Marc Geldhof

Characterization of antigenic regions in the porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus by the use of peptide-specific serum antibodies

The porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is an RNA virus that causes reproductive failure in sows and boars, and respiratory disease in pigs of all ages. Antibodies against several viral envelope proteins are produced upon infection, and the glycoproteins GP4 and GP5 are known targets for virus neutralization. Still, substantial evidence points to the presence of more, yet unidentified neutralizing antibody targets in the PRRSV envelope proteins. The current study aimed to identify and characterize linear antigenic regions (ARs) within the entire set of envelope proteins of the European prototype PRRSV strain Lelystad virus (LV). Seventeen LV-specific antisera were tested in pepscan analysis on GP2, E, GP3, GP4, GP5 and M, resulting in the identification of twenty-one ARs that are capable of inducing antibodies upon infection in pigs. A considerable number of these ARs correspond to previously described epitopes in different European- and North-American-type PRRSV strains. Remarkably, the largest number of ARs was found in GP3, and two ARs in the GP3 ectodomain consistently induced antibodies in a majority of infected pigs. In contrast, all remaining ARs, except for a highly immunogenic epitope in GP4, were only recognized by one or a few infected animals. Sensitivity to antibody-mediated neutralization was tested for a selected number of ARs by in vitro virus-neutralization tests on alveolar macrophages with peptide-purified antibodies. In addition to the known neutralizing epitope in GP4, two ARs in GP2 and one in GP3 turned out to be targets for virus-neutralizing antibodies. No virus-neutralizing antibody targets were found in E, GP5 or M. Since the neutralizing AR in GP3 induced antibodies in a majority of infected pigs, the immunogenicity of this AR was studied more extensively, and it was demonstrated that the corresponding region in GP3 of virus strains other than LV also induces virus-neutralizing antibodies. This study provides new insights into PRRSV antigenicity, and contributes to the knowledge on protective immunity and immune evasion strategies of the virus.

Development of an experimental inactivated PRRSV vaccine that induces virus-neutralizing antibodies

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) can induce reproductive disorders and is involved in the porcine respiratory disease complex, causing tremendous economic losses to the swine industry. Inactivated PRRSV vaccines are preferred over attenuated vaccines because of their safety and flexibility towards emerging virus strains, but the efficacy of current inactivated PRRSV vaccines is questionable. In this study, experimental inactivated PRRSV vaccines were developed, based on two formerly optimized inactivation procedures: UV irradiation and treatment with binary ethylenimine (BEI). In a first experiment, it was shown that vaccination with UV- or BEI-inactivated virus in combination with Incomplete Freunds Adjuvant induced virus-specific antibodies and strongly primed the virus-neutralizing (VN) antibody response. Subsequently, the influence of adjuvants on the immunogenicity of neutralizing epitopes on the inactivated virus was investigated. It was shown that vaccination with BEI-inactivated virus in combination with a commercial oil-in-water adjuvant induced high titers (3.4 log(2)) of VN antibodies in 6/6 pigs, instead of only priming the neutralizing antibody response. After challenge, neutralizing antibody titers in these vaccinated animals rose to a mean value of 5.5 log(2), and the duration of the viremia was reduced to an average of 1 week. This study shows that, by the use of an optimized inactivation procedure and a suitable adjuvant, inactivated PRRSV vaccines can be developed that induce VN antibodies and offer partial protection upon challenge.

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) causes apoptosis during its replication in fetal implantation sites

Reproductive failure due to porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is characterized by late-term abortions, early farrowing and an increase of dead and mummified fetuses and weak-born piglets. The mechanism of PRRSV-induced reproductive failure is poorly understood. Human pregnancies, complicated by some pathogens leading to reproductive disorders exhibit increased apoptosis in the fetal membranes. Because PRRSV-target cells are present in endometrium/fetal placentas from healthy sows and PRRSV-infected macrophages in other organs die by apoptosis, we hypothesized that PRRSV can replicate and induce apoptosis in the fetal implantation sites at the last stage of gestation. In the present study, identification, localization and quantification of the PRRSV-positive and apoptotic cells were performed in the fetal implantation sites. Three dams were inoculated intranasally with 10(5) TCID(50) PRRSV 07V063 at 90 days of gestation and sampled at 10 days post-inoculation. Two non-inoculated dams that were euthanized at 100 days of gestation served as control animals. Inoculation of the dams resulted in a viremia that lasted until the end of the study. Transplacental PRRSV spread was detected in all inoculated dams. Using immunofluorescence staining, single PRRSV-positive cells were found in the endometrial connective tissues adjacent to both PRRSV-positive and PRRSV-negative fetuses. In the fetal placental mesenchyme of the PRRSV-positive fetuses, infected cells were more abundant and spread focally. Double staining showed that all PRRSV-positive cells in the fetal implantation sites were positive for sialoadhesin and CD163. Apoptotic cells (TUNEL+) were detected in endometrium and fetal placentas of both non- and PRRSV-inoculated dams. The number of apoptotic cells was significantly higher in PRRSV-positive endometrium/fetal placentas. PRRSV caused apoptosis in infected cells since 20-61% of PRRSV-positive cells were apoptotic and in surrounding cells since 43-91% of the apoptotic cells were virus-negative. The main conclusion obtained from the present study is that PRRSV replicates in the fetal implantation sites and causes apoptosis in infected macrophages and surrounding cells at the last stage of gestation. The possible mode of PRRSV replication in the fetal implantation sites and the events that might contribute to the reproductive disorders are discussed.

