Laurie B. Gower

Biomimetic Model Systems for Investigating the Amorphous Precursor Pathway and Its Role in Biomineralization

Biologically-formed hard tissues, referred to as biominerals, have intrigued the materials engineering community for years because of the high degree of crystallographic control that is exerted during the precipitation of the bioinorganic crystals. In recent years, there has been a shift in attention, from prior studies that focused on specific organic-inorganic interactions that modulate the crystal morphology via the conventional crystallization pathway, to recent studies that find that many biominerals are formed via an amorphous precursor pathway. It has become clear that the things we thought we had learned about biominerals before, may or may not be relevant to truly understanding the mechanisms involved in biomineralization. Having witnessed this paradigm shift first hand, I am inclined to provide a review from this historical perspective, where I hope to belay some ideas about where we were, where we are, and where we are going, with respect to understanding how these shells and other biominerals are formed. Therefore, one goal of this review is to try and provide a link between the prior literature and the new literature, which might be useful to newcomers in the field, whom I suspect may find it confusing and difficult to integrate the findings in these different types of studies across this time period. A second goal is to try and integrate some of the knowledge obtained from in vitro model systems, which can be more amenable to obtaining mechanistic information, with the in vivo and ex vivo observational studies on biominerals. A third goal is to demonstrate that there may be certain unifying principles found in biomineral systems that seem widely diverse, such as from diatoms, to mollusk shells, to vertebrate bones and teeth. A final goal (the not so hidden agenda), is to demonstrate that not only is there as strong likelihood that many biominerals are formed by an amorphous precursor, but that the amorphous phase may possess fluidic properties that impart new processing capabilities to the system. Of course those who know my work will readily assess that I am referring to the polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process, which has been a primary focus in my lab. Along these lines, some new hypotheses are presented regarding the morphogenesis of certain biominerals, such as mollusk nacre, kidney stones, and bones and teeth, along with a review of the literature that provides support to these new ideas. The intent is to stimulate thoughtful discussions in this rapidly emerging area, which seemingly provides a unifying principle in biomineralization. 1.1. Biomineral Overview Biominerals that have intrigued the materials engineer for years. The diversity of biominerals became particularly evident by the variety of books on biominerals that emerged in the late 80’s to 90’s,1–11 which has continued with a few more recent additions to this nice collection.12–16 Many people are probably not even aware of the diversity of biologically formed minerals, so a sampling is provided in Table 1 to illustrate some of the different chemistries that evolved in the formation of various biological hard tissues. The calcium carbonate (CaCO3) biominerals of invertebrates, such as mollusk shells and sea urchin spines, have been particularly well studied due to their accessibility, and because of the high degree of crystallographic control that is achieved in these biologically formed crystals. The calcium phosphate (CaP) biominerals of the vertebrates, such as bones and teeth, have also been extensively investigated because of their remarkable structure and mechanical properties, and for the more obvious reasons of health related issues.14 Calcium oxalate (CaOx) biominerals can be found in plants, but the majority of studies have focused on the pathological form of CaOx that is found in kidney stones, which often occurs in conjunction with CaP deposits.8,14 Table 1 Examples of the diversity of biominerals. This list is by no means comprehensive, where some 70 different mineral phases have been identified to date.1–11

Deposition of calcium carbonate films by a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process

Abstract A polypeptide additive has been used to transform the solution crystallization of calcium carbonate to a solidification process of a liquid-phase mineral precursor. In situ observations reveal that polyaspartate induces liquid–liquid phase separation of droplets of a mineral precursor. The droplets deposit on the substrate and coalesce to form a coating, which then solidifies into calcitic tablets and films. Transition bars form during the amorphous to crystalline transition, leading to sectorization of calcite tablets, and the defect textures and crystal morphologies are atypical of solution grown crystals. The formation of nonequilibrium crystal morphologies using an acidic polypeptide may have implications in the field of biomineralization, and the environmentally friendly aspects of this polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process may offer new techniques for aqueous-based processing of ceramic films, coatings, and particulates.

Scanning electron microscopic analysis of the mineralization of type I collagen via a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process.

