Lydia Komarnicky

Ten-year results in 1070 patients with stages I and II breast cancer treated by conservative surgery and radiation therapy

Background. One thousand seventy patients treated conservatively for Stages I and II breast cancer between the years 1982 and 1994 were reviewed. The median follow‐up was 40 months with a maximum follow‐up of 152 months.

Breast-Conserving Therapy after Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy: Long-term Results

Abstract:  The purpose of this study was to determine patterns of ipsilateral breast tumor recurrence (IBTR) and local‐regional recurrence (LRR) after neoadjuvant chemotherapy and breast‐conserving therapy (BCT). A total of 153 breast cancer patients were treated with neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by conservative surgery and radiation therapy between 1980 and 2002. The clinical stage (American Joint Committee on Cancer [AJCC] 1997) at diagnosis was IIA in 22%, IIB in 28%, IIIA in 39%, and IIIB in 11%. The prechemotherapy T size distribution was less than 2 cm in 5 patients, 2.1–5 cm in 100 patients, and greater than 5.1 cm in 48 patients. Sixty‐seven patients (44%) underwent cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and 5‐fluorouracil (CMF)‐based chemotherapy and 86 (56%) underwent Adriamycin‐based chemotherapy. Thirty‐seven patients (24%) had a complete pathologic response in the breast. All procedures were performed by a single surgeon (G.F.S.). The surgery was local excision alone in 19 patients, local excision and axillary lymph node dissection (ALND) in 130 patients, and ALND alone in 4 patients. Eleven patients had positive surgical margins. Rates of LRR‐, IBTR‐, and distant metastasis (DM)‐free survival were calculated by the Kaplan–Meier method. Patient and pathologic variables were then analyzed in an attempt to identify predictors of clinical outcome. With a median follow‐up period of 55 months (range 6–200 months), eight patients developed LRR, five of which were classified as IBTR. Five‐ and 10‐year actuarial rates of LRR‐free, IBTR‐free, and DM‐free survival were 93% and 88%, 96% and 91%, and 70% and 58%, respectively. Pretreatment and pathologic parameters that positively correlated with IBTR were advanced stage (p = 0.03) and margin positivity (p = 0.04). No other clinical factors were predictive of higher recurrence. BCT results in a low rate of IBTR and LRR in appropriately selected patients. Advanced stage at presentation is associated with increased risk of IBTR, although overall recurrence is low. In selected cases, BCT is safe and an effective alternative to mastectomy. 

Plaque radiotherapy for selected orbital malignancies: preliminary observations: the 2002 Montgomery Lecture, part 2.

Purpose To describe the principles and preliminary results of plaque brachytherapy for selected orbital malignancies. Methods A custom-designed Iodine-125 plaque, designed to deliver a target dose of 50 Gray, was placed surgically in the region from which an orbital malignancy was partially resected. The mean dose to the target area was 50 Gray. The initial and follow-up patient data were reviewed. Results Of the 8 patients, the diagnosis was adenoid cystic carcinoma of the lacrimal gland (4 cases), orbital invasion by basal cell carcinoma (2), orbital extension of conjunctival melanoma (1), and metastatic carcinoma (1). Of the 4 with adenoid cystic carcinoma, there was microscopic residual tumor after excision and orbital exenteration was considered. Three have tumor control with follow-up of 1, 3, and 6 years. One patient required exenteration for recurrence separate from the field of brachytherapy and is free of tumor after 10 years. All 4 patients are alive and well with tumor control. Of the 2 patients with orbital extension of basal cell carcinoma, tumor control without recurrence has been achieved in both after 2 years. The patient with orbital metastasis responded to plaque radiotherapy, with no orbital recurrence, but died of systemic metastasis. The patient with orbital melanoma had local orbital recurrence separate from the area of irradiation and is currently being treated for systemic metastasis. Conclusions Based on preliminary observations, plaque radiotherapy appears to be a reasonable alternative to exenteration and external irradiation for selected orbital malignancies.

