Mark Gottlieb

Geographic Variation in the Use of Breast-Conserving Treatment for Breast Cancer

BACKGROUND In the past decade there has been an increase in the use of treatment designed to conserve the breast for women with breast cancer. The extent to which such treatment has been adopted in various regions of the country and whether characteristics of hospitals and patients predict its use is not known, however. METHODS We used national data on Medicare claims for inpatient care provided in 1986 to study 36,982 women 65 to 79 years of age, who had local or regional breast cancer and underwent either mastectomy or breast-conserving treatment (local excision, quadrantectomy, or subtotal mastectomy). Information about the hospitals at which these women were treated was obtained from an American Hospital Association survey. RESULTS Of the 36,982 women, 12.1 percent had breast-conserving surgery and 87.9 percent had a mastectomy. The frequency of breast-conserving surgery ranged from 3.5 percent to 21.2 percent in various states. The highest rate of use was in the Middle Atlantic states (20.0 percent) and New England (17.2 percent), and the lowest was in the East South Central states (5.9 percent) and the West South Central states (7.3 percent). Breast-conserving treatment was used more often in urban than in rural areas, in teaching hospitals than in nonteaching hospitals, in large hospitals than in small hospitals, and in hospitals with on-site radiation therapy or geriatric services than in others. Most of the geographic variation persisted after adjustment for the characteristics of hospitals and patients for which data were available. CONCLUSIONS There is substantial geographic variation in the use of breast-conserving surgery, which cannot be explained by differences in hospital characteristics. Hospital characteristics that were independently redictive of greater use of breast-conserving surgery were the size of the metropolitan area, the status of the institution as a teaching hospital, and the availability of radiation therapy and geriatric services.

Risk of blood contamination and injury to operating room personnel

The potential for transmission of deadly viral diseases to health care workers exists when contaminated blood is inoculated through injury or when blood comes in contact with nonintact skin. Operating room personnel are at particularly high risk for injury and blood contamination, but data on the specifics of which personnel are at greater risk and which practices change risk in this environment are almost nonexistent. To define these risk factors, experienced operating room nurses were employed solely to observe and record the injuries and blood contaminations that occurred during 234 operations involving 1763 personnel. Overall 118 of the operations (50%) resulted in at least one person becoming contaminated with blood. Cuts or needlestick injuries occurred in 15% of the operations. Several factors were found to significantly alter the risk of blood contamination or injury: surgical specialty, role of each person, duration of the procedure, amount of blood loss, number of needles used, and volume of irrigation fluid used. Risk calculations that use average values to include all personnel in the operating room or all operations performed substantially underestimate risk for surgeons and first assistants, who accounted for 81% of all body contamination and 65% of the injuries. The area of the body contaminated also changed with the surgical specialty. These data should help define more appropriate protection for individuals in the operating room and should allow refinements of practices and techniques to decrease injury.

Low-dose amphotericin B prophylaxis against invasive Aspergillus infections in allogeneic marrow transplantation

PURPOSE Invasive Aspergillus infections cause significant morbidity and mortality in marrow transplant patients. In this study, we examined whether administration of intravenous low-dose prophylactic amphotericin B could reduce the incidence and mortality associate with invasive aspergillosis in patients undergoing allogenic marrow transplantation. PATIENTS AND METHODS The subjects of this analysis were 186 consecutive patients undergoing allogeneic marrow transplantation in an adult bone marrow transplant unit between July 1, 1985, and September 30, 1990, utilizing consistent disease-specific chemoirradiation and graft-versus-host disease protocols. The incidence, morbidity, and case fatality of invasive aspergillosis in the study group receiving amphotericin chemoprophylaxis were compared with that in two historic cohorts managed without prophylactic amphotericin B. Univariate and multivariate statistical analyses were performed to examine whether an apparent protective effect could be attributed to differences in patient and treatment variables among the cohorts and to determine potential toxicities of the chemoprophylaxis regimen. RESULTS There was a significant reduction in both the incidence (p = 0.003) and mortality (p = 0.03) of invasive aspergillosis in patients receiving amphotericin B chemoprophylaxis as compared with those not receiving chemoprophylaxis. The prophylactic amphotericin B schedule, as employed here, was not associated with increased renal or hepatic toxicity as compared with that in historically managed patients. CONCLUSION These data suggest that the risks of invasive aspergillosis in allogeneic marrow transplant recipients can be reduced by administration of prophylactic amphotericin B during the pretransplant and peritransplant periods.

