Martin Welch

Quorum Sensing in Gram-Negative Bacteria: Small-Molecule Modulation of AHL and AI-2 Quorum Sensing Pathways

Numerous species of bacteria employ a mechanism of intercellular communication known as quorum sensing. This signaling process allows the cells comprising a bacterial colony to coordinate their gene expression in a cell-density dependent manner.1-3 Quorum sensing is mediated by small diffusible molecules termed autoinducers that are synthesized intracellularly (throughout the growth of the bacteria) and released into the surrounding milieu. As the number of cells in a bacterial colony increases, so does the extracellular concentration of the autoinducer. Once a threshold concentration is reached (at which point the population is considered to be “quorate”), productive binding of the autoinducer to cognate receptors within the bacterial cells occurs, triggering a signal transduction cascade that results in population-wide changes in gene expression.4-6 Thus, quorum sensing enables the cells within a bacterial colony to act cooperatively, facilitating population-dependent adaptive behavior.6 Quorum sensing has been shown to play a critical role in both pathogenic and symbiotic bacteria-host interactions.5 In symbionts, significant quorum sensing phenotypes include bioluminescence and root nodulation.7-11 Several clinically relevant pathogens use quorum sensing systems to regulate processes associated with virulence; this enhances the survival prospects of the bacteria because a coordinated attack on the host is only made when the bacterial population reaches a high population density, increasing the likelihood that the hosts defenses will be successfully overwhelmed.12,13 For example, in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, quorum sensing is involved in the formation of biofilms and their tolerance to antimicrobial agents14-17 and the innate host immune * To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: +44 (0)1223 336498. Fax: +44 (0)1223 336362. E-mail: spring@ch.cam.ac.uk. † Department of Chemistry. ‡ Department of Biochemistry. Chem. Rev. 2011, 111, 28–67 28

N‐acyl homoserine lactone binding to the CarR receptor determines quorum‐sensing specificity in Erwinia

Quorum sensing via an N‐acyl homoserine lactone (HSL) pheromone controls the biosynthesis of a carbapenem antibiotic in Erwinia carotovora. Transcription of the carbapenem biosynthetic genes is dependent on the LuxR‐type activator protein, CarR. Equilibrium binding of a range of HSL molecules, which are thought to activate CarR to bind to its DNA target sequence, was examined using fluorescence quenching, DNA bandshift analysis, limited proteolysis and reporter gene assays. CarR bound the most physiologically relevant ligand, N‐(3‐oxohexanoyl)‐L‐homoserine lactone, with a stoichiometry of two molecules of ligand per dimer of protein and a dissociation constant of 1.8 μM, in good agreement with the concentration of HSL required to activate carbapenem production in vivo. In the presence of HSL, CarR formed a very high molecular weight complex with its target DNA, indicating that the ligand causes the protein to multimerize. Chemical cross‐linking analysis supported this interpretation. Our data show that the ability of a given HSL to facilitate CarR binding to its target DNA sequence is directly proportional to the affinity of the HSL for the protein.

Combating Multidrug‐Resistant Bacteria: Current Strategies for the Discovery of Novel Antibacterials

The introduction of effective antibacterial therapies for infectious diseases in the mid-20th century completely revolutionized clinical practices and helped to facilitate the development of modern medicine. Many potentially life-threatening conditions became easily curable, greatly reducing the incidence of death or disability resulting from bacterial infections. This overwhelming historical success makes it very difficult to imagine life without effective antibacterials; however, the inexorable rise of antibiotic resistance has made this a very real and disturbing possibility for some infections. The ruthless selection for resistant bacteria, coupled with insufficient investment in antibacterial research, has led to a steady decline in the efficacy of existing therapies and a paucity of novel structural classes with which to replace them, or complement their use. This situation has resulted in a very pressing need for the discovery of novel antibiotics and treatment strategies, the development of which is likely to be a key challenge to 21st century medicinal chemistry.

