Luis Somoza

Reply to comment from Blanco et al. (2015) on “Evidence from acoustic imaging for submarine volcanic activity in 2012 off the west coast of El Hierro (Canary Islands, Spain) by Pérez et al. [Bull. Volcanol. (2014), 76:882–896]

We begin by noting our appreciation for the comment from Blanco et al. (2015) on BEvidence from acoustic imaging for submarine volcanic activity in June 2012 off the west coast of El Hierro (Canary Islands, Spain)^ by Pérez et al. (2014) because it provides the opportunity to maintain an open scientific debate on this issue within the right framework. This is especially important because one of the co-authors of the comment from Blanco et al. (2015) had previously made a suggestion to us that we should not send the acoustic imaging data taken on June 28, 2012, for publication. In our opinion, this recommendation was detrimental to open scientific debate, which is always tremendously beneficial for the development of science. Secondly, the comment from Blanco et al. (2015) suggests that readers may have been confused; we emphasize that the submarine volcanic activity in 2012 off the west coast of El Hierro described by Pérez et al. (2014) was not, as inferred by Blanco et al. (2015), a volcanic eruption. It has been well documented (e.g., Italiano and Nuccio 1991; Caracausi et al. 2005; García et al. 2006; Pérez and Hernández 2007) that new and/or sporadic volcanic activities, such as relatively weak or significant visible degassing processes during volcanic unrest, have commonly occurred both in subaerial and submarine environments of volcanic systems. Such activity includes things that are not a volcanic eruption, which implies release of juvenile volcanic material and not just the sudden release of steam/gas. Pérez et al. (2014) used only acoustic imaging data taken on June 28 as evidence for submarine volcanic activity in 2012 off the west coast of El Hierro. Without this data, it would have been impossible for us to submit our scientific contribution for publication.

Pockmarks on either side of the Strait of Gibraltar: formation from overpressured shallow contourite gas reservoirs and internal wave action during the last glacial sea-level lowstand?

Integrating novel and published swath bathymetry (3,980 km2), as well as chirp and high-resolution 2D seismic reflection profiles (2,190 km), this study presents the mapping of 436 pockmarks at water depths varying widely between 370 and 1,020 m on either side of the Strait of Gibraltar. On the Atlantic side in the south-eastern Gulf of Cádiz near the Camarinal Sill, 198 newly discovered pockmarks occur in three well localized and separated fields: on the upper slope (n=14), in the main channel of the Mediterranean outflow water (MOW, n=160), and on the huge contourite levee of the MOW main channel (n=24) near the well-known TASYO field. These pockmarks vary in diameter from 60 to 919 m, and are sub-circular to irregularly elongated or lobate in shape. Their slope angles on average range from 3° to 25°. On the Mediterranean side of the strait on the Ceuta Drift of the western Alborán Basin, where pockmarks were already known to occur, 238 pockmarks were identified and grouped into three interconnected fields, i.e. a northern (n=34), a central (n=61) and a southern field (n=143). In the latter two fields the pockmarks are mainly sub-circular, ranging from 130 to 400 m in diameter with slope angles averaging 1.5° to 15°. In the northern sector, by contrast, they are elongated up to 1,430 m, probably reflecting MOW activity. Based on seismo-stratigraphic interpretation, it is inferred that most pockmarks formed during and shortly after the last glacial sea-level lowstand, as they are related to the final erosional discontinuity sealed by Holocene transgressive deposits. Combining these findings with other existing knowledge, it is proposed that pockmark formation on either side of the Strait of Gibraltar resulted from gas and/or sediment pore-water venting from overpressured shallow gas reservoirs entrapped in coarse-grained contourites of levee deposits and Pleistocene palaeochannel infillings. Venting was either triggered or promoted by hydraulic pumping associated with topographically forced internal waves. This mechanism is analogous to the long-known effect of tidal pumping on the dynamics of unit pockmarks observed along the Norwegian continental margin.

Phosphorites, Co-rich Mn nodules, and Fe-Mn crusts from Galicia Bank, NE Atlantic: Reflections of Cenozoic tectonics and paleoceanography

A wide variety of marine mineral deposits were recovered from 750 to 1400 m water depths on Galicia Bank, Iberian margin. Mineral deposits include: (1) carbonate fluorapatite phosphorite slabs and nodules that replaced limestone and preserved original protolith fabric. (2) Ferromanganese vernadite crusts with high Mn and Fe (Mn/Fe = 1) contents, and thick stratabound layers consisting mainly of Mn (up to 27% MnO) and Fe (15% Fe2O3), which impregnated and replaced the phosphorite. (3) Co-rich Mn nodules are composed of romanechite and todorokite laminae. Mn-rich layers (up to 58% MnO) contain up to 1.8% Co. (4) Goethite nodules with Fe up to 67% Fe2O3 have low Mn and trace metals. We interpret this mineralization paragenesis to be related to major changes in oceanographic and tectonic regimes. Three phosphatization generations formed hardgrounds dated by 87Sr/86Sr isotopes as late Oligocene, early Miocene, and latest early Miocene. During the latest early Miocene, the hardground was fractured and breached due to regional intraplate tectonism, which was coeval with a widespread regional erosional unconformity. The stratabound layers and Co-rich manganese nodules were derived from low-temperature geothermally driven hydrothermal fluids, with fluid conduits along reactivated faults. During middle and late Miocene, the introduction of vigorous deep water flow from the Arctic generated growth of hydrogenetic ferromanganese crusts. Finally, growth of diagenetic Fe-rich nodules (late Pliocene) was promoted by the introduction of hypersaline Mediterranean Outflow Water into the Atlantic Ocean.

