Marshall T. Morgan

Delayed Recognition and Infection Control for Tuberculosis Patients in the Emergency Department

STUDY OBJECTIVE The recent increase in tuberculosis (TB) cases may have an important effect on emergency department infection-control measures. We describe infection-control interventions for TB patients admitted through the ED and hypothesize that ED suspicion of TB is associated with more rapid isolation and treatment. DESIGN Retrospective chart review. SETTING The ED of a 400-bed urban, university-affiliated county hospital. PARTICIPANTS Fifty-five patients with TB culture-positive and acid-fast bacillus stain-positive respiratory specimens who were evaluated in the ED during 1991 and 1992. RESULTS We identified cases from the mycobacteriology log. Demographic and historical data and time elapsed before initiation of infection-control measures and TB therapy were recorded. We assessed the relationships of individual clinical findings and the ED presumptive diagnosis of TB (predictor variables) to time elapsed before isolation and therapy (outcome variables) with the log-rank test. The median time (interquartile range) from ED registration to isolation was 8 hours (range, 3 to 13 hours). An ED presumptive diagnosis of TB was made in 71% of cases and was significantly associated with shorter time elapsed before isolation (5 hours [range, 2 to 10 hours] versus 21 hours [range, 11 to 111 hours]; P < .001) and less time elapsed before therapy (12 hours [range, 9 to 22 hours] versus 128 hours [68 to 374 hours]; P < .001). We found TB exposure, radiographic changes typical of TB, absence of HIV risk factors, presence of cough, and sputum production to be associated with more rapid isolation. CONCLUSION Among patients with active pulmonary TB in the ED, TB is often unsuspected and isolation measures are often not used. ED suspicion of TB is associated with more rapid isolation and treatment.

The Clinical Investigation and Management of Chest Pain in an Emergency Department: Quality Assessment by Criteria Mapping

Criteria Mapping, a recently developed chart review method, was tested for its ability to assess the quality of symptom investigation and management for the presenting complaint of chest pain in an emergency department. A criteria map, which is based on decision making logic and permits use of criteria relevant to individual patients, was used to review the records of 137 patients who were examined for chest pain and subsequently discharged from the emergency department. All 111 patients assessed as receiving adequate process had positive outcomes. Twenty-six charts (19 per cent) were determined to have inadequate process, having failed at least one relevant and critical criterion; 23 of these 20 patients had positive outcomes. Review of the unmet criteria in these 23 charts revealed their uncertain predictive validity regarding immediate risk of death. We conclude that the Criteria Mapping method—the first reported technique for evaluating care for patient problems (as opposed to diagnoses)—provides an effective and feasible means for assessing the quality of symptom investigation and management.

Effect of Cardiologist ECG Review on Emergency Department Practice

STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine the effect of cardiology review of ECGs on emergency department practice. METHODS We carried out a prospective cohort study at an urban teaching ED. Our subjects were adult patients undergoing electrocardiography. We prospectively collected 1,000 consecutive ECGs and classified them by severity according to the following system: class 1, normal or minor abnormalities only; class 2, abnormalities with potential to alter case management; and class 3, potentially life-threatening abnormalities. Actual ECG readings by ED physicians (who had access to computerized interpretations at the time of treatment) were compared with those of staff cardiology quality-assurance reviewers; if they were not in agreement, an expert cardiology panel blindly chose the superior interpretation. Subsequently, an expert emergency physician panel reviewed discordant readings for discharged patients to determine the need for further action. RESULTS Of 1,000 ECGs, the readings for 190 (19%) were significantly discordant. The expert cardiology panel preferred the ED reading in 72 cases (38%) and the staff cardiology reading in 118 (62%). In 30 other cases no ED reading was recorded in the medical record. Of the 148 cases in which the expert cardiology panel agreed with the cardiology reading or there was no ED reading, 102 patients were admitted and 46 discharged. Of the 46 discharges, 8 cardiology readings were categorized as class 1, leaving only 38 cases in which the staff cardiology reading might have affected the ED decision to discharge a patient. All of these readings were in class 2, with the exception of one unclassifiable diagnosis. There were no class 3 readings. On expert emergency physician panel review of these 38 ECGs and interpretations, only 8 (.8%, 95% confidence interval, .3% to 1.6%) were considered sufficiently important to warrant chart review. In actual practice, none of these cases was affected by the ECG quality-assurance (QA) process. Two of these patients died during our 1-year follow-up. In one of these cases, the ECG QA process could have altered the patients outcome. CONCLUSION The existing ECG review process as mandated by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO) will likely have minimal influence on patient outcomes at our institution. We should establish the effectiveness of this mandated QA process before committing scarce resources to its performance.

Failure to Agree on the Electrocardiographic Diagnosis of Ventricular Tachycardia

STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine the extent of interobserver agreement in the ECG diagnosis of ventricular tachycardia (VT) by using a four-step algorithm and three observers. METHODS Simulated emergency department setting from records of an urban university teaching hospital. All ECGs taken in the ED during a 2-year period that showed a QRS duration of more than 120 msec and a heart rate faster than 110 beats per minute were reviewed. ECGs were categorized as demonstrating sinus rhythm (SR), irregular broad-complex tachycardia (I-BCT), or regular broad-complex tachycardia (BCT). Copies of the BCT ECGs and short clinical histories were given to each of three emergency physicians, who used a published, four-step algorithm (the Brugada algorithm) to categorize the BCT ECGs as indicating VT, indicating supraventricular tachycardia with aberrancy (SVT-A), or indeterminate. Interobserver agreement was assessed with the K-statistic. RESULTS The records contained 178 ECGs, 88 of which were SR, 63 I-BCT, and 27 BCT. The 27 BCT ECGs were selected for review. The emergency physicians disagreed with each other 22% of the time in differentiating VT from SVT-A (K = .58). CONCLUSION Application of the algorithm to actual clinical practice in the ED would probably result in the misdiagnosis of a substantial minority of patients having BCT, with potentially serious adverse consequences.

