Mark R. Gertner

The Uncertainty Of Radio Frequency Treatment Of Renal Cell Carcinoma: Findings At Immediate And Delayed Nephrectomy

PURPOSE Radio frequency thermal therapy for the ablation of renal cell carcinoma has been reported. Outcomes are usually measured by imaging alone. We have performed ex vivo and in vivo experiments using radio frequency in porcine models in our laboratory. We now report our early experience in the treatment of renal cell carcinoma in patients who underwent post-radio frequency radical or partial nephrectomy. MATERIALS AND METHODS We treated 10 patients diagnosed with small renal masses with radio frequency. All masses were biopsied before treatment. In 4 patients 5 renal cell carcinomas were treated with radio frequency after surgical exposure of the tumor followed immediately by partial or radical nephrectomy (acute group). Six other patients were treated percutaneously with ultrasound or computerized tomography guided radio frequency under local anesthesia and intravenous sedation 7 days before partial or radical nephrectomy (delayed group). A median of 2 radio frequency cycles was applied. Mean total heating time was 17 minutes 15 seconds. Specimens were analyzed grossly and histologically. Triphasic contrast-enhanced computerized tomography and/or magnetic resonance imaging was performed before and 7 days after radio frequency treatment in the delayed group. RESULTS Mean radiological largest diameter of all 11 masses was 2.4 cm. and mean gross diameter was 2.2 cm. Pathological examination demonstrated residual viable tumor in approximately 5% of the volume in 4 of the 5 tumors in the acute group and in 3 of the 6 masses of the delayed group. In 1 delayed case the viable tumor appeared to be in contact with the renal vein. No significant complications were observed in 9 of the 10 patients. In 1 delayed case, a subcapsular hepatic hematoma, biliary fistula and pneumonia developed and resolved. CONCLUSIONS Based on our experience, we continue to consider percutaneous radio frequency for the treatment of small renal cell carcinomas as a potentially curative therapy. However, complete tumor cell death appears to be difficult to achieve with our current treatment protocol. More phase II testing is indicated to ensure that this technique is an effective and reproducible treatment alternative.

Image Guided Photothermal Focal Therapy for Localized Prostate Cancer: Phase I Trial

PURPOSE We ascertained the feasibility and safety of image guided targeted photothermal focal therapy for localized prostate cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS Twelve patients with biopsy proven low risk prostate cancer underwent interstitial photothermal ablation of the cancer. The area of interest was confirmed and targeted using magnetic resonance imaging. Three-dimensional ultrasound was used to guide a laser to the magnetic resonance to ultrasound fused area of interest. Target ablation was monitored using thermal sensors and real-time Definity contrast enhanced ultrasound. Followup was performed with a combination of magnetic resonance imaging and prostate biopsy. Validated quality of life questionnaires were used to assess the effect on voiding symptoms and erectile function, and adverse events were solicited and recorded. RESULTS Interstitial photothermal focal therapy was technically feasible to perform. Of the patients 75% were discharged home free from catheter the same day with the remainder discharged home the following day. The treatment created an identifiable hypovascular defect which coincided with the targeted prostatic lesion. There were no perioperative complications and minimal morbidity. All patients who were potent before the procedure maintained potency after the procedure. Continence levels were not compromised. Based on multicore total prostate biopsy at 6 months 67% of patients were free of tumor in the targeted area and 50% were free of disease. CONCLUSIONS Image guided focal photothermal ablation of low risk and low volume prostate cancer is feasible. Early clinical, histological and magnetic resonance imaging responses suggest that the targeted region can be ablated with minimal adverse effects. It may represent an alternate treatment approach to observation or delayed standard therapy in carefully selected patients. Further trials are required to demonstrate the effectiveness of this treatment concept.

Real-time magnetic resonance imaging-guided focal laser therapy in patients with low-risk prostate cancer.

Two patients with low-risk prostate cancer (PCa) were treated with outpatient in-bore magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-guided focal laser ablation. The tumor was identified on MRI. A laser fiber was delivered via a catheter inserted through a perineal template and guided to the target with MRI. The tissue temperature was monitored during laser ablation by MRI thermometry. Accumulated thermal damage was calculated in real time. Immediate post-treatment contrast-enhanced MRI confirmed devascularization of the target. No adverse events were noted. MRI-guided focal laser therapy of low-risk PCa is feasible and may offer a good balance between cancer control and side effects.

