Markus Schmidt-Heydt

Stress induction of mycotoxin biosynthesis genes by abiotic factors

Systematic expression analysis of mycotoxin biosynthesis genes by real-time PCR and microarray was carried out to examine the relationship between growth and general expression patterns in relation to single environmental factors such as temperature, water activity (a(w)) and pH and water activity x temperature interactions. For single parameters, one major peak of expression occurred close to optimum growth conditions. However, a second minor peak was observed under suboptimal growth conditions, when intermediate environmental stress was imposed on Aspergillus parasiticus (afl genes), Penicillium verrucosum (ota genes) and Fusarium culmorum (tri genes). This expression profile pattern was more pronounced in relation to changes in temperature and a(w) than to pH. In a two-factorial experimental design with temperature xa(w) regimes, again two peaks of expression were observed for cluster genes after microarray analysis, one close to those giving optimal growth and one under imposed stress conditions. Interestingly, when the activity of single genes of the microarray data were plotted in relation to the two parameters, again a two-peak expression profile became obvious independently for both parameters. Expression of the mycotoxin biosynthesis genes was followed exactly by phenotypic mycotoxin production. This expression profile appears to be generic across the mycotoxigenic fungi examined.

Complex regulation of the aflatoxin biosynthesis gene cluster of Aspergillus flavus in relation to various combinations of water activity and temperature

A microarray analysis was performed to study the effect of varying combinations of water activity and temperature on the activation of aflatoxin biosynthesis genes in Aspergillusflavus grown on YES medium. Generally A. flavus showed expression of the aflatoxin biosynthetic genes at all parameter combinations tested. Certain combinations of a(w) and temperature, especially combinations which imposed stress on the fungus resulted in a significant reduction of the growth rate. At these conditions induction of the whole aflatoxin biosynthesis gene cluster occurred, however the produced aflatoxin B(1) was low. At all other combinations (25 degrees C/0.95 and 0.99; 30 degrees C/0.95 and 0.99; 35 degrees C/0.95 and 0.99) a reduced basal level of cluster gene expression occurred. At these combinations a high growth rate was obtained as well as high aflatoxin production. When single genes were compared, two groups with different expression profiles in relation to water activity/temperature combinations occurred. These two groups were co-ordinately localized within the aflatoxin gene cluster. The ratio of aflR/aflJ expression was correlated with increased aflatoxin biosynthesis.

A gene cluster of the ochratoxin A biosynthetic genes inPenicillium

A putative ochratoxin A (OTA) biosynthetic gene cluster inP. nordicum has been identified. The first part of the gene cluster is located on a DNA fragment of 10 kb in length and harbours three genes. A gene with high homology to an alkaline serine protease gene (accession number AY557343), which represents the upstream border of the cluster. Furthermore the fragment carries a large part (about 2 kb) of the 5′ end of a polyketide synthase (otapksPN, accession number AY196315) and a complete non-ribosomal peptide synthetase (otanpsPN, accession number AY534879). The second part of the cluster is located on a 4.3 kb fragment that harbours three open reading frames (ORFs) encoding putative OTA biosynthetic proteins: one incomplete ORF at the 5′ end of the fragment demonstrated homology to an organic anion transporter from rat kidneys (otatraPN). This transporter has been described to be responsible for the transport of toxic OTA out of the cell. One complete ORF of 951 nucleotides is also located on this fragment. This gene has limited homology to a chloroperoxidase fromGluconobacter oxidans. At the 3′ end of this DNA fragment is an incomplete open reading frame of a potential nitrate transporter. The transcription of all putative OTA biosynthetic genes is increased under OTA conducive conditions. The expression kinetics of the genes resembles that of secondary metabolite biosynthetic genes, in which these genes are co-ordinately expressed during the late growth phase.PCR analysis demonstrated that the gene cluster is only present in the two ochratoxin A producingPenicillium species,P. verrucosum andP. nordicum. P. nalgiovense, a species occurring in the same habitat asP. nordicum carries inactive homologues of the genes. All other species proved to be negative for the genes. This was also true for OTA producing Aspergilli.

A systems approach to model the relationship between aflatoxin gene cluster expression, environmental factors, growth and toxin production by Aspergillus flavus

A microarray analysis was used to examine the effect of combinations of water activity (aw, 0.995–0.90) and temperature (20–42°C) on the activation of aflatoxin biosynthetic genes (30 genes) in Aspergillus flavus grown on a conducive YES (20 g yeast extract, 150 g sucrose, 1 g MgSO4·7H2O) medium. The relative expression of 10 key genes (aflF, aflD, aflE, aflM, aflO, aflP, aflQ, aflX, aflR and aflS) in the biosynthetic pathway was examined in relation to different environmental factors and phenotypic aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) production. These data, plus data on relative growth rates and AFB1 production under different aw × temperature conditions were used to develop a mixed-growth-associated product formation model. The gene expression data were normalized and then used as a linear combination of the data for all 10 genes and combined with the physical model. This was used to relate gene expression to aw and temperature conditions to predict AFB1 production. The relationship between the observed AFB1 production provided a good linear regression fit to the predicted production based in the model. The model was then validated by examining datasets outside the model fitting conditions used (37°C, 40°C and different aw levels). The relationship between structural genes (aflD, aflM) in the biosynthetic pathway and the regulatory genes (aflS, aflJ) was examined in relation to aw and temperature by developing ternary diagrams of relative expression. These findings are important in developing a more integrated systems approach by combining gene expression, ecophysiological influences and growth data to predict mycotoxin production. This could help in developing a more targeted approach to develop prevention strategies to control such carcinogenic natural metabolites that are prevalent in many staple food products. The model could also be used to predict the impact of climate change on toxin production.

