Karen Veltri

A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials comparing endoscopic and open carpal tunnel decompression.

Controversy exists regarding the benefit of endoscopic carpal tunnel release versus open carpal tunnel release in terms of grip/pinch strength, scar tenderness, pain, return to work, reversible/irreversible nerve damage, and adverse effects. Although a number of randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews have been published on the subject, to date, no large definitive randomized controlled trial or meta-analysis has been performed comparing endoscopic to open carpal tunnel release. This meta-analysis was undertaken to address the effectiveness of endoscopic carpal tunnel release relative to open carpal tunnel release. Key outcome measures from 13 randomized controlled trials were extracted and statistically combined. Heterogeneity was observed in three of the outcomes (i.e., grip strength, pain, and return to work), but the causes of heterogeneity could not be explained because of insufficient detail in the reported studies. Using the Jadad et al. scale, nine of 13 studies were of low methodologic quality. The effect sizes were compared between the studies that were rated as high quality and the studies that were rated as low quality on the Jadad et al. scale. Similarly, the studies that were rated as high quality on the Gerritsen et al. scale were compared with those that were rated as low quality. No clinically significant difference in effect sizes was apparent between studies of high and low methodologic quality. This meta-analysis supports the conclusion that endoscopic carpal tunnel release is favored over the open carpal tunnel release in terms of a reduction in scar tenderness and increase in grip and pinch strength at a 12-week follow-up. With regard to symptom relief and return to work, the data are inconclusive. Irreversible nerve damage is uncommon in either technique; however, there is an increased susceptibility to reversible nerve injury that is three times as likely to occur with endoscopic carpal tunnel release than with open carpal tunnel release.

A prospective study of patients undergoing breast reduction surgery: health-related quality of life and clinical outcomes.

Background: This study assessed the health-related quality of life experienced by breast reduction patients using four reliable and validated health-related quality-of-life measures. Methods: Consecutive patients with breast hypertrophy completed the Health Utilities Index Mark 2, the Health Utilities Index Mark 3, and the Breast Reduction Assessment Value and Outcomes instruments (the Short Form 36, the Multidimensional Body-Self Rating Questionnaire Appearance Assessment, and the Breast-Related Symptom Questionnaire) at 1 week and 1 day before surgery and at 1, 6, and 12 months after surgery. Results: For the 52 patients in the study, mean scores for all quality-of-life instruments increased from the preoperative assessments to the postoperative assessments. The mean quality-adjusted life years gained per patient because of the surgery was 0.12 during the 1-year follow-up period. There was a positive relationship (p < 0.001) between breast resection weight and body mass index. However, body mass index and tissue resection weight were not significantly associated with Health Utilities Index Mark 3 change scores (p > 0.05). Conclusions: Patients who undergo breast reduction experience an important improvement in health-related quality of life according to four established measures. The improvement is most noticeable between 1 day before surgery and 1 month after surgery, after which it stabilizes for up to 1 year. The health-related quality-of-life effect of the surgery translates into an expected lifetime gain of 5.32 quality-adjusted life years, which is equivalent to each patient living an additional 5.32 years in perfect health. The authors conclude that there is no justification for the ongoing restriction or denials of third-party payments based on body mass index.

Decompression of the common peroneal nerve: experience with 20 consecutive cases.

A retrospective review of 20 patients with common peroneal nerve palsy treated with decompression between 1986 and 1997 was undertaken. Subjects were evaluated preoperatively and postoperatively by electromyography, nerve conduction, and clinical measures. The mean interval between the onset of symptoms to surgery (operative delay) was 15.9 months. The mean postoperative follow‐up was 32.2 months with a minimum follow‐up of 1 year. Decompression was performed at the level of the fibular neck and slightly distally at the tendinous origin of the peroneus longus using a standard approach to release tight fascial structures or scar tissue. External neurolysis was performed using the operating microscope in two cases for which scarring of the nerve was identified intraoperatively. Postoperatively, 19 of 20 patients showed improvement in ankle dorsiflexion as assessed by the Medical Research Council scale. Electromyographic examination was useful in the preoperative evaluation and selection of patients for decompression surgery. In conclusion, decompression even after a 1‐year delay may offer benefit and suggest early intervention in patients with a severe lesion. (Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 107: 1183, 2001.)

