Mark F. Schray

Adjuvant radiation therapy after surgical resection of solitary brain metastasis: Association with pattern of failure and survival

We reviewed patients treated by resection of solitary cerebral metastasis at the Mayo Clinic from January 1, 1972, to December 1, 1982. Eighty-five patients rendered clinically disease-free and who received intramural follow-up after craniotomy were studied. Adjuvant whole-brain radiation therapy (WBRT) was delivered to 34, and 51 were observed after craniotomy. Pattern-of-failure analysis showed a much smaller incidence of subsequent brain relapse in the adjuvant WBRT group than in the observation group (21% versus 85%, respectively). Multivariate analysis utilizing 17 patient, tumor, and treatment characteristics showed adjuvant WBRT to have the strongest association with brain control (p less than 0.0001). The only other variable which was significant (p less than 0.01) was multilobe involvement of the metastatic lesion, which was associated with a greater likelihood of brain failure. Systemic failures were more frequent (61% versus 37%), and the proportion of patients remaining disease-free (29% versus 4%) was higher in the adjuvant group. Those patients who received adjuvant WBRT to a dose of 39 Gy or greater manifested an 11% rate of subsequent brain failure versus a 31% rate when less than 39 Gy was delivered. The median survival was longer for the adjuvant WBRT group (21 months versus 11.5 months). Multivariate analysis indicated that adjuvant WBRT was one of several variables (including female gender, long disease-free survival, and good neurologic function prior to craniotomy) significantly associated with improved survival. This study suggests that adjuvant cranial irradiation may help prevent clinical recurrence of resected metastatic intracranial disease and that improved control of intracranial disease may be associated with an improved survival in patients without clinical evidence of systemic disease at the time of craniotomy.

Solitary plasmacytoma of bone: mayo clinic experience

A review of 46 cases of solitary plasmacytoma of bone was undertaken in an attempt to better define the clinical features and prognostic indicators associated with this disease. Criteria for inclusion in the study included the following: (a) solitary lytic bone lesion on skeletal survey; (b) histologic confirmation of the lesion; and (c) bone marrow plasmacytosis of less than 10 percent. Patients with extramedullary plasmacytomas and osteosclerotic lesions were excluded. All patients were evaluated with serum and urine protein studies at the time of diagnosis. The median follow-up was 90 months with a minimum of 30 months. Fifty-four percent of the lesions involved the vertebral column. The thoracic spine was the single most commonly involved site (13/46 patients). The initial lesion was treated with radiotherapy in all but three patients in whom complete surgical resection was achieved. Total doses ranged from less than 20 Gy to 70 Gy with a median of 39.75 Gy. Overall, 54% developed multiple myeloma, 2% failed with new bone lesions without multiple myeloma, and 11% developed local recurrences. No patient receiving 45 Gy or more to the solitary lesion had a local failure. While the median time to progression was 18 months, 23% of the failures occurred after 60 months. The five local failures occurred at 7, 12, 18, 40, and 114 months. The overall survival was 74% at 5 years and 45% at 10 years. The 5- and 10-year disease-free survivals, however, were 43 and 25%, respectively. Evidence of abnormal serum and/or urine protein was found in 25 of 46 patients. Neither survival nor disease-free survival was significantly influenced by the presence of abnormal proteins even if they persisted after irradiation.

Identification of prognostic factors and risk groups in patients found to have nodal metastasis at the time of radical hysterectomy for early-stage squamous carcinoma of the cervix☆

