Mark G. J. Hartl

ITS-NANO - Prioritising nanosafety research to develop a stakeholder driven intelligent testing strategy

BackgroundTo assess the risk of all nanomaterials (NMs) on a case-by-case basis is challenging in terms of financial, ethical and time resources. Instead a more intelligent approach to knowledge gain and risk assessment is required.MethodsA framework of future research priorities was developed from the accorded opinion of experts covering all major stake holder groups (government, industry, academia, funders and NGOs). It recognises and stresses the major topics of physicochemical characterisation, exposure identification, hazard identification and modelling approaches as key components of the current and future risk assessment of NMs.ResultsThe framework for future research has been developed from the opinions of over 80 stakeholders, that describes the research priorities for effective development of an intelligent testing strategy (ITS) to allow risk evaluation of NMs. In this context, an ITS is a process that allows the risks of NMs to be assessed accurately, effectively and efficiently, thereby reducing the need to test NMs on a case-by-case basis.For each of the major topics of physicochemical characterisation, exposure identification, hazard identification and modelling, key-priority research areas are described via a series of stepping stones, or hexagon diagrams structured into a time perspective. Importantly, this framework is flexible, allowing individual stakeholders to identify where their own activities and expertise are positioned within the prioritisation pathway and furthermore to identify how they can effectively contribute and structure their work accordingly. In other words, the prioritisation hexagon diagrams provide a tool that individual stakeholders can adapt to meet their own particular needs and to deliver an ITS for NMs risk assessment. Such an approach would, over time, reduce the need for testing by increasing the reliability and sophistication of in silico approaches.The manuscript includes an appraisal of how this framework relates to the current risk assessment approaches and how future risk assessment could adapt to accommodate these new approaches. A full report is available in electronic format (pdf) at http://www.nano.hw.ac.uk/research-projects/itsnano.html.ConclusionITS-NANO has delivered a detailed, stakeholder driven and flexible research prioritisation (or strategy) tool, which identifies specific research needs, suggests connections between areas, and frames this in a time-perspective.

Variability of heat shock proteins and glutathione S-transferase in gill and digestive gland of blue mussel, Mytilus edulis

Glutathione S-transferase (GST) and heat shock proteins (hsps) 40, 60, 70 and 90 were determined by immunoblotting using actin as an internal control in Mytilus edulis from one station outside (site1) and three stations within (sites 2-4) Cork Harbour, Ireland. Comparisons were made between gill and digestive gland and between sites. Gill shows generally higher hsp 60, 70 and 90 while digestive gland has higher hsp 40. Site 1 showed higher gill hsps 40 and 70 than sites 2-4 while gill GST was higher in sites 3 and 4 than 1 and 2. Comparison with sites in the North Sea (site 5: outside Tjärnö in The Koster archipelago in the Skagerack) and Baltic Sea (site 6: Askö island) also revealed lower hsps 40 and 70 in site 6 (low salinity) than site 5 (high salinity) although hsps 60, 70 and 90 were detectable in digestive gland unlike sites 1-4. Previously, only hsp 70 had been studied at these sites [Mar. Environ. Res. 39. (1995), 181]. At the mRNA level, gill hsp 70 is 80-fold higher at Tjärnö than Askö. These data suggest that, while salinity may slightly decrease hsp 40 and 70, both hsp 70 and GST are selectively up-regulated by approx. 10- and 3-fold, respectively, at Tjärnö compared to the other sites which we attribute to exposure to more widely fluctuating pollution levels.

Organotin and osmoregulation : Quantifying the effects of environmental concentrations of sediment-associated TBT and TPhT on the freshwater-adapted European flounder, Platichthys flesus (L.)

