Lois M. Crowe

Preservation of Membranes in Anhydrobiotic Organisms: The Role of Trehalose

Trehalose is a nonreducing disaccharide of glucose commonly found at high concentrations in anhydrobiotic organisms. In the presence of trehalose, dry dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) had a transition temperature similar to that of the fully hydrated lipid, whereas DPPC dried without trehalose had a transition temperature about 30 degrees Kelvin higher. Results obtained with infrared spectroscopy indicate that trehalose and DPPC interact by hydrogen bonding between the OH groups in the carbohydrate and the polar head groups of DPPC. These and previous results show that this hydrogen bonding alters the spacing of the polar head groups and may thereby decrease van der Waals interactions in the hydrocarbon chains of the DPPC. This interaction between trehalose and DPPC is specific to trehalose. Hence this specificity may be an important factor in the ability of this molecule to stabilize dry membranes in anhydrobiotic organisms.

Interactions of sugars with membranes

Water profoundly affects the stability of biological membranes, and its removal leads to destructive events including fusion and liquid crystalline to gel phase transitions. In heterogeneous mixtures such as those found in biological membranes the phase transitions can lead to increases in permeability and lateral phase separations that often are irreparable. Certain sugars are capable of preventing these deleterious events by inhibiting fusion during drying and by maintaining the lipid in a fluid state in the absence of water. As a result, the increased permeability and lateral phase separations that accompany dehydration are absent. The weight of the evidence suggests strongly that there is a direct interaction between the sugars and lipids in the dry state. Although the evidence is less clear about whether these sugars can interact directly with hydrated bilayers, there are strong suggestions in the literature that sugars free in solution or covalently linked to membrane constituents can also affect the physical properties and presumably the stability of bilayers. Finally, we have far less evidence concerning the mechanism by which they do so, but the same sugars are also capable of preserving the structure and function of both membrane-bound and soluble proteins in the absence of water. We believe these effects may be important in the survival of intact cells and organisms such as seeds in the absence of water. Furthermore, in view of the practical importance of preserving biological structures we suspect that the results described here will ultimately have important applications in biology and medicine.

Is trehalose special for preserving dry biomaterials

Simple sugars, especially disaccharides, stabilize biomaterials of various composition during air-drying or freeze-drying. We and others have provided evidence that direct interaction, an interaction that we believe is essential for the stabilization, between the sugar and polar groups in, for example, proteins and phospholipids occurs in the dry state. Some researchers, however, have suggested that the ability of the sugar to form a glass is the only requirement for stabilization. More recently, we have shown that both glass formation and direct interaction of the sugar and headgroup are often required for stabilization. In the present study, we present a state diagram for trehalose glass and suggest that the efficacy of this sugar for stabilization may be related to its higher glass transition temperatures at all water contents. We also show that trehalose and trehalose:liposome preparations form trehalose dihydrate as well as trehalose glass when rehydrated with water vapor. Formation of the dihydrate sequesters water, which might otherwise participate in lowering the glass transition temperature to below ambient. Because samples remain in the glassy state at ambient temperatures, viscosity is high and fusion between liposomes is prevented.

Are freezing and dehydration similar stress vectors? A comparison of modes of interaction of stabilizing solutes with biomolecules.

Abstract Evidence is reviewed that freezing and dehydration are fundamentally different stress vectors: (a) Proteins, membranes, phospholipids, and living cells and organisms all contain about 0.25 g nonfreezable H2O/g dry weight. By definition, this H2O is not removed by freezing. (b) Dehydration, by contrast with freezing, can remove the nonfreezable H2O. Removing this H2O results in profound changes in the physical properties of biomolecules, particularly phospholipids and proteins, (c) The mechanisms of preservation of proteins during freezing and drying are completely different. The specificity for solute requirements for stabilization of proteins during freezing is low; any solute that is preferentially excluded from the hydration shell of a protein is also a cryoprotectant. (d) By contrast, stabilization of proteins during drying requires direct interaction between the stabilizing molecule and the protein, probably involving hydrogen bonding between the stabilizer and polar residues in the protein. The specificity is very high in this case; only carbohydrates are effective, and of those that have been tested trehalose is the most effective, (e) Less is understood about the mechanism of stabilization of phospholipid bilayers during freezing, but it is clear that while many solutes will preserve liposomes during freezing, only a few (of which trehalose is the most effective) will preserve them during drying. Stabilization of bilayers during drying requires direct interaction between the sugar and polar head groups of the phospholipids.

Preservation of freeze-dried liposomes by trehalose

One of the practical difficulties with the frequently proposed use of liposomes for delivery of water-soluble substances to cells in whole organisms is that liposomes are relatively unstable during storage. We have studied the ability of trehalose, a carbohydrate commonly found at high concentrations in organisms capable of surviving dehydration, to stabilize dry liposomes. With trehalose both inside and outside the bilayer, almost 100% of trapped solute was retained in rehydrated vesicles previously freeze-dried with 1.8 g trehalose/g dry phospholipid. Trehalose is very effective at inhibiting fusion between liposomes during drying, as assessed by freeze-fracture and resonance energy transfer between fluorescent probes incorporated into the bilayer. However, inhibition of fusion alone does not account for the preservation of the dry liposomes, since the concentration of trehalose required to prevent leakage is more than 10-fold that required to prevent fusion. We provide evidence that stabilization of the dry liposomes requires depression of transition temperature and consequent maintenance of the constituent lipids in the dry liposomes in a liquid crystalline phase.