Influence of radiation dose on positive surgical margins in women undergoing breast conservation therapy.

PURPOSE Positive surgical margins adversely influence local tumor control in breast conservation therapy (BCT). However, reports have conflicted regarding whether an increased radiation dose can overcome this poor prognostic factor. In this study, we evaluated the influence of an increased radiation dose on tumor control in women with positive surgical margins undergoing BCT. METHODS AND MATERIALS Between 1978 and 1994, 733 women with pathologic Stage I-II breast cancer and known surgical margin status were treated at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital with BCT. Of these 733 patients, 641 women had a minimal tumor bed dose of 60 Gy and had documentation of their margin status; 509 had negative surgical margins, and 132 had positive surgical margins before definitive radiotherapy. Complete gross excision of the tumor and axillary lymph node sampling was obtained in all patients. The median radiation dose to the primary site was 65.0 Gy (range 60-76). Of the women with positive margins (n = 132), the influence of higher doses of radiotherapy was evaluated. The median follow-up time was 52 months. RESULTS The local tumor control rate for patients with negative margins at 5 and 10 years was 94% and 88%, respectively, compared with 85% and 67%, respectively, for those women with positive margins (p = 0.001). The disease-free survival rate for the negative margin group at 5 and 10 years was 91% and 82%, respectively, compared with 76% and 71%, respectively, for the positive margin group (p = 0.001). The overall survival rate of women with negative margins at 5 and 10 years was 95% and 90%, respectively. By comparison, for women with positive surgical margins, the overall survival rate at 5 and 10 years was 86% and 79%, respectively (p = 0.008). A comparison of the positive and negative margin groups revealed that an increased radiation dose (whether entered as a dichotomous or a continuous variable) >65.0 Gy did not improve local tumor control (p = 0.776). On Cox multivariate analysis, margin status and menopausal status had prognostic significance for local tumor control and DFS. CONCLUSION Patients with positive surgical margins have a higher risk of local tumor recurrence and worse survival when undergoing BCT. Higher doses of radiation are unable to provide an adequate level of local control in patients with positive margins.

Plaque Radiotherapy for Juxtapapillary Choroidal Melanoma: Tumor Control in 650 Consecutive Cases

PURPOSE To evaluate treatment of juxtapapillary choroidal melanoma with plaque radiotherapy and to investigate the role of supplemental transpupillary thermotherapy (TTT). DESIGN Retrospective, comparative case series. PARTICIPANTS We included 650 consecutive eyes with juxtapapillary choroidal melanoma within 1 mm of the optic disc. METHODS Eyes with juxtapapillary choroidal melanoma receiving plaque radiotherapy over a 31-year period from October 1974 to November 2005 were included in the study. The TTT and no TTT groups were analyzed separately and compared. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Local tumor control, metastasis, and tumor-related mortality. RESULTS The median basal tumor diameter was 10 mm (range, 1.5-21) and median thickness was 3.5 mm (range, 0.5-14.8). In 481 eyes (74%), the tumor was directly adjacent to the optic disc and in 169 eyes (26%) the posterior tumor margin was between 0.1 and 1.0 mm from the optic disc. The circumpapillary extent of the tumor was <4 clock-hours in 321 eyes (50%), 4-8 clock-hours in 250 eyes (38%), and >8 clock-hours in 79 eyes (12%). Plaque radiotherapy using iodine-125 in 616 eyes (95%), cobalt-60 in 19 eyes (3%), iridium-192 in 12 eyes (2%), and ruthenium-106 in 3 eyes (<1%) delivered a median radiation dose of 8000 cGy (range, 3600-15 500) to the tumor apex and adjunctive TTT was used in 307 eyes (56%). Kaplan-Meier estimates for tumor recurrence, metastasis, and death were 14%, 11%, and 4% at 5 years and 21%, 24%, and 9% at 10 years, respectively. Eyes treated with additional TTT showed slight (statistically nonsignificant) reduction in recurrence and metastasis. Using multivariable analysis, factors predictive of tumor recurrence included foveolar tumor requiring TTT (hazard ratio, 5.07; P<0.001) and greater tumor thickness (hazard ratio, 1.29 per mm increase; P<0.001). Factors predictive of metastasis included greater tumor base (hazard ratio, 1.21 per mm increase; P<0.001) and increasing intraocular pressure (hazard ratio, 1.11 per mmHg increase; P = 0.020). CONCLUSIONS Plaque radiotherapy for juxtapapillary melanoma provides local tumor control in approximately 80% of eyes at 10 years. In subjects who received TTT, there was slight but nonsignificant improved local tumor control and lower metastatic rate.

