Klaus Peter Sauer

Gender differences and individual variation in the immune system of the scorpionfly Panorpa vulgaris (Insecta : Mecoptera)

From investigations of the vertebrate immune system gender specific differences in individual immunocompetence are well known. In general, females seem to possess more powerful immune systems than males. In invertebrates, the situation is much less clear. Therefore, we investigated the immune system of an invertebrate species, the scorpionfly Panorpa vulgaris. We found a high degree of individual variation in both traits studied, the lysozyme-like antibacterial activity of hemolymph and the capacity for in vitro phagocytosis of artificial particles. These two immune traits were positively correlated. As expected, hemolymph derived from females had higher lysozyme-like activity and hemocytes from females phagocytosed more particles. The difference in phagocytosis was mainly based on higher total hemocyte counts and higher proportions of phagocytically active cells in females, while the average number of ingested particles per active phagocyte was not significantly different. The observed gender differences are discussed in the context of reproductive strategies and parasite-mediated sexual selection.

Strategic male mating effort and cryptic male choice in a scorpionfly

In animal species with high male mating effort, males often find themselves in a dilemma: by increasing their mating effort, the gain from each copulation increases but simultaneously reduces available resources and, thus, the opportunity for future copulations. Therefore, we expect males to spend less reproductive resources on matings that provide low reproductive potential, thereby saving resources for future copulations, possibly with high–quality females, a sort of cryptic male choice. However, the strength of the trade–off between investment in a current mating and resources available for future matings must not be the same for all males. Males with relatively high mating costs should allocate their limited resources more cautiously than males with more plentiful resources. Here, we examine this prediction in the scorpionfly Panorpa cognata. Prior to copulation, males produce a large salivary mass on which females feed during copulation. We show that the production of larger salivary masses leads to longer copulations. Moreover, the size of the salivary gland and salivary mass increases with increasing male condition. However, males in poor condition make a relatively higher mating investment than males in good condition. We therefore expect male condition to influence cryptic male choice. In accordance with our hypothesis, only males in poor condition choose cryptically, producing larger salivary masses in copulations with females of high fecundity.

The immunocompetence handicap hypothesis: testing the genetic predictions

The immunocompetence handicap hypothesis suggests that the immune system competes for resources with sexually selected ornaments; variation in ornaments might reflect genetic variation for immunocompetence. We tested this genetic prediction by mating scorpionfly females to males differing in the expression of a condition‐dependent ornament trait, saliva secretion, and then comparing offspring immunocompetence. We found several indications of an immunocompetence handicap in our study: females had superior immunocompetence compared with males, the different immune traits were positively correlated, and there were indications of genetic variation in immune traits. However, we found no significant difference in the immunocompetence of offspring derived from males differing in ornament expression, only a tendency for sons of ornamented males to possess slightly better immunocompetence. The estimated effect of fathers on offspring immunocompetence was rather small, but it might be a sufficient benefit of female choice, provided that the costs of choice are small. We conclude that the genetic benefit of female choice is small concerning offspring immunocompetence, but the immunocompetence handicap principle might nevertheless work in scorpionflies.

Determinants of sperm transfer in the scorpionfly Panorpa cognata: male variation, female condition and copulation duration

Recent studies suggest that sperm production and transfer may have significant costs to males. Male sperm investment into a current copulation may therefore influence resources available for future matings, which selects for male strategic mating investment. In addition, females may also benefit from actively or passively altering the number of sperm transferred by males. In the scorpionfly Panorpa cognata, the number of sperm transferred during copulation depended on copulation duration and males in good condition (residual weight) copulated longer and also transferred more sperm. Moreover, sperm transferred and stored per unit time was higher in copulations with females in good condition than in copulations with females in poor condition. Males varied greatly and consistently in their sperm transfer rate, indicative of costs associated with this trait. The duration of the pairing prelude also varied between males and correlated negatively with the males sperm transfer rate, but no other male character correlated significantly with male sperm transfer rate. The results are consistent with strategic mating effort but sperm transfer could also be facilitated by the physical size of females and/or females in good condition may be more cooperative during sperm transfer.

