Marco Pelizzone

Acoustic to Electric Pitch Comparisons in Cochlear Implant Subjects with Residual Hearing

The aim of this study was to assess the frequency–position function resulting from electric stimulation of electrodes in cochlear implant subjects with significant residual hearing in their nonimplanted ear. Six cochlear implant users compared the pitch of the auditory sensation produced by stimulation of an intracochlear electrode to the pitch of acoustic pure tones presented to their contralateral nonimplanted ear. Subjects were implanted with different Clarion® electrode arrays, designed to lie close to the inner wall of the cochlea. High-resolution radiographs were used to determine the electrode positions in the cochlea. Four out of six subjects presented electrode insertions deeper than 450°. We used a two-interval (one acoustic, one electric), two-alternative forced choice protocol (2I-2AFC), asking the subject to indicate which stimulus sounded the highest in pitch. Pure tones were used as acoustic stimuli. Electric stimuli consisted of trains of biphasic pulses presented at relatively high rates [higher than 700 pulses per second (pps)]. First, all electric stimuli were balanced in loudness across electrodes. Second, acoustic pure tones, chosen to approximate roughly the pitch sensation produced by each electrode, were balanced in loudness to electric stimuli. When electrode insertion lengths were used to describe electrode positions, the pitch sensations produced by electric stimulation were found to be more than two octaves lower than predicted by Greenwoods frequency–position function. When insertion angles were used to describe electrode positions, the pitch sensations were found about one octave lower than the frequency–position function of a normal ear. The difference found between both descriptions is because of the fact that these electrode arrays were designed to lie close to the modiolus. As a consequence, the site of excitation produced at the level of the organ of Corti corresponds to a longer length than the electrode insertion length, which is used in Greenwoods function. Although exact measurements of the round window position as well as the length of the cochlea could explain the remaining one octave difference found when insertion angles were used, physiological phenomena (e.g., stimulation of the spiral ganglion cells) could also create this difference. From these data, analysis filters could be determined in sound coding strategies to match the pitch percepts elicited by electrode stimulation. This step might be of main importance for music perception and for the fitting of bilateral cochlear implants.

Low-pass filtering in amplitude modulation detection associated with vowel and consonant identification in subjects with cochlear implants

Temporal auditory analysis of acoustic events in various frequency channels is influenced by the ability to detect amplitude modulations which for normal hearing involves low-pass filtering with a cutoff frequency around 100 Hz and a rejection slope of about 10 dB per decade. These characteristics were established in previous studies measuring modulation transfer functions. For cochlear implant subjects, the delivery of detailed amplitude modulation information has been recently shown to result in very significant improvements in speech understanding. Several previous studies on cochlear implant subjects have reported capacities for temporal resolution rather equivalent to those of normally hearing subjects but with some notable individual differences. Recently two studies on some cochlear implant subjects indicated modulation transfer functions often quite similar to those of normal hearing but exhibiting marked individual differences in shape and absolute sensitivity. The present study compared amplitude modulation detection and phonetic recognition in a group of cochlear implant subjects to determine the extent to which the two tasks are correlated. Nine individuals who had been implanted with an Ineraid device and who demonstrated open speech understanding ranging from excellent to poor were chosen and tested in the present study. For each subject modulation transfer functions were measured at the most apical electrode and phonetic recognition of isolated vowels and intervocalic consonants was assessed. Results showed a strong correlation between the depth of high-frequency rejection in modulation transfer functions and success in vowel and consonant intelligibility. These results emphasize the importance of temporal speech features and offer perspectives for customizing signal processing in cochlear implants.

Adaptation to Steady-State Electrical Stimulation of the Vestibular System in Humans

Objectives: Efforts are being made toward the development of a vestibular implant. If such a device is to mimic the physiology of the vestibular system, it must first be capable of restoring a baseline or “rest” activity in the vestibular pathways and then modulating it according to the direction and velocity of head movements. The aim of this study was to assess whether a human subject could adapt to continuous electrical stimulation of the vestibular system, and whether it was possible to elicit artificial smooth oscillatory eye movements via modulation of the stimulation. Methods: One bilaterally deaf patient with bilateral vestibular loss received a custom-modified Med-E1 cochlear implant in which one electrode was implanted in the vicinity of the left posterior ampullary nerve. This electrode was activated with biphasic pulse trains of 400-μs phase duration delivered at a repetition rate of 200 pulses per second. The resulting eye movements were recorded with 2-dimensional binocular video-oculography. Results: Successive “on-off” cycles of continuous electrical stimulation resulted in a progressively shorter duration of the nystagmic response. Once the adapted state was reached upon constant stimulation, amplitude or frequency modulations of electrical stimulation produced smooth oscillatory conjugated eye movements. Conclusions: Although this is a case study of one patient, the results suggest that humans can adapt to electrical stimulation of the vestibular system without too much discomfort. Once the subject is in the adapted state, the electrical stimulation can be modulated to artificially elicit smooth eye movements. Therefore, the major prerequisites for the feasibility of a vestibular implant for human use are fulfilled.

