Mario Quevedo

Intrapopulation niche partitioning in a generalist predator limits food web connectivity

Predators are increasingly recognized as key elements in food webs because of their ability to link the fluxes of nutrients and energy between spatially separated food chains. However, in the context of food web connectivity, predator populations have been mainly treated as homogeneous units, despite compelling evidence of individual specialization in resource use. It is conceivable that individuals of a predatory species use different resources associated with spatially separated food chains, thereby decoupling cross-habitat linkages. We tested whether intrapopulation differences in habitat use in the generalist freshwater predator Eurasian perch (Perca fluviatilis) led to long-term niche partitioning and affected the degree of ecological habitat coupling. We evaluated trophic niche variability at successively larger timescales by analyzing gut contents and stable isotopes (delta13C and delta15N) in liver and muscle, tissues that provide successively longer integration of trophic activity. We found that the use of distinct habitats in perch led to intrapopulation niche partitioning between pelagic and littoral subpopulations, consistent through the various timescales. Pelagic fish showed a narrower niche, lower individual specialization, and more stable trophic behavior than littoral fish, as could be expected from inhabiting a relatively less diverse environment. This result indicated that substantial niche reduction could occur in a generalist predator at the subpopulation level, consistent with the use of a habitat that provides fewer chances of individual specialization. We showed that intrapopulation niche partitioning limits the ability of individual predators to link spatially separated food chains. In addition, we suggest a quantitative, standardized approach based on stable isotopes to measure the degree of habitat coupling mediated by a top predator.

Evidence of heavy predation by Noctiluca scintillans on Acartia clausi (Copepoda) eggs off the central Cantabrian coast (NW Spain)

A large proliferation of Noctiluca scintillans (Dinophyceae: Noctilucidea) was observed in neritic waters off the central Cantabrian coast during late April 1995. Eggs of Acartia clausi (Crustacea: Copepoda) were the most conspicuous prey within vacuoles of Noctiluca. Noctiluca ingested 73 % of the total stock of A. clausi eggs. This intense predation on copepod eggs could potentially affect the recruitment of nauplii. The potential impact on the stock of Acartia clausi eggs and on the daily egg production of the population is discussed. There is a negative correlation between the average number of ingested eggs by a single Noctiluca cell and the abundance of Noctiluca. This fact, coupled with the lack of significant correlation between the former variable and the abundance of Acartia clausi eggs, suggests that interference processes play a major role in regulating the predator-prey interaction between Noctiluca and Acartia eggs.

Habitat selection by Cantabrian capercaillie Tetrao urogallus cantabricus at the edge of the species' distribution

Abstract We studied the patterns of habitat availability and use by the Cantabrian capercaillie Tetrao urogallus cantabricus, an isolated and endangered population at the southwestern edge of the species distribution. We combined field surveys and GIS analyses to show that this population differs from its conifer-specialist conspecifics in that it inhabits beech Fagus sylvatica and oak Quercus petraea forests, without specialisation as regards the tree species as long as enough forest cover remains. The habitat of Cantabrian capercaillie is highly fragmented, and smaller forest patches have been abandoned during the last few decades; the display areas that remain occupied are now located farther from forest edges. Lower tree density and more widespread distribution of bilberry Vaccinium myrtillus characterised the occupied display grounds. However, even abandoned areas showed tree densities well within the optimum range for capercaillie and bilberry in other populations, a result that should be taken into account before any habitat management action is considered. We found that some non-forested habitats were also used by capercaillie, especially during the autumn and winter. We suggest that the protection of Cantabrian capercaillie should be tightly coupled with an effective, strict protection of the few remaining large forest fragments in the range, and that information about nesting and brood rearing habitat should be obtained. Conditions for understory development should be favoured, preventing overgrazing by ungulates. The natural, non-forested matrix should also be considered in management plans, as a direct source of food and shelter and an important feature determining connectivity among patches.

