.