L. Sorski

Improving postoperative immune status and resistance to cancer metastasis: a combined perioperative approach of immunostimulation and prevention of excessive surgical stress responses.

Background:Surgical procedures, including primary tumor resection, have been suggested to suppress immune competence and to promote postoperative infections and cancer metastasis. Catecholamines and prostaglandins were recently implicated in these processes, and in directly promoting tumor angiogenesis and invasion. Objective:To examine the integration of 2 complementary approaches to reduce postoperative immunosuppression and metastatic progression: (1) perioperative immunostimulation with CpG-C and (2) pharmacological blockade of the tumor-promoting and immunosuppressing effects of catecholamines and prostaglandins, using propranolol (P) and etodolac (E), respectively. Methods:F344 rats were treated before surgery with CpG-C, P+E, both interventions, or vehicles, and were intravenously inoculated with syngeneic MADB106 mammary adenocarcinoma cells. Blood was withdrawn, marginating-pulmonary leukocytes were harvested, and NK activity and lung MADB106 tumor retention were assessed. In addition, C57BL/6 mice were implanted with syngeneic B16F10.9 melanoma cells. When tumors reached 100 mm3, mice were treated with CpG-C/vehicle, and 24 hours later the tumor was excised along with P+E/vehicle treatment. Recurrence-free survival was monitored thereafter. Results:Each of the regimens alone, CpG-C or P+E, showed improvement in most indices examined, including improved long-term recurrence-free survival rates. Most importantly, the combined treatment yielded additive or synergistic effects, further improving tumor clearance from the lungs and enhancing NK numbers and cytotoxicity via different, but complimentary, mechanisms. Conclusions:Treatment aimed at perioperative enhancement of CMI and simultaneous inhibition of excessive catecholamine and prostaglandin responses, employing CpG-C, propranolol, and etodolac, could be successful in limiting postoperative immunosuppression and metastatic progression, more so than each treatment alone.

In vivo suppression of NK cell cytotoxicity by stress and surgery: glucocorticoids have a minor role compared to catecholamines and prostaglandins.

Most in vitro and ex-vivo studies indicate a profound suppression of NK cell cytotoxicity (NKCC) by glucocorticoids; while catecholamines and prostaglandins were reported both to suppress and to enhance NKCC. However, methodological considerations hinder our ability to deduce from these findings to the impact of endogenous release of these factors on in vivo levels of NKCC and their implications to NK-dependent resistance to pathologies in living humans or animals. Here we used an in vivo approach that sensitively and specifically reflects NKCC in living F344 rats, based on lung clearance of NK-sensitive tumor cells (MADB106), and based on comparing effects between NK-intact and NK-depleted rats. To study the role of corticosterone, epinephrine, and prostaglandins, we administered these factors to rats, or antagonized their endogenous release following different stress paradigms or surgery. The results indicated that endogenous or exogenous elevated corticosterone levels can suppress in vivo NKCC levels, but only under some conditions, and mostly secondarily to the NK-suppressing impact of epinephrine. Specifically, corticosterone-induced NKCC suppression occurred (i) only under prolonged, but not short exposure to stress, and mainly in males; (ii) was smaller than the prominent impact of epinephrine; (iii) was mostly ascribed to corticosterone-induced potentiation of the effects of epinephrine or/and prostaglandins; and (iv) was completely abolished through antagonizing epinephrine or/and prostaglandins. Overall, these findings markedly limit the significance of stress/surgery-induced corticosterone release in the in vivo suppression of NKCC, and highlight the blockade of epinephrine or/and prostaglandins as effective and clinically feasible approaches to overcome such immuno-suppressive effects.

