Mariya Moosajee

Translational bypass of nonsense mutations in zebrafish rep1, pax2.1 and lamb1 highlights a viable therapeutic option for untreatable genetic eye disease.

The extensive molecular genetic heterogeneity seen with inherited eye disease is a major barrier to the development of gene-based therapeutics. The underlying molecular pathology in a considerable proportion of these diseases however are nonsense mutations leading to premature termination codons. A therapeutic intervention targeted at this abnormality would therefore potentially be relevant to a wide range of inherited eye diseases. We have taken advantage of the ability of aminoglycoside drugs to suppress such nonsense mutations and partially restore full-length, functional protein in a zebrafish model of choroideraemia (chm(ru848); juvenile chorio-retinal degeneration) and in two models of ocular coloboma (noi(tu29a) and gup(m189); congenital optic fissure closure defects). In vitro cell-based assays showed significant readthrough with two drugs, gentamicin and paromomycin, which was confirmed by western blot and in vitro prenylation assays. The presence of either aminoglycoside during zebrafish development in vivo showed remarkable prevention of mutant ocular phenotypes in each model and a reduction in multisystemic defects leading to a 1.5-1.7-fold increase in survival. We also identified a significant reduction in abnormal cell death shown by TUNEL assay. To test the hypothesis that optic fissure closure was apoptosis-dependent, the anti-apoptotic agents, curcumin and zVAD-fmk, were tested in gup(m189) embryos. Both drugs were found to reduce the size of the coloboma, providing molecular evidence that cell death is required for optic fissure remodelling. These findings draw attention to the value of zebrafish models of eye disease as useful preclinical drug screening tools in studies to identify molecular mechanisms amenable to therapeutic intervention.

Systemic aminoglycoside treatment in rodent models of retinitis pigmentosa.

We studied the potential of systemically administered aminoglycosides as a therapy for retinal degeneration resulting from premature termination codon (PTC) mutations. Aminoglycosides were systemically delivered to two rodent models of retinal degeneration: a transgenic rat model of dominant disease caused by a PTC in rhodopsin (S334ter); and a mouse model of recessive disease (rd12) caused by a PTC in the retinoid isomerase Rpe65. Initial luciferase reporter assays were undertaken to measure the efficiency of gentamicin-induced read-through in vitro. These experiments indicated that gentamicin treatment induced on average a 5.3% extra read-through of the S334ter PTC in vitro, but did not affect the rd12 PTC. Beginning at postnatal day 5, animals received daily subcutaneous injections of gentamicin or geneticin at a range of doses. The effect of the treatment on retinal degeneration was examined by histopathology and electroretinography (ERG). Systemic treatment with aminoglycoside significantly increased the number of surviving photoreceptors in the S334ter rat model over several weeks of treatment, but was not effective in slowing the retinal degeneration in the rd12 mouse model. Similarly, ERG recordings indicated better preservation of retinal function in the treated S334ter rats, but no difference was observed in the rd12 mice. Daily subcutaneous injection of 12.5mug/g gentamicin was the only regimen that inhibited retinal degeneration without apparent adverse systemic side effects. Reduced effectiveness beyond postnatal day 50 correlated with reduced ocular penetration of drug as seen in gentamicin-Texas red (GTTR) conjugation experiments. We conclude that, in the rat model, an approximately 5% reduction of abnormal truncated protein is sufficient to enhance photoreceptor survival. Such a change in truncated protein is consistent with beneficial effects seen when aminoglycosides has been used in other, non-ocular animal models. In the rd12 mouse, lack of efficacy was seen despite this particular PTC being theoretically more sensitive to aminoglycoside modification. We conclude that aminoglycoside read-through of PTCs in vitro and in vivo cannot be predicted just from genomic context. Because there is considerable genetic heterogeneity amongst retinal degenerations, pharmacologic therapies that are not gene-specific have significant appeal. Our findings suggest that if adverse issues such as systemic toxicity and limited ocular penetration can be overcome, small molecule therapeutics, such as aminoglycosides, which target classes of mutation could hold considerable potential as therapies for retinal disease.

Single choroideremia gene in nonmammalian vertebrates explains early embryonic lethality of the zebrafish model of choroideremia.

PURPOSE Mutations of the CHM gene underlie the X-linked chorioretinal degeneration choroideremia (CHM). The affected gene product, Rab Escort Protein (REP)1, mediates the posttranslational prenyl modification of Rab GTPases. In patients with CHM, the related REP2 partially compensates for the loss of function of REP1. The objective of this investigation was to study the natural history of disease in a zebrafish model of CHM. METHODS Zebrafish chm(-/-) were bred and subjected to extensive histologic analysis and TUNEL assays, and cellular extracts were used for immunoblot and in vitro prenylation assays. A detailed evolutionary analysis was performed on the REP family. RESULTS The retina of chm(-/-) zebrafish develops normally for the first 4 days postfertilization (dpf) but that catastrophic multilayer degeneration synchronous with severe multisystem disease follows. Mean survival time is 4.8 dpf. At the onset of generalized disease, a significant reduction in rep expression levels and activity, with unprenylated rabs accumulating in the cytosol was demonstrated. Extensive bioinformatic analysis of the REP family of proteins revealed a single rep isoform in fish and other nonmammalian vertebrates and invertebrates that is similar to mammalian REP1. CONCLUSIONS REP1 appears to be the ancestral gene in the family, whereas the intronless REP2 gene is restricted to the mammalian lineage. The results of this study propose that in chm(-/-) zebrafish, maternally derived rep allows initial successful development of the embryo, but its gradual loss leads to multisystem disease and invariably to lethality. In its current form, the chm(-/-) zebrafish has limited usefulness.