Tobacco-Smoke Exposure in Children Who Live in Multiunit Housing

OBJECTIVE: There is no safe level of secondhand tobacco-smoke exposure, and no previous studies have explored multiunit housing as a potential contributor to secondhand tobacco-smoke exposure in children. We hypothesized that children who live in apartments have higher cotinine levels than those who live in detached homes, when controlling for demographics. METHODS: We analyzed data from the 2001–2006 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. The housing types we included in our study were detached houses (including mobile homes), attached houses, and apartments. Our study subjects were children between the ages of 6 and 18 years. Cotinine levels were used to assess secondhand tobacco-smoke exposure, and those living with someone who smoked inside the home were excluded. χ2 tests, t tests, and Tobit regression models were used in Stata. Sample weights accounted for the complex survey design. RESULTS: Of 5002 children in our study, 73% were exposed to secondhand tobacco smoke. Children living in apartments had an increase in cotinine of 45% over those living in detached houses. This increase was 212% (P < .01) for white residents and 46% (P < .03) for black residents, but there was no significant increase for those of other races/ethnicities. At every cutoff level of cotinine, children in apartments had higher rates of exposure. The exposure effect of housing type was most pronounced at lower levels of cotinine. CONCLUSIONS: Most children without known secondhand tobacco-smoke exposure inside the home still showed evidence of tobacco-smoke exposure. Children in apartments had higher mean cotinine levels than children in detached houses. Potential causes for this result could be seepage through walls or shared ventilation systems. Smoking bans in multiunit housing may reduce childrens exposure to tobacco smoke.

Minimal increase in use of breast-conserving surgery from 1986 to 1990.

Substantial geographic and hospital-based variations have been documented in the use of breast-conserving surgery (BCS) in 1986. The authors studied the patterns of adoption of this procedure from 1986 to 1990. National Medicare inpatient claims were used to study women aged 65 to 79 who underwent an operation for local or regional breast cancer in 1986 (38,679 patients) or 1990 (43,083 patients). Breast-conserving surgery was used for 5,509 (14.1%) of the Medicare patients in 1986 and 6,476 (15.0%) in 1990. The only region with an increase in BCS use from 1986 to 1990 was New England. Many hospitals had low volumes of operations, with a median of six to seven patients annually. Ten percent of the hospitals performed 55% of the conservative operations. Large hospitals, urban hospitals, and those with higher patient volumes or a cancer center were somewhat more likely to have increased use of BCS by 1990. Despite the substantial evidence supporting BCS as an alternative to mastectomy, the overall use of BCS in Medicare inpatients increased minimally from 1986 to 1990. Many patients are treated in hospitals with little experience with BCS. Hospitals using more BCS in 1986 were somewhat more likely to increase the use of BCS by 1990.

The relationship of hospital characteristics and the results of peer review in six large states

To determine which characteristics of hospitals may be related to a higher quality of care, the association of hospital characteristics with the outcomes of medical record review by state Peer Review Organizations (PROs) was studied. The two data sources were: 1) the AHA 1986 Annual Survey of Hospitals and 2) reviews completed between July 1987 through June 1988 from six large PROs. For each hospital the percentage of cases that failed physician review (the confirmed problem rate) was computed. Hospital characteristics evaluated included financial status, ownership, medical training, technological sophistication, and size. The following characteristics were significantly associated with a lower confirmed problem rate: a higher occupancy rate, greater payroll expenses per bed, a higher proportion of physicians who were board-certified specialists, greater technological sophistication, a higher number of beds, a higher proportion of nurses who were registered, and membership in the Council of Teaching Hospitals. Public hospitals had higher problems rates than private not-for-profit hospitals. All characteristics significantly related to higher confirmed problem rates were also related to higher adjusted mortality rates in a previous study of 3,100 U.S. hospitals. The results suggest that hospital resources, including financial status, training of medical personnel, and availability of sophisticated equipment, are related to the quality of care provided by the hospital.

