Lisa A. Sampson

Pulmonary Thermal Ablation: Comparison of Radiofrequency and Microwave Devices by Using Gross Pathologic and CT Findings in a Swine Model

PURPOSE To compare the performance of equivalently sized radiofrequency and microwave ablation applicators in a normal porcine lung model. MATERIALS AND METHODS All experiments were approved by an institutional animal care and use committee. A total of 18 ablations were performed in vivo in normal porcine lungs. By using computed tomographic (CT) fluoroscopic guidance, a 17-gauge cooled triaxial microwave antenna (n = 9) and a 17-gauge cooled radiofrequency (RF) electrode (n = 9) were placed percutaneously. Ablations were performed for 10 minutes by using either 125 W of microwave power or 200 W of RF power delivered with an impedance-based pulsing algorithm. CT images were acquired every minute during ablation to monitor growth. Animals were sacrificed after the procedure. Ablation zones were then excised and sectioned transverse to the applicator in 5-mm increments. Minimum and maximum diameter, cross-sectional area, length, and circularity were measured from gross specimens and CT images. Comparisons of each measurement were performed by using a mixed-effects model; P < .05 was considered to indicate a significant difference. RESULTS Mean diameter (3.32 cm +/- 0.19 [standard deviation] vs 2.70 cm +/- 0.23, P < .001) was 25% larger with microwave ablation and mean cross-sectional area (8.25 cm(2) +/- 0.92 vs 5.45 cm(2) +/- 1.14, P < .001) was 50% larger with microwave ablation, compared with RF ablation. With microwave ablation, the zones of ablation were also significantly more circular in cross section (mean circularity, 0.90 +/- 0.06 vs 0.82 +/- 0.09; P < .05). One small pneumothorax was noted during RF ablation but stabilized without intervention. CONCLUSION Microwave ablation with a 17-gauge high-power triaxial antenna creates larger and more circular zones of ablation than does a similarly sized RF applicator in a preclinical animal model. Microwave ablation may be a more effective treatment of lung tumors.

Microwave Ablation versus Radiofrequency Ablation in the Kidney: High-power Triaxial Antennas Create Larger Ablation Zones than Similarly Sized Internally Cooled Electrodes

PURPOSE To determine whether microwave ablation with high-power triaxial antennas creates significantly larger ablation zones than radiofrequency (RF) ablation with similarly sized internally cooled electrodes. MATERIALS AND METHODS Twenty-eight 12-minute ablations were performed in an in vivo porcine kidney model. RF ablations were performed with a 200-W pulsed generator and either a single 17-gauge cooled electrode (n = 9) or three switched electrodes spaced 1.5 cm apart (n = 7). Microwave ablations were performed with one (n = 7), two (n = 3), or three (n = 2) 17-gauge triaxial antennas to deliver 90 W continuous power per antenna. Multiple antennas were powered simultaneously. Temperatures 1 cm from the applicator were measured during two RF and microwave ablations each. Animals were euthanized after ablation and ablation zone diameter, cross-sectional area, and circularity were measured. Comparisons between groups were performed with use of a mixed-effects model with P values less than .05 indicating statistical significance. RESULTS No adverse events occurred during the procedures. Three-electrode RF (mean area, 14.7 cm(2)) and single-antenna microwave (mean area, 10.9 cm(2)) ablation zones were significantly larger than single-electrode RF zones (mean area, 5.6 cm(2); P = .001 and P = .0355, respectively). No significant differences were detected between single-antenna microwave and multiple-electrode RF. Ablation zone circularity was similar across groups (P > .05). Tissue temperatures were higher during microwave ablation (maximum temperature of 123 degrees C vs 100 degrees C for RF). CONCLUSIONS Microwave ablation with high-power triaxial antennas created larger ablation zones in normal porcine kidneys than RF ablation with similarly sized applicators.