Conflict Misleads Large Carnivore Management and Conservation: Brown Bears and Wolves in Spain.

Large carnivores inhabiting human-dominated landscapes often interact with people and their properties, leading to conflict scenarios that can mislead carnivore management and, ultimately, jeopardize conservation. In northwest Spain, brown bears Ursus arctos are strictly protected, whereas sympatric wolves Canis lupus are subject to lethal control. We explored ecological, economic and societal components of conflict scenarios involving large carnivores and damages to human properties. We analyzed the relation between complaints of depredations by bears and wolves on beehives and livestock, respectively, and bear and wolf abundance, livestock heads, number of culled wolves, amount of paid compensations, and media coverage. We also evaluated the efficiency of wolf culling to reduce depredations on livestock. Bear damages to beehives correlated positively to the number of female bears with cubs of the year. Complaints of wolf predation on livestock were unrelated to livestock numbers; instead, they correlated positively to the number of wild ungulates harvested during the previous season, the number of wolf packs, and to wolves culled during the previous season. Compensations for wolf complaints were fivefold higher than for bears, but media coverage of wolf damages was thirtyfold higher. Media coverage of wolf damages was unrelated to the actual costs of wolf damages, but the amount of news correlated positively to wolf culling. However, wolf culling was followed by an increase in compensated damages. Our results show that culling of the wolf population failed in its goal of reducing damages, and suggest that management decisions are at least partly mediated by press coverage. We suggest that our results provide insight to similar scenarios, where several species of large carnivores share the landscape with humans, and management may be reactive to perceived conflicts.

Diet and habitat selection in Cantabrian Capercaillie (Tetrao urogallus cantabricus): ecological differentiation of a rear-edge population

Cantabrian capercaillie Tetrao urogallus cantabricus is a peripheral population with distinctive phenotypic, biogeographic, and genetic characteristics. Hence, the population may also show substantial ecological differentiation associated with its habitat in purely deciduous forests. We assessed seasonal diet selection, small-scale habitat selection, and patterns of trophic niche width in Cantabrian capercaillie over two years. Diet was found to be a driver of small-scale habitat selection, a result consistent with previous studies of stand-scale habitat selection. Diet and habitat selection showed the importance of beech Fagus sylvatica, holly Ilex aquifolium, bilberry Vaccinium myrtillus, and ferns in Cantabrian capercaillie’s resource selection. Conversely, the abundant oaks Quercus petraea, birches Betula pubescens, and heaths Erica sp. were used below their availability. The reliance on bilberry appears as a unifying characteristic between central and peripheral capercaillie populations. Cantabrian capercaillie showed stronger reliance on understory resources than range-central populations. It also showed wider trophic niche and higher specialization of feeding events. Trophic niche patterns and reliance on ground resources indicated a marked ecological differentiation, which stresses the need for local data and specific conservation actions.

Demographic status and genetic tagging of endangered capercaillie in NW Spain.

Counting rare and elusive animals and evaluating their demographic status, are fundamental yet challenging aspects of population ecology and conservation biology. We set out to estimate population size (Nc), genetic effective population size (Ne gen), sex ratio, and movements based on genetic tagging for the threatened Cantabrian capercaillie. We used 9 microsatellite loci to genotype 134 droppings collected at 34 display areas during the breeding season. Using genetic capture-mark-recapture, we estimated 93 individuals (Nc, 95% CI: 70–116) in an area of about 500 km2, with sex ratio biased towards males (1∶1.6). Estimated Ne gen (35.5) was 38% of Nc, notably higher than the published average in wild populations. This capercaillie population is small and well within concern in terms of population viability. By genetic tagging, we detected mostly short movements; just a few males were recaptured between contiguous display areas. Non-invasive surveys of endangered populations have a great potential, yet adequate sample size and location are key to obtain reliable information on conservation status.