Anti-MRSA Agent Discovery Using Diversity-Oriented Synthesis†

Antibacterial drugs have played an essential role in the global increase in quality of life and life expectancy. However, these gains are at serious risk owing to bacterial drug resistance by so-called “superbugs”, such as methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). The discovery of new antibiotics with novel modes of action is vital to tackle the threat of multidrug-resistant bacteria. Traditionally, antibiotics have been discovered from natural sources; however, there are many disadvantages to using extracts (e.g. limited availability, bioactive constituent identification, and complex analogue synthesis). These problems have led to a complementary approach of synthesizing structurally diverse, natural-product-like small molecules directly and efficiently, an approach known as diversity-oriented synthesis (DOS). Whereas compound collections of a common scaffold decorated with diverse building blocks have been synthesized efficiently, there are limited examples of the synthesis of small molecules with a high degree of skeletal diversity (usually by a build–couple–pair strategy). Previously, we have used a diazoacetate starting unit to mimic nature8s divergent synthetic strategy with acetyl CoA (by a pluripotent functional-group strategy) to synthesize compounds with natural-product scaffolds (e.g. cocaine and warfarin). Herein, we report the use of a solid-supported phosphonate unit to synthesize 242 drug-like compounds based on 18 natural-product-like scaffolds in two to five steps and their use in discovering a new structural class of antibiotic with anti-MRSA activity. The solid-supported phosphonate 1 (Scheme 1) was identified as an attractive DOS starting unit for three key reasons. First, the reactive phosphonate functionality permits the stereoselective formation of a,b-unsaturated acyl imidazolidinones (2) that could be used to generate enantioselectively a wide range of scaffolds that can be diversified further. Second, the imidazolidinone linker not only enables twopoint binding of chiral catalysts but also permits divergent cleavage of the exocyclic acyl group (hydrolysis, reduction, esterification, and amide formation). Thirdly, immobilization of 1 on a silyl polystyrene support simplified reaction optimization and work-up procedures in the multistep parallel synthesis (total of over 1000 individual steps), thereby allowing the efficient production of milligram quantities of 242 compounds without the requirement for automation equipment. In the first step of the diversity-oriented synthesis, 1 was treated with aldehyde building blocks (aryl, heteroaryl, and alkyl; see the Supporting Information) to deliver twelve a,bunsaturated acyl imidazolidinones (2). The second steps of the solid-supported synthesis exploited three catalytic, enantioselective, divergent reaction pathways (Scheme 1): 1) [2+3] cycloaddition (reaction b, ee 60–65%, de 7899%), 2) dihydroxylation (reaction c, ee 88–91%), and 3) [4+2] cycloaddition (reaction d, ee 89–98%, de 74– 74%). Similar selectivities were observed when repeating the reactions in solution with a triisopropylsilyl-protected linker (as opposed to the diisopropylpolystyrene group; see the Supporting Information). The reactions were also conducted with achiral catalysts to give racemic products, which were used for the later steps of the synthesis. This procedure enabled the diversity-oriented synthesis to be streamlined to half the size, yet permitted the enantioselective synthesis of hits during the structure–activity relationship stages of this [*] Dr. G. L. Thomas, R. J. Spandl, F. G. Glansdorp, Dr. M. Ladlow, Dr. D. R. Spring Department of Chemistry, University of Cambridge Lensfield Road, Cambridge, CB2 1EW (UK) Fax: (+44) 1223-336362 E-mail: drspring@ch.cam.ac.uk Homepage: http://www-spring.ch.cam.ac.uk/

Applications of small molecule activators and inhibitors of quorum sensing in Gram-negative bacteria

Quorum sensing is a form of intercellular communication used by many species of bacteria that facilitates concerted interactions between the cells comprising a population. The phenotypes regulated by quorum sensing are extremely diverse, with many having a significant impact upon healthcare, agriculture, and the environment. Consequently there has been significant interest in developing methods to manipulate this signalling process and recent years have witnessed significant theoretical and practical developments. A wide range of small molecule modulators of quorum sensing systems has been discovered, providing an expansive chemical toolbox for the study and modulation of this signalling mechanism. In this review, a selection of recent case studies which illustrate the value of both activators and inhibitors of quorum sensing in Gram-negative bacteria are discussed.

Interrelationships between Colonies, Biofilms, and Planktonic Cells of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is a gram-negative bacterium and an opportunistic human pathogen that causes chronic infections in immunocompromised individuals. These infections are hard to treat, partly due to the high intrinsic resistance of the bacterium to clinically used antibiotics and partly due to the formation of antibiotic-tolerant biofilms. The three most common ways of growing bacteria in vitro are as planktonic cultures, colonies on agar plates, and biofilms in continuous-flow systems. Biofilms are known to express genes different from those of planktonic cells, and biofilm cells are generally believed to closely resemble planktonic cells in stationary phase. However, few, if any, studies have examined global gene expression in colonies. We used a proteomic approach to investigate the interrelationships between planktonic cells, colonies, and biofilms under comparable conditions. Our results show that protein profiles in colonies resemble those of planktonic cells. Furthermore, contrary to what has been reported previously, the protein profiles of biofilms were found to more closely resemble those of exponentially growing planktonic cells than those of planktonic cells in the stationary phase. These findings raise some intriguing questions about the true nature of biofilms.