Multiple Probe Radiofrequency Ablation: Pilot Study in an Animal Model

PURPOSE Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is becoming increasingly popular for the minimally invasive treatment of benign and malignant tumors. Currently available systems are limited to the use of a single probe because of electrical interactions between probes. The purpose of this study was to test a new prototype multiple probe generator with a built-in switching mechanism to determine if multiple zones of necrosis could be formed simultaneously without a significant penalty in terms of lesion size and procedure time. MATERIALS AND METHODS A dual probe generator was created by modifying a commercially available system into an alternating monopolar system with an external electronic switch controlled by a temperature feedback loop. A total of 20 radiofrequency (RF) lesions (conventional single probe, n = 10; switched dual probe, n = 10) were created in the livers of six adult pigs (temperature, 100 degrees C; 10-minute ablation). Lesions were excised and examined for volume, minimum diameter, and maximum diameter. RESULTS The time to target temperature was slightly greater for dual (3.5 minutes) versus single ablations (2.7 minutes). However, this resulted in only a 48 second (6.5%) longer total ablation time. There was no significant difference between conventional single and dual lesions for lesion volume (13.6 +/- 9.3 cm(3) versus 13.7 +/- 7.0 cm(3); P >.05), minimum diameter (1.63 +/- 0.56 cm(3) versus 1.61 +/- 0.53; P >.05) or maximum diameter (3.3 +/- 0.84 versus 3.4 +/- 0.55, P >.05). CONCLUSION A multiple probe RFA system that can simultaneously ablate multiple areas in the liver is feasible. If multiple probe units become clinically available, large or irregularly shaped lesions could be treated more effectively than with conventional single probe units, and multiple tumors could be ablated simultaneously, thus potentially decreasing procedure time and anesthetic complications.

Unintended thermal injuries from radiofrequency ablation: protection with 5% dextrose in water.

OBJECTIVE Radiofrequency ablation of hepatic tumors can lead to thermal injury of surrounding structures. Both saline and 5% dextrose in water (D5) have been used to displace these surrounding structures before radiofrequency ablation. The purpose of this study was to determine the relative effectiveness of these two fluids for protecting the diaphragm and lung during radiofrequency ablation. MATERIALS AND METHODS Ten female domestic swine (mean weight, 45 kg) underwent radiofrequency ablation at open surgery. Group 1 (n = 12 lesions) was pretreated with peritoneal D5 before radiofrequency ablation. Group 2 (n = 11 lesions) was pretreated with peritoneal 0.9% saline. A 2.7-mm spacer was placed between the liver surface and diaphragm in groups 1 and 2. Group 3 (n = seven lesions) served as a control group with no pretreatment regimen. Group 4, an additional control group (n = eight lesions), consisted of animals pretreated with D5 in which a larger spacer was used. After radiofrequency ablation, the animals were sacrificed and the liver, diaphragm, and lung were removed. The extent of thermal injury to the surface of each organ was recorded. RESULTS The animals in the D5 and saline pretreatment groups experienced fewer diaphragm injuries than the control animals (D5, p = 0.02). The smallest lesions in the lung and diaphragm were in the D5 group, followed by the saline and control groups (diaphragm, p = 0.0001; lung, p = 0.13). Diaphragm lesions were significantly smaller in the D5 and saline groups than in the control group (p = 0.0001 and 0.01, respectively). CONCLUSION Instillation of D5 into the peritoneal cavity before hepatic radiofrequency ablation decreases the risk and severity of diaphragm and lung injuries compared with no pretreatment or pretreatment with 0.9% saline in this animal model. Pretreatment with D5 may increase both the safety of and the number of patients eligible for treatment with thermal therapies.

Microwave Ablation with Triaxial Antennas Tuned for Lung: Results in an in Vivo Porcine Model

PURPOSE To prospectively determine in swine the size and shape of coagulation zones created in normal lung tissue by using small-diameter triaxial microwave antennas and to prospectively quantify the effects of bronchial occlusion and multiple antennas on the coagulation zone. MATERIALS AND METHODS The study was approved by the research animal care and use committee, and all husbandry and experimental studies were compliant with the National Research Councils Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals. Twenty-four coagulation zones (three per animal) were created at thoracotomy in eight female domestic swine (mean weight, 55 kg) by using a microwave ablation system with 17-gauge lung-tuned triaxial antennas. Ablations were performed for 10 minutes each by using (a) a single antenna, (b) a single antenna with bronchial occlusion, and (c) an array of three antennas powered simultaneously. The animals were sacrificed immediately after ablation. The coagulation zones were excised en bloc and sectioned into approximately 4-mm slices for measurement of size, shape, and circularity. Analysis of variance and two-sample t tests were used to identify differences between the three ablation groups. RESULTS The overall mean diameters of coagulation achieved with a single antenna and bronchial occlusion (4.11 cm +/- 1.09 [standard deviation]) and with multiple-antenna arrays (4.05 cm +/- 0.69) were significantly greater than the overall mean diameter achieved with a single antenna alone (3.09 cm +/- 0.83) (P = .016 for comparison with multiple antennas, P = .032 for comparison with bronchial occlusion). No significant differences in size were seen between the coagulation zones created with bronchial occlusion and those created with multiple antennas (P = .68). The coagulation zones in all groups were very circular (isoperimetric ratio > 0.80) at cross-sectional analysis. CONCLUSION A 17-gauge triaxial microwave ablation system tuned for lung tissue yielded large circular zones of coagulation in vivo in porcine lungs. The coagulation zones created with bronchial occlusion and multiple antennas were significantly larger than those created with one antenna.