Forward masking in different cochlear implant systems

The goal of this study was to evaluate, from a psychophysical standpoint, the neural spread of excitation produced by the stimulation of different types of intracochlear electrode arrays: the Ineraid, the Clarion S-Series on its own or with the Electrode Positioning System (EPS), and the Clarion HiFocus-I with the EPS. The EPS is an independent silicone part designed to bring the electrode array close to the modiolus. Forward masking was evaluated in 12 adult subjects (3 Ineraid, 4 Clarion S-Series, 3 Clarion S-Series+EPS, 3 HiFocus-I+EPS) by psychophysical experiments conducted using trains of biphasic stimuli (813 pulses per second, 307.6 micros/phase). Masker signals (+8 dB re: threshold, 300 ms) were applied to the most apical electrode. Probe signals (30 ms, 10-ms postmasker) were delivered to more basal electrodes. Masked and unmasked detection thresholds of probe signals were measured. For both Clarion HiFocus-I subjects, measurements were conducted in both monopolar and bipolar stimulus configurations. No major differences were found in forward masking between the different intracochlear electrode arrays tested in the monopolar configuration at suprathreshold levels equivalent to those used in speech-coding strategies, but significant differences were found between subjects. A significant negative correlation also was found between the level of forward masking and the consonant identification performance. These measurements showed that the neural spread of excitation was more restricted in the bipolar configuration than in the monopolar configuration for HiFocus-I subjects. It was found that CIS strategies implemented without using apical electrodes, which showed high levels of masking, could improve consonant identification.

Eye movements in response to electrical stimulation of the lateral and superior ampullary nerves.

Objectives: Recently, we demonstrated that it was possible to elicit vertical eye movements in response to electrical stimulation of the posterior ampullary nerve. In order to develop a vestibular implant, a second site of stimulation is required to encode the horizontal movements. Methods: Three patients with disabling Menieres disease were included in the study. Before a labyrinthectomy via a standard transcanal approach was performed, their lateral and anterior ampullary nerves were surgically exposed under local anesthesia through a procedure we recently developed. The attic was opened, the incus and malleus head were removed, and a small well was drilled above the horizontal portion of the facial nerve canal to place an electrode. This electrode was used to deliver balanced biphasic trains of electrical pulses. Results: The electrical stimuli elicited mainly horizontal nystagmus without simultaneous stimulation of the facial nerve. Conclusions: It is possible to stimulate electrically the lateral and superior ampullary nerves without simultaneous stimulation of the facial nerve. Because the nerves run close to each other, electrical stimulation provoked eye movements that were not purely horizontal, but also had some vertical components. Nevertheless, this site can be used to encode horizontal movements, because central adaptation may correct unnatural afferent vestibular cues delivered by a prosthetic sensor. The range of stimulus intensities that produced a response was broad enough for us to envision the possibility of encoding eye movements of various speeds.

Channel interactions with high-rate biphasic electrical stimulation in cochlear implant subjects

Channel interactions were assessed using high-rate stimulation in cochlear implant subjects using the Ineraid electrode array. Stimulation currents were applied on one intracochlear electrode and their effects on psychophysical detection thresholds on an adjacent electrode were measured. Stimuli were trains of brief, biphasic, 50-micros/phase pulses presented at a rate of 2000 pulses per second per channel. In experiment I, we studied how the detection of a probe signal was influenced by a sub-threshold perturbation signal presented either simultaneously or non-simultaneously (with no overlap) on an adjacent electrode. Results showed that simultaneous activation led to strong channel interactions, producing threshold changes consistent with instantaneous electric field summation. Non-simultaneous activation revealed much weaker interactions, producing threshold changes of opposite sign. In experiment II, we studied how the temporal delay between perturbation and probe pulses, as well as how the level of the perturbation signal influenced non-simultaneous channel interactions. First, threshold changes when reversing the polarity of the perturbation did progressively vanish when increasing the delay between pulses. This suggested that non-overlapping stimulation of adjacent electrodes produced channel interactions that were in part due to residual polarization of the nerve membrane. Second, increasing the perturbation to supra-threshold levels produced threshold elevations that were independent of the interpulse interval. This suggested channel interactions due to neural masking. These results provide insights into the different concurrently active mechanisms of channel interactions in cochlear implant systems using this type of stimuli.