Evolution of submarine eruptive activity during the 2011–2012 El Hierro event as documented by hydroacoustic images and remotely operated vehicle observations

Submarine volcanic eruptions are frequent and important events, yet they are rarely observed. Here we relate bathymetric and hydroacoustic images from the 2011 to 2012 El Hierro eruption with surface observations and deposits imaged and sampled by ROV. As a result of the shallow submarine eruption, a new volcano named Tagoro grew from 375 to 89 m depth. The eruption consisted of two main phases of edifice construction intercalated with collapse events. Hydroacoustic images show that the eruptions ranged from explosive to effusive with variable plume types and resulting deposits, even over short time intervals. At the base of the edifice, ROV observations show large accumulations of lava balloons changing in size and type downslope, coinciding with the area where floating lava balloon fallout was observed. Peaks in eruption intensity during explosive phases generated vigorous bubbling at the surface, extensive ash, vesicular lapilli and formed high-density currents, which together with periods of edifice gravitational collapse, produced extensive deep volcaniclastic aprons. Secondary cones developed in the last stages and show evidence for effusive activity with lava ponds and lava flows that cover deposits of stacked lava balloons. Chaotic masses of heterometric boulders around the summit of the principal cone are related to progressive sealing of the vent with decreasing or variable magma supply. Hornitos represent the final eruptive activity with hydrothermal alteration and bacterial mats at the summit. Our study documents the distinct evolution of a submarine volcano and highlights the range of deposit types that may form and be rapidly destroyed in such eruptions.

Evidence of a modern deep water magmatic hydrothermal system in the Canary Basin (eastern central Atlantic Ocean)

New seismic profiles, bathymetric data and sediment-rock sampling document for the first time the discovery of hydrothermal vent complexes and volcanic cones at 4800-5200 m depth related to recent volcanic and intrusive activity in an unexplored area of the Canary Basin (Eastern Atlantic Ocean, 500 km west of the Canary Islands). A complex of sill intrusions is imaged on seismic profiles showing saucer-shaped, parallel or inclined geometries. Three main types of structures are related to these intrusions. Type I consists of cone-shaped depressions developed above inclined sills interpreted as hydrothermal vents. Type II is the most abundant and is represented by isolated or clustered hydrothermal domes bounded by faults rooted at the tips of saucer-shaped sills. Domes are interpreted as seabed expressions of reservoirs of CH4- and CO2-rich fluids formed by degassing and contact metamorphism of organic-rich sediments around sill intrusions. Type III are hydrothermal-volcanic complexes originated above stratified or branched inclined sills connected by a chimney to the seabed volcanic edifice. Parallel sills sourced from the magmatic chimney formed also domes surrounding the volcanic cones. Core and dredges revealed that these volcanoes, which must be among the deepest in the world, are constituted by OIB-type, basanites with an outer ring of blue-green hydrothermal Al-rich smectite muds. Magmatic activity is dated, based on lava samples, at 0.78±0.05 and 1.61±0.09 Ma (K/Ar methods) and on tephra layers within cores at 25-237 ky. The Subvent hydrothermal-volcanic complex constitutes the first modern system reported in deep-water oceanic basins related to intraplate hotspot activity.

Onshore and Offshore Geomorphological Features of the El Golfo Debris Avalanche (El Hierro, Canary Islands)

This study shows an onshore-offshore morpho-structural characterization of the El Golfo flank collapse and debris avalanche on El Hierro (Canary Islands, Spain). Erosive and depositional features have been identified based on: LIDAR topography and geology from water galleries (onshore); and high-resolution 3.5 kHz and multichannel seismic reflection profiles, and multibeam data (offshore). The onshore headwall scarp shows a non-continuous profile formed by two semi-circular amphitheatres and extends offshore by a smooth chute. The chute ends at about 3000–3200 m water depth in the distal depositional area. Multichannel seismic profiles show two major subunits of chaotic reflectors in the debris avalanche deposits. Results suggest that the El Golfo debris avalanche event likely took place in multiple stages. Consequently, we suggest that the multistaged nature of El Golfo debris avalanche greatly reduces the tsunamigenic potential of these flank collapses.

GIS Catalogue of Submarine Landslides in the Spanish Continental Shelf: Potential and Difficulties for Susceptibility Assessment

This study presents the first version of a GIS catalogue of submarine landslides affecting the Spanish Continental Shelf pursuant UNCLOS (United Convention for the Law of the Sea) that comprise continental-type margins (Atlantic and Mediterranean) as well as hot-spot type volcanic islands and seamounts (Canary Archipelago). This first version compiles a total of 223 submarine landslides within an area of 1.5 million square kilometres. This catalogue, developed in a geographic information system, compiles information of each submarine landslide such as the name, location, typology, age, volume, source, dimensions (width, elongation), minimum and maximum height, minimum and maximum seafloor slopes. As a direct application and advantage of this digital catalogue, a first approach to a susceptibility map has been elaborated using GIS analysis tools taking into account the following available factors sourced from the geological maps of the Spanish continental margins: (i) faults map, (ii) active faults map, (iii) earthquakes density map, (iv) seafloor slope map and (v) seabed composition map. The potential and difficulties of this GIS catalogue of landslide as a first step in the submarine risk analysis are discussed. This first version of the GIS catalogue is conceived as the origin of a national submarine landslides database within the European network, which is being built as part of the EMODNET-Geology project.