Maria E. Ryan

Tetracyclines Inhibit Connective Tissue Breakdown by Multiple Non-Antimicrobial Mechanisms

A seminal experiment involving a germ-free rat model of connective tissue breakdown (followed soon thereafter by a series of in vitro studies) identified an unexpected non-antimicrobial property of tetracyclines (TCs). This ability of TCs to inhibit matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) such as collagenase was found to reflect multiple direct and indirect mechanisms of action, and to be therapeutically useful in a variety of dental (e.g., adult periodontitis) and medical (e.g., arthritis, osteoporosis, cancer) diseases. The site on the TC molecule responsible for its MMP-inhibitory activity was identified which led to the development of a series of chemically modified non-antimicrobial analogs, called CMTs, which also have therapeutic potential but do not appear to induce antibiotic side-effects. Longitudinal double-blind studies on humans with adult periodontitis have demonstrated that a sub-antimicrobial dose of doxycycline (previously reported to suppress collagenase activity in the periodontal pocket) is safe and effective and has recently been approved by the FDA as an adjunct to scaling and root planing.

Potential of tetracyclines to modify cartilage breakdown in osteoarthritis.

For several decades, it has been recognized that an imbalance between activated matrix metalloproteinases, generated locally by both infiltrating and resident cells, and their endogenous inhibitors may play a role in the pathologic breakdown of the joint extracellular matrix in osteoarthritis. This understanding has stimulated the search for a number of synthetic matrix metalloproteinase inhibitors that could serve as potential therapeutic agents. Tetracycline analogues are currently on the threshold of approval as anti-matrix metalloproteinases for another extracellular matrix-destructive disease, periodontitis, and this application could be extended to osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis therapy. In this regard, specially formulated low-dose regimens of a commercially available tetracycline, doxycycline, have been used in long-term clinical trials and were found to reduce extracellular matrix breakdown, including bone loss, in adult periodontitis. Matrix metalloproteinase inhibition by tetracycline analogues is now recognized as complex, and multiple mechanisms have been proposed. A series of recently discovered nonantimicrobial chemically modified tetracyclines are potent inhibitors of several classes of matrix metalloproteinases, preventing collagen breakdown and bone loss in a variety of animal models, although these analogues have not yet been approved for human use. Various tetracyclines have reduced the severity of osteoarthritis in animal models, indicating therapeutic potential for this class of compounds in the future.

Excessive matrix metalloproteinase activity in diabetes : Inhibition by tetracycline analogues with zinc reactivity

Diabetes mellitus in rats is characterized by excessive activity of several matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), notably collagenase(s) and gelatinase(s), in skin, gingiva, and other tissues. A number of tetracyclines (TCs), both antimicrobial compounds as well as chemically modified non-antimicrobial TC analogues (CMTs) are known to possess potent inhibitory activity against these enzymes. Three conventional antimicrobial TCs and six CMTs were used in this study. In vitro, doxycycline was shown to possess higher inhibitory capacity (i.e. lower IC(max)) against diabetic rat skin collagenase than either minocycline or tetracycline HCl. Addition of excess zinc partially reversed the proteinase inhibition by TCs. In vivo, using rats made diabetic with streptozotocin (STZ), oral administration of various TCs led to decreased weight loss and substantial reductions in the activity of both skin collagenase and skin gelatinase (primarily MMP-9, 92 kDa) without affecting blood glucose. Using an in vitro spectrophotometric technique, the Zn(++) reactivity of several CMTs was assessed and found to be positively related to the potency of these compounds as MMP inhibitors. One particular CMT (CMT-5, pyrazole analogue), which is neither antimicrobial nor capable of binding metal cations, did not inhibit the MMPs. TCs have potential utility in management of diabetic complications mediated by excessive activity of MMPs.

