Luis A. Valdivia

Hamster-to-rat heart and liver xenotransplantation with FK506 plus antiproliferative drugs

Heterotopic hamster hearts transplanted to unmodified LEW rats underwent humoral rejection in 3 days. Survival was prolonged to a median of 4 days with 2 mg/kg/day FK506. As monotherapy, 15 mg/kg/day cyclophosphamide greatly prolonged graft survival--far more than could be accomplished with RS-61443, brequinar (BQR), mizoribine, methotrexate, or deoxyspergualin. However, when FK506 treatment, which was ineffective alone, was combined with a short induction course (14 or 30 days) of subtherapeutic BQR, RS-61443, or cyclophosphamide, routine survival of heart xenografts was possible for as long as the daily FK506 was continued. In addition, a single large dose of 80 mg/kg cyclophosphamide 10 days preoperatively allowed routine cardiac xenograft survival under FK506. The ability of these antimetabolites to unmask the therapeutic potential of FK506 correlated, although imperfectly, with the prevention of rises of preformed heterospecific cytotoxic antibodies immediately postoperatively. As an adjunct to FK506, azathioprine was of marginal value, whereas mizoribine, methotrexate, and deoxyspergualin (DSPG) were of intermediate efficacy. After orthotopic hepatic xenotransplantation, the perioperative survival of the liver with its well-known resistance to antibodies was less dependent than the heart on the antimetabolite component of the combined drug therapy, but the unsatisfactory results with monotherapy of FK506, BQR, RS-61443, or cyclophosphamide were changed to routine success by combining continuous FK506 with a short course of any of the other drugs. Thus, by breaking down the antibody barrier to xenotransplantation with these so-called antiproliferative drugs, it has been possible with FK506 to transplant heart and liver xenografts with consistent long-term survival of healthy recipients.

Prevention of chronic rejection in mouse aortic allografts by combined treatment with CTLA4-Ig and anti-CD40 ligand monoclonal antibody

BACKGROUND In this study, using a murine model of aortic allotransplantation, the role of blockade of signaling through CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40 ligand costimulatory pathways in the evolvement of posttransplant vasculopathy was examined. METHODS Aortic allografts were transplanted across C57BL/1OJ (H2b)-->C3H (H2k) strain combinations. Transient or more stable blockade of second signaling was achieved by either a single injection or multiple injections of CTLA4-Ig fusion protein (200 microg/dose i.p.) and/or anti-CD40 ligand (CD40L) monoclonal antibody (250 microg i.m.). At day 30 after transplantation, the grafts were harvested for histopathological and immunohistochemical examination. RESULTS Similar to allografts of untreated animals, aortic allografts obtained from recipients treated with either CTLA4-Ig or anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody alone exhibited marked narrowing of the lumen primarily due to concentric intimal thickening caused by proliferation of alpha-smooth muscle actin-positive cells. Contemporaneous treatment, however, with either a single injection or multiple injections of CTLA4-Ig and anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody resulted in marked diminution of intimal thickening. Interestingly, concurrent prolonged inhibition of CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40L pathways resulted in complete abrogation of the development of posttransplant arteriopathy. CONCLUSION These data suggest that a more stable disruption of signaling through costimulatory pathways may be required to obviate the development of posttransplant vasculopathy.

Evidence that deoxyspergualin prevents sensitization and first-set cardiac xenograft rejection in rats by suppression of antibody formation