Habitat partitioning and molting site fidelity in Tetrao urogallus cantabricus revealed through stable isotopes analysis

AbstractSexual dimorphism is often associated with different feeding strategies between sexes because of distinct nutritional demands or intake rates. Capercaillie (Tetrao urogallus) is the most sexually dimorphic grouse, thus sexual segregation in resource use is likely. This study assessed intrapopulation variation in the diet related to habitat use, focusing on differential feeding behaviors between Capercaillie females and males. We used stable isotopes analyses in feathers of Cantabrian Capercaillie, a population living at the southern edge of the range in purely deciduous forests. We analyzed feathers of females and males, and sorted them according to the dominant tree species in the patch where they were found. Mean isotopic values differed both between sexes and among forest types. The latter explained most of the isotopic variance, suggesting that birds consistently selected certain forest types to molt. Capercaillie females showed wider trophic niche and seemingly more intra-gender diversity in resource use than males. The differences between sexes in the trophic variability support the sexual segregation reported in previous studies which is associated with females using the more micro-habitat diverse treeline areas, while males mainly use the inner areas of the forests. Stable isotope analysis proved very useful to assess intersexual niche partitioning in rare species living in rugged terrains where it is logistically difficult to rely on direct approaches (i.e. direct observation, capture and radio-tracking).ZusammenfassungAnalyse stabiler Isotope belegt Habitataufteilung und Mauserplatztreue beiTetrao urogallus cantabricus Ein Geschlechtsdimorphismus geht aufgrund von Unterschieden im Nahrungsbedarf oder den Aufnahmeraten häufig mit unterschiedlichen Nahrungsstrategien der Geschlechter einher. Unter den Raufußhühnern weist das Auerhuhn (Tetrao urogallus) den stärksten Geschlechtsdimorphismus auf, was eine geschlechtsspezifische Ressourcennutzung wahrscheinlich macht. Diese Arbeit behandelt die Variation in der Nahrungszusammensetzung innerhalb einer Population im Zusammenhang mit der Habitatnutzung und setzt dabei den Schwerpunkt auf das unterschiedliche Nahrungsverhalten von Auerhähnen und –hennen. Dazu wurden stabile Isotope in Federn des Kantabrischen Auerhuhns untersucht, einer Population, die reine Nadelwälder am Südrand des Verbreitungsgebietes bewohnt. Federn von Männchen und Weibchen wurden analysiert und anhand der am Fundort vorherrschenden Baumart gruppiert. Die mittleren Isotopenwerte unterschieden sich sowohl zwischen den Geschlechtern als auch zwischen den Waldtypen. Letzteres erklärte den Hauptteil der Isotopenvarianz, was darauf hindeutet, dass die Vögel zur Mauser gezielt bestimmte Waldtypen aufsuchen. Auerhennen nutzten eine breitere Nahrungsnische und zeigten offenbar eine stärkere innergeschlechtliche Variation in der Ressourcennutzung als die Hähne. Diese Geschlechtsunterschiede im Nahrungsspektrum bestätigen die aus früheren Studien bekannte Geschlechtertrennung, die damit zusammenhängt, dass die Weibchen die an Mikrohabitaten reichere Baumgrenzenzone nutzen, während die Männchen hauptsächlich die inneren Waldbereiche aufsuchen. Die Analyse stabiler Isotope erwies sich als gut geeignet für die Untersuchung der geschlechtsspezifischen Einnischung seltener Arten in unwegsamem Gelände, wo direkte Ansätze (z. B. Sichtbeobachtung, Fang und Radiotelemetrie) Problemen verbunden sind.