In a retrospective study conducted at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, the University of Michigan, and the Mayo Clinic, 185 patients with previously untreated FIGO stage IB and IIA squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix were found to have nodal metastasis at the time of radical hysterectomy and pelvic lymphadenectomy. Of these patients, 103 received adjuvant pelvic irradiation. Cancer recurred in 76 patients; the median time to recurrence was 3.1 years. The prognostic significance of patient age, clinical stage, lesion diameter, number and location of nodal metastases, and use of adjuvant radiation therapy was determined by multivariate analysis. Only patient age (P = 0.0006), lesion diameter (P less than 0.0001), and number of nodal metastases (P = 0.0004) were noted to be significant factors in determining overall survival. Rates of recurrence were also related to these factors. Employment of these significant variables led to identification of four risk groups. In general, patients with small cervical lesions (diameter less than 1 cm) and no more than two nodes with metastases fell into the low-risk category; those patients with large cervical lesions (diameter greater than 4 cm) and more than two involved nodes fell into the high-risk category. All other patients were categorized into intermediate-risk groups. Ten-year survival was 92% in the low-risk group (n = 13), 70% in the low-intermediate-risk group (n = 66), 56% in the high-intermediate-risk group (n = 66), and 13% in the high-risk group (n = 20). This risk group classification identifies subgroups of early-stage cervical carcinoma patients found to have nodal metastasis at the time of radical hysterectomy that warrant appropriately selected adjuvant therapy.

Value of adjuvant whole-pelvis irradiation after Wertheim hysterectomy for early-stage squamous carcinoma of the cervix with pelvic nodal metastasis: A matched-control study☆

In a retrospective study, 185 patients with previously untreated stage IB or IIA (International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics) squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix were found to have pelvic nodal metastasis at the time of Wertheim hysterectomy and bilateral pelvic lymphadenectomy. Of these patients, 103 received adjuvant whole-pelvis irradiation and 82 received no adjuvant therapy. Median dose of pelvic irradiation was 5000 cGy. Among the irradiated patients, in 75% the dose was 5000 cGy or greater. Matching irradiated and nonirradiated patients according to stage, tumor size, and number and location of positive nodes yielded 60 pairs. Mean length of follow-up was 3.9 years for the 60 irradiated patients and 5.8 years for the non-irradiated patients. Kaplan-Meier overall and cancer-specific survival estimates for the two groups were not significantly different (P greater than 0.30). During the follow-up period, 21 surgery-only patients and 22 patients treated with adjuvant radiotherapy had recurrence, but adjuvant radiotherapy decreased the proportion of recurrences occurring in the pelvis alone--27% compared with 67% in the surgery-only group (P = 0.01).

Soft Tissue Sarcoma Integration of Brachytherapy, Resection, and External Irradiation

Between December 1981 and August 1988, 63 patients with clinically localized nonretroperitoneal soft tissue sarcomas underwent 65 brachytherapy procedures in conjunction with conservative resection with (61 tumors) or without (four tumors) external beam irradiation. Implant doses of 1500 to 2000 cGy were combined with 4500 to 5000 cGy of external irradiation. External irradiation was given preoperatively for larger lesions near bone or neurovascular structures, whereas it was used postoperatively for smaller, more resectable lesions or those that had previously been inadequately excised. There were 47 high‐grade tumors, 34 tumors > 5 cm, and nine patients with recurrent lesions (five with previous irradiation). With mean follow‐up of 20 months, conclusions on local control are tentative, but only two of 56 tumors (4%) with brachytherapy as part of initial management had recurred locally and three of nine recurrent tumors had re‐recurred locally. Only one of five local recurrences was within the implanted volume. Only two of 40 implantations (5%) performed at initial resection followed by postoperative external irradiation led to wound complications, whereas four of 16 implantations (25%) performed at resection after preoperative external irradiation were associated with wound problems. This technique does not increase local morbidity and may enhance local tumor control in comparison with either external radiation or brachytherapy alone as an adjuvant to conservative resection.