Clinical application of sensory protection of denervated muscle

Following proximal peripheral nerve injury, motor recovery is often poor due to prolonged muscle denervation and loss of regenerative potential. The transfer of a sensory nerve to denervated muscle results in improved functional recovery in experimental models. The authors here report the first clinical case of sensory protection. Following a total hip arthroplasty, this patient experienced a complete sciatic nerve palsy with no recovery at 3 months postsurgery and profound denervation confirmed electrodiagnostically. He underwent simultaneous neurolysis of the sciatic nerve and saphenous nerve transfers to the tibialis anterior branch of the peroneal nerve and gastrocnemius branch from the tibial nerve. He noted an early proprioceptive response. Electromyography demonstrated initially selective amelioration of denervation potentials followed by improved motor recovery in sensory protected muscles only. The patient reported clinically significant functional improvements in activities of daily living. The authors hypothesize that the presence of a sensory nerve during muscle denervation can improve functional motor recovery.

Application of the CONSORT statement to randomized controlled trials comparing endoscopic and open carpal tunnel release

BACKGROUND The CONSORT (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials) statement was developed by a group of clinical trialists, biostatisticians, epidemiologists and biomedical editors as a means to improve the quality of reports of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). The purpose of the present study is to assess the reporting quality of published RCTs that compare endoscopic carpal tunnel release (ECTR) with open carpal tunnel release (OCTR) using the CONSORT statement. METHODS A computerized literature search was conducted to identify all RCTs published from January 1989 to November 2004 that compared ECTR with OCTR. Foreign language studies were also included, and translated versions of these studies were obtained. Two investigators independently reviewed each eligible article and determined whether the authors reported on each of the 22 items of the CONSORT statement. Disagreements were resolved by consensus. The mean scores for studies published before the introduction of the CONSORT statement and those published afterward were compared. Similarly, a comparison was made between foreign language studies and those published in English. RESULTS Eighteen RCTs comparing ECTR with OCTR met the inclusion criteria. The total scores on the CONSORT checklist ranged from 3 to 20, with a mean score of 9.83+/-3.79 (the maximum possible score was 22). The six studies published in foreign language journals had a statistically significantly lower mean score than the studies published in English language journals (7.00+/-2.76 versus 11.25+/-3.49, respectively; P<0.05). The mean score was higher for studies published after 1996 than for those published in 1996 or earlier (12.14+/-3.80 versus 8.36+/-3.11, respectively; P<0.05). CONCLUSIONS The quality of reporting improved over time, but no study met all 22 criteria of the CONSORT statement. The CONSORT scores were higher for studies published after 1996 and for studies published in English language journals. Despite the improvement after 1996, most of these RCTs only reported one-half of the items listed on the CONSORT statement. Future investigators of surgical RCTs should make an effort to comply with the CONSORT checklist.

Ischemia of the hand secondary to radial artery thrombosis: A report of three cases.

Upper extremity arterial thrombosis, though rare, is more prevalent on the ulnar side of the circulation, with the most common etiology being repetitive blunt trauma to the hypothenar eminence. Radial artery thrombosis is even more rare and when it does occur, is associated most often with iatrogenic cannulation, producing subsequent thrombi and emboli. Three cases of spontaneous thrombosis of the radial artery extending to the superficial palmar arch and the princeps pollicis artery are presented here. Two patients underwent thrombectomies and one underwent excision of the thrombosed segment and reconstruction with a reversed saphenous vein graft. The etiology of the thrombus was consistent with cancer in two cases and trauma in one.

A mechanism for the loss of cytochrome P-450 in primary mouse hepatocytes

This study examined various biochemical parameters such as mitochondria and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), total heme and cyto P450 content in fresh hepatocytes and dedifferentiated hepatocytes. These parameters were chosen in order to understand the dramatic decrease in drug metabolism in cultured hepatocytes. The data in this study shows a temporal decrease in cytochrome P450, total heme and also a decrease in mitochondria. Also, the ratio of mtDNA content to mitochondrial density was found to increase as hepatocytes underwent dedifferentiation. Stereological analysis of cell preparations provided a measure of mitochondrial density per cell area and mtDNA content was assessed by the use of a specific radiolabelled probe. This study demonstrates that a loss of the organelle which is partially responsible for synthesis of heme correlates with a decrease in cytochrome P450.

Effects of differentiation of embryonal carcinoma cells (P19) on mitochondrial DNA content in vitro

SummaryThe embryonal carcinoma cell line P19 is derived from mouse teratocarcinomas. These pluripotent cells can be induced to differentiate into a variety of cell types by exposure to various drugs. We used retinoic acid to induce embryonal carcinoma cells to differentiate into neuronlike cells. In this study, we show that changes occur in mitochondria during differentiation of embryonal carcinoma cells to neuronlike cells. We found that various morphologic parameters such as mitochondrial fractional area and mitochondrial size decrease as embryonal carcinoma cells differentiate into neuronlike cells. Similar changes were also observed in mitochondrial DNA content. Stereologic analysis of cell preparations provided a measure of mitochondrial fractional area per cell and mtDNA content was assessed by radiolabeled mtDNA probe. This study establishes that mitochondria are regulated as cells differentiate.