Liat Cohen

Ocular injuries following sulfur mustard exposure: Pathological mechanism and potential therapy

Sulfur mustard (SM) is a potent vesicant, known for its ability to cause incapacitation and prolonged injuries to the eyes, skin and respiratory system. The toxic ocular events following sulfur mustard exposure are characterized by several stages: photophobia starting a few hours after exposure, an acute injury phase characterized by inflammation of the anterior segment and corneal erosions and a delayed phase appearing following a clinically silent period (years in human). The late injury appeared in part of the exposed eyes, expressed by epithelial defects and corneal neovascularization (NV), that lead to vision deficits and even blindness. During the last years we have characterized the temporal development of ocular lesions following SM vapor exposure in rabbits and have shown the existence of two sub-populations of corneas, those exhibiting delayed ocular lesions (clinically impaired) and those exhibiting only minor injuries if at all (clinically non-impaired). The aim of the present study was to investigate the pathological mechanism underlying the delayed injury by focusing on the unique characteristics of each sub-population and to test the efficacy of potential treatments. Clinically impaired corneas were characterized by chronic inflammation, increased matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) activity, poor innervation and limbal damage. Moreover, using impression cytology and histology, we identified the delayed lesions as typical for an ocular surface disorder under the category of limbal epithelial stem cell deficiency (LSCD). These results point to therapeutic directions, using anti-inflammatory drugs, MMPs inhibitors, neurotrophic factors and amniotic membrane transplantation. Topical anti-inflammatory drugs, either steroid (Dexamycin, DEX) or non-steroidal anti-infllammatory drug (NSAID, Voltaren Ophtha) were found to be beneficial in ameliorating the initial inflammatory response and in postponing the development of corneal NV, when given during the first week after exposure. When DEX was administered as a symptomatic treatment against NV, a significant regression in the angiogenic process was observed, however, the effect was temporal and blood vessels reappeared after therapy ceased. Chronic administration (8 weeks) of the MMP inhibitor Doxycycline was also effective in attenuation of the acute and delayed injury. Preliminary results, using amniotic membrane transplantation revealed some decrease of corneal edema with no effect on corneal NV. It is suggested that the chronic inflammation and prolonged impairment of corneal innervation are playing a role in the pathogenesis of the delayed LSCD following SM exposure by creating a pathological microenvironment to limbal epithelial stem cells, thus, leading to their slow death and to a second cascade of pathological events eventually resulting in severe long-term injuries. As of today, only topical anti-inflammatory drugs reached the criteria of an applicable efficient post-exposure ocular treatment for SM injuries. Further studies are required to investigate the effects of SM on epithelial stem cells and their involvement in the pathogenesis of the long-term injuries.

The Beneficial Effects of Doxycycline, An Inhibitor of Matrix Metalloproteinases, on Sulfur Mustard-Induced Ocular Pathologies Depend on the Injury Stage

Abstract Purpose: Sulfur mustard (SM) induces acute ocular lesions, including erosions and inflammation that may be followed by delayed injuries expressed by epithelial defects and neovascularization (NV). Based on the matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) activity, we evaluated the clinical and biochemical effects of topical treatment with doxycycline, an MMP inhibitor, targeted to the various injury stages. Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to SM vapor. A clinical follow-up was carried out up to 2 months. Tear fluid and cornea samples were collected at different time points for measurements of MMPs activity by zymography. Efficacy of a post-exposure topical doxycycline (2 mg/ml in phosphate buffer saline, ×4/d), targeted to the different phases of the clinical injury, was evaluated. Results: Elevated MMP-9 and MMP-2 activities were found in all corneas during the acute injury and in vascularized corneas during the delayed pathology. In the tear fluid, high MMP-9 activity and negligible MMP-2 activity were found in all the exposed eyes until after the appearance of the delayed pathology symptoms. Prolonged doxycycline treatment reduced MMP-9 activity in the tear fluid. During the acute phase, doxycycline treatment reduced corneal MMP-9 activity and the severity of the injury. Targeting the delayed pathology, doxycycline was clinically efficient only when treatment began before NV appearance. Conclusions: This in vivo study showed the involvement of MMP-9 and MMP-2 during different phases of the SM-induced ocular injury, and the potential of doxycycline treatment as a post exposure measure for reducing the acute injury and as a preventive therapy for ameliorating the delayed pathology. The tear fluid provided a non-invasive method for continuous follow-up of MMPs activity and revealed additional beneficial aspects of injury and the treatment.