This study provides evidence of antibodies playing an important role in hamster-to-rat cardiac xenograft rejection and discusses the use of 15-deoxyspergualin (DSG) to suppress this first-set rejection, as well as hyperacute rejection induced by sensitization. The effect of recipient splenectomy (Spx) as an adjuvant to DSG to control first set xenograft rejection was also examined. When hyperimmune serum was taken from control recipients at rejection time and injected i.v. into new recipients of cardiac xenografts, hyperacute graft rejection resulted. Survival depended on the amount of serum injected and ranged from 14.7±2.5 min with 3 ml of serum to 233.3± 61.1 min with 0.5 ml. Experiments on first-set xenograft rejection revealed that a dose of 2.5 mg/kg/day DSG could prolong xenograft survival from 3.410.5 days in untreated controls to 9.5±2.6 days (P<0.01). A dose of 5 mg/kg/day DSG, though it increased graft survival to 16.4±5.9 days, proved to be toxic to the recipients. Spx alone prolonged xenograft survival to 5.2±0.4 days, and, when combined with 2.5 mg/kg/day DSG administration, prolonged graft survival to 22.1±5.5 days (P<0.01 vs. DSG alone). The appearance of cytotoxic antibodies was delayed, and titers decreased from 1:256 in untreated controls to 1:16–1:64 both in the group that underwent Spx only and in the group that received 2.5 mg/kg/day DSG. Combined treatment suppressed antibody response for more than two weeks. Experiments on hyperacute rejection induced by sensitization revealed that 1 ml of hamster whole blood transfused into prospective heart recipients 1 week before grafting resulted in graft loss in 18.2±6.1 min. Pretransplant transfusion and concomitant daily administration of 5 mg/kg/day DSG until one day after grafting not only prevented hyperacute rejection but prolonged graft survival to 7.0±0.7 days. This survival was significantly longer than with DSG alone (4.2±0.8 days, P<0.01). We concluded that the marked suppression of antibody formation by DSG plays a major role in preventing first-set xenograft rejection and hyperacute rejection induced by sensitization.

Heat shock protein reactivity of lymphocytes isolated from heterotopic rat cardiac allografts

Although it is well known that cellular rejection is mediated by alloreactive lymphocytes, several investigators, including our group, have shown that such cells are a rather small proportion of the T cell infiltrate of the alolograft. We have therefore postulated that graft-infiltrating lymphocytes must recognize other antigens. Since heat shock protein (hsp)-specific lymphocytes have been shown to participate in several autoimmune diseases and in tumor immunity, we hypothesized that hsp-reactive lymphocytes are involved with allograft rejection. This hypothesis was tested with a rat model of heterotopic MHC-incompatible cardiac allografts (ACI into Lewis), whereby graft-infiltrating lymphocytes and spleen cells were tested in vitro with different recombinant mycobacterial hsp preparations. As expected, allograft lymphocytes showed proliferative responses to irradiated spleen cells from the donor. This proliferation was markedly augmented by hsp65 (3-fold) and hsp70 (5-fold), whereas hsp10 and the protein control ovalbumin had no effect. Proliferation of allograft lymphocytes to hsp in context with syngeneic splenocytes as antigen-presenting cells (APC) was seen primarily if small quantities of IL-2 had been added to the cultures. In contrast, hsp-specific proliferation was never observed with syngraft lymphocytes, even after addition of IL-2. Spleen cells from allograft and syngraft recipients showed hsp augmentation of alloproliferation, but the magnitude was less than that with allograft lymphocytes. Kinetic studies showed that hsp-reactive lymphocytes first appeared in the allograft on day 3 posttransplant. Tacrolimus immunosuppression of transplant rejection prevented the appearance of hsp-reactive lymphocytes in allografts. Culture conditions have been established to generate hsp65- and hsp70-specific T lymphocyte lines and clones from allograft-infiltrating cells. These cultured cells exhibited hsp reactivity only in context with self-APC, and this was augmented by small amounts of IL-2. These data provide strong evidence for the involvement of hsp-reactive lymphocytes in allograft rejection. We propose the concept that during rejection tissue stress induced by alloreactive effector lymphocytes promotes the recruitment and activation of hsp-reactive lymphocytes, especially in the presence of IL-2 released into the allogeneic environment of the transplant. These hsp-reactive T cells may play a role in the immune cascade of the inflammatory process of transplant rejection.

Improved surgical technique for the establishment of a murine model of aortic transplantation.