We have put forth the hypothesis that collagen is mineralized during bone formation by means of a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process, in which a liquid-phase mineral precursor could be drawn into the gaps and grooves of the collagen fibrils by capillary action, and upon solidification, leave the collagenous matrix embedded with nanoscopic crystallites of hydroxyapatite. This hypothesis is based upon our observations of capillarity seen for liquid-phase mineral precursors generated with calcium carbonate. Here, we demonstrate proof-of-concept of this mechanism by mineralizing Cellagen™ sponges (type I reconstituted bovine collagen) in the presence of a liquid-precursor phase to calcium carbonate. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to examine the mineralized collagen, which in combination with selective etching studies, revealed the extent to which the mineral phase infiltrated the collagenous matrix. A roughly periodic array of disk-like crystals was found to be embedded within the collagen fibers, demonstrating that the mineral phase spans across the diameter of the fibers. Some of the morphological features of the mineralized fibers in our in vitro model system are similar to those seen in natural bone (albeit of a different mineral phase), lending support to our hypothesis that these non-equilibrium morphologies might be generated by a PILP process. SEM provides a different perspective on the morphology of bone, and has been useful here for examining the extent of mineralization in composite structures generated via the PILP process. However, further investigation is needed to examine the nanostructural arrangement of the crystallites embedded within the collagenous matrix.

A metastable liquid precursor phase of calcium carbonate and its interactions with polyaspartate

Invertebrate organisms that use calcium carbonate extensively in the formation of their hard tissues have the ability to deposit biominerals with control over crystal size, shape, orientation, phase, texture, and location. It has been proposed by our group that charged polyelectrolytes, like acidic proteins, may be employed by organisms to direct crystal growth through an intermediate liquid phase in a process called the polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process. Recently, it has been proposed that calcium carbonate crystallization, even in the absence of any additives, follows a non-classical, multi-step crystallization process by first associating into a liquid precursor phase before transition into solid amorphous calcium carbonate (ACC) and eventually crystalline calcium carbonates. In order to determine if the PILP process involves the promotion, or stabilization, of a naturally occurring liquid precursor to ACC, we have analyzed the formation of saturated and supersaturated calcium carbonate–bicarbonate solutions using Ca2+ ion selective electrodes, pH electrodes, isothermal titration calorimetry, nanoparticle tracking analysis, 13C T2 relaxation measurements, and 13C PFG-STE diffusion NMR measurements. These studies provide evidence that, in the absences of additives, and at near neutral pH (emulating the conditions of biomineralization and biomimetic model systems), a condensed phase of liquid-like droplets of calcium carbonate forms at a critical concentration, where it is stabilized intrinsically by bicarbonate ions. In experiments with polymer additive, the data suggests that the polymer is kinetically stabilizing this liquid condensed phase in a distinct and pronounced fashion during the so called PILP process. Verification of this precursor phase and the stabilization that polymer additives provide during the PILP process sheds new light on the mechanism through which biological organisms can exercise such control over deposited CaCO3 biominerals, and on the potential means to generate in vitro mineral products with features that resemble biominerals seen in nature.

Development of bone-like composites via the polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process. Part 1: influence of polymer molecular weight.

Bone is an organic-inorganic composite consisting primarily of collagen fibrils and hydroxyapatite crystals intricately interlocked to provide skeletal and metabolic functions. Non-collagenous proteins (NCPs) are also present, and although only a minor component, the NCPs are thought to play an important role in modulating the mineralization process. During secondary bone formation, an interpenetrating structure is created by intrafibrillar mineralization of the collagen matrix. Many researchers have tried to develop bone-like collagen-hydroxyapatite (HA) composites via the conventional crystallization process of nucleation and growth. While those methods have been successful in inducing heterogeneous nucleation of HA on the surface of collagen scaffolds, they have failed to produce a composite with the interpenetrating nanostructured architecture of bone. Our group has shown that intrafibrillar mineralization of type I collagen can be achieved using a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process. In this process, acidic polypeptides are included in the mineralization solution to mimic the function of the acidic NCPs, and in vitro studies have found that acidic peptides such as polyaspartate induce a liquid-phase amorphous mineral precursor. Using this PILP process, we have been able to prepare collagen-HA composites with the fundamental nanostructure of bone, wherein HA nanocrystals are embedded within the collagen fibrils. This study shows that through further optimization a very high degree of mineralization can be achieved, with compositions matching that of bone. Synthetic collagen sponges were mineralized with calcium phosphate while analyzing various parameters of the reaction, with the focus of this report on the molecular weight of the polymeric process-directing agent. In order to determine whether intrafibrillar mineralization was achieved, an in-depth characterization of the mineralized composites was performed, including wide-angle X-ray diffraction, electron microscopy and thermogravimetric analyses. The results of this work lead us closer to the development of bone-like collagen-HA composites that could become the next generation of synthetic bone grafts.