How (un)useful is the pelvic ring stability examination in diagnosing mechanically unstable pelvic fractures in blunt trauma patients

OBJECTIVES Our goal was to evaluate the utility of the pelvic ring stability examination for detection of mechanically unstable pelvic fractures in blunt trauma patients. METHODS Retrospective chart review. RESULTS We enrolled 1,502 consecutive blunt trauma patients and found 115 patients with pelvic fractures including 34 patients with unstable pelvic fractures (Tile classification B and C). Unstable pelvic ring on physical examination had a sensitivity and specificity of 8% (95% CI 4-14) and 99% (95% CI 99-100), respectively, for detection of any pelvic fracture and 26% (95% CI 15-43) and 99.9% (95% 99-100), respectively, for detection of mechanically unstable pelvic fractures. The sensitivity and specificity of pelvic pain or tenderness in patients with Glasgow Coma Scale >13 were 74% (95% CI 64-82) and 97% (95% CI 96-98), respectively for diagnosing any pelvic fractures, and 100% (95% CI 85-100) and 93% (95% CI 92-95), respectively for diagnosing of mechanically unstable pelvic fractures. The sensitivity and specificity of the presence of pelvic deformity were 30% (95% CI 22-39) and 98% (95% CI 98-99), respectively for detection of any pelvic fracture and 55% (95% CI 38-70) and 97% (95% CI 96-98), respectively for detection of mechanically unstable pelvic fractures. CONCLUSIONS The presence of either pelvic deformity or unstable pelvic ring on physical examination has poor sensitivity for detection of mechanically unstable pelvic fractures in blunt trauma patients. Our study suggests that blunt trauma patients with Glasgow Coma Scale >13 and without pelvic pain or tenderness are unlikely to suffer an unstable pelvic fracture. A prospective study is needed to determine whether a set of clinical criteria can safely detect or exclude the presence of an unstable pelvic fracture.

Lack of evidence to support routine digital rectal examination in pediatric trauma patients.

Background: Current advanced trauma life support guidelines recommend that a digital rectal examination (DRE) should be performed as part of the initial evaluation of all trauma patients. Our primary goal was to estimate the test characteristics of the DRE in pediatric patients for the following injuries: (1) spinal cord injuries, (2) bowel injuries, (3) rectal injuries, (4) pelvic fractures, and (5) urethral disruptions. Methods: We conducted a nonconcurrent, observational, chart review study of a consecutive series of pediatric trauma patients. We enrolled all patients younger than 18 years seen in our ED from January 2003 to February 2005, for whom the trauma team was activated and who had a documented DRE. For each patient, we reviewed all available clinical documents in a computerized medical record system to identify the DRE findings followed by review of radiological reports, operative reports, and discharge summaries to identify specific injuries. Results: Two hundred thirteen patients met our selection criteria and were included in the analysis. We identified 3 patients with spinal cord injury (1% prevalence), 13 patients with bowel injury (6%), 5 patients with rectal injury (2%), 12 patients with a pelvic fracture (6%), and 1 patient with urethral disruption (0.5%). The DRE failed to diagnose (false-negative rate) 66% of spinal cord injuries, 100% of bowel injuries, 100% of rectal wall injuries, 100% of pelvic fractures, and 100% of urethral disruption injuries. Conclusions: The DRE has poor sensitivity for the diagnosis of spinal cord, bowel, rectal, bony pelvis, and urethral injuries. Our findings suggest that the DRE should not be routinely used in pediatric trauma patients.

Results of a 4-Hour Endotracheal Intubation Class for EMT-Basics

STUDY OBJECTIVE In 1994, the Department of Transportation made endotracheal intubation an optional EMT-Basic skill. To data, there have been no studies addressing the ability of this group to learn or perform this skill. We used a standarized mannequin test to perform a prospective evaluation of this intubation skills of basic EMTs immediately after a 4-hour course on endotracheal intubation. We hypothesized that the intubation success rates would be comparable with those of other types of providers newly trained in this skill. METHODS Eighty-three EMTS were selected/recruited from four EMS provider agencies. Ninety-six percent of the EMTs were men, and the average age was 38 years; average length of EMT experience was 9.4 years. Training was provided in classes of 6 to 14 persons and included 1 hour of didactic instruction, a 1-hour demonstration of intubation techniques, and 90 minutes of supervised practice with the mannequins in groups of 2 to 4 persons. Testing followed American Heart Association guidelines. Interrater reliability of test criteria was assessed. RESULTS Ninety-four percent (95% confidence interval 86% to 98%) of the EMTs passed the examination by intubating the mannequin within 35 seconds within 3 attempts. Of the successful EMTs, 94% succeeded on their first attempt, 3% on their second attempt, and 3% on their third. There were three esophageal intubations; all were detected immediately. Interrater agreement was 100% on the pass/fail decision. CONCLUSION This 4-hour class trained basic EMTs to perform endotracheal intubation on mannequins with a success rate of 94%. Further research should confirm the ability of EMT-Basics to detect esophageal intubation and address the retention of intubation skills, the applicability of these skills to the field, and the components of this course that were responsible for its success.