M. van der Schaar

The Red of a Rose; on the Significance of Stout's Category of Abstract Particulars

In this paper I argue for the thesis that Stout’s category of abstract particulars (what Husserl calls “moments’) has played a role in the transition from Bradleian idealism to British analytic philosophy. That category plays this role as part of a new theory of wholes, parts and relations that Stout develops in opposition to Bradley. In Stout’s theory abstract particulars are dependent parts of wholes. The critical remarks that G.E. Moore and Kevin Mulligan have made concerning Stout’s identification of abstract particulars and predicates are elaborated in this paper. Notwithstanding the fact that Stout mistakenly identifies abstract particulars with predicates, the category of abstract particulars may be of value in a theory of individuals, universals and truth-makers.