Pax2 regulates a fadd-dependent molecular switch that drives tissue fusion during eye development

Tissue fusion is an essential morphogenetic mechanism in development, playing a fundamental role in developing neural tube, palate and the optic fissure. Disruption of genes associated with the tissue fusion can lead to congenital malformations, such as spina bifida, cleft lip/palate and ocular coloboma. For instance, the Pax2 transcription factor is required for optic fissure closure, although the mechanism of Pax2 action leading to tissue fusion remains elusive. This lack of information defining how transcription factors drive tissue morphogenesis at the cellular level is hampering new treatments options. Through loss- and gain-of-function analysis, we now establish that pax2 in combination with vax2 directly regulate the fas-associated death domain (fadd) gene. In the presence of fadd, cell proliferation is restricted in the developing eye through a caspase-dependent pathway. However, the loss of fadd results in a proliferation defect and concomitant activation of the necroptosis pathway through RIP1/RIP3 activity, leading to an abnormal open fissure. Inhibition of RIP1 with the small molecule drug necrostatin-1 rescues the pax2 eye fusion defect, thereby overcoming the underlying genetic defect. Thus, fadd has an essential physiological function in protecting the developing optic fissure neuroepithelium from RIP3-dependent necroptosis. This study demonstrates the molecular hierarchies that regulate a cellular switch between proliferation and the apoptotic and necroptotic cell death pathways, which in combination drive tissue morphogenesis. Furthermore, our data suggest that future therapeutic strategies may be based on small molecule drugs that can bypass the gene defects causing common congenital tissue fusion defects.

Functional rescue of REP1 following treatment with PTC124 and novel derivative PTC-414 in human choroideremia fibroblasts and the nonsense-mediated zebrafish model

Choroideremia (CHM) is an X-linked chorioretinal dystrophy that is caused by mutations within a single gene, CHM Currently no effective treatment exists for these patients. Since over 30% of patients harbour nonsense mutations in CHM, nonsense suppression therapy using translational readthrough inducing drugs may provide functional rescue of REP1, thus attenuating progressive sight loss. Here, we employed two CHM model systems to systematically test the efficacy and safety of ataluren (PTC124) and its novel analog PTC-414: (1) the chmru848 zebrafish, the only nonsense mutation animal model of CHM harbouring a TAA nonsense mutation, and (2) a primary human fibroblast cell line from a CHM patient harbouring a TAG nonsense mutation. PTC124 or PTC-414 treatment of chmru848 embryos led to a ∼2.0-fold increase in survival, prevented the onset of retinal degeneration with reduced oxidative stress and apoptosis, increased rep1 protein by 23.1% (PTC124) and 17.2% (PTC-414) and restored biochemical function as confirmed through in vitro prenylation assays (98 ± 2% [PTC124] and 68 ± 5% [PTC-414]). In CHMY42X/y fibroblasts, there was a recovery of prenylation activity following treatment with either PTC124 (42 ± 5%) or PTC-414 (36 ± 11%), although an increase in REP1 protein was not detected in these cells, in contrast to the zebrafish model. This comprehensive study on the use of PTC124 and PTC-414 as successful nonsense suppression agents for the treatment of CHM highlights the translational potential of these drugs for inherited retinal disease.

Non-invasive anterior segment and posterior segment optical coherence tomography and phenotypic characterization of aniridia

OBJECTIVE To determine the value of optical coherence tomography (OCT) as a diagnostic tool in the critical evaluation of phenotypic variability seen in an aniridia family with a novel PAX6 mutation. DESIGN Genetic and observational family study. PARTICIPANTS Three-generation family segregating autosomal dominant aniridia. METHODS Ophthalmic examination included best-corrected visual acuity, slit-lamp biomicroscopy, direct and indirect ophthalmoscopy, tonometry, and OCT. PAX6 gene mutation analysis was carried out by direct sequencing of gene-specific PCR products and protein analysis by Western blot. RESULTS Intrafamilial variable expressivity was seen between 4 affected family members. Phenotype differences between twin children suggested that this was due to modifier gene effects rather than environment. Anterior segment OCT demonstrated a range of iridocorneal angle abnormalities and corneal thickening in only 3, but ciliary body hypoplasia in all 4 affected patients. Posterior segment OCT demonstrated dome-shaped, hypoplastic macular profiles in the 2 affected children. Novel outer retinal changes were also seen, suggestive of a phototoxic retinopathy not previously recognized in aniridia. Ocular disease segregated with a novel PAX6 Q178X nonsense mutation with Western blot analysis suggesting that this led to haploinsufficiency of PAX6 protein. CONCLUSIONS Non-contact OCT imaging allowed for a more detailed assessment of anterior and posterior segment disease in children and adults with aniridia plus nystagmus. This led to the identification of novel features and highlights a practical, non-contact strategy well suited to genotype/phenotype studies and the longitudinal management of aniridic glaucoma in children.