Randomized trial of one versus two adjuvant hyperthermia treatments per week in patients with superficial tumours

One test for thermotolerance development in a clinical situation is to evaluate the effects of altering the hyperthermia fractionation interval on tumour response to thermoradiotherapy. Between 1983 and 1990 44 evaluable advanced superficial tumours of miscellaneous origin in 41 patients were randomized to receive either once-weekly or twice-weekly external microwave hyperthermia treatments combined with radiation therapy. The mean age of patients was 62 years, and 85% had failed previous therapy. All lesions were less than 8 x 8 x 4 cm (L x W x D) and were heated by external 915 MHz microwaves. The mean radiation dose was 44 +/- 3 Gy (mean +/- SE) in the once-weekly group and 46 +/- 3 Gy in the twice-weekly group (p = 0.64). The mean volume of the lesions heated once weekly was 17 +/- 6 versus 23 +/- 5 cm3 for those heated twice weekly (p = 0.45). Hyperthermia was administered once weekly for 4.6 +/- 0.2 sessions (range 3-7) or twice weekly for 8.1 +/- 0.3 sessions (range 4-10). Thermometry was performed using 3.4 +/- 0.2 catheters and 5.1 +/- 0.6 thermal sensors per tumour in the once-weekly group, and 2.7 +/- 0.2 catheters and 5.8 +/- 0.3 thermal sensors per tumour in the twice-weekly group. Of the 44 evaluable randomized lesions a complete response (CR) at 2 months post-treatment was observed in 59% (13/22) heated once weekly and 55% (12/22) in those heated twice weekly. The prognostic factors predictive of tumour complete response were found by logistic regression analysis to be radiation dose and tumour volume, while the prognostic factors predictive of duration of response (Cox proportional hazards analysis) were median minimum tumour temperature (Tmin), minimum tumour temperature during the first heat treatment (Tmin1) and tumour volume. The duration of local control in lesions with Tmin < or = 39.5 degrees C was 11.7 +/- 1.9 months while for lesions with Tmin > 39.5 degrees C it was 23.0 +/- 4.2 months (p = 0.01). The ED50 was calculated by logistic regression to be 40 Gy (95% CI = 22-54 Gy) for once- and twice-weekly heated lesions. There was not a significant difference in tumour response or duration of response between populations randomized to receive once- versus twice-weekly hyperthermia treatments. There was also no difference in skin reaction rates between once- and twice-weekly hyperthermia treatments, nor could a correlation be found between any thermal parameter and skin reactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Iris Melanoma Management with Iodine-125 Plaque Radiotherapy in 144 Patients: Impact of Melanoma-Related Glaucoma on Outcomes