Adjuvant whole abdominopelvic irradiation for high risk endometrial carcinoma

Fifty-six patients with surgical Stage III or IV endometrial carcinoma, or earlier stage disease with two or more risk factors for peritoneal recurrence, were given postoperative whole abdomino-pelvic irradiation (WAPI) with nodal and vaginal boosts between November 1981 and May 1989. Mean age at diagnosis was 63 years. Twenty-seven patients were surgical Stage I-II, 17 Stage III, and 12 Stage IV. Thirty-seven (66%) had deep myometrial involvement, 34 (61%) had positive peritoneal cytology, 31 (55%) had high grade lesions, 20 (36%) had either serous-papillary or adenosquamous histologic variants, and 13 (23%) had up to 2 cm residual disease remaining after surgery. Mean overall follow-up was 45 months. The 7-year actuarial survival was 63.8% with a 7-year disease-free survival (DFS) of 60.9%. By surgical stage, the 7-year DSF was 77.1% for Stage I-II, 57.8% for Stage III, and 25.0% for Stage IV (p = 0.006). The 7-year DSF was 79.8% for those with lesions of Broders grade 1 or 2, and 46.9% for grades 3 or 4 (p = 0.001). Multivariate analysis demonstrated that of all covariates considered, only surgical stage and histologic grade had prognostic significance for survival and disease-free survival. Acute toxicity has been common but mild; chronic toxicity has been almost entirely subclinical with the exception of three cases of moderate to severe bowel toxicity. These results suggest that post-operative WAPI is a safe and efficacious treatment alternative for patients with surgical Stage I through III high-risk endometrial carcinoma.

Postoperative radiation therapy for epithelial ovarian cancer: the curative role based on a 24-year experience.

We updated 152 cases of epithelial ovarian cancer, International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) stages I through III, treated at the Stanford Medical Center (Stanford, Calif) with irradiation as the only postoperative therapy. In 133 patients, radiation was directed only to those regions of known disease, while it was delivered to the whole abdomen and pelvis by the Martinez technique in 19 patients. Mean follow-up time was 6.8 years. The results were analyzed as freedom from relapse (FFR) at 15 years; overall, FFR constituted 44% of the patients. Statistically significant differences of FFR appeared between stages II (60%) and III (16%); among the histopathologic variants endometrioid (64%), serous papillary (45%), and undifferentiated (7%); between pathologic grades 2 (68%) and 3 (20%); between amounts of postoperative residual disease less than 2 cm (48%) and greater than 2 cm (16%); and between ages less than 40 (80%) and greater than or equal to 40 (38%). Considering all stages and grades together, FFR in the 54 cases with unfavorable residuum (greater than 2 cm) was 14%. Among the 98 with favorable residuum (none, or less than 2 cm) FFR was 62%; and 14 (39%) of the 36 relapses were in the untreated upper abdomen. Results in the favorable group support effectiveness of irradiation as postoperative therapy. These patterns of relapse suggest that whole-abdominopelvic irradiation would further increase FFR. We believe that, for favorable disease as defined such radiotherapy should be the standard for comparison.

Management of malignant airway obstruction: Clinical and dosimetric considerations using an iridium-192 afterloading technique in conjunction with the neodymium-YAG laser

Fourteen patients with malignant airway obstruction have had 21 placements of a flexible nylon catheter for afterloading Iridium-192 using the flexible fiberoptic bronchoscope. Prescribed therapy was completed in 13 patients (18 courses). All patients had prior full-dose external irradiation, and no effective surgical or chemotherapeutic options remained. While many have had a trial of neodymium-YAG (yttrium-aluminum-garnet) laser therapy alone, eight patients received laser treatment one to three weeks prior to planned brachytherapy to provide immediate relief of symptoms and/or facilitate access and safe catheter placement. Most patients (64%) had recurrent squamous cell lung cancer. A dose of 3000 cGy is currently specified to 5 mm and 10 mm in the bronchus and trachea, respectively. Nine of the 13 treated patients have had follow-up bronchoscopy at approximately three months post-treatment with improvement documented in seven and progression in two patients. One patient was clinically improved without follow-up bronchoscopy, and three patients have had insufficient follow-up. A single patient treated with laser and 6000 rad at 5 mm developed a bronchoesophageal fistula. No other complication has been observed. The technique is simple and safe with the use of laser therapy when needed and appears to offer effective palliation in most patients even when standard therapy is exhausted.