The production of aflatoxin B1 or G1 by Aspergillus parasiticus at various combinations of temperature and water activity is related to the ratio of aflS to aflR expression

The influence of varying combinations of water activity (aw) and temperature on growth, aflatoxin biosynthesis and aflR/aflS expression of Aspergillus parasiticus was analysed in the ranges 17–42°C and 0.90–0.99 aw. Optimum growth was at 35°C. At each temperature studied, growth increased from 0.90 to 0.99 aw. Temperatures of 17 and 42°C only supported marginal growth. The external conditions had a differential effect on aflatoxin B1 or G1 biosynthesis. The temperature optima of aflatoxin B1 and G1 were not at the temperature which supported optimal growth (35°C) but either below (aflatoxin G1, 20–30°C) or above (aflatoxin B1, 37°C). Interestingly, the expression of the two regulatory genes aflR and aflS showed an expression profile which corresponded to the biosynthesis profile of either B1 (aflR) or G1 (aflS). The ratios of the expression data between aflS:aflR were calculated. High ratios at a range between 17 and 30°C corresponded with the production profile of aflatoxin G1 biosynthesis. A low ratio was observed at >30°C, which was related to aflatoxin B1 biosynthesis. The results revealed that the temperature was the key parameter for aflatoxin B1, whereas it was water activity for G1 biosynthesis. These differences in regulation may be attributed to variable conditions of the ecological niche in which these species occur.

Modelling the relationship between environmental factors, transcriptional genes and deoxynivalenol mycotoxin production by strains of two Fusarium species

The effect of changes in temperature/water activity (aw) on growth, deoxynivalenol (DON) production and trichothecene gene cluster expression (18 genes) for strains of Fusarium culmorum and Fusarium graminearum was studied. The expression data for six key transcription genes (TRI4, TRI5, TRI6, TRI10, TRI12 and TRI13) were analysed using multiple regression analyses to model the relationship between these various factors for the first time. Changes in aw and temperature significantly (p = 0.05) affected growth and DON. Microarray data on expression of these genes were significantly related to DON production for both strains. Multi-regression analysis was done and polynomial models found to best fit the relationship between actual/predicted DON production relative to the expression of these TRI genes and environmental factors. This allowed prediction of the amounts of DON produced in two-dimensional contour maps to relate expression of these genes to either aw or temperature. These results suggest complex interactions between gene expression (TRI genes), environmental factors and mycotoxin production. This is a powerful tool for understanding the role of these genes in relation to environmental factors and enables more effective targeted control strategies to be developed.

Influence of light on food relevant fungi with emphasis on ochratoxin producing species

The influence of light of varying wavelength on growth and ochratoxin A biosynthesis of Aspergillus carbonarius, A. niger, A. steynii and on Penicillium nordicum and P. verrucosum was analysed. For comparison the influence of light on various other food relevant fungi, including citrinin producers, was also tested. Generally the Aspergilli seem to be more resistant to light treatment than the Penicillia. Interestingly wavelengths from both sides of the spectrum, e. g. red (long wavelength, 627 nm) and blue (short wavelength 470-455 nm) had the strongest inhibitory effects on growth and ochratoxin A biosynthesis. Blue light generally had a stronger effect. Light of moderate wavelength, 590 to 530 nm, (yellow to green) had more a positive than a negative influence on growth or ochratoxin A biosynthesis compared to the control (dark incubation). The light effect on growth and ochratoxin A biosynthesis was dependent on the growth medium. In contrast to malt extract medium (MEA), YES medium, as an especially nutrient rich medium, had an attenuating effect on the reactivity against light. However the tendency of the response in both media was the same. Moreover, the light intensity strongly influences how the fungus reacts. Depending on the intensity and the resistance of the species a complete cessation of growth and/or inhibition of ochratoxin A biosynthesis could be achieved. Light irradiation has the opposite effect on ochratoxin A than citrinin, two mycotoxins which can be produced simultaneously in P. verrucosum. Citrinin was produced essentially under light conditions which inhibited ochratoxin A biosynthesis. The same was true for a derivative of ochratoxin, in particular a derivative of ochratoxin β in A. carbonarius. A. carbonarius produced high amounts of the ochratoxin β derivative under blue light when the production of ochratoxin A was ceased at the most inhibiting conditions used (MEA, royal blue light, 455 nm, 1700 lx). Light has a growth stalling but not inactivating effect on aerial mycelia. If a non-growing colony under light is shifted to the dark it immediately grows normally. However on spores blue light has a deactivating effect. After incubation of spores of P. verrucosum for 24h under blue light up to 97% of the spores were no longer able to germinate. Again the spores of the Aspergilli were much more resistant.