In vitro mineralization of dense collagen substrates: A biomimetic approach toward the development of bone-graft materials

Bone is an organic-inorganic composite which has hierarchical structuring that leads to high strength and toughness. The nanostructure of bone consists of nanocrystals of hydroxyapatite embedded and aligned within the interstices of collagen fibrils. This unique nanostructure leads to exceptional properties, both mechanical and biological, making it difficult to emulate bone properties without having a bone-like nanostructured material. A primary goal of our groups work is to use biomimetic processing techniques that lead to bone-like structures. In our prior studies, we demonstrated that intrafibrillar mineralization of porous collagen sponges, leading to a bone-like nanostructure, can be achieved using a polymer-induced liquid precursor (PILP) mineralization process. The objective of this study was to investigate the use of this polymer-directed crystallization process to mineralize dense collagen substrates. To examine collagen scaffolds that truly represent the dense-packed matrix of bone, manatee bone was demineralized to isolate its collagen matrix, consisting of a dense, lamellar osteonal microstructure. This biogenic collagen scaffold was then remineralized using polyaspartate to direct the mineralization process through an amorphous precursor pathway. The various conditions investigated included polymer molecular weight, substrate dimension and mineralization time. Mineral penetration depths of up to 100 μms were achieved using this PILP process, compared to no penetration with only surface precipitates observed for the conventional crystallization process. Electron microscopy, wide-angle X-ray diffraction and thermal analysis were used to characterize the resulting hydroxyapatite/collagen composites. These studies demonstrate that the original interpenetrating bone nanostructure and osteonal microstructure could be recovered in a biogenic matrix using the PILP process.

Biomimetic Mineralization of Woven Bone-Like Nanocomposites: Role of Collagen Cross-Links

Ideal biomaterials for bone grafts must be biocompatible, osteoconductive, osteoinductive and have appropriate mechanical properties. For this, the development of synthetic bone substitutes mimicking natural bone is desirable, but this requires controllable mineralization of the collagen matrix. In this study, densified collagen films (up to 100 μm thick) were fabricated by a plastic compression technique and cross-linked using carbodiimide. Then, collagen-hydroxyapatite composites were prepared by using a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) mineralization process. Compared to traditional methods that produce only extrafibrillar hydroxyapatite (HA) clusters on the surface of collagen scaffolds, by using the PILP mineralization process, homogeneous intra- and extrafibrillar minerals were achieved on densified collagen films, leading to a similar nanostructure as bone, and a woven microstructure analogous to woven bone. The role of collagen cross-links on mineralization was examined and it was found that the cross-linked collagen films stimulated the mineralization reaction, which in turn enhanced the mechanical properties (hardness and modulus). The highest value of hardness and elastic modulus was 0.7 ± 0.1 and 9.1 ± 1.4 GPa in the dry state, respectively, which is comparable to that of woven bone. In the wet state, the values were much lower (177 ± 31 and 8 ± 3 MPa) due to inherent microporosity in the films, but still comparable to those of woven bone in the same conditions. Mineralization of collagen films with controllable mineral content and good mechanical properties provide a biomimetic route toward the development of bone substitutes for the next generation of biomaterials. This work also provides insight into understanding the role of collagen fibrils on mineralization.