Improved outcome at 10 years for serous-papillary/clear cell or high-risk endometrial cancer patients treated by adjuvant high-dose whole abdomino-pelvic irradiation

PURPOSE The aim of the study was to evaluate the 10-year treatment outcome of utilizing adjuvant high-dose whole abdominal irradiation (WAPI technique) with a pelvic/vaginal boost in patients with stage I-III endometrial carcinoma at high risk for intra-abdominopelvic recurrence, including serous-papillary and clear cell histologies. MATERIAL AND METHODS In a prospective nonrandomized trial, 132 patients were treated with adjuvant WAPI between November 1981 and October 2001. Forty-three patients (32%) were 1998 FIGO stage I-II and 89 (68%) were stage III. Pathological features included the following: 66 (52%) with deep myometrial invasion, 50 (38%) with positive peritoneal cytology, 89 (67%) with high-grade lesions, 25 (19%) with positive pelvic/para-aortic lymph nodes, and 58 (45%) with serous-papillary or clear cell histology. RESULTS The mean follow up was 6.4 years (range 0.6-16.1). For the entire group, the 5- and 10-year cause-specific survival (CSS) was 77 and 72%, whereas the disease-free survival (DFS) was 55 and 45%. When stratified by histology the 5- and 10-year CSS for adenocarcinoma was 75 and 70%, while serous-papillary/clear cell was 80 and 74% (P = 0.314). The 5- and 10-year DFS for adenocarcinoma was 59 and 49%, whereas serous-papillary/clear cell was 49 and 38% (P = 0.563). For surgical stages I-II, the 5-year CSS was 83% for adenocarcinoma and 89% for serous-papillary (P = 0.353). For stage III, it was 73 and 62% (P = 0.318), respectively. Forty-six patients (35%) relapsed. The first site of failure was the abdomen/pelvis in 27/46 (59%). When stratified by histologic variant, 34% of patients with adenocarcinoma and 41% with serous-papillary developed recurrent disease. In multivariate regression analysis only advancing age was of prognostic significance for CSS (P = 0.025) and DFS (P = 0.026). Chronic grade 3/4 GI toxicity was seen in 14%, and 2% of patients developed grade 3 renal toxicity. CONCLUSION High-dose adjuvant WAPI is very effective treatment with excellent 10-year results for stage I-III endometrial carcinoma with risk factors for intra-abdominopelvic recurrence, including serous-papillary or clear cell histology. The low long-term complication rate with high CSS makes high-dose WAPI the treatment of choice for these patients with significant comorbidities.

Evaluation of treatment and survival after positive second-look laparotomy☆

During the 9-year interval 1977 through 1985, of 250 patients undergoing second-look laparotomy, 116 (46%) were found to have clinically occult ovarian carcinoma. Salvage therapy consisted of external irradiation in 37, intraperitoneal 32P in 12, chemotherapy in 63, and no therapy in 3 or other therapy in 1. Eligible follow-up time ranged from 1 to 9 years. The Kaplan-Meier projected median time-to-progression and survival were 15 and 22.5 months, respectively, with 4-year progression-free and overall survival rates being 21 and 27%, respectively. Survival was independent of the original stage of disease but was significantly influenced by histologic grade and microscopic (55%) versus macroscopic (19%) residual tumor after the laparotomy. Projected 4-year salvage rates in patients with microscopic or residual disease less than or equal to 5 mm was 72, 39, and 19% for intraperitoneal 32P, external irradiation (33/37, whole abdominopelvic), and chemotherapy, respectively. However, multivariable analysis demonstrated that histologic grade and isotope therapy retained independent influence on survival, but no therapeutic advantage for external irradiation over chemotherapy was demonstrable. Furthermore, use of regimens that were identical to, partially altered from, or different from the first-trial agents did not affect chemotherapy salvage rates.