Kathy I. Kennedy

Effectiveness of the lactational amenorrhea method in Pakistan.

OBJECTIVE To determine the efficacy of the lactational amenorrhea method of family planning (amenorrhea during full or nearly full breastfeeding for 6 months postpartum). DESIGN Prospective noncomparative study. SETTING Normal breastfeeding women in Karachi and Multan, Pakistan, most delivered at home by a midwife. PATIENTS Three hundred ninety-nine newly delivered mothers who successfully had breastfed a previous child and chose the lactational amenorrhea method to prevent a subsequent pregnancy, 391 of whom were followed for a full year. INTERVENTIONS Mothers were taught, before or shortly after delivery, to use the method and were interviewed in their homes each month by a Lady Health Visitor. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE Life-table pregnancy rates. Periods of postpartum or lactational abstinence were excluded in the calculation of the pregnancy rates. RESULTS During full or nearly full breastfeeding, while the women were amenorrheic and not otherwise contracepting, the rate of pregnancy was 0.6%. The pregnancy rate during lactational amenorrhea alone was 1.1% at 1 year postpartum. CONCLUSION The lactational amenorrhea method was found to be highly effective for 6 months. A high degree of contraceptive protection endures for a full year during lactational amenorrhea, but not after the return of menses during breastfeeding.

Premature introduction of progestin-only contraceptive methods during lactation

Experts on contraceptive technology concur that progestin-only methods can be used safely during lactation. However, very few studies exist of the effects on lactation of the introduction of progestin-only methods prior to the sixth postpartum week. Since progesterone withdrawal is the likely stimulus that initiates lactogenesis, it appears necessary for natural progesterone levels to decline to baseline before a progestin-only contraceptive is initiated. Therefore, the use of such contraceptive methods should be delayed for at least 3 days after the birth. Non-hormonal methods remain the first choice category of contraceptive methods for breastfeeding women, since there is no possibility that they will interfere with lactation. Progestin-only methods comprise a viable and often desirable next choice category, although the timing of their commencement must be determined with care in order to support lactation.

Breast-feeding and the return to ovulation in Durango, Mexico *

Twenty-nine breast-feeding mothers and 10 non-breast-feeding postpartum comparison mothers from a rural area of Mexico were followed longitudinally until ovulation resumed. A simple set of guidelines is described involving three obvious milestones for the breast-feeding mother to safely use the natural contraceptive benefit of breast-feeding. Those milestones are: the first vaginal bleeding episode, the initiation of supplementation, and the childs monthly birthday. In the absence of bleeding and supplementation, 100% of breast-feeding mothers remained anovular for 3 months postpartum, 96% for 4 months, 96% for 5 months, and 96% for 6 months. This suggests that, if a mother understands these three conditions, she can use breast-feeding alone as effectively as modern family planning methods for the prevention of pregnancy.

Policy Considerations for the Introduction and Promotion of the Lactational Amenorrhea Method: Advantages and Disadvantages of LAM

Some attributes of LAM are unquestionably positive, such as the fact that it is effective. Clinical trials of LAM have upheld the Bellagio Consensus that the chance of pregnancy is less than 2% in the first 6 months postpartum in amenorrheic women who are fully or nearly fully breastfeeding. Secondary data analyses in numerous settings have drawn the same conclusion. Whether as a strategy or a method, used correctly or even if used imperfectly, LAM is a reliable way to avoid pregnancy. To the extent that LAM represents an additional contraceptive option, this is also clearly positive since a broad array of contraceptive options maximizes the likelihood of finding a good fit between user and method, and increases contraceptive use. Other characteristics of LAM represent potentially positive impacts. If LAM is shown to be an effective conduit to other modern methods, the implications are profoundly positive. If LAM is cost effective, for households and/or for programs, this will also make the method extraordinarily attractive. Conversely, some aspects of LAM are negative, such as the fact that it affords no protection against STDs, it requires counseling from a well-informed provider, and intensive breastfeeding can make heavy demands on the womans time. Many of the remaining attributes of LAM may not be important to a policy decision about LAM promotion. For example, whether LAM is actualized as a strategy or a method may not be important to a decision to promote LAM, although it has a huge impact on how services are delivered. Some factors may be profound on a local or individual level. For example, one simple factor, such as the absence of full/nearly full breastfeeding, can rule out the method as an option, while another, such as the fact that it provides the needed waiting period during vasectomy counseling, can make LAM the method of choice. Although LAM seems unlikely to have widespread popularity in societies like the United States, within such settings are breastfeeding women for whom other contraceptive choices are not satisfactory and to whom LAM is attractive. Although clinicians cannot be expected to directly provide LAM education in every setting, women should be informed about LAM as an effective contraceptive choice, and clinicians should be prepared to make referrals to competent sources. The future of LAM, especially in terms of formal, programmatic initiatives, may continue to be focussed in transitional and less developed settings. Comparative cost/benefit analyses for both the family planning program and the household will contribute meaningfully to decisions about whether to use LAM and whether to include LAM in national and local family planning policies and programs. The most important call to action is to implement operations research designed to determine what factors, if any, will maximize the uptake of a second modern contraceptive method after LAM protection expires among never-users of family planning, to compare this with other contraceptive strategies, and to evaluate the cost aspects. If the potential of LAM to be a conduit to other modern contraceptive methods is effectively realized, the method can be profoundly important in the development of communities and in family formation. Because LAM is effective in preventing pregnancies, and because it extends the range of contraceptive choices, considering LAM on the policy level is always appropriate. Despite the array of drawbacks to LAM, as with any other family planning method, the potential assets of LAM, especially the promise to introduce nonusers to contraception, are sufficiently important to warrant the introduction of LAM within an operations research framework to both capitalize on its intrinsic strengths and determine its programmatic robustness. In the 10 years since the concept of LAM was pronounced as the Bellagio Consensus, claims have been made both for and against its use. During this time, program and policy leaders have been giv

