Karen Roberts

Achieving Accurate Compound Concentration in Cell-Based Screening: Validation of Acoustic Droplet Ejection Technology

Compound handling is a fundamental and critical step in compound screening throughout the drug discovery process. Although most compound-handling processes within compound management facilities use 100% DMSO solvent, conventional methods of manual or robotic liquid-handling systems in screening workflows often perform dilutions in aqueous solutions to maintain solvent tolerance of the biological assay. However, the use of aqueous media in these applications can lead to suboptimal data quality due to compound carryover or precipitation during the dilution steps. In cell-based assays, this effect is worsened by the unpredictable physical characteristics of compounds and the low DMSO tolerance within the assay. In some cases, the conventional approaches using manual or automated liquid handling resulted in variable IC50 dose responses. This study examines the cause of this variability and evaluates the accuracy of screening data in these case studies. A number of liquid-handling options have been explored to address the issues and establish a generic compound-handling workflow to support cell-based screening across our screening functions. The authors discuss the validation of the Labcyte Echo reformatter as an effective noncontact solution for generic compound-handling applications against diverse compound classes using triple-quad liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry. The successful validation and implementation challenges of this technology for direct dosing onto cells in cell-based screening is discussed. (Journal of Biomolecular Screening 2009:452-459)

Structure-Guided Design of Highly Selective and Potent Covalent Inhibitors of Erk1/2.

The RAS/RAF/MEK/ERK signaling pathway has been targeted with a number of small molecule inhibitors in oncology clinical development across multiple disease indications. Importantly, cell lines with acquired resistance to B-RAF and MEK inhibitors have been shown to maintain sensitivity to ERK1/2 inhibition by small molecule inhibitors. There are a number of selective, noncovalent ERK1/2 inhibitors reported along with the promiscuous hypothemycin (and related analogues) that act via a covalent mechanism of action. This article reports the identification of multiple series of highly selective covalent ERK1/2 inhibitors informed by structure-based drug design (SBDD). As a starting point for these covalent inhibitors, reported ERK1/2 inhibitors and a chemical series identified via high-throughput screening were exploited. These approaches resulted in the identification of selective covalent tool compounds for potential in vitro and in vivo studies to assess the risks and or benefits of targeting this pathway through such a mechanism of action.

Protein-Ligand Crystal Structures Can Guide the Design of Selective Inhibitors of the FGFR Tyrosine Kinase.

The design of compounds that selectively inhibit a single kinase is a significant challenge, particularly for compounds that bind to the ATP site. We describe here how protein-ligand crystal structure information was able both to rationalize observed selectivity and to guide the design of more selective compounds. Inhibition data from enzyme and cellular screens and the crystal structures of a range of ligands tested during the process of identifying selective inhibitors of FGFR provide a step-by-step illustration of the process. Steric effects were exploited by increasing the size of ligands in specific regions in such a way as to be tolerated in the primary target and not in other related kinases. Kinases are an excellent target class to exploit such approaches because of the conserved fold and small side chain mobility of the active form.

Synthesis and pharmacological characterization of novel druglike corticotropin-releasing factor 1 antagonists.

To identify new CRF(1) receptor antagonists, an attempt to modify the bis-heterocycle moiety present in the top region of the dihydropyrrole[2,3]pyridine template was made following new pharmacophoric hypothesis on the CRF(1) receptor antagonists binding pocket. In particular, the 2-thiazole ring, present in the previous series of compounds, was replaced by more hydrophilic non aromatic heterocycles able to make appropriate H-bond interactions with amino acid residues Thr192 and Tyr195. This exploration, followed by an accurate analysis of the substitution of the pendant aryl ring, enabled to identify in vitro potent compounds showing excellent pharmacokinetics and outstanding in vivo activity in animal models of anxiety, both in rodents and primates.