Effects of carbohydrates on membrane stability at low water activities

The relative effectiveness of a variety of carbohydrates in preserving the structural and functional integrity of membranes at low water activities was studied, using Ca-transporting microsomes from muscle as a model membrane. The order of effectiveness (greatest to lowest) was: trehalose, lactose, maltose, cellobiose, sucrose, glucose, fructose, sorbitol, raffinose, myo-inositol, glycerol. At the highest concentrations of the most effective sugars tested, microsomes were obtained upon rehydration that were similar structurally and functionally to fresh membranes. The least effective carbohydrates, alcohol sugars, all appear to be fusogenic. A structural explanation for relative effectiveness of the sugars was sought, but no clear relationship was found, except that effectiveness does not appear to be related to the number of position of hydroxyl groups available for hydrogen bonding.

Small heat-shock proteins regulate membrane lipid polymorphism

Thermal stress in living cells produces multiple changes that ultimately affect membrane structure and function. We report that two members of the family of small heat-shock proteins (sHsp) (α-crystallin and Synechocystis HSP17) have stabilizing effects on model membranes formed of synthetic and cyanobacterial lipids. In anionic membranes of dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol and dimyristoylphosphatidylserine, both HSP17 and α-crystallin strongly stabilize the liquid-crystalline state. Evidence from infrared spectroscopy indicates that lipid/sHsp interactions are mediated by the polar headgroup region and that the proteins strongly affect the hydrophobic core. In membranes composed of the nonbilayer lipid dielaidoylphosphatidylethanolamine, both HSP17 and α-crystallin inhibit the formation of inverted hexagonal structure and stabilize the bilayer liquid-crystalline state, suggesting that sHsps can modulate membrane lipid polymorphism. In membranes composed of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and phosphatidylglycerol (both enriched with unsaturated fatty acids) isolated from Synechocystis thylakoids, HSP17 and α-crystallin increase the molecular order in the fluid-like state. The data show that the nature of sHsp/membrane interactions depends on the lipid composition and extent of lipid unsaturation, and that sHsps can regulate membrane fluidity. We infer from these results that the association between sHsps and membranes may constitute a general mechanism that preserves membrane integrity during thermal fluctuations.

Stabilization of phosphofructokinase with sugars during freeze-drying: characterization of enhanced protection in the presence of divalent cations

Phosphofructokinase purified from rabbit skeletal muscle is fully inactivated after freeze-drying and dissolution. The addition of trehalose or maltose to the enzyme solution prior to freeze-drying results in a recovery of up to 80% of the original activity. Slightly less stabilization is imparted by sucrose, whereas glucose and galactose at concentrations up to 500 mM are relatively ineffective at protecting phosphofructokinase. Addition of ionic zinc to enzyme-sugar mixtures prior to freeze-drying greatly enhances the stabilization imparted by the above sugars. This effect is not simply due to the summation of the individual protective capacities of zinc and the sugar. Zinc alone affords no protection, but a high degree of stabilization is achieved when zinc is added to a sugar solution, even when the sugar is at a concentration at which, by itself, it is totally ineffective. In the presence of a constant sugar concentration (100 mM), freeze-dry stabilization of phosphofructokinase is increased as the concentration of zinc is increased. When the zinc concentration is held constant (0.9 mM) and the sugar concentration varied, the maximum stabilization is noted with less than 200 mM sugar. At higher solute concentrations the degree of enhancement decreases such that with 500 mM sugar the addition of zinc results in only a slight increase in protection. Several other organic solutes (proline, 4-hydroxyproline, glycine, trimethylamine N-oxide, glycerol and myo-inositol) that afford cryoprotection to phosphofructokinase, an effect enhanced by the addition of zinc, do not stabilize the enzyme during freeze-drying, even if zinc is present. The addition of ionic copper, cadmium, nickel, cobalt, calcium and manganese to trehalose-phosphofructokinase solutions prior to freeze-drying also increases the percentage of activity recovered after dissolution. Magnesium is ineffective in this respect.

Effects of three stabilizing agents—Proline, betaine, and trehalose—on membrane phospholipids

We have studied the interaction between three compounds which accumulate in organisms under hydration stress--proline, betaine, and trehalose--and the membrane phospholipids dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC), palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC), and dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine in bulk solution. Film balance studies reveal that these compounds increase the area/molecule of these lipids. Differential scanning calorimetry has been employed to investigate the effect these agents have on the gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transition of multilamellar and small unilamellar vesicles of DMPC, dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, and POPC:phosphatidylserine (90:10 mole ratio) in bulk solution. In the presence of 1 M proline, trehalose, or betaine, the midtransition temperature in small unilamellar vesicles is reduced (up to 7 degrees C in 1 M trehalose), and the transition broadened. In contrast, multilamellar vesicles of similar lipid composition show an increased transition temperature in the presence of the same concentration of these compounds. This result suggests that the inner lamellae in multilamellar vesicles may be dehydrated with only a few outer lamellae exposed to the protective compound. Finally, we have used stereomodels of phosphatidylcholine to investigate the mechanism of action of these agents. Hydrogen bonding of trehalose to the head group region results in an increase in the distance between head groups of 6.9 A. This amount of spreading compares well with data from the monolayer experiments which indicate that maximal spreading of DMPC monolayers by trehalose is 6.5 A. Molecular models of proline and betaine have also been constructed, and these models suggest potential interactions between these compounds and phosphatidylcholines. For the amphipath proline, this interaction may involve intercalation between phospholipid head groups.

Lessons from nature: the role of sugars in anhydrobiosis

A review of the role of sugars in anhydrobiosis is presented.