Radiofrequency ablation: simultaneous application of multiple electrodes via switching creates larger, more confluent ablations than sequential application in a large animal model.

PURPOSE To compare radiofrequency (RF) ablations created by using a sequential technique to those created simultaneously by using a switching algorithm in ex vivo and in vivo liver models. MATERIALS AND METHODS RF ablation was performed by using either sequential or switched application of three cooled electrodes in a 2-cm triangular array in ex vivo bovine liver (28 total ablations) and in vivo swine liver (12 total ablations) models. For sequential ablations, electrodes were powered for 12 minutes each with a 5-minute rest interval between activations to simulate electrode repositioning. Switched ablations were created by using a multiple-electrode switching system for 12 minutes. Temperatures were measured during ex vivo experiments at four points in the ablation zone. Ablation zones were measured for minimum and maximum diameter, cross-sectional area, and isoperimetric ratio. Mann-Whitney and Wilcoxon matched pairs tests were used to identify differences between groups. RESULTS The switched application created larger and more circular zones of ablation than did the sequential application, with mean (+/-standard deviation) ex vivo cross-sectional areas of 25.4 cm(2) +/- 5 .3 and 18.8 cm(2) +/- 6.6 (P = .001), respectively, and mean in vivo areas of 17.1 cm(2) +/- 5.1 and 13.2 cm(2) +/- 4.2 (P < .05). Higher temperatures and more rapid heating occurred with the switched application; switched treatments were 74% faster than sequential treatments (12 vs 46 minutes). In the sequential group, subsequent ablations grew progressively larger due to local ischemia. CONCLUSIONS Switched application of three electrodes creates larger, more confluent ablations in less time than sequential application. Thermal synergy and ablation-induced ischemia both substantially influence multiple-electrode ablations.

Early Small-Bowel Ischemia: Dual-Energy CT Improves Conspicuity Compared with Conventional CT in a Swine Model

PURPOSE To compare dual-energy computed tomography (CT) with conventional CT for the detection of small-bowel ischemia in an experimental animal model. MATERIALS AND METHODS The study was approved by the animal care and use committee and was performed in accordance with the Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals issued by the National Research Council. Ischemic bowel segments (n = 8) were created in swine (n = 4) by means of surgical occlusion of distal mesenteric arteries and veins. Contrast material-enhanced dual-energy CT and conventional single-energy CT (120 kVp) sequences were performed during the portal venous phase with a single-source fast-switching dual-energy CT scanner. Attenuation values and contrast-to-noise ratios of ischemic and perfused segments on iodine material-density, monospectral dual-energy CT (51 keV, 65 keV, and 70 keV), and conventional 120-kVp CT images were compared. Linear mixed-effects models were used for comparisons. RESULTS The attenuation difference between ischemic and perfused segments was significantly greater on dual-energy 51-keV CT images than on conventional 120-kVp CT images (mean difference, 91.7 HU vs 47.6 HU; P < .0001). Conspicuity of ischemic segments was significantly greater on dual-energy iodine material-density and 51-keV CT images than on 120-kVp CT images (mean contrast-to-noise ratios, 4.9, 4.3, and 2.1, respectively; P < .0001). Although attenuation differences on dual-energy 65- and 70-keV CT images were not significantly different from those on 120-kVp images (55.0 HU, 45.8 HU, and 47.6 HU, respectively; 65 keV vs 120 kVp, P = .15; 70 keV vs 120 kVp, P = .46), the contrast-to-noise ratio was greater for the 65- and 70-keV images than for the 120-kVp images (4.4, 4.1, and 2.1 respectively; P < .0005). CONCLUSION Dual-energy CT significantly improved the conspicuity of the ischemic bowel compared with conventional CT by increasing attenuation differences between ischemic and perfused segments on low-kiloelectron volt and iodine material density images.

High-powered Microwave Ablation with a Small-gauge, Gas-cooled Antenna: Initial Ex Vivo and In Vivo Results