Continuous stress disrupts immunostimulatory effects of IL-12

Immune stimulation by biological response modifiers is a common approach in tumor immunotherapy. IL-12 was found effective in various animal studies, but clinical trials showed limited success. However, among other differences, animal models do not simulate psychological or physiological stress while employing IL-12, whereas cancer patients often experience distress while treated with immunostimulants. Thus, in the current study we assessed the impact of continuous stress on the efficacy of IL-12 immunostimulation. F344 rats were subjected to a pharmacological stress paradigm (continuous administration of a β-adrenergic agonist) or to a 20 h behavioral stress paradigm (wet cage exposure) commencing 2h before IL-12 administration. Twenty-six hours after stress initiation, we studied indices known to reflect IL-12 immunostimulatory impacts, including NK cell numbers and activity in different immune compartments, and in vivo resistance to MADB106 lung tumor colonization. The results indicated that both the pharmacological and behavioral stress paradigms significantly reduced the increase in the number and activity of marginating-pulmonary NK cells evident in non-stressed IL-12 treated animals. Additionally, stressed animals exhibited a lower IL-12-induced improvement of MADB106 lung clearance, an in vivo index that markedly depends on total marginating-pulmonary NK activity. These deleterious effects of stress were more prominent in males than in females. Overall, the findings demonstrate that prolonged stress exposure can disrupt the efficacy of simultaneous immunostimulatory treatments, irrespective of stress effects on baseline immune measures. Neuroendocrine and cellular mediating mechanisms are yet unknown, but the potential clinical ramifications of these findings warrant consideration in clinical trials employing immunostimulatory agents.

Perioperative treatment with the new synthetic TLR-4 agonist GLA-SE reduces cancer metastasis without adverse effects

The use of TLR agonists as an anti‐cancer treatment is gaining momentum given their capacity to activate various host cellular responses through the secretion of inflammatory cytokines and type‐I interferons. It is now also recognized that the perioperative period is a window of opportunity for various interventions aiming at reducing the risk of cancer metastases—the major cause of cancer related death. However, immune‐stimulatory approach has not been used perioperatively given several contraindications to surgery. To overcome these obstacles, in this study, we used the newly introduced, fully synthetic TLR‐4 agonist, Glucopyranosyl Lipid‐A (GLA‐SE), in various models of cancer metastases, and in the context of acute stress or surgery. Without exerting evident adverse effects, a single systemic administration of GLA‐SE rapidly and dose dependently elevated both innate and adaptive immunity in the circulation, lungs and the lymphatic system. Importantly, GLA‐SE treatment led to reduced metastatic development of a mammary adenocarcinoma and a colon carcinoma by approximately 40–75% in F344 rats and BALB/c mice, respectively, at least partly through elevating marginating‐pulmonary NK cell cytotoxicity. GLA‐SE is safe and well tolerated in humans, and currently is used as an adjuvant in phase‐II clinical trials. Given that the TLR‐4 receptor and its signaling cascade is highly conserved throughout evolution, our current results suggest that GLA‐SE may be a promising immune stimulatory agent in the context of oncological surgeries, aiming to reduce long‐term cancer recurrence.

The misleading nature of in vitro and ex vivo findings in studying the impact of stress hormones on NK cell cytotoxicity

In vitro and ex vivo studies assessing the impact of stress hormones on immune competence commonly replace the natural milieu of leukocytes with an artificial medium, excluding plasma factors, hormones, and cytokines. Given prevalent inconsistencies between in vitro, ex vivo, and in vivo findings, we studied whether such procedures could yield misleading outcomes regarding the impact of stress hormones on NK cell cytotoxicity (NKCC), using fresh human whole blood samples. We found that in the presence of plasma 10-30-fold higher concentrations of cortisol, epinephrine, and prostaglandin-E2 (PGE2) were required to reach suppression levels evident in the context of artificial medium. Importantly, whereas the NK suppressive effects of PGE2 occurred immediately and remained stable upon prolonged exposure, the suppressive effects of cortisol slowly increased over time. Last, to simulate the exclusion of stress factors in the ex vivo approach, we subjected whole blood to stress hormones (as occurs in vivo), and abruptly removed them. We found that the effects of epinephrine and PGE2 quickly disappeared, while the effects of cortisol persisted. Overall, these findings demonstrate the potential misleading nature of in vitro and ex vivo procedures, and specifically suggest that (i) the common in vitro findings of profound suppression of NKCC by stress hormones are overestimation of their direct effects expected in vivo; and (ii) the common ex vivo approach cannot reflect the direct in vivo suppressive effects of epinephrine and PGE2 on NKCC, while inflating the effects of glucocorticoids. Some of these fallacies may be circumvented by using non-delayed whole blood NKCC assays in humans.