MMP‐Mediated Events in Diabetes

ABSTRACT: Both Type I and Type II diabetes mellitus (DM) have been associated with unusually aggressive periodontitis. Accordingly, rat models of both types of DM were used to study (i) mechanisms mediating this systemic/local interaction and (ii) new pharmacologic approaches involving a series of chemically modified tetracyclines (CMTs) that have lost their antimicrobial but retained their host‐modulating (e.g., MMP‐inhibitory) properties. In vitro experiments on tissues from Type I DM rats demonstrated that several of these CMTs were better matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) inhibitors than was anti‐bacterial doxycycline (doxy), except for CMT‐5, which, unlike the other MMP inhibitors, was found not to react with zinc. Data from in vivo studies on the same rat model generally supported the relative efficacy of these compounds: the CMTs and doxy were found to inhibit MMP activity, enzyme expression, and alveolar bone loss. To examine other long‐term complications such as nephropathy and retinopathy, a Type II (ZDF) model of DM was studied. Treatment of these DM rats with CMT‐8 produced a 37% (p < 0.05), 93% (p < 0.001), and 50% (p < 0.01) reduction in the incidence of cataract development, proteinuria, and tooth loss, respectively; whereas the doxy‐treated ZDF rats showed little or no effect on these parameters. CMT treatment decreased mortality of the Type II ZDF diabetic animals, clearly indicating that CMTs, but not commercially available antibiotic tetracyclines (TCs), may have therapeutic applications for the long‐term management of diabetes.

Clinical studies on the management of periodontal diseases utilizing subantimicrobial dose doxycycline (SDD).

Periodontitis, the most common chronic inflammatory condition known to mankind, is a disease that results in the destruction of tooth supporting tissues. Periodontitis is initiated by a bacterial biofilm on the tooth surface below the gingival margin. Until fairly recently it was assumed that the bacteria were the primary cause of tissue destruction, however, a large body of research has revealed that it is the patients immune response that is actually responsible for the majority of the breakdown of tooth supporting tissues. Contemporary thinking suggests that successful, long term management of chronic periodontitis may combine both local mechanical and antimicrobial strategies to reduce the microbial bio-burden along with modulation of the host, patients excessive, immuno-inflammatory response to the bacterial exposure known as host modulatory therapy (HMT). Based on extensive literature documenting the enzymatic inhibition and related anti-inflammatory properties of the tetracyclines, a new drug was developed as a host modulatory agent and approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for use as an adjunct to conventional scaling and root planing for the treatment of chronic periodontitis. A subantimicrobial dose of doxycycline (SDD) at 20 mg (Periostat(®)) has been found to be a safe and effective adjunct when taken twice daily for at least 3 months and up to 24 months in randomized placebo controlled clinical trials. Periostat(®) is currently the only FDA approved inhibitor of the matrix metalloproteinases implicated in the plaque-induced pathologic degradation of connective tissue collagen of the periodontal supporting structures. This review paper begins with a brief description of the disease process known as periodontitis followed by an extensive review of the Phase I-IV clinical trial data that established the safety and efficacy of sub-antimicrobial dose doxycycline (SDD) as an adjunct to scaling and root planing for the treatment of periodontitis.

A chemically modified nonantimicrobial tetracycline (CMT-8) inhibits gingival matrix metalloproteinases, periodontal breakdown, and extra-oral bone loss in ovariectomized rats.

ABSTRACT: Estrogen deficiency in the postmenopausal (PM) female is the major cause of osteoporosis and may contribute to increased periodontal disease, including alveolar bone loss, seen in these women. In the current study, an animal model of PM osteoporosis, the OVX adult female rat, was studied to determine: (i) the relationship between periodontal breakdown and skeletal bone loss, and (ii) the effect of CMT‐8 on gingival collagenase and bone loss. OVX rats were daily gavaged with CMT‐8 (1, 2, or 5 mg/rat) for 28 or 90 days; non‐OVX rats and those gavaged with vehicle alone served as controls. Elevated collagenase activity, assessed using [3H‐methyl] collagen as substrate in the presence or absence of APMA, was seen in the gingiva of the OVX rats, and CMT‐8 therapy suppressed this effect. Western blot revealed a similar pattern for MMP‐8 and MMP‐13 concentrations. The changes in the gingival collagenase activity paralleled changes in periodontal bone loss, which, in turn, reflected trabecular bone density changes. Preliminary studies on PM humans administered sub‐antimicrobial tetracycline as a matrix metalloproteinase inhibitor are under way.

