Kevin C. Radil

Performance and Durability of High Temperature Foil Air Bearings for Oil-Free Turbomachinery

The performance and durability of advanced, high temperature foil air bearings are evaluated under a wide range (10 to 50 kPa) of loads at temperatures from 25° to 650 °C. The bearings are made from uncoated nickel based superalloy foils. The foil surface experiences sliding contact with the shaft during initial start/stop operation. To reduce friction and wear, the solid lubricant coating, PS304, is applied to the shaft by plasma spraying. PS304 is a NiCr based Cr2O3 coating with silver and barium fluoride/calcium fluoride solid lubricant additions. The results show that the bearings provide lives well in excess of 30,000 cycles under all of the conditions tested. Several bearings exhibited lives in excess of 100,000 cycles. Wear is a linear function of the bearing load. The excellent performance measured in this study suggests that these bearings and the PS304 coating are well suited for advanced high temperature, oil-free turbomachinery applications. Presented at the 55th Annual Meeting Nashville, Tennessee May 7–11, 2000

The role of radial clearance on the performance of foil air bearings

Load capacity tests were conducted to determine how radial clearance variations affect the load capacity coefficient of foil air bearings. Two Generation III foil air bearings with the same design but possessing different initial radial clearances were tested at room temperature against an as-ground PS304 coated journal operating at 30000 rpm. Increases in radial clearance were accomplished by reducing the journals outside diameter via an in-place grinding system. From each load capacity test the bearing load capacity coefficient was calculated from the rule-of-thumb (ROT) model developed for foil air bearings. The test results indicate that, in terms of the load capacity coefficient, radial clearance has a direct impact on the performance of the foil air bearing. Each test bearing exhibited an optimum radial clearance that resulted in a maximum load capacity coefficient. Relative to this optimum value are two separate operating regimes that are governed by different modes of failure. Bearings operating with radial clearances less than the optimum exhibit load capacity coefficients that are a strong function of radial clearance and are prone to a thermal runaway failure mechanism and bearing seizure. Conversely, a bearing operating with a radial clearance twice the optimum suffered only a 20% decline in its maximum load capacity coefficient and did not experience any thermal management problems. However, it is unknown to what degree these changes in radial clearance had on other performance parameters, such as the stiffness and damping properties of the bearings. Presented as a Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers Paper at the ASME/STLE Tribology Conference in Cancun, Mexico October 27–30, 2002

Design, Fabrication, and Performance of Open Source Generation I and II Compliant Hydrodynamic Gas Foil Bearings

Foil gas bearings are self-acting hydrodynamic bearings made from sheet metal foils comprised of at least two layers. The innermost “top foil” layer traps a gas pressure film that supports a load while a layer or layers underneath provide an elastic foundation. Foil bearings are used in many lightly loaded, high-speed turbomachines such as compressors used for aircraft pressurization and small microturbines. Foil gas bearings provide a means to eliminate the oil system leading to reduced weight and enhanced temperature capability. The general lack of familiarity of the foil bearing design and manufacturing process has hindered their widespread dissemination. This paper reviews the publicly available literature to demonstrate the design, fabrication, and performance testing of both first- and second-generation bump-style foil bearings. It is anticipated that this paper may serve as an effective starting point for new development activities employing foil bearing technology.

A systems approach to the solid lubrication of foil air bearings for oil-free turbomachinery

Foil air bearings are self-acting hydrodynamic bearings which rely upon solid lubricants to reduce friction and minimize wear during sliding which occurs at start-up and shutdown when surface speeds are too low to allow the formation of a hydrodynamic air film. This solid lubrication is typically accomplished by coating the nonmoving foil surface with a thin, soft polymeric film. The following paper introduces a systems approach in which the solid lubrication is provided by a combination of self lubricating shaft coatings coupled with various wear resistant and lubricating foil coatings. The use of multiple materials, each providing different functions is modeled after oil-lubricated hydrodynamic sleeve bearing technology which utilizes various coatings and surface treatments in conjunction with oil lubricants to achieve optimum performance. In this study, room temperature load capacity tests are performed on journal foil air bearings operating at 14,000 rpm. Different shaft and foil coating technologies such as plasma sprayed composites, ceramic, polymer and inorganic lubricant coatings are evaluated as foil bearing lubricants. The results indicate that bearing performance is improved through the individual use of the lubricants and treatments tested. Further, combining several solid lubricants together yielded synergistically better results than any material alone. @DOI: 10.1115/1.1609485#