Effects of Sexual Dimorphism and Landscape Composition on the Trophic Behavior of Greater Prairie-Chicken

Partitioning of ecological niche is expected in lekking species that show marked sexual size dimorphism as a consequence of sex-specific ecological constraints. However, niche partitioning is uncertain in species with moderate sexual dimorphism. In addition, the ecological niche of a species may also be affected by landscape composition; particularly, agricultural fragmentation may greatly influence the trophic behavior of herbivores. We studied trophic niche variation in Greater Prairie-Chickens (Tympanuchus cupido), a grouse species that shows moderate sex-dimorphism. Greater Prairie-Chickens are native to tallgrass prairies of North America, although populations persist in less natural mosaics of cropland and native habitats. We used stable isotope analysis of carbon and nitrogen in blood, claws and feathers to assess seasonal differences in trophic niche breadth and individual specialization between male and female Greater Prairie-Chickens, and between birds living in continuous and fragmented landscapes. We found that females showed broader niches and higher individual specialization than males, especially in winter and autumn. However, differences between females and males were smaller in spring when birds converge at leks, suggesting that females and males may exhibit similar feeding behaviors during the lekking period. In addition, we found that birds living in native prairies showed greater annual trophic variability than conspecifics in agricultural mosaic landscapes. Native habitats may provide greater dietary diversity, resulting in greater diversity of feeding strategies.

Gut length plasticity in perch: into the bowels of resource polymorphisms: GUT LENGTH PLASTICITY IN PERCH

Recent research has suggested that individual specialization within populations could be substantial and more common than previously acknowledged. Eurasian perch is one of many species of fish in lakes of postglacial origin that displays a morphological and dietary variation tightly coupled to the littoral and pelagic habitats of the lake. The occurrence of such resource polymorphisms might have important consequences for local adaptation and might also be an important initial step in speciation. I have investigated the importance of a number of factors for the development of resource polymorphisms using perch as a study organism. I found a weak genetic basis for morphological differences, and the environmental influence on morphology was of such a magnitude that an induced morphology could be reversed. The results nevertheless suggested that genetic differentiation could be substantial at small spatial and temporal scales, even within habitats. Several environmental factors were shown to influence the morphological development, and the results also suggest that behavioral differences could mediate a morphological response. I also found evidence for that competition-driven divergence might only occur when divergence in resource use is favoured at the same time as growth rates are kept sufficiently high for character divergence to be effective. The results finally indicate that divergence in the gut length of individuals might co-vary with habitat and diet use in resource polymorphic populations. This might enhance habitat fidelity and possibly also facilitate the persistence of resource polymorphisms since individuals should experience a cost of switching diets due to a too specific digestive system. Based on these findings I conclude that small scaled genetic differentiation might be more common than currently acknowledged, that more multi-factorial studies are needed if we are to fully understand the mechanisms behind trait diversity, and that competition not always favors divergence.

Gut length plasticity in Eurasian perch : Into the bowels of resource polymorphisms

Recent research has suggested that individual specialization within populations could be substantial and more common than previously acknowledged. Eurasian perch is one of many species of fish in lakes of postglacial origin that displays a morphological and dietary variation tightly coupled to the littoral and pelagic habitats of the lake. The occurrence of such resource polymorphisms might have important consequences for local adaptation and might also be an important initial step in speciation. I have investigated the importance of a number of factors for the development of resource polymorphisms using perch as a study organism. I found a weak genetic basis for morphological differences, and the environmental influence on morphology was of such a magnitude that an induced morphology could be reversed. The results nevertheless suggested that genetic differentiation could be substantial at small spatial and temporal scales, even within habitats. Several environmental factors were shown to influence the morphological development, and the results also suggest that behavioral differences could mediate a morphological response. I also found evidence for that competition-driven divergence might only occur when divergence in resource use is favoured at the same time as growth rates are kept sufficiently high for character divergence to be effective. The results finally indicate that divergence in the gut length of individuals might co-vary with habitat and diet use in resource polymorphic populations. This might enhance habitat fidelity and possibly also facilitate the persistence of resource polymorphisms since individuals should experience a cost of switching diets due to a too specific digestive system. Based on these findings I conclude that small scaled genetic differentiation might be more common than currently acknowledged, that more multi-factorial studies are needed if we are to fully understand the mechanisms behind trait diversity, and that competition not always favors divergence.