Mating System and Sexual Selection in the Scorpionfly Panorpa vulgaris (Mecoptera: Panorpidae)

Panorpa vulgaris has become a model insect for testing theories of sexual selection. This contribution summarizes that which has been learned in recent years and presents new data that clearly show that the mating system of P. vulgaris is not simply a resource-defense polygyny, as has previously been thought. In P. vulgaris neither the pattern in food exploitation nor the ratio of variance in the lifetime reproductive success of the two sexes is in accordance with that expected in resource defense polygynous mating systems. Lifetime mating duration is the most important proximate determinant of male fitness. Males employing alternative mating tactics obtain copulations of varying duration in relation to the following sequence: saliva secretion  1  food offering  1  no gift. The number of salivary masses which males provide to females during their lifetime is significantly correlated with the lifetime condition index. The condition index depends on the fighting prowess of males and their ability to find food items. Thus saliva secretion of Panorpa is considered a Zahavian handicap, which can serve as an honest quality indicator used by mating females. Our results confirm four main predictions of the indicator model of the theory of sexual selection: (a) the indicator signals high ecological quality of its bearer, (b) the indicator value increases with phenotypic quality, (c) the indicator value is positively correlated with the genetic quality affecting offspring fitness in a natural selection context, and (d) the quality indicator is more costly for low- than for high-quality individuals. The evolutionary consequences of the mating pattern and the sperm competition mechanism in P. vulgaris are discussed in the context the way in which sexual selection creates and maintains sperm mixing and the evolution of a promiscuous mating system.

DNA Fingerprinting and Profiling in Behavioural Ecology

Behavioural ecology focusses on the evolution and maintenance of different behaviours in all kinds of animals, i.e. it asks why a specific behavioural trait could have evolved and how it is maintained within a population or species (for an introduction to behavioural ecology see e.g. [1]). Natural and sexual selection should favour those individuals behaving in a way that maximizes their reproductive success, since those individuals give more copies of their genes (including those promoting this behaviour) to the next generation than individuals that do not share the behavioural trait (see also [1]). This means that sexual selection (and from a specific point of view also natural selection) is nothing more than nonrandom differential reproduction.

Low frequency of extra-pair paternity in Common Gulls (Larus canus) as revealed by DNA fingerprinting

During the last decade, the mating systems of many bird species have been analysed using molecular genetic methods. Most of these studies were performed on Passeriformes while Non-Passeriformes were rarely investigated. To fill this gap, we analysed blood samples of 24 Common Gull (Larus canus) families from two Polish colonies using DNA fingerprinting. A total of 55 of 56 chicks was unequivocally assigned to their genetic parents. Only two of these chicks (3.6%) from two different broods resulted from extra-pair copulations, the other 53 could be attributed to the putative parents; i.e., intraspecific brood parasitism was not observed. With respect to the number of breeding pairs investigated, the frequency of extra-pair paternity amounted to 8.3%. Thus, extra-pair paternity is relatively infrequent compared to other bird species. This result is surprising because the percentage of observed extra-pair copulations (i.e., mainly forced copulations in Common Gulls) in relation to the absolute number of copulations was 15.7% in the colonies studied. A possible reason for the disproportionate number of forced copulations and the lower percentage of resulting extra-pair young may include different mechanisms for paternity control by the pair males and/or by females. In den letzten 10 Jahren wurde das Paarungssystem vieler Vogelarten auch mit Hilfe molekulargenetischer Methoden näher untersucht. Dabei standen vor allem verschiedene Singvogelarten im Vordergrund, während Nicht-Singvogelarten kaum berücksichtigt wurden. Die vorliegende Untersuchung an Sturmmöwen (Larus canus) soll helfen diese Lücke zu schließen. Hierzu wurden die Blutproben von 24 Sturmmöwenfamilien zweier polnischer Kolonien mit Hilfe des genetischen Fingerabdruckverfahrens untersucht. Bei 55 der 56 untersuchten Küken konnten eindeutige Aussagen zur Elternschaft gemacht werden. Nur zwei Küken (3,6%) aus zwei unterschiedlichen Bruten gingen auf Kopulationen außerhalb des Paarbundes zurück, die restlichen 53 stammten von den sozialen Eltern ab, d. h. Fälle von innerartlichem Brutparasitismus konnten nicht nachgewiesen werden. In bezug auf den prozentualen Anteil an Brutpaaren, deren Bruten Jungtiere enthielten, die das Resultat von Kopulationen außerhalb des Paarbundes waren, ergab sich ein Wert von 8,3%. Dieser Wert ist im Vergleich mit anderen Vogelarten sehr niedrig. Der geringe Anteil an Vaterschaften außerhalb des Paarbundes verwundert, da der Anteil von Kopulationen außerhalb des Paarbundes, die von den Männchen bei Sturmmöwen meist gewaltsam erzwungen werden, im Vergleich zur Gesamtzahl beobachteter Kopulationen in den untersuchten Kolonien 15,7% betrug und damit deutlich höher lag, als dies auf der Basis der Ergebnisse der DNA-Fingerprinting Untersuchungen zu erwarten gewesen wäre. Mögliche Gründe für die Diskrepanz zwischen dem Anteil der erzwungenen Kopulationen außerhalb des Paarbundes und dem Anteil der resultierenden Küken sind verschiedene Mechanismen der Vaterschaftskontrolle durch die Paarmännchen und/oder durch die Weibchen.