Aortic allotransplantation is a reliable procedure to study the evolvement of chronic rejection in mice. The progressive nature of this process in mice is characterized by diffuse and concentric myointimal proliferation which is inevitably associated with variable degrees of luminal constriction. These vascular changes are comparable to those that are witnessed in organ allografts undergoing chronic rejection in humans, underscoring its utility as a model of choice for the study of the development of this lesion. Whilst improved surgical technique has resulted in markedly enhanced graft survival, the results are far from being acceptable. Realizing this limitation, we embarked on developing a modified technique for aortic transplantation which would allow for improved graft survival in mice. A bypass conduit was created by end‐to‐side anastomosis of a segment of the donors thoracic aorta into the infrarenal portion of the recipients abdominal aorta. Using this technique, the graft survival was >98% with evidence in allotransplanted aorta of morphological changes pathognomonic of chronic rejection. On the contrary, no histopathological anomalies were discerned in aortic grafts transplanted across syngeneic animals. This modified surgical approach ameliorates the unacceptably high graft loss associated with earlier techniques, further extending the utility of this model as a tool to study the molecular and cellular mechanisms rudiment to the evolvement of chronic rejection.

Prolonged survival of hamster-to-rat liver xenografts using splenectomy and cyclosporine administration.

The immunosuppressive effect of splenectomy, alone or in combination with cyclosporine (CsA), was examined in hamster-to-rat orthotopic liver xenografts. The mean survival time was 7.3±0.5 days in untreated controls, 7.6±0.8 days with 40 mg/kg/day CsA, 7.2±0.4 days with splenectomy alone, and 17.6±5.6 days with splenectomy combined with 30 mg/kg/day CsA (P < 0.01). The longest survival time was 27 days in this group. Marked enlargement of the spleen and high lymphocytotoxic antibody titer were characteristic of the unmodified recipients and those treated with CsA alone. Splenectomy by itself decreased the antibody formation without improvement of graft survival. In animals treated with the combined regimen, the lymphocytotoxic antibody titer was significantly suppressed, and the PMN and round cell infiltration were greatly reduced. Therefore, a synergistic effect was postulated between cyclosporine and splenectomy in this liver xenograft system.

Abrogation of chronic rejection in a murine model of aortic allotransplantation by prior induction of donor-specific tolerance.

Aortic allotransplantation in mice has been well established as a model of choice to study the evolvement of chronic rejection, the etiopathology of which is believed to be that of immune origin. This has prompted the postulation that prior induction of donor-specific tolerance would attenuate or abrogate the underlying events that culminate in posttransplant arteriosclerosis. To study the effects of donor-specific tolerance on chronic rejection, we performed orthotopic liver transplantation without immunosuppression in mice 30 days before aortic allotransplantation across C57Bl/ 10J (H2b)-->C3H (H2k) strain combinations (group III). Aortic allografting in syngeneic (group I; C3H-->C3H) and allogeneic (group II, C57Bl/10J-->C3H) animals served as controls. No morphological changes were evidenced in the transplanted aortas in group I animals. Contrarily, aortic allografts in group II animals underwent a self-limiting acute cellular rejection, which resolved completely and was succeeded by day 30 after transplantation by histopathological changes pathognomonic of chronic rejection. There was evidence for diffuse myointimal thickening, progressive concentric luminal narrowing, and patchy destruction of internal elastic membranes resulting in massive vascular obliteration by day 120 after transplantation. It was of interest that no arteriosclerotic changes were observed for the duration of follow-up (up to 120 days after transplantation) in transplanted aortas (liver donor-type) harvested from animals in group III. However, vasculopathy was prominent in third-party aortic grafts transplanted into tolerant recipients. Taken together, these data suggest that prior induction of tolerance abrogates the development of chronic rejection; this protection seems to be donor specific.