An Experimental Investigation into the Temperature Profile of a Compliant Foil Air Bearing

A series of tests was performed to determine the internal temperature profile in a compliant bump-type foil journal air bearing operating at room temperature under various speed and load conditions. The temperature profile was collected by instrumenting a foil bearing with nine type-K thermocouples arranged in the center and along the bearings edges in order to measure local temperatures and estimate thermal gradients in the axial and circumferential directions. To facilitate the measurement of maximum temperatures from viscous shearing in the air film, the thermocouples were tack-welded to the backside of the bumps that were in direct contact with the top foil. The mating journal was coated with a high-temperature solid lubricant that, together with the bearing, underwent high-temperature start-stop cycles to produce a smooth, steady-state run-in surface. Tests were conducted at speeds from 20 to 50 krpm and loads ranged from 9 to 222 N. The results indicate that, over the conditions tested, both journal rotational speed and radial load are responsible for heat generation with speed playing a more significant role in the magnitude of the temperatures. The temperature distribution was nearly symmetric about the bearing center at 20 and 30 krpm but became slightly skewed toward one side at 40 and 50 krpm. Surprisingly, the maximum temperatures did not occur at the bearing edge, where the minimum film thickness is expected, but rather in the middle of the bearing, where analytical investigations have predicted the air film to be much thicker. Thermal gradients were common during testing and were strongest in the axial direction from the middle of the bearing to its edges, reaching 3.78° C/mm. The temperature profile indicated the circumferential thermal gradients were negligible.

The Effect of Journal Roughness and Foil Coatings on the Performance of Heavily Loaded Foil Air Bearings

Foil air bearing load capacity tests were conducted to investigate if a solid lubricant coating applied to the surface of the bearings top foil can function as a break-in coating. Two foil coating materials, a conventional soft polymer film (polyimide) and a hard ceramic (alumina), were independently evaluated against as-ground and worn (run-in) journals coated with NASA PS304, a high-temperature solid lubricant composite coating. The foil coatings were evaluated at journal rotational speeds of 30,000 rpm and at 25 °C. Tests were also performed on a foil bearing with a bare (uncoated) nickel-based superalloy top foil to establish a baseline for comparison. The test results indicate that the presence of a top foil solid lubricant coating is effective at increasing the load capacity performance of the foil bearing. Compared to the uncoated baseline, the addition of the soft polymer coating on the top foil increased the bearing load coefficient by 120 percent when operating against an as-ground journal surface and 85% against a run-in journal surface. The alumina coating increased the load coefficient by 40 percent against the as-ground journal but did not have any effect when the bearing was operated with the run-in journal. The results suggest that the addition of solid lubricant films provide added lubrication when the air film is marginal, indicating that as the load capacity is approached foil air bearings transition from hydrodynamic to mixed and boundary lubrication. Presented at the 56th Annual Meeting in Orlando, Florida May 20–24, 2001

Thermal Management Techniques for Oil-Free Turbomachinery Systems

Tests were performed to evaluate three different methods of utilizing air to provide thermal management control for compliant journal foil air bearings. The effectiveness of the methods was based on bearing bulk temperature and axial thermal gradient reductions during air delivery. The first method utilized direct impingement of air on the inner surface of a hollow test journal during operation. The second, less indirect method achieved heat removal by blowing air inside the test journal parallel to the shaft axis to simulate air flowing axially through a hollow shaft. The third method emulated the most common approach to removing heat by forcing air axially through the bearings support structure. Internal bearing temperatures were measured with three type K thermocouples embedded in the bearing that measured general internal temperatures and axial thermal gradients. Testing was performed in a 1 atm, 260°C ambient environment with the bearing operating at 60 krpm, and supporting a load of 222 N. Air volumetric flows of 0.06, 0.11, and 0.17 m3/min at approximately 150 to 200°C were used. The tests indicate that all three methods provide thermal management but at different levels of effectiveness. Axial cooling of the bearing support structure had a greater effect on the bulk temperature for each air flow and demonstrated that the thermal gradients could be influenced by the directionality of the air flow. Direct air impingement on the journals inside surface provided uniform reductions in both bulk temperature and thermal gradients. Similar to the direct method, indirect journal cooling had a uniform cooling effect on both bulk temperatures and thermal gradients but was the least effective of the three methods.