PURPOSE To evaluate the performance of a gas-cooled, high-powered microwave system. MATERIALS AND METHODS Investigators performed 54 ablations in ex vivo bovine livers using three devices-a single 17-gauge cooled radiofrequency(RF) electrode; a cluster RF electrode; and a single 17-gauge, gas-cooled microwave (MW) antenna-at three time points (n = 6 at 4 minutes, 12 minutes, and 16 minutes). RF power was applied using impedance-based pulsing with maximum 200 W generator output. MW power of 135 W at 2.45 GHz was delivered continuously. An approved in vivo study was performed using 13 domestic pigs. Hepatic ablations were performed using single applicators and the above-mentioned MW and RF generator systems at treatment times of 2 minutes (n = 7 MW, n = 6 RF), 5 minutes (n = 23 MW, n = 8 RF), 7 minutes (n = 11 MW, n = 6 RF), and 10 minutes (n = 7 MW, n = 9 RF). Mean transverse diameter and length of the ablation zones were compared using analysis of variance (ANOVA) with post-hoc t tests and Wilcoxon rank-sum tests. RESULTS Single ex vivo MW ablations were larger than single RF ablations at all time points (MW mean diameter range 3.5-4.8 cm 4-16 minutes; RF mean diameter range 2.6-3.1 cm 4-16 minutes) (P < .05). There was no difference in mean diameter between cluster RF and MW ablations (RF 3.3-4.4 cm 4-16 minutes; P = .4-.9). In vivo lesion diameters for MW (and RF) were as follows: 2.6 cm ± 0.72 (RF 1.5 cm ± 0.14), 3.6 cm ± 0.89 (RF 2.0 cm ± 0.4), 3.4 cm ± 0.87 (RF 1.8 cm ± 0.23), and 3.8 cm ± 0.74 (RF 2.1 cm ± 0.3) at 2 minutes, 5 minutes, 7 minutes, and 10 minutes (P < .05 all time points). CONCLUSIONS Gas-cooled, high-powered MW ablation allows the generation of large ablation zones in short times.

Multiple-Electrode Radiofrequency Ablation of Hepatic Malignancies: Initial Clinical Experience

OBJECTIVE The objective of our study was to retrospectively analyze our initial clinical experience with percutaneous multiple-electrode radiofrequency ablation and evaluate its safety and efficacy for treating hepatic malignancies. MATERIALS AND METHODS Thirty-eight malignant hepatic tumors (mean diameter, 2.7 cm; range, 0.7-10.0 cm) in 23 patients (12 men and 11 women; mean age, 65 years; range, 40-84 years) were treated in 26 radiofrequency ablation sessions with an impedance-based multiple-electrode system. One, two, or three (mean, 2.4) 17-gauge electrodes were placed, and tumors were ablated using a combination of CT and sonography for guidance and monitoring. Electrodes were placed in close proximity (mean spacing: two electrodes, 1.0 cm; three electrodes, 1.4 cm) to treat large tumors or were used independently to treat several tumors simultaneously. Contrast-enhanced CT scans were obtained immediately after ablation to determine technical success and evaluate for complications. Follow-up CT scans at 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months (mean, 4 months) after ablation were obtained to assess for tumor progression and new metastases. RESULTS Local control was achieved in 37 of 38 tumors, 34 of which were treated in one session. Ablations created with closely spaced electrodes had a mean diameter of 4.9 cm. The total ablation time was reduced by approximately 54% compared with an equivalent number of ablations performed with a single-electrode system (1,014 vs 2,196 minutes). Three complications occurred: one death from a presumed postprocedure pulmonary embolus, one pneumothorax, and one asymptomatic perihepatic hemorrhage. CONCLUSION Multiple-electrode radiofrequency ablation appears to be a safe and effective means of achieving local control in large or multiple hepatic malignancies at short-term follow-up.

Temperature Isotherms during Pulmonary Cryoablation and their Correlation with the Zone of Ablation

PURPOSE To determine the expected ablation zone size and associated isotherms when using clinically available percutaneous cryoprobes for pulmonary cryoablation in a porcine lung model. MATERIALS AND METHODS Seven ablations were performed in the lungs of three adult pigs using clinically available 2.4-mm cryoprobes (Endocare, Inc, Irvine, California) and a 10-minute double-freeze protocol. Five 18-gauge thermocouples were positioned at 5-mm increments (ie, 5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 mm) from the cryoprobe. Real-time tissue temperatures were recorded during the cryoablation. The isotherms obtained during the ablation and the pathological ablation zones were measured. RESULTS The pathologic zone of complete necrosis had a mean diameter of 2.4 + or - 0.2 cm, with a mean area of 4.6 + or - 0.6 cm(2) and a circularity of 0.95 + or - 0.04. In comparison, the mean diameter (+ or - standard deviation) of the 0 degrees C, -20 degrees C, and -40 degrees C isotherms were 3.1 + or - 0.2 cm, 2.3 + or - 0.3 cm, and 1.8 + or - 0.4 cm, respectively. The -20 degrees C isotherm was most closely related to the pathologic zone of ablation. CONCLUSIONS This study establishes the temperature isotherms and associated ablation zone size that can be expected with modern percutaneous cryoprobes in an in vivo porcine lung model.