Clinical utility gene card for: choroideremia.

1. Name of the Disease (Synonyms): Choroideremia (Tapetochoroidal dystrophy) 2. OMIM# of the Disease: 303100 3. Name of the Analysed Genes or DNA/Chromosome Segments: CHM (formerly REP1, GGTA, RAB geranylgeranyl transferase component A or RAB GG transferase) 4. OMIM# of the Gene(s): 300390 Review of the analytical and clinical validity as well as of the clinical utility of DNA-based testing for mutations in the CHM gene in diagnostic, predictive and prenatal settings and for risk assessment in relatives.

The zebrafish eye-a paradigm for investigating human ocular genetics.

Although human epidemiological and genetic studies are essential to elucidate the aetiology of normal and aberrant ocular development, animal models have provided us with an understanding of the pathogenesis of multiple developmental ocular malformations. Zebrafish eye development displays in depth molecular complexity and stringent spatiotemporal regulation that incorporates developmental contributions of the surface ectoderm, neuroectoderm and head mesenchyme, similar to that seen in humans. For this reason, and due to its genetic tractability, external fertilisation, and early optical clarity, the zebrafish has become an invaluable vertebrate system to investigate human ocular development and disease. Recently, zebrafish have been at the leading edge of preclinical therapy development, with their amenability to genetic manipulation facilitating the generation of robust ocular disease models required for large-scale genetic and drug screening programmes. This review presents an overview of human and zebrafish ocular development, genetic methodologies employed for zebrafish mutagenesis, relevant models of ocular disease, and finally therapeutic approaches, which may have translational leads in the future.

Nonsyndromic Retinal Dystrophy due to Bi-Allelic Mutations in the Ciliary Transport Gene IFT140

PURPOSE Mutations in the ciliary transporter gene IFT140, usually associated with a severe syndromic ciliopathy, may also cause isolated retinal dystrophy. A series of patients with nonsyndromic retinitis pigmentosa (RP) due to IFT140 was investigated in this study. METHODS Five probands and available affected family members underwent detailed phenotyping including retinal imaging and electrophysiology. Whole exome sequencing was performed on two probands, a targeted sequencing panel of 176 retinal genes on a further two, and whole genome sequencing on the fifth. Missense mutations of IFT140 were further investigated in vitro using transient plasmid transfection of hTERT-RPE1 cells. RESULTS Eight affected patients from five families had preserved visual acuity until at least the second decade; all had normal development without skeletal manifestations or renal failure at age 13 to 67 years (mean, 42 years; median, 44.5 years). Bi-allelic mutations in IFT140 were identified in all families including two novel mutations: c.2815T > C (p.Ser939Pro) and c.1422_23insAA (p.Arg475Asnfs*14). Expression studies demonstrated a significantly reduced number of cells showing localization of mutant IFT140 with the basal body for two nonsyndromic mutations and two syndromic mutations compared with the wild type and a polymorphism. CONCLUSIONS This study highlights the phenotype of nonsyndromic RP due to mutations in IFT140 with milder retinal dystrophy than that associated with the syndromic disease.

Mechanism and evidence of nonsense suppression therapy for genetic eye disorders

Abstract Between 5 and 70% of genetic disease is caused by in‐frame nonsense mutations, which introduce a premature termination codon (PTC) within the disease‐causing gene. Consequently, during translation, non‐functional or gain‐of‐function truncated proteins of pathological significance, are formed. Approximately 50% of all inherited retinal disorders have been associated with PTCs, highlighting the importance of novel pharmacological or gene correction therapies in ocular disease. Pharmacological nonsense suppression of PTCs could delineate a therapeutic strategy that treats the mutation in a gene‐ and disease‐independent manner. This approach aims to suppress the fidelity of the ribosome during protein synthesis so that a near‐cognate aminoacyl‐tRNA, which shares two of the three nucleotides of the PTC, can be inserted into the peptide chain, allowing translation to continue, and a full‐length functional protein to be produced. Here we discuss the mechanisms and evidence of nonsense suppression agents, including the small molecule drug ataluren (or PTC124) and next generation ‘designer’ aminoglycosides, for the treatment of genetic eye disease. HighlightsMechanism of nonsense suppression therapy.Recent developments in pharmacological nonsense suppression.Evidence of nonsense suppression agents in ocular disease.Implications for the treatment of genetic eye disorders.