Mark Heyland

Working length of locking plates determines interfragmentary movement in distal femur fractures under physiological loading

BACKGROUND This study aimed to investigate the influence of the screw location and plate working length of a locking plate construct at the distal femur on interfragmentary movement under physiological loading. METHODS To quantitatively analyse the influence of plate working length on interfragmentary movements in a locking plate construct bridging a distal femur fracture, a finite element model based on CT (computed tomography) data was physiologically loaded and fracture gap conditions were calculated. Four working lengths with eight screw variations each were systemically analysed. FINDINGS Interfragmentary movements for axial (12-19%, p<0.001) and shear movements (-7.4-545%, p<0.001) at all tested nodes increased significantly with longer plate working length, whereas screw variations within the groups revealed no significant influence. The working length (defined by screw location) dominates the biomechanical fracture gap conditions. INTERPRETATION The current finite element analysis demonstrates that plate working length significantly influences interfragmentary movements, thereby affecting the biomechanical consequences of fracture healing.

Semi-rigid screws provide an auxiliary option to plate working length to control interfragmentary movement in locking plate fixation at the distal femur

BACKGROUND Extent and orientation of interfragmentary movement (IFM) are crucially affecting course and quality of fracture healing. The effect of different configurations for implant fixation on successful fracture healing remain unclear. We hypothesize that screw type and configuration of locking plate fixation profoundly influences stiffness and IFM for a given load in a distal femur fracture model. METHODS Simple analytical models are presented to elucidate the influence of fixation configuration on construct stiffness. Models were refined with a consistent single-patient-data-set to create finite-element femur models. Locking plate fixation of a distal femoral 10mm-osteotomy (comminution model) was fitted with rigid locking screws (rLS) or semi-rigid locking screws (sLS). Systematic variations of screw placements in the proximal fragment were tested. IFM was quantitatively assessed and compared for different screw placements and screw types. RESULTS Different screw allocations significantly affect IFM in a locking plate construct. LS placement of the first screw proximal to the fracture (plate working length, PWL) has a significant effect on axial IFM (p < 0.001). Replacing rLS with sLS caused an increase (p < 0.001) of IFM under the plate (cis-cortex) between +8.4% and +28.1% for the tested configurations but remained constant medially (<1.1%, trans-cortex). Resultant shear movements markedly increased at fracture level (p < 0.001) to the extent that plate working length increased. The ratio of shear/axial IFM was found to enhance for longer PWL. sLS versus rLS lead to significantly smaller ratios of shear/axial IFM at the cis-cortex for PWL of ≥ 62 mm (p ≤ 0.003). CONCLUSION Mechanical frame conditions can be significantly influenced by type and placement of the screws in locking plate osteosynthesis of the distal femur. By varying plate working length stiffness and IFM are modulated. Moderate axial and concomitantly low shear IFM could not be achieved through changes in screw placement alone. In the present transverse osteotomy model, ratio of shear/axial IFM with simultaneous moderate axial IFM is optimized by the use of appropriate plate working length of about 42-62 mm. Fixation with sLS demonstrated significantly more axial IFM underneath the plate and may further contribute to compensation of asymmetric straining.

Interfragmentary lag screw fixation in locking plate constructs increases stiffness in simple fracture patterns

BACKGROUND The aim of the current biomechanical cadaver study was to quantify the influence of an additional lag screw on construct stiffness in simple fracture models at the distal femur stabilised with a locking plate. METHODS For biomechanical testing paired fresh frozen human femora of 5 donors (mean age: 71 (SD 9) years) were chosen. Different locking plate configurations either with or without interfragmentary lag screw were tested under torsional load (2/4Nm/deg) or axial compression forces (500/1000N). FINDINGS Data show that plate constructs with interfragmentary lag screw reveal similar axial and torsional stiffness values compared to intact bone as opposed to bridging plate constructs that showed significantly lower stiffness for both loading conditions. INTERPRETATION The current biomechanical testing unveils that the insertion of a lag screw combined with a locking plate dominates over a bridging plate construct at the distal femur in terms of axial and torsional stiffness.

Selecting boundary conditions in physiological strain analysis of the femur: Balanced loads, inertia relief method and follower load

Selection of boundary constraints may influence amount and distribution of loads. The purpose of this study is to analyze the potential of inertia relief and follower load to maintain the effects of musculoskeletal loads even under large deflections in patient specific finite element models of intact or fractured bone compared to empiric boundary constraints which have been shown to lead to physiological displacements and surface strains. The goal is to elucidate the use of boundary conditions in strain analyses of bones. Finite element models of the intact femur and a model of clinically relevant fracture stabilization by locking plate fixation were analyzed with normal walking loading conditions for different boundary conditions, specifically re-balanced loading, inertia relief and follower load. Peak principal cortex surface strains for different boundary conditions are consistent (maximum deviation 13.7%) except for inertia relief without force balancing (maximum deviation 108.4%). Influence of follower load on displacements increases with higher deflection in fracture model (from 3% to 7% for force balanced model). For load balanced models, follower load had only minor influence, though the effect increases strongly with higher deflection. Conventional constraints of fixed nodes in space should be carefully reconsidered because their type and position are challenging to justify and for their potential to introduce relevant non-physiological reaction forces. Inertia relief provides an alternative method which yields physiological strain results.