Focal Laser Ablation for Prostate Cancer Followed by Radical Prostatectomy: Validation of Focal Therapy and Imaging Accuracy

An increased incidence of low-risk prostate cancer (PCa) has led investigators to develop focal therapy as a management option for PCa. We evaluated the effects of focal laser ablation (FLA) on PCa tissue and the accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in determining ablated lesion volume by comparing the whole-mount histology and MRI in four patients that underwent FLA followed by radical prostatectomy. Ablated areas were characterized by homogeneous coagulation necrosis. The MRI-calculated ablated volume correlated well with histopathology. We found that FLA creates confluent ablation with no evidence of viable cells in treated regions. Postablation MRI is able to determine the ablation accurately.

Ultrasound properties of liver tissue during heating

The objective of this work was to determine changes in the ultrasound properties of heated tissues, with potential application to monitoring of minimally invasive thermal therapy (MITT). Changes in backscatter coefficients and frequency-dependent attenuation coefficients were measured over the frequency range 2.5 MHz to 5 MHz from heated samples of store-bought fresh bovine liver, which was used as a tissue model. Individual liver samples were heated from 37 degrees C to either 50 degrees C, 55 degrees C, 60 degrees C, 65 degrees C or 70 degrees C by warm water. The backscatter coefficient increased during the first 3 min by a factor of 1.09 and 1.11 before the tissue reached 50 degrees C and 55 degrees C, respectively. A decrease in backscatter coefficient followed at 50 degrees C by a factor of 1.12 below the initial level and, at 55 degrees C, the backscatter coefficient dropped below the initial level by a factor of 1.19. The backscatter coefficient decreased within the first 2 min by a factor of 1.22 before the tissue reached 60 degrees C, then increased gradually to a factor of 1.05 below the initial level. At 65 degrees C and 70 degrees C, the changes in backscatter coefficient were highly variable, which may have been due to production of gas microbubbles in the heated tissues. The ultrasound attenuation coefficient increased by as much as 1.48 dB cm-1 over a 30-min period at 70 degrees C. First-order rate parameters derived from the attenuation results revealed one rate process at 50 degrees C and 55 degrees C and two rate processes at 60 degrees C, 65 degrees C and 70 degrees C. An activation energy of 1.00 x 10(4) cal mol-1 was derived from the second rate constants at 60 degrees C, 65 degrees C and 70 degrees C, which indicates that changes in attenuation may be due to protein denaturation. In conclusion, ultrasound image monitoring of thermal therapy treatment in liver may be feasible; however, the backscatter coefficient changes during heating are small and are of the same order as the variation in these changes from point to point in the tissue.

Development of a radiofrequency based thermal therapy technique in an in vivo porcine model for the treatment of small renal masses.

PURPOSE Incidentally detected small renal tumors appear to grow slowly and be localized to the kidney. Minimally invasive therapies are being investigated as alternatives to standard surgical techniques. Radiofrequency ablation has been reported for the treatment of small renal cell carcinomas. We developed a radiofrequency technique and established its efficacy and safety in a large animal model. METHODS AND METHODS A total of 22 lesions were created in normal kidneys of 7 pigs. Radiofrequency energy was administered during open exposure of the kidneys or percutaneously under ultrasound guidance. Lesion development was monitored with gray-scale and power Doppler ultrasound. To avoid heating surrounding tissues new hydro-dissection and gas-dissection techniques were developed. Lesion sizes and characteristics were assessed by ultrasound and pathological examination. RESULTS No complications were observed due to probe insertion and removal. Perirenal structures were thermally damaged before the development and application of the dissection techniques. Lesion size was accurately predicted by gray-scale ultrasound on day 7. Loss of perfusion in the ablated volume was confirmed by power Doppler ultrasound. Lesions were wedge-shaped, presumably due to the effects of heating on segmental blood flow distribution. Pathological examination revealed changes consistent with thermal injury and ischemic type infarction. CONCLUSIONS Radiofrequency thermal therapy is an effective and efficient method for ablating normal renal tissue in the pig. It may be applied percutaneously under ultrasound guidance with minimal complications provided that vital adjacent structures are protected from thermal damage. Further studies are required in humans before adopting this technique as definitive treatment for small renal cell carcinoma.

Ultrasound imaging of thermal therapy in in vitro liver

The objective of this work was to image liver tissue heated to temperatures below the vaporization threshold as a function of time, to test the feasibility of real-time ultrasound monitoring to control lesion size during minimally invasive thermal therapy (MITT). Two experiments were devised. In one experiment, a thermal gradient was established in a rectangular volume of tissue to correlate changes in ultrasound image echogenicity (B-mode image brightness) with tissue temperature. In the other, a thermal lesion was produced in a rectangular volume of tissue by an interstitial microwave antenna, and the progression of the lesion was monitored by ultrasound. In both experiments, the echogenicity of the tissue increased slightly for tissue temperatures up to 40 degrees C, but became lower than that of unheated tissue for temperatures above 40 degrees C. In the second experiment, images of the lesion were compared with a photograph of the lesion taken after the experiment was complete. The final lesion was composed of two concentric regions--an inner region of heavily coagulated tissue and an outer region of less-damaged tissue. These two damaged regions indicated that increased ultrasound attenuation was largely responsible for the decreased echogenicity observed in the ultrasound images, and the increase in echogenicity of tissue heated to temperatures up to 40 degrees C is thought to be due to decreased ultrasound attenuation at these temperatures.