Chronic (5 weeks) exposure of freshwater-adapted European flounder, Platichthys flesus (L.), to environmental concentrations of sediment-associated tri-n-butyltin chloride (TBTCl) and triphenyltin chloride (TPhTCl) caused significant changes to hydromineral fluxes and membrane permeability, mechanisms that maintain osmotic homeostasis. The half-time of exchange of tritiated water (THO) in TBTCl- and TPhTCl-exposed fish was significantly increased during the first 2 weeks of the experiment and then decreased steadily, eventually reaching the level that the control group had constantly maintained throughout the experiment. This change in apparent water permeability was accompanied by a significant decrease in diffusional water flux across the membranes. Passive Na(+)-efflux across the gills was increased significantly but effluxes in the control group were near constant over the same time span. Drinking rates in the organotin groups increased significantly while the rate of urine production did not change. This lead to an increased net water balance in the organotin groups and consequently to a significant reduction of the blood osmolality of both organotin groups when compared to a control. There would appear to be a metabolic cost attached to the changes produced by exposure to environmental levels of organotin compounds which are manifested as a minimal increase in body length compared to the controls.

Effects of contaminated sediment from Cork Harbour, Ireland on the cytochrome P450 system of turbot.

Hatchery-reared juvenile turbot (Scophthalmus maximus L.) were exposed for 3 weeks, under laboratory conditions, to inter-tidal sediments collected from polluted sites in Cork Harbour (Whitegate and Agahda) and a reference site at Ballymacoda Co., Cork, Ireland. The potential of the sediment exposure to induce cytochrome P450 activities and CYP1A1 in the fish was assessed. Chemical analysis revealed that the sediments originating from the reference and harbour sites were contaminated principally with PAHs-the harbour sites having double the levels of those at the reference site. Following 3 weeks exposure to the sediments western blotting demonstrated a strong immunogenic response for CYP1A1 in the liver, but not for gill or intestine. P450 activities were generally significantly higher than those exposed to reference site sediment. Liver was the most responsive tissue with significantly greater P450 activities compared with gill and intestinal tissues.

A two-species biomarker model for the assessment of sediment toxicity in the marine and estuarine environment using the comet assay.

Sediments frequently cause damage to biota due to the accumulation of toxic compounds and the bioavailability of sediment-associated contaminants. Damage can be assessed using biomarkers, such as the degree of genotoxic impact following in vivo exposure to contaminants. Genotoxic damage, expressed as single-strand DNA breaks, was measured in cells isolated from haemolymph/blood, gill and digestive gland/liver from the clam Tapes semidecussatus and turbot Scophthalmus maximus, using the single cell gel electrophoresis (Comet Assay). Both animals were exposed for three weeks to sediment samples collected from a polluted site and a ‘clean’ reference site. The level of DNA damage was assessed using an image analysis package and expressed as % tail DNA. Throughout the study, significant differences in DNA damage were recorded for each tissue type, in both species, between animals exposed to the two sediment samples. However, turbot appeared to be a more sensitive indicator species, because, due to lower background levels, they were able to detect a significant difference between reference site and background values. This suggests that turbot, rather than clams, are more suitable as a sentinel species for the assessment of genotoxic impact of low-level contamination in aquatic sediments and highlights the need for a two- or multi-species approach.

Microplastic contamination of intertidal sediments of Scapa Flow, Orkney: A first assessment

The concentration of microplastic particles and fibres was determined in the intertidal sediments at selected sites in Scapa Flow, Orkney, using a super-saturated NaCl flotation technique to extract the plastic and FT-IR spectroscopy to determine the polymer types. Mean concentrations were 730 and 2300kg-1 sediment (DW), respectively. Detailed spatial and quantitative analysis revealed that their distribution was a function of proximity to populated areas and associated wastewater effluent, industrial installations, degree of shore exposure and complex tidal flow patterns. Sediment samples from Orkney showed similar levels of microplastic contamination as in two highly populate industrialized mainland UK areas, The Clyde and the Firth of Forth. It was concluded that relative remoteness and a comparative small island population are not predictors of lower microplastic pollution. Furthermore, a larger concerted effort across Scotland and the UK is required to establish a baseline microplastic database for the evaluation of future policy measures.