Non-antibacterial tetracycline formulations: clinical applications in dentistry and medicine

In 1983, it was first reported that tetracyclines (TCs) can modulate the host response, including (but not limited to) inhibition of pathologic matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) activity, and by mechanisms unrelated to the antibacterial properties of these drugs. Soon thereafter, strategies were developed to generate non-antibacterial formulations (subantimicrobial-dose doxycycline; SDD) and compositions (chemically modified tetracyclines; CMTs) of TCs as host-modulating drugs to treat periodontal and other inflammatory diseases. This review focuses on the history and rationale for the development of: (a) SDD which led to two government-approved medications, one for periodontitis and the other for acne/rosacea and (b) CMTs, which led to the identification of the active site of the drugs responsible for MMP inhibition and to studies demonstrating evidence of efficacy of the most potent of these, CMT-3, as an anti-angiogenesis agent in patients with the cancer, Kaposis sarcoma, and as a potential treatment for a fatal lung disease (acute respiratory distress syndrome; ARDS). In addition, this review discusses a number of clinical studies, some up to 2 years’ duration, demonstrating evidence of safety and efficacy of SDD formulations in humans with oral inflammatory diseases (periodontitis, pemphigoid) as well as medical diseases, including rheumatoid arthritis, post-menopausal osteopenia, type II diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and a rare and fatal lung disease, lymphangioleiomyomatosis.

How do Tetracyclines Work

This paper is a summary of a panel discussion by the following panelists: L. Golub, J. te Koppele, G. Nieman, M. Nelson, R. Ashley, T. Sorsa, and S. Simon. The panel discussed the mechanisms by which the tetracyclines and their non-antimicrobial counterparts may provide therapeutic efficacy in a variety of chronic and acute diseases.

Non-antibacterial tetracyclines modulate mediators of periodontitis and atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease: A mechanistic link between local and systemic inflammation

Periodontitis, one of the most common chronic inflammatory diseases afflicting man, is increasingly being recognized as a risk factor for atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD). Non-antimicrobial tetracyclines are known to have inhibitory effects on inflammatory mediators and effector molecules, including cytokines and matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), associated with both diseases. In this paper, we discuss the evidence that doxycycline and related non-antibiotic chemically modified tetracyclines (e.g., CMT-3) can effectively reduce cytokine (TNF-α, IL-6, and MCP-1) production by human mononuclear inflammatory cells when stimulated either by endotoxin (LPS) or by a complex of C-reactive protein/oxidized LDL cholesterol relevant to the pathogenesis of periodontal disease and ASCVD, respectively. This inhibition by tetracycline compounds appears to be mediated at least in part by a suppression of the phosphorylation/activation of the NFκB cell signaling pathway. We are currently conducting clinical trials on patients who exhibit both diseases, and our preliminary data suggest that virtually all acute coronary syndrome (ACS) patients exhibit moderate-to-severe periodontitis, a higher incidence of this oral inflammatory disease than that seen in the population at large. In other studies, a non-antimicrobial formulation of doxycycline (SDD) has been found to dramatically reduce hsCRP, IL-6 and MMP-9 levels in plasma of ACS patients, and SDD has also been found to significantly increase serum levels of both cardio-protective HDL cholesterol and its core molecule apolipoprotein A-I in ASCVD-vulnerable patients with periodontitis. Our current research suggests that one mechanism involved may be the ability of SDD to inhibit MMP-mediated HDL loss by protecting apolipoprotein A-I from proteinase attack. These pleiotropic mechanisms of non-antimicrobial tetracyclines provide significant therapeutic potential to treat chronic inflammatory diseases including both periodontitis and ASCVD.

Tetracyclines inhibit protein glycation in experimental diabetes.

Glycation of proteins, which is accelerated in the diabetic state, has been implicated in many of the long-term complications of diabetes. This process can be inhibited by members of the tetracycline family of compounds. This novel finding is supported by studies conducted on drug (streptozotocin)induced Type I and genetic (ZDF/Gmi-fa/fa) Type II diabetic rats. These animals were orally gavaged daily with 5 mg of doxycycline and a variety of non-antimicrobial chemically modified tetracycline derivatives for time periods of 3 weeks to 11 months, while control untreated diabetic and nondiabetic animals were gavaged with vehicle alone (2% CMC). Blood and tissue samples were collected and analyzed for glucose and glycated proteins. None of the treatments had any effect on the severity of hyperglycemia or the intracellular glycation of hemoglobin of either Type I or II diabetic animals. However, the tetracycline analogues did affect the extracellular glycation of several proteins such as those found in the serum as well as skin collagen. In the Type II (ZDF) animals, initial mortality (3-5 months) was seen only in the doxycycline-treated animals, associated with infection by tetracycline-resistant micro-organisms, which was eventually surpassed by mortality rates in the untreated diabetics (6-9 months). CMT treatment not only decreased mortality but also increased longevity in the Type II diabetic animals, most likely by preventing the development of a number of long-term complications of uncontrolled diabetes, including glycation of proteins, that eventually lead to the demise of untreated diabetic animals.