Delayed Loss of Corneal Epithelial Stem Cells in a Chemical Injury Model Associated with Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency in Rabbits

Purpose: Ocular injuries following exposure to the chemical agent sulfur mustard (SM) are characterized by acute corneal erosions and inflammation of the anterior segment that may be followed by delayed Partial Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency (LSCD), expressed clinically by corneal neovascularization and epithelial defects. LSCD may derive from direct destruction of limbal stem cells or indirectly from altered limbal stromal niche. The aim of this study was to investigate the mechanism underlying LSCD in SM injuries, focusing on the effects of the chemical on limbal epithelium. Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to SM vapor and were observed by slit lamp examinations and pachymetry. Eyes were taken for histological and molecular biology evaluations at different time points (4 h–4 weeks), to include acute and delayed injuries. Epithelial stem cells were identified by ABCG2, p63 and by in vivo BrdU labeling for slow cycling cells. Results: Limbal stem cells were not damaged during the acute phase following SM exposure, in contrast to the severe injury of the central corneal epithelium. On the contrary, limbal epithelium became activated, responding to corneal insult with a wound healing process, as shown by histology and by transient elevation of the stem cells markers. Simultaneously, inflammation was taking place in the limbal stroma lasting for weeks. A gradual loss of stem cells was observed later-on (2–4 weeks), associated with typical symptoms of LSCD. Conclusions: LSCD associated with SM ocular toxicity was not derived from a direct cytotoxic effect on the epithelial stem cells, but apparently from pathological events at the limbal stroma, that produced an abnormal microenvironment for the stem cells, triggering their gradual death. The results, and in particular the absence of a primary damage to the epithelial stem cells, indicate the presence of a therapeutic window for intervention to avoid the development of the delayed LSCD.

Cultivation and characterization of limbal epithelial stem cells on contact lenses with a feeder layer: toward the treatment of limbal stem cell deficiency.

Purpose: Limbal epithelial sheets are used to promote corneal surface reconstruction after the detection of limbal epithelial stem cell deficiency. The aim of this study was to evaluate a novel combination of limbal stem cells (LSCs) maintained on contact lenses (CLs) in the presence of a 3T3 feeder cell layer regarding preservation of stem cell phenotype and the potential use for future in vivo transplantation. Methods: Limbal epithelial cells were isolated from rabbit cornea and cultured with 3T3 cells on CLs. The preservation of LSC phenotype was determined using p63&agr; and ABCG2 immunostaining, whereas epithelial differentiation was evaluated using CK3 and CK19. The colony-forming assay was used to determine the percentage of LSCs in cultures. Finally, CLs seeded with PKH26-labeled LSCs were transferred to rabbit eyes after performing a surgical keratectomy, and the transition and phenotype of labeled cells on the corneal surface were evaluated in whole-mount corneas. Results: Proliferation of individual limbal cells was observed on CLs with a 3T3 feeder cell layer, showing holoclone formation and retention of viable stem or progenitor cell phenotype. Finally, a higher transition of cultivated cells after a dual sequential CL transplantation to the ocular surface was observed, showing the preservation of the LSC phenotype in the corneal surface. Conclusions: Limbal cells cultivated on a CL carrier overlaying a 3T3 feeder layer are mitotically active and retain the LSC phenotype. This novel technique of using CLs as a carrier offers an easily manipulable and nonimmunogenic method for transferring LSCs for ocular surface reconstruction in patients with limbal epithelial stem cell deficiency.

Prolonged impairment of corneal innervation after exposure to sulfur mustard and its relation to the development of delayed limbal stem cell deficiency.

Purpose: Ocular injuries after exposure to the vesicant sulfur mustard (SM) are characterized by acute corneal erosions and inflammation of the anterior segment that may be followed by delayed limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD), expressed clinically by corneal neovascularization and epithelial defects. The present study aimed to investigate the involvement of corneal nerves in the development of the delayed LSCD. Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to SM vapor and observed clinically up to 1 month. Morphology and density of corneal nerves were studied in acetylcholinesterase-stained whole-mount corneas at different time points after exposure. Corneal calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) was measured and the relation to clinical symptoms was tested. Results: Degeneration of nerve terminals was observed a few hours after exposure simultaneously with the typical signs of SM ocular toxicity. Although corneal erosions healed within days, the nerves continued to disintegrate under a Wallerian degeneration pattern and their density declined significantly at 1 week in both central and peripheral corneal regions. Sprouting and regenerative nerve fibers were observed later in most of the corneas; however, healing was partial and often abnormal and was correlated with corneal edema. CGRP levels decreased at 24 hours and then increased significantly at 1 to 4 weeks, concomitant with the reinnervation process and development of the late injuries. Conclusions: The prolonged impairment of corneal nerves, together with chronic inflammation implied by edema, and abnormal increase in CGRP may contribute to a pathological environment for corneal epithelial stem cells, leading to their death and to the development of the SM-induced delayed LSCD.