INTERSTITIAL MICROWAVE THERMAL THERAPY FOR PROSTATE CANCER: METHOD OF TREATMENT AND RESULTS OF A PHASE I/II TRIAL

PURPOSE Interstitial microwave thermal therapy is experimental treatment for prostate cancer with the goal of curing disease, while causing fewer complications than standard treatment options. We present a method for delivering interstitial microwave thermal therapy using microwave radiating helical antennae inserted percutaneously under transrectal ultrasound guidance. We report the results of a trial of this method in 25 patients in whom primary external beam radiation therapy had previously failed. This patient group currently has limited curative options that are associated with a high complication rate. However, these recurrent tumors often remain localized to the prostate, and so they may be amenable to localized therapy. MATERIALS AND METHODS Patients with proved prostatic adenocarcinoma were candidates for treatment when prostate specific antigen (PSA) was 15 ng./ml. or less and prostate volume was 50 cc. or less. Followup included PSA measurement, digital rectal examination, urinalysis, and documentation of adverse events at 4, 8, 12 and 24 weeks. Sextant biopsy was performed at week 24. The procedure involved the insertion of 5 antennae percutaneously through a modified brachytherapy template. The antenna arrangement was determined based on computer simulated predictions of temperature throughout the prostate. The prostate was dissected away from the rectum by an injection of sterile saline to provide a thermal barrier that protected the rectum from thermal damage. Temperatures were monitored using interstitial mapping thermistor probes that were also inserted through the template. A minimum peripheral target temperature of 55C but less than 70C was maintained for 15 to 20 minutes, while the urethra, rectum and hydrodissection space remained below 42C. The urethra and rectum were actively cooled in addition to hydrodissection. RESULTS Peripheral target temperatures of 55C were achieved. The urethra and rectum remained at a safe temperature. The procedure, including setup and treatment, required approximately 2.5 hours of operating room time. At 24 weeks the PSA nadir was 0.5 ng./ml. or less in 52% of patients and 0.51 to 4 ng./ml. was achieved in an additional 40%. The negative biopsy rate at 24 weeks was 64%, assuming that 3 patients lost to followup would have had positive results. No major complications were observed and in most cases minor complications resolved within 3 months. CONCLUSIONS Interstitial microwave thermal therapy for prostate cancer was developed to heat the prostate safely to a cytotoxic temperature. Experience with 25 patients in whom external beam radiation therapy for prostate cancer had failed indicates that the treatment is safe. Although our series indicates that this therapy may be effective, further studies and longer followup are required in larger patient groups to confirm the potential role of this therapy as an option for recurrent and primary prostate cancer.

Interstitial Microwave Thermal Therapy for Prostate Cancer

Thermal therapy is used to kill tumors by heating them to temperatures >50 degrees C for an extended period of time. Cell death results from thermal coagulation. The energy sources available for this approach include radiofrequency electrodes, microwave antennas, laser fiberoptics, and ultrasound transducers. Each of these modalities has the potential to be delivered in a minimally invasive manner, and many theoretical and experimental investigations of these devices have been performed. This review describes current knowledge of interstitial microwave thermal therapy for prostate cancer. Examples are given from an ongoing trial in patients who have recurrent or persistent disease following radiation therapy. Future directions for pretreatment planning and real-time monitoring and control are discussed. These techniques have the potential to optimize treatments on a patient-specific basis and will be instrumental in planned future trials of this therapy as first line for prostate cancer.

Interstitial microwave thermal therapy and its application to the treatment of recurrent prostate cancer.

Interstitial microwave thermal therapy may be an effective alternative to surgery for the treatment of some solid tumours. Arrays of helical antennae can produce complex heating patterns which when combined with active cooling of normal tissue structures can provide conformal heating for thermal coagulation of tumours. The development of a clinical protocol involving phantom and animal model studies, treatment planning, tissue property measurement and methods for on-line treatment monitoring is reviewed. The technology developed has been applied to the problem of recurrent prostate cancer following failed radiation treatment where available curative options are associated with high normal tissue morbidity. The purpose was to develop a treatment option for this group of patients with a very low side-effect profile that would not preclude further treatment if the disease progressed. Results of a Phase I/II trial demonstrate safety, promising efficacy and a low complication rate. As the technology for delivering this treatment matures, larger multi-institutional trials should be considered.