The duration and character of postpartum bleeding among breast-feeding women*

Objective To examine the postpartum bleeding experience of a cohort of breast-feeding women and to compare it with the conventional definition of lochia. Methods Four hundred seventy-seven experienced breast-feeding women in Manila, the Philippines, were followed prospectively from delivery and recorded vaginal bleeding in a menstrual diary. The median duration of lochia was calculated using survival analysis. In addition, all bleeding separate from lochia within the first 8 weeks postpartum was noted. Results The median duration of lochia was 27 days and did not vary by age, parity, sex or weight of the infant, breast-feeding frequency, or level of supplementation. More than one-fourth of the women experienced a bleeding episode separated from the original lochial flow by at least 4 bleeding-free days and beginning no later than postpartum day 56. Ten breast-feeding women may have had their first menstrual bleed before day 56. Conclusions Lochia lasted substantially longer than the conventional assumption of 2 weeks. It was common for postpartum bleeding to stop and again or to be characterized by intermittent spotting or bleeding. Return of menses is rare among fully breast-feeding. Return of menses is rare among fully breast-feeding women in the first 8 weeks postpartum.

Breastfeeding and the symptothermal method.

This prospective study was conducted among experienced users of periodic abstinence methods in Sydney, Montreal, and Birmingham (England) in order to describe the relationship between a laboratory measurement of ovulation and the natural symptoms of fertility during breastfeeding. Daily urinary estrogen and pregnanediol glucuronide assays were used to estimate the date of ovulation and to determine potentially fertile days. A standard set of Symptothermal Method (STM) rules was applied to daily STM records to assess the correspondence of the natural symptoms of fertility to the underlying hormonal profile. The STM symptoms and rules accurately identified 77-94 percent of the womens potentially fertile days, but abstinence was also recommended on about half of the days when the women were not fertile. An integrated set of common rules for STM use during breastfeeding is highly sensitive but not specific in its ability to screen for ovulation.

Effects of breastfeeding on women's health

Research about the effects of breastfeeding on maternal health has concentrated primarily on breast cancer, bone loss, and maternal depletion. Breastfeeding may provide some protection against breast cancer. Adequate maternal nutrition, a prolonged period of weaning, and adequate child spacing are expected to alleviate any potential bone loss or maternal depletion caused by breastfeeding. Regardless of how one chooses to weigh the relative benefits and risks of breastfeeding to the mother, it seems clear that the programmatic tasks are to see that breastfeeding women are adequately fed and enabled to space their pregnancies.

The recovery of fertility during breast-feeding in Assiut, Egypt

A longitudinal study of twenty-six breast-feeding and twelve non-breast-feeding postpartum women was conducted in Assiut, Egypt in order to determine the time that ovulation resumed after childbirth, and the effect of breast-feeding frequency on the period of lactational anovulation. Breast-feeding women experienced the onset of follicular development, vaginal bleeding, ovulation and pregnancy significantly later than women who did not breast-feed. Ovulatory and non-ovulatory breast-feeders reported similar frequencies of breast-feeding episodes. The introduction of dietary supplements commonly preceded ovulation. An algorithm using three simple variables observable to the breast-feeding mother was found to predict up to 100% of the first ovulations. All breast-feeding women who did not give supplements and did not have a vaginal bleeding episode by 6 months postpartum were anovular by strict criteria for ovulation. Ovulation did not precede bleeding or supplementation in the women who experienced these events before 6 months, yielding a highly effective formula for preventing unplanned pregnancy by the informed use of breast-feeding.

A new approach to measuring menstrual pattern change after sterilization

Methodologic problems with previous research on menstrual changes after sterilization have resulted in conflicting results. This research overcomes these problems by restricting the categories of patients and by minimizing recall difficulties. When the methodologic approach is improved, the result is that the majority of women experience no change, and among those who do, changes in one direction are counterbalanced by changes in the other direction. Three cycles preceding sterilization were compared with three cycles 12 months after the operation for four menstrual parameters. The parameters were examined separately and simultaneously by means of an index of menstrual pattern changes. Rings and spring-loaded clips were associated with less change than other methods of occlusion. The most important variable was the patients menstrual pattern at the time of admission. Women defined as having abnormal patterns were three times more likely to experience change than women with normal cycles, and many of the former experienced change in the direction of normality.

A comparison of two U.S. surveys of infant feeding.

This study compares the 1988 National Maternal and Infant Health Survey (NMIHS) and the 1989 Ross Laboratories Mothers Survey with respect to sample characteristics and proportions of women who breastfed. Weighted proportions of women included in the two surveys were compared according to various characteristics to see how well they represented U.S. childbearing women. A z-statistic was produced to test for significant differences in the proportions who breastfed. In 1988-89, 52.2% of American women breastfed according to the Ross survey and 53.4% according to the NMIHS. Despite differences in sample size, sampling technique and the application of sample weights, the difference between the surveys was only 1 percentage point, and most levels of most variables examined were comparable. The Ross survey is a valuable source of data because it is ongoing, and it is generally corroborated by the NMIHS. The NMIHS is probably more representative of the U.S. population of childbearing women, and is a reliable source of data for setting U.S. objectives concerning infant feeding, and for the study of other issues vis-a-vis breastfeeding.