A Variable Region in GP4 of European-Type Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus Induces Neutralizing Antibodies Against Homologous But Not Heterologous Virus Strains

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) can induce severe reproductive failure in sows, and is involved in the porcine respiratory disease complex. The glycoprotein GP4 of the European prototype PRRSV strain Lelystad virus (LV) contains a linear neutralizing epitope that is located in a highly variable region. The current study aimed to evaluate the antibody response against this and other epitopes on GP4 to infection of pigs with European-type PRRSV. It was shown that three virus strains, differing in the region that corresponds to the neutralizing epitope on GP4 of LV, strongly induce antibodies against this area. Antibodies against the epitopes of the different virus strains were purified from polyclonal swine sera, and used in virus-neutralization tests on primary alveolar macrophages. This revealed that antibodies against the variable region in GP4 of different virus strains are able to neutralize infection with homologous but not heterologous virus strains.

GP4-specific neutralizing antibodies might be a driving force in PRRSV evolution

The structural envelope glycoprotein GP4 of European porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) strains contains a highly variable neutralizing epitope that is susceptible to neutralizing antibody-mediated selective pressure in vitro. In this study, it was analyzed what happens with this neutralizing epitope during infection in vivo in the presence of neutralizing antibodies. A neutralizing antibody-mediated selective pressure was created in 30 pigs by vaccination prior to inoculation with infectious Lelystad virus (LV). Nine viable neutralizing antibody-escape variants were isolated from 9 of these pigs and their neutralizing antibody-escape mutant-identity was confirmed by the acquired resistance to neutralization by autologous neutralizing sera. Six out of 9 neutralizing antibody-escape variants contained aa substitutions in the GP4 neutralizing epitope and had become resistant to neutralization by a monoclonal antibody (mAb) against this epitope. In addition, in all 6 corresponding pigs, antibodies against this epitope were detected early in infection. In contrast to these 6 virus variants, the 3 other antibody-escape variants did not contain aa substitutions in the GP4 neutralizing epitope and were still sensitive to neutralization by the GP4-specific mAb. These antibody-escape variants were isolated from pigs that did not contain antibodies against this epitope early in infection. All these findings together strongly indicate that aa substitutions in the GP4 neutralizing epitope can abrogate antibody recognition, and that neutralizing antibodies might be responsible for the selection of neutralizing antibody-resistant variants with aa substitutions in the neutralizing epitope on GP4. In conclusion, this study indicates that neutralizing antibodies in pigs might be a driving force in the rapid evolution of the neutralizing epitope on GP4 of European PRRSV strains.

Comparison of the efficacy of autogenous inactivated Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus (PRRSV) vaccines with that of commercial vaccines against homologous and heterologous challenges