Temporal Properties of Visual Perception on Electrical Stimulation of the Retina

PURPOSE To investigate the elementary temporal properties of electrically evoked percepts in blind patients chronically implanted with an epiretinal prosthesis. METHODS Nine subjects were presented with isolated stimuli of variable duration and pulse rate. Stimulation amplitude was set to the upper comfortable level and a group of 2 × 2 adjacent electrodes was simultaneously activated. First, subjects were asked to verbally describe their visual perception paying particular attention to the time-course of brightness. Then, in subsequent trials, they described the brightness time dependence using a joystick while auditory feedback of joystick position was provided. RESULTS All subjects described a bright, well-localized percept at stimulus onset. Only one subject reported such a bright, well-localized visual sensation during an entire 10-second stimulation trial. For the remaining eight subjects, it faded more or less rapidly (in four cases <0.5 second) and was often followed by a percept described as less bright, poorly localized, and having different color. Only initial percepts at stimulation onset seemed bright and localized enough to reconstruct a patterned image. Changing stimulation pulse rate influenced the time course of perception only in some cases but the effect was not systematic. CONCLUSIONS Percepts differed considerably across subjects, probably because of the considerable variations in the progression and remodeling processes associated with the disease. Appropriate coding of a patterned image under such conditions appears challenging. Further research of the underlying mechanisms of visual perception upon electrical stimulation of the retina is required to optimize stimulation paradigms and to better establish patient selection criteria.

Artificial balance: restoration of the vestibulo-ocular reflex in humans with a prototype vestibular neuroprosthesis

The vestibular system plays a crucial role in the multisensory control of balance. When vestibular function is lost, essential tasks such as postural control, gaze stabilization, and spatial orientation are limited and the quality of life of patients is significantly impaired. Currently, there is no effective treatment for bilateral vestibular deficits. Research efforts both in animals and humans during the last decade set a solid background to the concept of using electrical stimulation to restore vestibular function. Still, the potential clinical benefit of a vestibular neuroprosthesis has to be demonstrated to pave the way for a translation into clinical trials. An important parameter for the assessment of vestibular function is the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR), the primary mechanism responsible for maintaining the perception of a stable visual environment while moving. Here we show that the VOR can be artificially restored in humans using motion-controlled, amplitude modulated electrical stimulation of the ampullary branches of the vestibular nerve. Three patients received a vestibular neuroprosthesis prototype, consisting of a modified cochlear implant providing vestibular electrodes. Significantly higher VOR responses were observed when the prototype was turned ON. Furthermore, VOR responses increased significantly as the intensity of the stimulation increased, reaching on average 79% of those measured in healthy volunteers in the same experimental conditions. These results constitute a fundamental milestone and allow us to envision for the first time clinically useful rehabilitation of patients with bilateral vestibular loss.

Within-patient longitudinal speech reception measures with continuous interleaved sampling processors for Ineraid implanted subjects

OBJECTIVE To assess within-subject changes in speech reception over time in a group of Ineraid subjects fitted with continuous interleaved sampling (CIS) wearable processors fabricated in Geneva. To compare asymptotic performance between CIS and Ineraid processors for the same subjects. DESIGN Twelve patients, all users of the 4-channel Ineraid cochlear implant system for several years and with no previous experience of CIS processors in daily life, were equipped with Geneva Wearable Processors programmed to implement a high-rate CIS sound processing strategy using four to six channels. Their speech reception performance with CIS processors was monitored over a period of 1 yr with consonant and vowel identification tests. For comparison, speech reception performance also was measured with Ineraid processors before switching to CIS and after 6 mo of non-use of Ineraid processors. RESULTS At fitting, CIS processors produced significantly better consonant identification but no better vowel identification. Subsequently, consonant and vowel scores with CIS processors improved progressively to asymptote after 6 mo of daily use. At 6 mo and beyond, performance with CIS processors was significantly superior to that obtained with Ineraid processors on both consonant and vowel identification tests. Control tests made with Ineraid processors after 6 mo of non-use of the device yielded results that were indistinguishable from those obtained before the study. CONCLUSIONS The full potential of the CIS strategy is not revealed at fitting. Accumulation of daily experience provides significant improvements, asymptotic performance being reached after about 4 to 6 mo of use. All Ineraid users might greatly benefit from CIS processors.

Electrically Evoked Responses in Cochlear Implant Patients

Highly reproducible recordings of evoked responses elicited by electrical stimulation of the auditory nerve were obtained in a group of 4 totally deaf patients implanted with a multichannel intracochlear prosthesis. They were compared to auditory evoked responses obtained in a normal-hearing subject tested with the same equipment. The most striking observation drawn from these data is certainly the close resemblance, at all latencies, between evoked responses elicited by electrical stimulation and those elicited by acoustic stimulation. The remarkable correspondence of waveform morphology, waveform amplitude and interpeak latencies provides indirect evidence that the same sequence of events is triggered in the central auditory system in both cases. Those aspects of the responses which differ significantly are easily interpreted by the physical and physiological properties of the different types of stimulation.