PURPOSE To evaluate the outcomes of iris melanoma managed with plaque radiotherapy on the basis of the initial presence or absence of glaucoma. DESIGN Retrospective, comparative case series. PARTICIPANTS A total of 144 patients. INTERVENTION Custom-designed iodine-125 plaque radiotherapy delivering planned 8000 cGy to melanoma apex using transcorneal application. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Tumor control and treatment-related complications. RESULTS Of 144 patients with iris melanoma, glaucoma was present at the initial visit in 58 (40%). Causes of elevated intraocular pressure included angle infiltration by melanoma in 50 patients (86%), angle neovascularization in 4 patients (7%), and hyphema in 4 patients (7%). At presentation, the eyes displaying iris melanoma with glaucoma (vs. without glaucoma) were statistically more likely to display angle tumor (66% vs. 43%), with minimal thickness (1.9 vs. 2.9 mm), and melanoma seeding in iris stroma (7 vs. 3 clock hours) and angle (5 vs. 2 clock hours). Plaque radiotherapy was performed in all cases. Kaplan-Meier estimates at 7 years post-treatment revealed no statistical differences in outcomes of local recurrence (14% vs. 15%), enucleation (14% vs. 11%), or metastasis (2% vs. 0%) comparing eyes with and without glaucoma. Of the entire group, multivariate analysis for factors predictive of recurrence included partial (vs. complete) anterior segment irradiation and postradiotherapy glaucoma. Factors related to enucleation included diabetes mellitus, poor initial visual acuity, higher radiation dose to tumor apex, and tumor recurrence. There were no factors predictive of metastasis. CONCLUSIONS Iodine-125 plaque radiotherapy provides adequate tumor control for iris melanoma with a low metastatic potential of 1% at 7 years. Iris melanoma with secondary glaucoma showed a statistically significant greater likelihood of flat tumor with iris and angle seeding and no difference in outcomes compared with eyes without glaucoma. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S) The author(s) have no proprietary or commercial interest in any materials discussed in this article.

Plaque radiotherapy for juxtapapillary choroidal melanoma overhanging the optic disc in 141 consecutive patients.

OBJECTIVE To evaluate tumor control with plaque radiotherapy for juxtapapillary choroidal melanoma that overhangs the optic disc. METHODS Retrospective medical record review of 141 consecutive patients with data on complications of treatment, final visual acuity, visual loss, enucleation, tumor recurrence, metastasis, and death. RESULTS The median patient age was 61 years. Presenting symptoms included reduced visual acuity in 72 eyes (51%), photopsia in 14 (10%), and visual field defect in 18 (13%); 35 patients (25%) were asymptomatic. The median tumor basal diameter was 11 mm and the median thickness was 5.2 mm. The tumor overhung 50% or less of the disc in 88 eyes (62%) and more than 50% of the disc in 53 eyes (38%). In 19 cases (13%), the tumor overhung the entire disc. All patients were treated with plaque radiotherapy, using a notched design in 126 eyes (89%) and a round design in 14 eyes (10%), with iodine 125 in 132 eyes (94%) and cobalt 60 in 9 eyes (6%). The median radiation dose to the tumor apex was 8500 cGy. Adjuvant transpupillary thermotherapy was used in 54 eyes (39%). During a mean follow-up of 56 months, complications included nonproliferative retinopathy in 61 eyes (51%), proliferative retinopathy in 26 (22%), maculopathy in 44 (37%), papillopathy in 57 (48%), neovascular glaucoma in 23 (19%), and vitreous hemorrhage in 48 (40%). A final visual acuity of 20/200 or worse was measured in 72 eyes (77%), and visual loss of more than 5 Snellen lines occurred in 59 eyes (63%). Enucleation was necessary in 27 eyes (23%). Tumor recurrence was found in 12 eyes (10%). Metastasis developed in 15 patients (13%) and death in 4 cases (3%). CONCLUSIONS Using plaque radiotherapy for choroidal melanoma overhanging the optic disc, local tumor control was achieved in 90% of cases. Tumor and radiation effects led to poor visual acuity in 77% of eyes. The metastatic rate was 13% and the mortality rate was 3%.

Scleral necrosis after plaque radiotherapy of uveal melanoma: a case-control study.