Plasma IL-12 levels are suppressed in vivo by stress and surgery through endogenous release of glucocorticoids and prostaglandins but not catecholamines or opioids

IL-12 is a prominent Th1 differentiator and leukocyte activator. Ample studies showed suppression of IL-12 production by numerous stress factors, including prostaglandins, catecholamines, glucocorticoids, and opioids, but did so in vitro and in the context of artificial leukocyte activation, not simulating the in vivo setting. In a recent study we reported in vivo suppression of plasma IL-12 levels by behavioral stress and surgery. The current study aims to elucidate neuroendocrine mechanisms underlying this phenomenon in naïve F344 rats. To this end, both adrenalectomy and administration of specific antagonists were used, targeting the aforementioned stress factors. The results indicated that corticosterone and prostaglandins are prominent mediators of the IL-12-suppressing effects of stress and surgery, apparently through directly suppressing leukocyte IL-12 production. Following surgery, endogenous prostaglandins exerted their effects mainly through elevating corticosterone levels. Importantly, stress-induced release of epinephrine or opioids had no impact on plasma IL-12 levels, while pharmacological administration of epinephrine reduced plasma IL-12 levels by elevating corticosterone levels. Last, a whole blood in vitro study indicated that prostaglandins and corticosterone, but not epinephrine, suppressed IL-12 production in non-stimulated leukocytes, and only corticosterone did so in the context of CpG-C-induced IL-12 production. Overall, the findings reiterate the notion that results from in vitro or pharmacological in vivo studies cannot indicate the effects of endogenously released stress hormones under stress/surgery conditions. Herein, corticosterone and prostaglandins, but not catecholamines or opioids, were key mediators of the suppressive effect of stress and surgery on in vivo plasma IL-12 levels in otherwise naïve animals.

Resilience of the Immune System in Healthy Young Students to 30-Hour Sleep Deprivation with Psychological Stress

Objective: Young adults often encounter sleep deprivation and stressful events. Both have been separately reported to modulate immunity, and occasionally they occur simultaneously. We assessed the combined effects of these conditions on immune competence in healthy students. Methods: Twenty-three participants (mean age 24 years; SD 1.86; 14 females) were exposed to 30 h of sleep deprivation during which they conducted physiological, social and cognitive tasks. The control group consisted of 18 participants (mean age 23.67 years; SD 1.46; 11 females). All participants underwent cognitive and psychological evaluations at 10:00 AM, followed by blood and saliva collection, 3 days before sleep deprivation induction and on the morning following it. Immune/endocrine measures included blood counts of lymphocytes, granulocytes, monocytes and natural killer (NK) cells; levels of several cell surface markers; NK cytotoxicity; plasma levels of interleukin (IL)-6, IL-10, dehydroepiandrosterone and neuropeptide Y, and plasma and salivary cortisol levels. Results: Although the experimental protocol significantly elevated state anxiety and psychological dissociation levels, no effects were evident in any of the immunological/endocrine indices. In contrast, expected sex differences in immune measures were found, including significantly higher NK cytotoxicity and monocyte counts in males, validating the integrity of the measurements. Conclusions: The findings suggest resilience of the immune system to a combined sleep deprivation and stressful exposure in young adults, while previous studies reported immune perturbations following either of these conditions separately. These apparent contradictions might reflect differences in the study design or in the methodology used for immunological assessments, including the time of sample collection, the combination of sleep deprivation with stress and our in vivo assessment of cytokine levels.

PGE2 suppresses NK activity in vivo directly and through adrenal hormones: effects that cannot be reflected by ex vivo assessment of NK cytotoxicity.