Oxidative stress induces the biosynthesis of citrinin by Penicillium verrucosum at the expense of ochratoxin

Penicillium verrucosum is a fungus that can produce ochratoxin A and citrinin, two structurally related nephrotoxic mycotoxins. P. verrucosum usually occurs on wheat but can occasionally also be found in NaCl rich habitats such as salted cheeses or olives, indicating that this fungus can adapt to different environments. The ratio of ochratoxin A to citrinin produced by P. verrucosum is shifted to one of either mycotoxin at the expense of the other dependent on the environmental conditions. High NaCl concentrations shift secondary metabolite biosynthesis towards ochratoxin A production. P. verrucosum copes with NaCl stress by increased ochratoxin A biosynthesis, ensuring chloride homeostasis. Ochratoxin A carries chlorine in its molecule and can excrete chlorine from the cell. It was further shown that the regulation of ochratoxin A by high NaCl conditions is mediated by the HOG MAP kinase signal transduction pathway. Here it is shown that high oxidative stress conditions, evoked for example by increasing concentrations of Cu(2+) cations in the growth medium, shift secondary metabolite biosynthesis of P. verrucosum from ochratoxin A to citrinin. The production of citrinin normalizes the oxidative status of the fungal cell under oxidative stress conditions leading to an adaptation to these environmental conditions and protects against increased oxidative stress caused by increased Cu(2+) concentrations. Moreover citrinin also protects against light of short wavelength, which may also increase the oxidative status of the environment. The biosynthesis of citrinin is apparently regulated by a cAMP/PKA signaling pathway, because increasing amounts of external cAMP reduce citrinin biosynthesis in a concentration dependent manner. These conditions lead to the cross-regulation of the ochratoxin A/citrinin secondary metabolite pair and support the adaptation of P. verrucosum to different environments.

HOG MAP kinase regulation of alternariol biosynthesis in Alternaria alternata is important for substrate colonization.

Strains of the genus Alternaria are ubiquitously present and frequently found on fruits, vegetables and cereals. One of the most commonly found species from this genus is A. alternata which is able to produce the mycotoxin alternariol among others. To date only limited knowledge is available about the regulation of the biosynthesis of alternariol, especially under conditions relevant to food. Tomatoes are a typical substrate of A. alternata and have a high water activity. On the other hand cereals with moderate water activity are also frequently colonized by A. alternata. In the current analysis it was demonstrated that even minor changes in the osmotic status of the substrate affect the alternariol biosynthesis of strains from vegetables resulting in nearly complete inhibition. High osmolarity in the environment is usually transmitted to the transcriptional level of downstream regulated genes by the HOG signal cascade (high osmolarity glycerol cascade) which is a MAP kinase transduction pathway. The phosphorylation status of the A. alternata HOG (AaHOG) was determined. Various concentrations of NaCl induce the phosphorylation of AaHOG in a concentration, time and strain dependent manner. A strain with a genetically inactivated aahog gene was no longer able to produce alternariol indicating that the activity of the aahog gene is required for alternariol biosynthesis. Further experiments revealed that the biosynthesis of alternariol is important for the fungus to colonize tomato tissue. The tight water activity dependent regulation of alternariol biosynthesis ensures alternariol biosynthesis at conditions which indicate an optimal colonization substrate for the fungus.

Chlorogenic acid, a metabolite identified by untargeted metabolome analysis in resistant tomatoes, inhibits the colonization by Alternaria alternata by inhibiting alternariol biosynthesis

Tomato fruits can be contaminated by saprophytic strains of Alternaria alternata which is the reason for the frequent occurrence of Alternaria toxins like alternariol, alternariol monomethylether or tenuazonic acid in these types of products. It was shown earlier that alternariol is a colonization factor for tomatoes. In the current analysis two different tomato genotypes were analysed by untargeted comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC×GC-MS). This analysis revealed clear differences in the metabolic profiles which were paralleled by differences in resistance towards Alternaria colonization. One of the genotypes was more resistant against A. alternata infection and contained high amounts of chlorogenic acid in contrast to the other genotype which was sensitive against infection. In in vitro analysis, chlorogenic acid reduced alternariol biosynthesis during the first days of growth of A. alternata. Expression analysis of the alternariol polyketide synthase gene, a key gene in the biosynthesis of alternariol, also revealed a temporal reduction in its expression in the first phases of growth. However by chromatographic analysis it could be demonstrated that chlorogenic acid was degraded over time. This degradation leads to a relief of inhibition resulting in an only temporal inhibition of alternariol biosynthesis. In vivo colonization experiments revealed that chlorogenic acid reduces colonization of tomatoes by A. alternata in a concentration dependent manner, which however is partly counteracted by the addition of alterariol.