BackgroundThe porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is a rapidly evolving pathogen of swine. At present, there is a high demand for safe and more effective vaccines that can be adapted regularly to emerging virus variants. A recent study showed that, by the use of a controlled inactivation procedure, an experimental BEI-inactivated PRRSV vaccine can be developed that offers partial protection against homologous challenge with the prototype strain LV. At present, it is however not known if this vaccine can be adapted to currently circulating virus variants. In this study, two recent PRRSV field isolates (07 V063 and 08 V194) were used for BEI-inactivated vaccine production. The main objective of this study was to assess the efficacy of these experimental BEI-inactivated vaccines against homologous and heterologous challenge and to compare it with an experimental LV-based BEI-inactivated vaccine and commercial inactivated and attenuated vaccines. In addition, the induction of challenge virus-specific (neutralizing) antibodies by the different vaccines was assessed.ResultsIn a first experiment (challenge with 07 V063), vaccination with the experimental homologous (07 V063) inactivated vaccine shortened the viremic phase upon challenge with approximately 2 weeks compared to the mock-vaccinated control group. Vaccination with the commercial attenuated vaccines reduced the duration of viremia with approximately one week compared to the mock-vaccinated control group. In contrast, the experimental heterologous (LV) inactivated vaccine and the commercial inactivated vaccine did not influence viremia. Interestingly, both the homologous and the heterologous experimental inactivated vaccine induced 07 V063-specific neutralizing antibodies upon vaccination, while the commercial inactivated and attenuated vaccines failed to do so.In the second experiment (challenge with 08 V194), use of the experimental homologous (08 V194) inactivated vaccine shortened viremia upon challenge with approximately 3 weeks compared to the mock-vaccinated control group. Similar results were obtained with the commercial attenuated vaccine. The experimental heterologous (07 V063 and LV) inactivated vaccines did not significantly alter viremia. In this experiment, 08 V194-specific neutralizing antibodies were induced by the experimental homologous and heterologous inactivated vaccines and a faster appearance post challenge was observed with the commercial attenuated vaccine.ConclusionsThe experimental homologous inactivated vaccines significantly shortened viremia upon challenge. Despite the concerns regarding the efficacy of the commercial attenuated vaccines used on the farms where the field isolates were obtained, use of commercial attenuated vaccines clearly shortened the viremic phase upon challenge. In contrast, the experimental heterologous inactivated vaccines and the commercial inactivated vaccine had no or only a limited influence on viremia. The observation that homologous BEI-inactivated vaccines can provide a more or less standardized, predictable degree of protection against a specific virus variant suggests that such vaccines may prove useful in case virus variants emerge that escape the immunity induced by the attenuated vaccines.

Impact of a novel inactivated PRRS virus vaccine on virus replication and virus-induced pathology in fetal implantation sites and fetuses upon challenge

Preventing congenital infection is important for the control of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome (PRRS). Recently, in our laboratory, an inactivated porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) vaccine has been developed. Promising results in young pigs encouraged us to test the vaccine potency to prevent congenital infection. In the present study, the performance of this experimental inactivated vaccine was investigated in pregnant gilts. An advanced protocol was used to test the PRRSV vaccine efficacy. This protocol is based on recent insights in the pathogenesis of congenital PRRSV infections. Three gilts were vaccinated with an experimental PRRSV 07V63 inactivated vaccine at 27, 55, and 83 days of gestation. Three unvaccinated gilts were included as controls. At 90 days of gestation, all animals were intranasally inoculated with 10(5) tissue culture infectious dose 50 (TCID(50)) of PRRSV 07V63. Twenty days postchallenge animals were euthanized and sampled. The vaccinated gilts quickly developed virus neutralizing (VN) antibodies starting from 3 to 7 days postchallenge (1.0 to 5.0 log2). In contrast, the unvaccinated gilts remained negative for VN antibodies after challenge. The vaccinated gilts had shorter viremia than the control gilts. Gross pathology (mummification) was observed in 8% of the fetuses from vaccinated gilts and in 15% of the fetuses from unvaccinated gilts. The number of fetuses with severe microscopic lesions in the fetal implantation sites (a focal detachment of the trophoblast from the uterine epithelium; a focal, multifocal, or full degeneration of the fetal placenta) was lower in the vaccinated (19%) versus unvaccinated (45%) gilts (P < 0.05). The number of PRRS-positive cells in the fetal placentae was higher in unvaccinated versus vaccinated gilts (P < 0.05). In contrast, the number of PRRS-positive cells in the myometrium/endometrium was higher in vaccinated versus unvaccinated gilts (P < 0.05). Fifty-seven percent of the fetuses from the vaccinated gilts and 75% of the fetuses from the unvaccinated gilts were PRRSV-positive. In conclusion, implementation of the novel experimental inactivated PRRSV vaccine primed the VN antibody response and slightly reduced the duration of viremia in gilts. It also reduced the number of virus-positive fetuses and improved the fetal survival, but was not able to fully prevent congenital PRRSV infection. The reduction of fetal infection and pathology is most probably attributable to the vaccine-mediated decrease of PRRSV transfer from the endometrium to the fetal placenta.

Antibody response and maternal immunity upon boosting PRRSV-immune sows with experimental farm-specific and commercial PRRSV vaccines

The porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) causes reproductive failure in sows and respiratory disease in pigs of all ages. Despite the frequent use of vaccines to maintain PRRSV immunity in sows, little is known on how the currently used vaccines affect the immunity against currently circulating and genetically divergent PRRSV variants in PRRSV-immune sows, i.e. sows that have a pre-existing PRRSV-specific immunity due to previous infection with or vaccination against the virus. Therefore, this study aimed to assess the capacity of commercially available attenuated/inactivated PRRSV vaccines and autogenous inactivated PRRSV vaccines - prepared according to a previously optimized in-house protocol - to boost the antibody immunity against currently circulating PRRSV variants in PRRSV-immune sows. PRRSV isolates were obtained from 3 different swine herds experiencing PRRSV-related problems, despite regular vaccination of gilts and sows against the virus. In a first part of the study, the PRRSV-specific antibody response upon booster vaccination with commercial PRRSV vaccines and inactivated farm-specific PRRSV vaccines was evaluated in PRRSV-immune, non-pregnant replacement sows from the 3 herds. A boost in virus-neutralizing antibodies against the farm-specific isolate was observed in all sow groups vaccinated with the corresponding farm-specific inactivated vaccines. Use of the commercial attenuated EU type vaccine boosted neutralizing antibodies against the farm-specific isolate in sows derived from 2 farms, while use of the commercial attenuated NA type vaccine did not boost farm-specific virus-neutralizing antibodies in any of the sow groups. Interestingly, the commercial inactivated EU type vaccine boosted farm-specific virus-neutralizing antibodies in sows from 1 farm. In the second part of the study, a field trial was performed at one of the farms to evaluate the booster effect of an inactivated farm-specific vaccine and a commercial attenuated EU-type vaccine in immune sows at 60 days of gestation. The impact of this vaccination on maternal immunity and on the PRRSV infection pattern in piglets during their first weeks of life was evaluated. Upon vaccination with the farm-specific inactivated vaccine, a significant increase in farm-specific virus-neutralizing antibodies was detected in all sows. Virus-neutralizing antibodies were also transferred to the piglets via colostrum and were detectable in the serum of these animals until 5 weeks after parturition. In contrast, not all sows vaccinated with the commercial attenuated vaccine showed an increase in farm-specific virus-neutralizing antibodies and the piglets of this group generally had lower virus-neutralizing antibody titers. Interestingly, the number of viremic animals (i.e. animals that have infectious virus in their bloodstream) was significantly lower among piglets of both vaccinated groups than among piglets of mock-vaccinated sows and this at least until 9 weeks after parturition. The results of this study indicate that inactivated farm-specific PRRSV vaccines and commercial attenuated vaccines can be useful tools to boost PRRSV-specific (humoral) immunity in sows and reduce viremia in weaned piglets.

Pathologic and virologic findings in mid-gestational porcine foetuses after experimental inoculation with PCV2a or PCV2b.

Two major genotypes of porcine circovirus type 2 (PCV2) have been described: PCV2a and PCV2b. Previous studies mainly used PCV2a to experimentally reproduce reproductive failure in sows. This study aims to determine the clinical and virological outcome of surgical inoculation of 55-day-old immuno-incompetent porcine foetuses with PCV2a or PCV2b. Twelve foetuses were inoculated with PCV2: three with the post-weaning multisystemic wasting syndrome (PMWS)-associated PCV2a strain Stoon-1010, three with the reproductive failure-associated PCV2a strain 1121, three with the PMWS-associated PCV2b strain 48285 and three with the porcine dermatitis and nephropathy syndrome-associated PCV2b strain 1147. Four foetuses were mock-inoculated with cell culture medium. At 21 days post-inoculation eleven out of twelve PCV2-inoculated foetuses were oedematous and had distended abdomens, whereas one had a normal external appearance. All PCV2-inoculated foetuses had haemorrhages and congestion in internal organs and an enlarged liver. High PCV2 titres (>10(4.5)TCID(50)/g tissue) were found in all PCV2-inoculated foetuses, especially in the heart, spleen and liver. High numbers of PCV2-infected cells (>1000 infected cells/10mm(2) tissue) were observed in the hearts. PCR and DNA sequencing of the capsid gene recovered pure PCV2a and pure PCV2b sequences from PCV2a- and PCV2b-inoculated foetuses, respectively. All mock-inoculated and the remaining foetuses were normal in appearance and were PCV2 negative in virus titrations and indirect immunofluorescence stainings. The present study shows that PCV2a and PCV2b induce similar gross pathological lesions and replicate to similar high titres in organs of 55-day-old immuno-incompetent porcine foetuses.

Micro‐Dissecting the Pathogenesis and Immune Response of PRRSV Infection Paves the Way for More Efficient PRRSV Vaccines

Porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV) is the most important infectious pathogen in pigs worldwide nowadays. Due to its genetic drift and increasing power to escape from immunity, PRRSV becomes more and more difficult to control. Based on a better knowledge of PRRSV, its interaction with the host cell, the macrophage, its pathogenesis and the immunity against this virus, new vaccines can now be constructed. This research-based development of new generation vaccines will allow swine industry to face the devastating consequences of PRRSV infections in the future. The present review summarizes the present knowledge on the pathogenesis, the immune response and the research-based vaccine development.