Diversity-oriented synthesis of macrocyclic peptidomimetics

Structurally diverse libraries of novel small molecules represent important sources of biologically active agents. In this paper we report the development of a diversity-oriented synthesis strategy for the generation of diverse small molecules based around a common macrocyclic peptidomimetic framework, containing structural motifs present in many naturally occurring bioactive compounds. Macrocyclic peptidomimetics are largely underrepresented in current small-molecule screening collections owing primarily to synthetic intractability; thus novel molecules based around these structures represent targets of significant interest, both from a biological and a synthetic perspective. In a proof-of-concept study, the synthesis of a library of 14 such compounds was achieved. Analysis of chemical space coverage confirmed that the compound structures indeed occupy underrepresented areas of chemistry in screening collections. Crucial to the success of this approach was the development of novel methodologies for the macrocyclic ring closure of chiral α-azido acids and for the synthesis of diketopiperazines using solid-supported N methylmorpholine. Owing to their robust and flexible natures, it is envisaged that both new methodologies will prove to be valuable in a wider synthetic context.

Synthesis and stability of small molecule probes for Pseudomonas aeruginosa quorum sensing modulation

The human pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa uses N-butyryl-L-homoserine lactone (BHL) and N-(3-oxododecanyl)-L-homoserine lactone (OdDHL) as small molecule intercellular signals in a phenomenon known as quorum sensing (QS). QS modulators are effective at attenuating P. aeruginosa virulence; therefore, they are a potential new class of antibacterial agent. The lactone in BHL and OdDHL is hydrolysed under physiological conditions. The hydrolysis proceeds at a rate faster than racemisation of the alpha-chiral centre. Non-hydrolysable, non-racemic analogues (small molecule probes) were designed and synthesised, replacing the lactone with a ketone. OdDHL analogues were found to be relatively unstable to decomposition unless they were difluorinated between the beta-keto amide. Stability studies on a non-hydrolysable, cyclohexanone analogue indicated that racemisation of the alpha-chiral centre was relatively slow. This analogue was assayed to show that the L-isomer is likely to be responsible for the QS autoinducing activity in P. aeruginosa and Serratia strain ATCC39006.

Bacterial and mammalian cell response to poly(3-sulfopropyl methacrylate) brushes loaded with silver halide salts

This study investigates the antibacterial and cytotoxic effect of surfaces with sulphonate brushes containing silver salts. By using the same type of samples for both cytotoxicity and antibacterial studies, these two parameters could be compared in a controlled way. The silver was incorporated into the brush in four different forms to enable release of silver ions at different concentrations and different rates. It was found that although the surfaces displayed very good antibacterial properties in buffer solutions, this effect disappeared in systems with high protein content. Similarly, the silver-containing surfaces displayed cytotoxic effects in the absence of serum proteins but this effect was reduced in the presence of serum. The speciation of silver in the different solutions is discussed. Cytotoxic and antibacterial effects are compared at the different silver concentrations released. The implications of a concentration range where silver could be used to kill bacterial without harmful effects on mammalian cells are also discussed and questioned.

Carbapenem antibiotic biosynthesis in Erwinia carotovora is regulated by physiological and genetic factors modulating the quorum sensing-dependent control pathway

Erwinia carotovora produces the β‐lactam antibiotic, carbapenem, in response to a quorum sensing signalling molecule, N‐(3‐oxohexanoyl)‐ l‐homoserine lactone (OHHL). We have mapped the OHHL‐dependent promoter upstream of the first of the biosynthetic genes, carA. We have also analysed the effect on this promoter of the known genetic regulators of carbapenem expression, carR, carI (encoding homologues of LuxR and LuxI respectively) and hor (encoding a SlyA/MarR‐like transcriptional regulator). We describe a previously unknown promoter located within the carA‐H operon. This promoter does not respond to CarR and is required for quorum sensing‐independent expression of the carbapenem resistance determinants encoded by the carFG genes. We have mapped the carR, carI and hor transcription start points, shown that CarR is positively autoregulated in the presence of OHHL, and have demonstrated negative feedback affecting transcription of carI. In addition, various environmental  and physiological factors were shown to impinge on the transcription of the car biosynthetic genes. The nature of the carbon source and the temperature of growth influence carbapenem production by modulating the level of the OHHL signalling molecule, and thereby physiologically fine‐tune the quorum sensing regulatory system.