A Male Sex Pheromone in a Scorpionfly

It has been postulated that males of a number of scorpionfly species produce sex pheromones. This is based on the observation that females often respond only to conspecific males when they evert their genital pouch, the proposed site of pheromone release. In this study, we prove that in Panorpa germanica (Mecoptera, Panorpidae), the eversion of a male’s genital pouch is associated with the release of a volatile sex pheromone. In dual choice situations, females showed a high preference for ‘calling’ (males with everted genital pouch) over noncalling individuals. Volatiles emitted by males and females were collected and identified by coupled gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. Two aldehydes [(2E,6Z)-nona-2,6-dienal and (E)-non-2-enal] were characteristic of calling males but not of noncalling or immature males or females. Bioassays with synthetic compounds confirmed that the identified substances are attractive to females. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first identification of a sex pheromone in scorpionflies.

Amorous scorpionflies: causes and consequences of the long pairing prelude of Panorpa cognata

The scorpionfly Panorpa cognata has a prolonged premating period. After the male attracts a female, there is usually a long delay, from a few minutes to almost 7 h, before the male initiates copulation by secreting a salivary mass. In our experiments, we manipulated the amount of food, and hence the condition, of males and then measured their premating duration. The premating duration was strongly influenced by male nutrient availability and, consequently, male mating resource limitation. Males with ample resource availability, that is with large salivary glands, initiated copulations faster than males with limited resources. In addition, premating duration decreased with increasing male age. The secretion of a salivary mass was more likely to result in a successful copulation if males delayed copulation. When males initiated copulation soon after attracting a mate, nuptial gift offering often failed because of interruption by other scorpionflies or female rejection. Since the value of each invested salivary mass is high for males with limited resources, we suggest that these males invest prudently: to enhance the probability of a return on their investment, they delay secreting the salivary mass until they are confident that females are motivated to mate. Furthermore, with this strategy, males enhance the likelihood of copulating in a sheltered location, where they are unlikely to be interrupted by intruders. Alternative hypotheses are that males in poor condition have more difficulty in persuading females or that males with small salivary glands need longer to produce the salivary mass.

Patterns of sperm use in the scorpionfly Panorpa germanica L. (Mecoptera: Panorpidae)

Sperm competition can be a powerful selective force in the evolution of reproductive strategies and mating systems. In studies on sperm competition, patterns of sperm use are typically reported as the mean species value of P2, determined as the proportion of offspring sired by the second male to copulate with a doubly mated female. However, the within-species variance in P2 has mostly been ignored, although taking this variance into account may be crucial for understanding the underlying mechanisms of sperm competition. Paternity analysis among the offspring of doubly mated females of Panorpa germanica (Mecoptera, Panorpidae) revealed a relationship between relative copulation durations of both males and the proportion of offspring each male will sire. This correlation between proportional copulation durations and paternity suggests mixing of sperm from different males inside the female’s spermatheca. Yet, sperm mixing appears to be incomplete, as paternity was overall slightly shifted towards the second male on average fathering a higher proportion of the offspring than its relative copulation duration would predict in case of complete sperm mixing. For individual males, however, the outcome of sperm competition is rather unpredictable as the intraspecific variance in P2 was found to be very high, irrespective of copulation durations. Possible causes of the observed variance in P2 and the partial last male sperm precedence are discussed.