Functional Remineralization of Dentin Lesions Using Polymer-Induced Liquid-Precursor Process

It was hypothesized that applying the polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) system to artificial lesions would result in time-dependent functional remineralization of carious dentin lesions that restores the mechanical properties of demineralized dentin matrix. 140 µm deep artificial caries lesions were remineralized via the PILP process for 7–28 days at 37°C to determine temporal remineralization characteristics. Poly-L-aspartic acid (27 KDa) was used as the polymeric process-directing agent and was added to the remineralization solution at a calcium-to-phosphate ratio of 2.14 (mol/mol). Nanomechanical properties of hydrated artificial lesions had a low reduced elastic modulus (ER = 0.2 GPa) region extending about 70 μm into the lesion, with a sloped region to about 140 μm where values reached normal dentin (18–20 GPa). After 7 days specimens recovered mechanical properties in the sloped region by 51% compared to the artificial lesion. Between 7–14 days, recovery of the outer portion of the lesion continued to a level of about 10 GPa with 74% improvement. 28 days of PILP mineralization resulted in 91% improvement of ER compared to the artificial lesion. These differences were statistically significant as determined from change-point diagrams. Mineral profiles determined by micro x-ray computed tomography were shallower than those determined by nanoindentation, and showed similar changes over time, but full mineral recovery occurred after 14 days in both the outer and sloped portions of the lesion. Scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive x-ray analysis showed similar morphologies that were distinct from normal dentin with a clear line of demarcation between the outer and sloped portions of the lesion. Transmission electron microscopy and selected area electron diffraction showed that the starting lesions contained some residual mineral in the outer portions, which exhibited poor crystallinity. During remineralization, intrafibrillar mineral increased and crystallinity improved with intrafibrillar mineral exhibiting the orientation found in normal dentin or bone.

Association of Randall Plaque With Collagen Fibers and Membrane Vesicles

PURPOSE Idiopathic calcium oxalate kidney stones develop by calcium oxalate crystal deposition on Randall plaque. The mechanisms involved in Randall plaque formation are still unclear. We hypothesized that Randall plaque formation is similar to that of vascular calcification, involving components of extracellular matrix, including membrane bound vesicles and collagen fibers. To verify our hypothesis we critically examined renal papillary tissue from patients with stones. MATERIALS AND METHODS We performed 4 mm cold cup biopsy of renal papillae on 15 patients with idiopathic stones undergoing percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Tissue was immediately fixed and processed for analysis by various light and electron microscopic techniques. RESULTS Spherulitic calcium phosphate crystals, the hallmark of Randall plaque, were seen in all samples examined, including in interstitium and laminated basement membrane of tubular epithelium. Large crystalline deposits were composed of dark elongated strands mixed with spherulites. Strands showed banded patterns similar to collagen. Crystal deposits were surrounded by collagen fibers and membrane bound vesicles. Energy dispersive x-ray microanalysis and electron diffraction identified the crystals as hydroxyapatite. Few kidneys were examined and urinary data were not available on all patients. CONCLUSIONS Results showed that crystals in Randall plaque are associated with collagen and membrane bound vesicles. Collagen fibers appeared calcified and vesicles contained crystals. Crystal deposition in renal papillae may have started with membrane vesicle induced nucleation and grown by the further addition of crystals at the periphery in a collagen framework.

Multifunctional role of osteopontin in directing intrafibrillar mineralization of collagen and activation of osteoclasts.

Mineralized collagen composites are of interest because they have the potential to provide a bone-like scaffold that stimulates the natural processes of resorption and remodeling. Working towards this goal, our group has previously shown that the nanostructure of bone can be reproduced using a polymer-induced liquid-precursor (PILP) process, which enables intrafibrillar mineralization of collagen with hydroxyapatite to be achieved. This prior work used polyaspartic acid (pASP), a simple mimic for acidic non-collagenous proteins, to generate nanodroplets/nanoparticles of an amorphous mineral precursor which can infiltrate the interstices of type-I collagen fibrils. In this study we show that osteopontin (OPN) can similarly serve as a process-directing agent for the intrafibrillar mineralization of collagen, even though OPN is generally considered a mineralization inhibitor. We also found that inclusion of OPN in the mineralization process promotes the interaction of mouse marrow-derived osteoclasts with PILP-remineralized bone that was previously demineralized, as measured by actin ring formation. While osteoclast activation occurred when pASP was used as the process-directing agent, using OPN resulted in a dramatic effect on osteoclast activation, presumably because of the inherent arginine-glycine-aspartate acid ligands of OPN. By capitalizing on the multifunctionality of OPN, these studies may lead the way to producing biomimetic bone substitutes with the capability of tailorable bioresorption rates.