Anti-VEGF Therapy (Bevacizumab) for Sulfur Mustard-Induced Corneal Neovascularization Associated with Delayed Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency in Rabbits

Abstract Purpose: To investigate the involvement of VEGF in corneal neovascularization (CNV) following sulfur mustard (SM) exposure and to test the therapeutic effects of bevacizumab (Avastin) in respect to dose, route of administration and timing. Materials and methods: Topical bevacizumab (6 or 25 mg/ml, ×2/day) was applied to rabbit eyes, before or after appearance of NV, following SM vapor exposure, and was compared with subconjunctival injection (25 mg/ml, ×2/week) and topical dexamethasone (1%, ×4/day). Treatments were given for 3 weeks. VEGF levels were monitored by immunohistochemistry and ELISA assay. Clinical evaluations included slit-lamp examination, impression cytology for diagnosis of Limbal Stem Cell Deficiency (LSCD), pachymetry, measurement of NV length and histology. Results: Corneal NV was developed, as early as 2 weeks after exposure, in 50–70% of the eyes, associated with increased levels of VEGF. Topical bevacizumab treatment with both doses, starting at 4 weeks, reduced vascularization. Subconjunctival injection and topical dexamethasone were more potent. A combined treatment of dexamethasone and bevacizumab improved the anti-angiogenic efficacy, yet, there was no effect on LSCD. Topical bevacizumab treatment starting at 1 week, when VEGF was elevated but before appearance of NV, had no effect. Conclusions: VEGF was involved in corneal angiogenesis in SM-induced ocular injury. Bevacizumab was beneficial in reducing CNV by both, topical or subconjunctival injection, when given as a symptomatic therapy with or without dexamethasone, however with no effect on SC deficiency. Further studies on the pathological mechanism of SM-induced ocular surface disorder may direct towards improved therapy.

Endothelial cell damage following sulfur mustard exposure in rabbits and its association with the delayed-onset ocular lesions

Objective: Ocular injuries following exposure to the toxic agent sulfur mustard (SM) are characterized by acute corneal erosions and inflammation of the anterior segment that may be followed by delayed corneal injuries, expressed clinically by neovascularization and epithelial defects. The present study aimed to investigate the effects of SM on corneal endothelium (CE) during the acute and delayed phase in relation to the development of the long-term pathology. Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to SM vapor. A clinical follow-up including pachymetry for measurement of corneal thickness were conducted up to 3 months following exposure. In vivo analysis of corneal endothelium in the central and peripheral cornea was carried out, using a contact specular microscopy. orphometric analysis of cell area and number of cells was performed, to include the acute and delayed phases. Eyes were taken for histology at different time points following exposure (1 h to 3 months). TUNEL staining (Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labeling) was conducted for detection of apoptosis during the acute phase. Results: SM induced acute corneal erosions and prolonged anterior segment inflammation. Corneal thickness increased within hours, declined after few days but remained higher compared to baseline value for months after the exposure, indicating a chronic edema. Apoptotic alterations were first observed at 6 h resulting in a significant decline in the number of endothelial cells at 24–48 h following exposure. Healing of the endothelium was relatively fast and at one week the Descemet’s membrane was resurfaced, yet, the density and morphology of the cells was often abnormal. Moreover, histological evaluation revealed deformation and enlargement of many cells (polymegathism and pleomorphism), thickening and double layered Descemet’s membrane. These changes were more pronounced in corneas displaying delayed pathology. Discussion and conclusions: SM induced apoptotic cell death of endothelial cells that was accompanied by corneal edema. The impaired healing of the endothelium, including the decrease in endothelial cell density was associated with the delayed-onset injuries. Since human corneal endothelium is almost amitotic, endothelium toxicity should be taken into consideration when testing potential treatments against ocular injuries following SM exposure.

Ocular Surface Changes After Sulfur Mustard Exposure in Rabbits, Monitored by Impression Cytology

Purpose: Ocular injuries after exposure to sulfur mustard (SM) are characterized by acute corneal erosion and inflammation of the anterior segment that may be followed by delayed corneal neovascularization and epithelial defects, associated with limbal stem cell deficiency in part of the exposed eyes. This study aimed to further clarify the mechanism of the late injury by monitoring SM-induced cytological alterations in the ocular surface, in relation to the clinical symptoms, using impression cytology (IC). Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to SM vapor (n = 20) and were clinically observed up to 4 weeks. Samples for IC were collected simultaneously from the upper bulbar conjunctiva, limbus, and cornea and then fixed and stained with periodic acid–Schiff and hematoxylin. At 1 month, animals were killed and eyes dissected and processed for histology. Results: Concomitant with clinical symptoms of SM ocular toxicity, IC showed significant long-term loss of conjunctival goblet cells shortly after exposure, followed by abnormal differentiation toward squamous metaplasia. Simultaneously with corneal erosion, apoptotic bodies and cellular debris were seen in the corneal epithelium, followed by regeneration at 1 week. Migration of conjunctival goblet cells toward the cornea was noted in neovascularized eyes, as early as 1 week, indicating limbal stem cell deficiency. The IC findings were supported by histological evaluation. Conclusions: Continuous monitoring of the ocular surface after SM exposure by IC enables earlier detection of pathology and therapeutic intervention, therefore, is recommended for routine follow-up of casualties. Prolonged loss of goblet cells may point toward the role of mucin in the pathogenesis.