A Screening Assay Cascade to Identify and Characterize Novel Selective Estrogen Receptor Downregulators (SERDs)

Here, we describe an approach to identify novel selective estrogen receptor downregulator (SERD) compounds with improved properties such as oral bioavailability and the potential of increased efficacy compared to currently marketed drug treatments. Previously, methodologies such as Western blotting and transient cell reporter assays have been used to identify and characterize SERD compounds, but such approaches can be limited due to low throughput and sensitivity, respectively. We have used an endogenous cell-imaging strategy that has both the throughput and sensitivity to support a large-scale hit-to-lead program to identify novel compounds. A screening cascade with a suite of assays has been developed to characterize compounds that modulate estrogen receptor α (ERα)-mediated signaling or downregulate ERα levels in cells. Initially, from a focused high-throughput screening, novel ERα binders were identified that could be modified chemically into ERα downregulators. Following this, cellular assays helped determine the mechanism of action of compounds to distinguish between on-target and off-target compounds and differentiate SERDs, selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERM) compounds, and agonist ERα ligands. Data are shown to exemplify the characterization of ERα-mediated signaling inhibitors using a selection of literature compounds and illustrate how this cascade has been used to drive the chemical design of novel SERD compounds.

Structure-Guided Discovery of Potent and Selective Inhibitors of ERK1/2 from a Modestly Active and Promiscuous Chemical Start Point.

There are a number of small-molecule inhibitors targeting the RAS/RAF/MEK/ERK signaling pathway that have either been approved or are in clinical development for oncology across a range of disease indications. The inhibition of ERK1/2 is of significant current interest, as cell lines with acquired resistance to BRAF and MEK inhibitors have been shown to maintain sensitivity to ERK1/2 inhibition in preclinical models. This article reports on our recent work to identify novel, potent, and selective reversible ERK1/2 inhibitors from a low-molecular-weight, modestly active, and highly promiscuous chemical start point, compound 4. To guide and inform the evolution of this series, inhibitor binding mode information from X-ray crystal structures was critical in the rapid exploration of this template to compound 35, which was active when tested in in vivo antitumor efficacy experiments.

Cellular assay optimization: part I: the use of large-scale transiently transfected cryobanks and introduction of a c-Myc tag to design a standardized ELISA process.

This study investigated the use of large-scale transiently transfected cryopreserved cells for medium-throughput cellular screening. The data generated indicated that preprepared transiently transfected cryobanks can be used for cell-based assays and in fact can greatly enhance the consistency of data generated by cellular screens. In addition to this, a generic enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay method was designed that introduced a c-Myc tag to four different targets and allowed all four cell assays to be run using a standardized process. These process improvements yielded cost savings and greatly reduced the required resource, as well as reducing timelines for developing cellular assays.

Cellular assay optimization: part II: the use of a simple integrated robotic work cell to allow the multiplexed batching of cellular assays.

This report describes the implementation of an automated work cell with commercially available hardware and software, capable of handling up to 15 separate reagents for performing 96-well or 384-well assays but with a small footprint and only a single liquid dispenser and two plate washers. Extremely flexible software was used to enable this simple work cell to perform processes that would traditionally require a much larger, more expensive automation platform. With the development of the C-Myc assays for the targets DYRK, BMX, PERK, and FAK, the authors describe a software solution to multibatch assays to run simultaneously, reducing reagent dead volume and increasing the efficiency of running multiple assays such that the time to generate data across multiple targets was significantly shortened. Although a larger automated system with multiple robotic arms and extensive equipment would also be able to process multiple assays simultaneously, the work cell we have described represents an inexpensive and flexible, easily upgradable option suitable for a wider range of labs.

Implementation and Challenges of Direct Acoustic Dosing into Cell-Based Assays

Since the adoption of Labcyte Echo Acoustic Droplet Ejection (ADE) technology by AstraZeneca in 2005, ADE has become the preferred method for compound dosing into both biochemical and cell-based assays across AstraZeneca research and development globally. The initial implementation of Echos and the direct dosing workflow provided AstraZeneca with a unique set of challenges. In this article, we outline how direct Echo dosing has evolved over the past decade in AstraZeneca. We describe the practical challenges of applying ADE technology to 96-well, 384-well, and 1536-well assays and how AstraZeneca developed and applied software and robotic solutions to generate fully automated and effective cell-based assay workflows.