Karen D. Moore

Immunologic Impact and Clinical Outcomes After Surgical Exposure to Bovine Thrombin

ObjectiveTo determine prospectively the immunologic response and adverse clinical events in surgical patients exposed to bovine thrombin during cardiac surgical procedures. Summary Background DataTopical bovine thrombin is used extensively as a hemostatic agent during cardiovascular surgery. Antibodies developing after exposure to bovine thrombin have been anecdotally associated with hemorrhagic complications. MethodsOne hundred fifty-one patients undergoing cardiac surgical procedures were prospectively recruited for this study before surgical exposure with topical bovine thrombin. Immunoassays were used to determine antibody levels against both bovine and human coagulation proteins before and after exposure to bovine thrombin. Alterations in coagulation assay parameters and adverse clinical events were followed in all patients enrolled in the study. ResultsBaseline elevated antibody levels to one or more bovine coagulation proteins were observed most frequently in patients with a prior history of a surgical procedure during which bovine thrombin is frequently used. More than 95% of patients developed a seropositive response to bovine coagulation proteins, and 51% manifested elevated antibody levels to the corresponding human coagulation proteins after bovine thrombin exposure. Postoperative coagulation abnormalities were more common in patients with antibodies to human coagulation proteins. Patients with multiple elevated antibody levels to bovine proteins before surgery were more likely to sustain an adverse clinical outcome after surgery. Using a logistic regression model, the adjusted odds ratio for sustaining an adverse event with multiple elevated antibody levels to bovine proteins before surgery was 5.40. ConclusionsBovine thrombin preparations are highly immunogenic and appear to be associated with an increased risk for adverse clinical outcomes during subsequent surgical procedures. The clinical safety of these commonly used preparations needs to be reassessed, and reexposure to these agents should likely be avoided.

Antibodies to topical bovine thrombin correlate with access thrombosis

Bovine thrombin is often used topically to promote hemostasis during vascular surgery, including dialysis-access placement. Patients frequently develop antibodies to bovine thrombin preparations, and some may develop antiphospholipid antibodies. We evaluated 88 hemodialysis patients for the presence of antibodies to topical bovine thrombin to determine if elevated antibody levels correlated with vascular access thrombosis. Twenty-seven patients (30.7%) had elevated antibody levels to topical bovine thrombin. More patients with elevated antibody levels had prior vascular access thrombosis than patients with normal antibody levels (13 of 27 versus 5 of 61 patients; P < 0.001). This difference was almost entirely the result of greater levels of thrombosis in patients with polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) grafts and elevated antibody levels. In these patients, 11 of 13 patients (84.6%) with elevated antibody levels had a previous thrombosis compared with 2 of 15 patients (13. 3%) with normal antibody levels (P < 0.001). Patients with elevated antibody levels and PTFE grafts also had more prior thromboses (1.92 +/- 1.60 versus 0.133 +/- 0.35 thromboses; P < 0.01) and a greater thrombosis rate (66.89 +/- 63.71 versus 4.65 +/- 12.05 thromboses/100 patient-years; P < 0.01) than patients with normal antibody levels. There were no differences in the frequency of myocardial infarction, coronary artery bypass, access age, presence of diabetes mellitus, platelet counts, anticardiolipin antibody, albumin, lactate dehydrogenase, or C-reactive protein levels. In conclusion, patients with PTFE grafts and elevated antibody levels to topical bovine thrombin had significantly more vascular access thrombosis.

Antibodies to Prothrombin, Factor V, and β2-Glycoprotein I and Vascular Access Thrombosis

We studied 88 hemodialysis patients for the presence of antibodies to human factor II (hFII), bovine factor V (bFV), and human &bgr;2-glycoprotein I (&bgr;2GPI). Forty-one patients had elevated anti-hFII antibodies, 17 had elevated anti-bFV antibodies, and 9 had elevated anti-&bgr;2GPI antibodies. Fifty-two patients had elevated antibodies to one or more protein. Patients with PTFE grafts had elevated antibodies most frequently (21 [75%]vs. 20 fistulas [45%;p = 0.016 compared with PTFE] and 11 tunneled catheters [68.8%]). Twelve of 13 patients (92.3%) with PTFE grafts and thrombosis had elevated antibody levels, compared with 9 of 15 without thrombosis (60%;p = 0.049). The number of thromboses and mean thrombosis rates were significantly higher in PTFE patients with antibodies (1.24 vs. 0.14 thromboses, p < 0.01; 42.67 vs. 6.44 thromboses/100 patient years, p < 0.05). When analyzed individually, thrombotic complications occurred more frequently in patients with PTFE grafts and elevated anti-bFV antibodies (p = 0.016), but did not correlate with anti-hFII or anti-&bgr;2GPI antibodies. Thrombotic complications did not correlate with elevated antibody levels in patients with AV fistulas or cuffed catheters. In conclusion, hemodialysis patients with PTFE grafts frequently have elevated antibodies to FII, FV, and &bgr;2GPI, and the presence of elevated antibody levels to one or more of these proteins is associated with an increased thrombotic risk. Further studies are necessary to determine whether limiting exposure to bovine thrombin preparations will decrease the incidence of these antibodies and PTFE graft thrombosis.

Binding of factor VIII inhibitors to discrete regions of the factor VIII C2 domain disrupt phospholipid binding.

We characterized seven factor VIII inhibitors with epitopes in the C2 domain of factor VIII using a series of factor V C2 domain chimeras that substituted exon-sized fragments of the C2 domain of factor VIII for the corresponding regions of factor V. All inhibited co-factor activity of factor VIII and six inhibited binding of factor VIII to phosphatidylserine. Inhibitors Hz, JN and GK32 bound epitopes within amino acids S2173–K2281; inhibitors GK24 and TO bound epitopes within amino acids V2223–Y2332; and inhibitors UNC11 and UNC12 bound epitopes throughout the C2 domain (amino acids S2173–Y2332). Inhibitors Hz, JN and UNC12 inhibited the co-factor activity of chimera 5A, which substituted amino acids S2173–Q2222 of factor VIII for the corresponding region of factor V, in a prothrombinase assay. This inhibition could be partially reversed by pre-incubation of chimera 5A with phospholipid vesicles, suggesting that these antibodies interfered with phospholipid binding. Inhibitors UNC11 and UNC12, on the other hand, did not inhibit the binding of chimera 1A to phosphatidylserine, suggesting that binding to the segment spanning amino acids V2282–Y2332 does not necessarily block phospholipid binding. These results agree with the model of the phospholipid-binding site determined by crystal structure of the C2 domain of factor VIII.