Maintenance of bivalve hemocytes for the purpose of delayed DNA strand break assessment using the comet assay

The lack of appropriate methods for storing intact and viable cells for the purpose of delayed DNA strand break analysis has hitherto limited the application of the Comet assay to in vitro or in vivo laboratory studies and restricted ecologically more relevant field‐collected samples to sites in proximity to suitable laboratory facilities. In the present article, osmotically corrected cell culture media Hanks Balanced Salt Solution (HBSS) and Leibovitz Media (L‐15) were assessed for their suitability as temporary storage media of blue mussel (Mytilus edulis) hemocytes. It was found that hemocytes maintained in either HBSS or L‐15 could be stored for at least 7 days at 4°C without any significant deterioration in cell viability (Trypan blue) or increase in DNA strand breaks, expressed as % tail DNA. This approach allows the acquisition and examination of samples from organisms exposed in situ at previously unsuitable remote sites, thereby greatly increasing the potential ecological relevance of Comet assay‐derived genotoxicity data. Environ. Mol. Mutagen., 2010.

Sediment-associated tri-n-butyltin chloride and its effects on osmoregulation of freshwater-adapted 0-group European flounder, Platichthys flesus (L.).

The disruption of osmoregulatory processes was examined in European flounders exposed to environmental concentrations (150 ng TBTCl g(-1) dry weight sediment) of sediment-associated tri-n-butyltin chloride (TBTCl), by using radiotracers to measure changes in hydromineral fluxes and water balance. The water permeabilities of TBTCl-exposed fish varied during the course of the experiment and were significantly lower than those of the corresponding controls that did not change significantly with time. It was found that the maximum decrease in water permeability of TBTCl-exposed fish occurred after 14 days; thereafter there was an increase towards control values. However, there was a differential reduction of the diffusional (P(d)) and osmotic (P(os)) permeability coefficients, where the former decreased more rapidly than the latter, reflecting the reduction of diffusional membrane permeability and the increasing importance of osmotic permeability. In fish exposed to TBTCl sodium efflux and drinking rates were significantly increased but Na(+)/K(+)-ATPase activities and urine production rates were not affected. The effects of TBTCl exposure are also manifested at the level of the whole organism by a reduction in the increase of the body length of exposed fish, when compared to controls. It was concluded that tributyltin-n-chloride in sediments is capable of significantly disrupting the osmoregulatory functions of a benthic estuarine fish, at concentrations found in the sediments of Southampton Water and the River Itchen.

Neutral red cytotoxicity assays for assessing in vivo carbon nanotube ecotoxicity in mussels — Comparing microscope and microplate methods

The purpose of the present study was to compare two neutral red retention methods, the more established but very labour-intensive microscope method (NRR) against the more recently developed microplate method (NRU). The intention was to explore whether the sample volume throughput could be increased and potential operator bias avoided. Mussels Mytilus sp. were exposed in vivo to 50, 250 and 500 μg L(-1) single (SWCNTs) or multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs). Using the NRR method, SWCNTs and MWCNTs caused concentration dependent decreases in neutral red retention time. However, a concentration dependent decrease in optical density was not observed using the NRU method. We conclude that the NRU method is not sensitive enough to assess carbon nanotube ecotoxicity in vivo in environmentally relevant media, and recommend using the NRR method.

Potentiating toxicological interaction of single-walled carbon nanotubes with dissolved metals.

The present study explored the ecotoxicology of single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) and their likely interaction with dissolved metals, with a focus on the effect of in vivo exposure in marine mussels. Any nano-scale effects were negated by the tendency of uncoated SWCNTs to agglomerate in water, particularly with high ionic strength as is the case in estuarine and full-strength seawater. However, SWCNTs, in combination with natural organic matter, remained suspended in seawater for long enough to become available to filter-feeding mussels, leading to their concentration on and increased contact with gill epithelia during exposure. For the first time, the authors describe a potentiating toxicological effect, expressed as DNA strand breaks obtained using the comet assay, on divalent metals afforded by negatively charged SWCNT agglomerates in seawater at concentrations as low as 5 µg L⁻¹. This is supported by the observation that SWCNTs alone were only toxic at concentrations ≥100 µg L⁻¹ and that the SWCNT-induced DNA damage was correlated with oxidative stress only in the absence of metals. If these laboratory experiments are confirmed in the natural environment, the present results will have implications for the understanding of the role of carbon nanotubes in environmental metal dynamics, toxicology, and consequently, regulatory requirements.