Acute and long-term ocular effects of acrolein vapor on the eyes and potential therapies

Abstract Objective: Acrolein is a potent irritant and a vesicant that was used by the French during WWI as the warfare agent named: “papite”. Nowadays, it is produced in large amounts all over the world in the industry for the production of acrylic acid and for agriculture use as herbicide. The aim of this study was to characterize the effects of acute eye exposure to acrolein vapor and to evaluate the efficacy of a topical post-exposure combination treatment with a local anesthetic and a steroid. Methods: Rabbit eyes were exposed to three doses of acrolein vapor (low, intermediate and high) and treated topically with either 0.4% benoxinate hydrochloride (localin, for 2 h) or dexamethasone (dexamycin, for 6 days) or a combination of both drugs. Clinical follow-up using slit lamp examinations and histological evaluation was performed 4 weeks post-exposure. Results: Acrolein vapor caused immediate eye closure with excess tearing, corneal erosions and severe inflammation of the anterior chamber. This was followed by corneal neovascularization (NV) starting as early as 1 week post-exposure. The damage to the eyes was long lasting, and at 4 weeks following exposure, significant pathological changes were observed. Immediate post-exposure application of the local anesthetic, localin, prevented the eye closure, and the dexamycin treatment reduced significantly the initial inflammation as well as the extent and incidence of corneal NV. Conclusions: Short-term eye exposure to the irritant acrolein may result in immediate eye closure and long lasting pathologies that could lead to blindness. An anti-inflammatory treatment combined with short-term application of a local anesthetic prevents incapacitation and might minimize significantly the extent of eye injuries.

Successful single treatment with ziv-aflibercept for existing corneal neovascularization following ocular chemical insult in the rabbit model

Purpose To evaluate the efficacy of ziv‐aflibercept as a treatment for established corneal neovascularization (NV) and to compare its efficacy to that of bevacizumab following ocular chemical insult of sulfur mustard (SM) in the rabbit model. Methods Chemical SM burn was induced in the right eye of NZW rabbits by vapor exposure. Ziv‐aflibercept (2 mg) was applied once to neovascularized eyes by subconjunctival injection while subconjunctival bevacizumab (5 mg) was administered twice a week, for 3 weeks. Non‐treated exposed eyes served as a control. A clinical follow‐up employed by slit‐lamp microscope, was performed up to 12 weeks following exposure and digital photographs of the cornea were taken for measurement of blood vessels length using the image analysis software. Eyes were taken for histological evaluation 2, 4 and 8 weeks following treatment for general morphology and for visualization of NV, using H&E and Masson Trichrome stainings, while conjunctival goblet cell density was determined by PAS staining. Results Corneal NV developed, starting as early as two weeks after exposure. A single subconjunctival treatment of ziv‐aflibercept at 4 weeks post exposure, significantly reduced the extent of existing NV already one week following injection, an effect which lasted for at least 8 weeks following treatment, while NV in the non‐treated exposed eyes continued to advance. The extensive reduction in corneal NV in the ziv‐aflibercept treated group was confirmed by histological evaluation. Bevacizumab multiple treatment showed a benefit in NV reduction, but to a lesser extent compared to the ziv‐aflibercept treatment. Finally, ziv‐aflibercept increased the density of conjunctival goblet cells as compared to the exposed non‐treated group. Conclusions Subconjunctival ziv‐aflibercept single treatment presented a highly efficient long‐term therapeutic benefit in reducing existing corneal NV, following ocular sulfur mustard exposure. These findings show the robust anti‐angiogenic efficacy of ziv‐aflibercept and demonstrate the advantage of this treatment over the other anti‐angiogenic therapies in ameliorating corneal NV and protecting the ocular surface. HighlightsA single subconjunctival 2 mg ziv‐aflibercept (80 &mgr;l) treatment drastically reduced existing corneal NV already one week following treatment.The ziv‐aflibercept treatment presented a prolonged and higher efficacy in ameliorating corneal NV than the bevacizumab treatment.The ziv‐aflibercept treatment dramatically improved the conjunctival goblet cell density.