Advanced Rotor Support Technologies for Closed Brayton Cycle Turbines

Closed Brayton Cycle (CBC) turbine generators are a leading power conversion candidate for long life space missions. In these systems, a recirculating gas is heated by nuclear, solar or other heat energy source then fed into a high speed turbine which drives an electrical generator. For closed cycle systems such as these, the working fluid also passes through the bearing compartments thus serving as a lubricant and bearing coolant. Compliant surface foil gas bearings are well suited for the rotor support systems of these advanced turbines. Foil bearings develop a thin hydrodynamic gas film which separates the rotating shaft from the bearing preventing wear. During start-up and shut down when speeds are low, rubbing occurs. Solid lubricants are used to reduce starting torque and minimize wear. Unlike fixed geometry rigid gas bearings, foil bearings are flexible and readily accommodate misalignment, thermal gradients and other system effects. Further, their stiffness and damping properties can be tailored for specific applications. In this paper the use of foil bearings as the rotor support system for a CBC will be reviewed. Bearing performance in inert gas and the bearing integration process will be discussed. In addition, a proven four step bearing-rotor integration process will be introduced which includes rotordynamic studies, bearing development and testing, experimental rotor simulation tests and finally system level turbine tests.

Foil Bearings Makes Oil-Free Turbocharger Possible

This paper describes an oil-free, 150 Hp turbocharger that was successfully operated with compliant foil bearings in a range of pitch and roll angles, including vertical operation, thereby demonstrating its viability for aircraft applications. On a gas test stand the turbocharger was operated to 120,000 rpm, under extreme conditions. In addition, the compliant foil bearing-supported turbocharger successfully tolerated shock and vibration of 40 g. Advanced technologies have been applied to the second generation of this turbocharger, shown in Figure 1, including self acting, compliant foil hydrodynamic air bearings with advanced coatings capable, of operation above 815 °C (1500°F). Journal foil bearings with maximum load capacity up to 670 kPa (97 psi) were used in conjunction with thrust foil bearings capable of maximum loads to 570 kPa (83 psi). Bearing component development tests demonstrated 30,000 start stop cycles at 815 °C (1500°F) with a newly developed, solid lubricant coating, KOROLON™. KOROLON™ exhibits a coefficient of friction of less than 0.1 at a wide range of temperatures. Current-designed foil bearings with KOROLON™ have immensely decreased turbolag, allowing acceleration from rest to over 100,000 rpm in less than 2 seconds. Advanced bearing stiffness maintained rotor total axial end-to-end motion within 100 microns (0.004 inch). Total radial static and dynamic motion was controlled within 25 microns (0.001 inch). Development of this high speed turbomachine included bearing and solid lubricant component development tests, rotor-bearing dynamic simulator qualification and gas stand tests of the assembled turbocharger. Gas stand and simulator test results revealed stable bearing temperatures, low rotor vibrations, good shock tolerance and the ability of the rotor bearing system to sustain overspeed conditions beyond 120,000 rpm. This combination of component and integrated rotor-bearing system technology addresses many of the issues associated with application of compliant foil bearings to industrial compressors, blowers, and gas turbine engines, overcoming many of the inherently show-stopping and debilitating features of rolling element bearings, i.e., speed and temperature limitations.Copyright

The Performance of PS400 Subjected to Sliding Contact at Temperatures from 260 to 927°C

ABSTRACT Adequate high-temperature lubrication between loaded surfaces in sliding contact can be one of the most challenging tribological problems confronting todays designers. In an attempt to provide a possible solution a test program was initiated to evaluate PS400, a recently patented, high-temperature solid lubricant coating. Made from nickel–molybdenum–aluminum, chrome oxide, silver, and barium fluoride–calcium fluoride, PS400 is a variant of the earlier coating, PS304, but is formulated for higher density, smoother surface texture, and greater dimensional stability. It was initially developed to minimize the start–stop wear in foil air bearings but is expected to perform well in other high-temperature applications where sliding friction and wear are a concern, such as variable inlet guide vanes and process control valve stems. To better define its operational capabilities, a series of tests was conducted to study the behavior of PS400 under reciprocating sliding contact at temperatures from 260 to 927°C. The tests were performed on stationary, uncoated cobalt-based superalloy bushings loaded against reciprocating PS400-coated shaft specimens in a flat-on-cylinder configuration at Hertz contact pressures from 14.1 to 20.1 MPa. For tests conducted below 927°C, friction coefficients ranged from 0.37 to 0.84 with wear factors on the order of 10−5 and 10−6 at the high temperatures but substantially increased at the lowest temperature. Data collected at 927°C were limited because the coating was found to be dimensionally unstable at this temperature.