Predictors of Treatment Dropout from a Spouse Abuse Abatement Program

This study evaluated predictors of dropout among men who began and attended at least 1 session of a cognitive-behavioral, skills training oriented spouse abuse abatement counseling program. Based on prior research, a number of demographic, criminal justice, partner violence pattern, and personality characteristics were studied. Dropout prediction was assessed at 2 phases of program participation, during assessment (early drop) and during intervention (late drop). Overall, few of the variables studied predicted dropout. Early dropout was predicted by high rates of police contact for violent crimes, failure to self-report an alcohol problem, and paranoid personality characteristics. Late dropout was predicted by both high and moderate levels of police contact for violent crimes, and borderline personality characteristics. An Age X Violent Crime interaction suggested that young violent offenders are more likely to complete treatment. The overall model accounted for only 7.15% of the variance. Clinical and research implications are discussed.

A Comparison of the Urological Complications Associated with Long-Term Management of Quadriplegics with and without Chronic Indwelling Urinary Catheters

The primary objective of this retrospective study was to compare the incidence of urological complications and renal deterioration in post-traumatic quadriplegic patients managed with or without a chronic indwelling urinary catheter. The charts of 57 consecutive patients who sustained traumatic cervical spinal cord injury between 1970 and 1980 were reviewed. All of the patients received the initial management or rehabilitation therapy at our institution. The unique features of this clinical review are that a large cohort of patients was followed for a minimum of 10 years, none of the 57 consecutive patients was lost to followup and a yearly excretory urogram provided an objective assessment of the renal units. The followup, and mechanism, level and degree of injury for the 32 patients managed with and 25 managed without a catheter were similar. Overall, the incidences of renal and bladder calculi, pyelonephritis, gross hematuria, penile/urethral erosion, urosepsis, urethral stricture, epididymitis and pyonephrosis were not significantly different in the catheterized and noncatheterized groups. The Kaplan-Meier analysis of the most recent excretory urogram demonstrated that the incidence of renal deterioration was also equivalent in the catheterized and noncatheterized groups. Our study suggests that the decision to manage quadriplegics with or without an indwelling catheter should not be based on relative risk of complications or renal deterioration. The decision to avoid an indwelling catheter in these patients should reflect patient comfort, convenience and quality of life.

Regulation of Smoking in Public Housing

The Department of Housing and Urban Development has issued a memorandum encouraging Public Housing Authorities to restrict smoking in public-housing units. The current law relevant to smoking regulations is reviewed and discussed.

The effect of legislative requirements on the use of breast-conserving surgery

BACKGROUND We studied the effect of state legislation requiring the disclosure of options for the treatment of breast cancer on the use of breast-conserving surgery in clinical practice. METHODS The National Cancer Institutes Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results registry provided data on women from 30 through 79 years of age who underwent breast-conserving surgery or mastectomy for local or regional breast cancer from 1983 through 1990. We examined the trend over time in use of breast-conserving surgery among patients in four sites (Connecticut, Iowa, Seattle, and Utah) where there were no state laws specifically requiring the disclosure of options for the treatment of breast cancer by physicians. For four additional sites (Detroit, Atlanta, New Mexico, and Hawaii) that had such legislation, we determined whether the rate of breast-conserving surgery after the legislation was different from the expected rate. RESULTS An attorney rated the legislation as giving most direction to physicians in Michigan, followed by Hawaii, Georgia, and New Mexico. The rate of breast-conserving surgery was up to 8.7 percent higher than expected in Detroit for six months after the passage of the Michigan law (P<0.01). The rate was up to 13.2 percent higher than expected in Hawaii for 12 months after that states law was passed (P<0.05) and up to 6.0 percent higher than expected in Atlanta for 3 months after the passage of the Georgia law (P<0.01). After these transient increases, the surgery rates reverted to the expected levels. No significant effect was detected in New Mexico, where only a resolution without legal force was passed. CONCLUSION Legislation requiring physicians to disclose options for the treatment of breast cancer appeared to have only a slight and transient effect on the rate of use of breast-conserving surgery.