PURPOSE To identify risk factors and outcome of scleral necrosis after plaque radiotherapy of uveal melanoma. DESIGN Case-control study. PARTICIPANTS A total of 73 cases with scleral necrosis and 73 controls without necrosis after plaque radiotherapy. Controls were matched for anteroposterior tumor epicenter and follow-up duration. INTERVENTION Plaque radiotherapy with iodine-125, cobalt-60, iridium-192, or ruthenium-106. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Scleral necrosis. RESULTS Of 5057 patients treated with plaque radiotherapy for uveal melanoma, 73 (1%) developed radiotherapy-induced scleral necrosis. Scleral necrosis occurred in <1% of patients (3/1140) when plaque radiotherapy was used for tumors <3 mm in thickness, 1% of patients (33/3155) with 3- to 8-mm tumor thickness, and 5% of patients (37/762) with >8-mm-thick tumors. On the basis of tumor location, scleral necrosis was detected after plaque radiotherapy of iris melanoma in 0% of patients (0/91), ciliary body melanoma in 29% of patients (67/235), and choroid melanoma in <1% of patients (6/4731). The mean time interval between plaque radiotherapy and scleral necrosis was 32 months (median, 23 months; range, 4-126 months). The mean basal dimension of scleral necrosis was 4 mm (median, 3 mm; range, 1-15 mm), equivalent to 29% of mean tumor base (median, 24%; range, 6%-100%) and 22% of mean plaque size (median, 19%; range, 5%-75%). Multivariate analysis of factors that predicted clinically evident scleral necrosis included ciliary body (P = 0.0001) and pars plana to ora serrata (P < 0.0001) locations of anterior tumor margin, tumor thickness ≥ 6 mm (P = 0.0001), and radiation dose ≥ 400 Gy to the outer sclera (P = 0.0455). Scleral necrosis remained stable in 48% of patients (35/73), increased in size/severity in 48% of patients (35/73), or progressed to scleral perforation in 4% of patients (3/73) over a mean follow-up of 79 months (median, 54 months; range, 5-351 months). Treatment of scleral necrosis included observation in 81% of patients (59/73), scleral patch graft in 14% of patients (10/73), and enucleation in 5% of patients (4/73). CONCLUSIONS Scleral necrosis after plaque radiotherapy of uveal melanoma was detected in 1% of cases. Factors predictive of scleral necrosis included increasing tumor thickness, ciliary body and peripheral choroidal location, and higher radiation dose to sclera. Most patients (81%) did not require treatment, and 4% evolved to full-thickness perforation. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S) The author(s) have no proprietary or commercial interest in any materials discussed in this article.

The response of human tumour blood flow to a fractionated course of thermoradiotherapy

The response of human tumour blood flow to a fractionated course of thermoradiotherapy was documented in four superficial but bulky tumours (three adenocarcinomas, one melanoma). Blood flow was measured 15, 30, 45, and 60 min after the onset of heating. These measurements were made at the same intra-tumour point during each heat fraction by use of a modified thermal clearance technique in which a correction was made for the heat dissipated by thermal conduction. This point was at least 2 cm beneath the surface in the central portion of the tumour. Extracellular pH was measured within 1 cm of this point prior to the first heat fraction and 2-3 weeks later. Hyperthermia was administered for 60 min, twice a week for 4 weeks by use of a 16-channel 915 MHz microwave applicator. Each patient also received a radiation dose of 40 Gy fractionated at 2 Gy/fx, five times a week (adenocarcinomas) or 4 Gy/fx, twice a week (melanoma). Blood flow remained relatively constant during heating after steady state conditions were attained. However, an overall decrease in tumour blood flow was observed in each patient over the course of thermoradiotherapy. In each case, a relatively small decrease in blood flow occurred between most heat fractions which resulted in an overall decrease which ranged from 50-100%. However, there was a tendency for blood flow to increase following the initial heat fraction at points where the steady state temperature was approximately 41 degrees C or less. Extracellular pH increased in two of three patients and decreased in the other.