Donor species complement after liver xenotransplantation : the mechanism of protection from hyperacute rejection

Hamster hearts transplanted into stable rat recipients of hamster livers (OLT rats) were hyperacutely rejected after transfer with unaltered rat antihamster hyperimmune serum (HS). This was followed by immediate liver xenograft rejection in 4 of 5 rats. In contrast, simple heat inactivation of the rat HS resulted in prolonged survival of hamster hearts to 25 days without deterioration effect in the liver xenografts. This effect was species-specific because third-party mouse heart grafts in OLT rats were hyperacutely rejected in minutes if either active or heat inactivated antimouse HS was given. In cytotoxicity experiments, the complement in OLT serum produced weak lysis of hamster lymphocytes, while efficiently doing so with mouse cell targets. Because normal hamster serum caused no lysis at all of hamster target cells, the residual low-grade lysis of OLT serum was possibly being mediated by extrahepatic sources of rat C. In conclusion, the homology of C and target cells represents a mechanism of protection that the liver confers to other organs, and that is most easily seen in xenografts but may be allospecifically operational with allografts as well within the limits of MHC restriction.

Expression of stress proteins and lymphocyte reactivity in heterotopic cardiac allografts undergoing cellular rejection.

This report addresses the concept that, during rejection, the allograft undergoes a stress response which leads to an increased expression of stress proteins, also called heat shock proteins (hsp), and the recruitment and activation of hsp-reactive lymphocytes. Recent studies in our laboratory have provided evidence that hsp-reactive T-cells are present in cardiac allografts undergoing rejection. In this study, an MHC incompatible heterotopic heart allograft model (ACI into LEW) was chosen to analyse the kinetics of hsp expression during the development of rejection. Allografts and syngrafts (LEW into LEW) were harvested every day during the first 5 days post-transplant. Immunoblot analysis of proteins extracted from graft stromal tissues was done with murine monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against various mammalian hsp. Proliferation studies were done to determine hsp reactivity of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes on different days post-transplant. Three types of stressful stimuli appeared to increase hsp expression in the allograft. The first was a physiological stress secondary to the trauma of the transplant procedure and ischaemia/reperfusion injury and this would occur in allogeneic and syngeneic grafts. During the first day after transplantation, both types of grafts showed higher expression of hsp72 and grp78 and to a lesser extent, hsp60 and grp75. On the second and third day, the expression of grp78 and grp96 was higher in allografts than in syngrafts and this may reflect an immunologically mediated stress response in the allograft when infiltrating hsp-reactive lymphocytes became first detectable in the allograft. The third type of stress appeared related to the inflammatory process associated with rejection. On the fourth and fifth day post-transplant, the allografts showed strong expression of at least five proteins of lower molecular mass reacting with hsp-specific mAbs; namely, approximately 40 kDa (detected by anti-hsp60), approximately 30 kDa (by anti-hsp72), approximately 45 kDa and approximately 32 kDa (by anti-hsp72 + hsc73), and approximately 50 kDa (by anti-grp78). At that time, the allograft began to show progressive inflammatory changes and tissue damage. The appearance of lower molecular mass hsp-crossreactive proteins might reflect a degradation of hsps which had increased expression earlier during the post-transplant period. This process may generate large quantities of hsp-derived peptides which may be presented by MHC molecules to graft-infiltrating T-cells. Another interpretation of the strong expression of lower molecular bands in later allografts is that they represent other stress proteins that crossreact with antibodies against hsp60 and hsp70 family members.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The future of transplantation: With particular reference to chimerism and xenotransplantation

The assumption for the last third of a century that stem cell-driven hematolymphopoietic chimerism was irrelevant to successful conventional whole organ transplantation has prompted alternative inadequate explanations of organ allograft acceptance. This assumption clouded the biologic meaning of successful organ as well as bone marrow transplantation, and precluded the development of a cardinal principle that accommodated all facets of transplantation. Recognition of this error and the incorporation of the chimerism factor into a two-way paradigm have allowed previous enigmas of organ as well as bone marrow engraftment to be explained. No credible evidence has emerged to interdict this interactive concept. If the two-way paradigm is correct, it will allow the remarkable advances that have been made in basic immunology to be more meaningfully exploited for transplantation, including that of xenografts.