Surgery can suppress in vivo levels of NK cell cytotoxicity (NKCC) through various mechanisms, including catecholamine-, glucocorticoid (CORT)-, and prostaglandin (PG)-mediated responses. However, PGs are synthesized locally following tissue damage, driving proinflammatory and CORT responses, while their systemic levels are often unaffected. Thus, we herein studied the role of adrenal factors in mediating in vivo effects of PGs on NKCC, using adrenalectomized and sham-operated F344 rats subjected to surgery or PGE(2) administration. In vivo and ex vivo approaches were employed, based on intravenous administration of the NK-sensitive MADB106 tumor line, and based on ex vivo assessment of YAC-1 and MADB106 target-line lysis. Additionally, in vitro studies assessed the kinetics of the impact of epinephrine, CORT, and PGE(2) on NKCC. The results indicated that suppression of NKCC by epinephrine and PGE(2) are short lasting, and cannot be evident when these compounds are removed from the in vitro assay milieu, or in the context of ex vivo assessment of NKCC. In contrast, the effects of CORT are long-lasting and are reflected in both conditions even after its removal. Marginating-pulmonary NKCC was less susceptible to suppression than circulating NKCC, when tested against the xenogeneic YAC-1 target line, but not against the syngeneic MADB106 line, which seems to involve different cytotoxicity mechanisms. Overall, these findings indicate that elevated systemic PG levels can directly suppress NKCC in vivo, but following laparotomy adrenal hormones mediate most of the effects of endogenously-released PGs. Additionally, the ex vivo approach seems limited in reflecting the short-lasting NK-suppressive effects of catecholamines and PGs.

The impact of surgical extent and sex on the hepatic metastasis of colon cancer

PurposeExtensive oncological surgeries were previously suggested to increase cancer recurrence rates. We herein studied the impact of different surgical procedures and sex on colorectal cancer liver metastasis, employing several tumor inoculation approaches in BALB/c mice.MethodsExperimental hepatic metastases of the syngeneic CT26 colorectal cancer line were induced either by intra-portal inoculation or intra-splenic inoculation, employing different tumor loads. Following intra-splenic inoculation, the entire spleen or an injected hemi-spleen was removed. Additionally, the magnitude of the surgical trauma accompanying the injection procedure was manipulated.ResultsIncreasing the surgical trauma by adding laparotomy or extending the length of the surgery and hypothermia did not significantly affect the number of liver metastases or liver weight for any of the injection methods and tumor loads. The development of metastasis was significantly greater in males than in females under all conditions studied—a difference not explained by the direct effects of sex hormones on in vitro CT26 proliferation or vitality.ConclusionConcurring with less controlled clinical observations, the surgical extensiveness did not significantly affect CT26 hepatic metastasis, potentially due to a ceiling effect of the surgical trauma on the metastatic process. The sexual dimorphism observed for the CT26 metastasis should be investigated in the context of surgical stress and considering anti-CT26 immunoreactivity.

CpG-C immunotherapeutic efficacy is jeopardized by ongoing exposure to stress: Potential implications for clinical use

Bi-directional influences between stress hormones and immune responses have been repeatedly documented, however, in the clinical setting they are rarely considered when immunotherapeutic approaches are used or studied in patients. As some immunotherapeutic treatments have shown great potential in animal models but have had limited success in patients, we hypothesize that ongoing psychological and physiological stress responses in patients, which do not characterize the setting of animal studies, contribute to this discrepancy. In the current study we examined the interaction between ongoing water stress and CpG-C immunotherapy to determine whether stress that precedes immunotherapy can modulate the efficacy of CpG-C immunostimulation. C57BL/6 mice were exposed to water stress or served as controls. Two hours following the commencement of the stress protocol animals were injected with CpG-C, non-CpG, or PBS, and sacrificed 1, 4 or 12h thereafter. We found that in CpG-C-treated animals stress eliminated the elevation of plasma IL-12, and synergistically elevated corticosterone levels. Furthermore, stress markedly reduced the total number of myeloid (33D1(+)), plasmacytoid (mPDCA-1(+)) and plasmacytoid-derived (33D1(+)mPDCA-1(+)) dendritic cells in CpG-C-treated animals, as well as the numbers of these cell sub-types expressing CD11b, CD80 and CD69. These changes were more dramatic in the blood than in the spleen. Overall, these findings indicate that under no-stress conditions CpG-C induces a robust immune response, which is significantly diminished when immunostimulation is attempted during ongoing stress. If these findings hold in humans, potential prophylactic treatments should be found to limit the deleterious effects of ongoing stress on the efficacy of immunotherapy.