Lynne Clay

There are risks to be taken and some just push it too far: how farmers perceive quad-bike incident risk

Objective: To qualitatively explore how farmers perceive personal risk of an occupational quad‐bike incident and develop a model of the factors that modify this perception.

Unrealistic optimism, fatalism, and risk-taking in New Zealand farmers' descriptions of quad-bike incidents: a directed qualitative content analysis

ABSTRACT Quad-bike incidents are a major cause of occupational injury and fatality on farms warranting health and safety attention. As part of a larger study, we carried out a face-to-face survey with 216 farmers in New Zealand. We quantitatively identified farmers’ propensity for risk-taking, unrealistic optimism, and fatalism as risk factors in quad-bike loss-of-control events (LCEs). The purpose of the analysis presented in this article was to use these same farmers’ recollections of LCEs to explore the a priori constructs in more detail using qualitative methods. Participants reporting one or more LCEs described their first LCE and any experienced in the previous 12 months. Participants provided open-text responses about what occurred at each LCE, their reflections, and general thoughts on LCE risk factors. Directed qualitative content analysis (QCA) was used to “unpack” risk-taking, unrealistic optimism, and fatalism whilst also delineating any additional concepts that farmers associate with LCEs. Risk-taking elements were more evident than unrealistic optimism or fatalism and more suggestive of farmers finding themselves in risky situations rather than engaging in risk-seeking behavior per se. Additional inductively derived categories of fatigue/stress, multitasking, inexperience, and quad-bike faults highlight the complex nature of LCEs and the importance of risk assessment covering these concepts as well as risky situations.

Perspectives on walking from people with multiple sclerosis and reactions to video self-observation

Abstract Purpose: People with multiple sclerosis (MS) rank walking among the most challenging aspects of their condition. A greater understanding of people’s perspectives concerning their walking may help to prioritize walking outcomes and strategies for optimizing walking. The purpose was to explore perceptions of walking in people with MS and to describe their reactions after observing themselves walk on video. Materials and methods: An interpretive thematic analysis study using face-to-face, semi-structured interviews was conducted with 14 people who self-identified a change in their walking due to MS. Participants were video-recorded walking and watched their video during the interview. Results: Four themes were identified: “awareness,” “acceptance,” “constant change,” and “increased effort.” People with MS develop awareness of how their walking performance looks and awareness of constantly-changing internal factors and external factors which impact their walking. Awareness of change in fatigue, temperature, terrain, and the use of aids in particular are perceived relevant to walking and to impact the effort required to walk. People with MS also describe differences in their acceptance of how others view their walking and the changes related to walking. An analogy with a marionette performing describes how people perceive walking as no longer automatic; instead walking requires the person to consciously pull the strings to walk. An increase in both the physical and cognitive effort is required to walk and an awareness and acceptance of a variety of changes in oneself and the lived world may help or hinder walking. People with MS are willing to watch themselves walk on video and are not surprised by what they observe. Conclusions: People with MS develop a learned self-awareness with variable levels of acceptance about their walking function and what it looks like. The perceptions on walking from persons with MS suggest that focusing on reducing the effort to walk and minimizing the constantly-changing variables may help to optimize walking. Implications for rehabilitation People with multiple sclerosis are challenged by the increased effort and constant change required to walk in their day-to-day lives. A focus on minimizing both the effort to walk and the changing variables (i.e., fluctuating symptoms and environmental factors) is warranted. People with multiple sclerosis develop a learned awareness of how they walk and how their walking looks. Acceptance of loss of walking function is variable. Video self-observation is a feasible tool which warrants further exploration for enhancing acceptance of walking function and accommodating strategies.

Measurement properties of instruments assessing permanent functional impairment of the spine: a systematic review protocol

Introduction Permanent functional impairment (PFI) of the spine is a rating system used by compensation authorities, such as workers compensation boards, to establish an appropriate level of financial compensation for persistent loss of function. Determination of PFI of the spine is commonly based on the assessment of spinal movement combined with other measures of physical and functional impairments; however, the reliability and validity of the measurement instruments used for these evaluations have yet to be established. The aim of this study is to systematically review and synthesise the literature concerning measurement properties of the various and different instruments used for assessing PFI of the spine. Methods Three conceptual groups of terms (1) PFI, (2) spinal disorder and (3) measurement properties will be combined to search Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, Scopus, PEDro, OTSeeker and Health and Safety Science Abstracts. We will examine peer-reviewed, full-text articles over the full available date range. Two reviewers will independently screen citations (title, abstract and full text) and perform data extraction. Included studies will be appraised as to their methodological quality using the COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments criteria. Findings will be summarised and presented descriptively, with meta-analysis pursued as appropriate. Ethics and dissemination This review will summarise the current level of evidence of measurement properties of instruments used for assessing PFI of the spine. Findings of this review may be applicable to clinicians, policy-makers, workers’ compensation boards, other insurers and health and safety organisations. The findings will likely provide a foundation and direction for future research priorities for assessing spinal PFI. PROSPERO registration number CRD42017060390.

Agricultural Quad-bike Incidents: Do Farmworkers Take Risks?

Agricultural Quad-bike Incidents: Do Farmworkers Take Risks? Lynne Clay MPhty, E. Jean Hay-Smith PhD, Gareth Treharne PhD & Stephan Milosavljevic PhD a Rehabilitation Teaching and Research Unit, Department of Medicine, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand b Centre for Health, Activity and Rehabilitation Research, School of Physiotherapy, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand c Department of Psychology, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand d School of Physical Therapy, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada Published online: 09 Jun 2014.