Martina Nilsson

Quantification of mtDNA mixtures in forensic evidence material using pyrosequencing

Analysis of mtDNA variation using Sanger sequencing does not allow accurate quantification of the components of mtDNA mixtures. An alternative method to determine the specific mixture ratios in samples displaying heteroplasmy, consisting of DNA contributions from several individuals, or containing contamination would therefore be valuable. A novel quantification system for mtDNA mixture analysis has been developed based on pyrosequencing technology, in which the linear relationship between incorporated nucleotides and released light allows quantification of the components of a sample. Within five polymerase chain reaction fragments, seven variable positions in the mtDNA control and coding region were evaluated using this quantification analysis. For all single nucleotide polymorphisms quantified in this study, a linear relationship was observed between the measured and expected mixture ratios. This mtDNA quantification assay is an easy to use, fast and accurate quantification system, with the ability to resolve and interpret major and minor mtDNA components in forensic mixture samples.

Forensic Casework Analysis Using the HVI/HVII mtDNA Linear Array Assay

The mitochondrial hypervariable regions I and II have proven to be a useful target for analysis of forensic materials, in which the amount of DNA is limited or highly degraded. Conventional mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequencing can be time-consuming and expensive, limitations that can be minimized using a faster and less expensive typing assay. We have evaluated the exclusion capacity of the linear array mtDNA HVI/HVII region-sequence typing assay (Roche Applied Science) in 16 forensic cases comprising 90 samples. Using the HVI/HVII mtDNA linear array, 56% of the samples were excluded and thus less than half of the samples require further sequencing due to a match or inconclusive results. Of all the samples that were excluded by sequence analysis, 79% could be excluded using the HVI/HVII linear array alone. Using the HVI/HVII mtDNA linear array assay, we demonstrate the potential to decrease sequencing efforts substantially and thereby reduce the cost and the turn-around time in casework analysis.

Forensic mitochondrial coding region analysis for increased discrimination using pyrosequencing technology.

Analysis of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is very useful when nuclear DNA analysis fails due to degradation or insufficient amounts of DNA in forensic analysis. However, mtDNA analysis has a lower discrimination power compared to what can be obtained by nuclear DNA (nDNA) analysis, potentially resulting in multiple individuals showing identical mtDNA types in the HVI/HVII region. In this study, the increase in discrimination by analysis of mitochondrial coding regions has been evaluated for identical or similar HVI/HVII sequences. A pyrosequencing-based system for coding region analysis, comprising 17 pyrosequencing reactions performed on 15 PCR fragments, was utilised. This assay was evaluated in 135 samples, resulting in an average read length of 81 nucleotides in the pyrosequencing analysis. In the sample set, a total of 52 coding region SNPs were identified, of which 18 were singletons. In a group of 60 samples with 0 or 1 control region difference from the revised Cambridge reference sequence (rCRS), only 12 samples could not be resolved by at least two differences using the pyrosequencing assay. Thus, the use of this pyrosequencing-based coding region assay has the potential to substantially increase the discriminatory power of mtDNA analysis.

Evaluation of mitochondrial DNA coding region assays for increased discrimination in forensic analysis

There is an increasing trend to use mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analysis in criminal investigations where only limited amounts of DNA are available. However, analysis of the mtDNA control region has the drawback of low discrimination power, due to the lack of recombination that results from uniparental (maternal) inheritance. As a strategy to increase discrimination, a number of typing assays detecting variation in the mitochondrial coding region have been developed. In this study, several of these assays are evaluated for their discriminatory capacity using data obtained from 495 complete Caucasian mtDNA sequences. In order to add a local geographic perspective to this evaluation, we have also sequenced and analysed the entire mtDNA from 20 individuals of Swedish origin. We find that the coding region assays are very useful for resolving sequences with identical HVI/HVII regions. The best-performing coding region assay was able to discriminate 46% of the resolvable sequences, compared to 20-30% for the other coding region assays we evaluated.

Analysis of the Putative Remains of a European Patron Saint–St. Birgitta

Saint Birgitta (Saint Bridget of Sweden) lived between 1303 and 1373 and was designated one of Europes six patron saints by the Pope in 1999. According to legend, the skulls of St. Birgitta and her daughter Katarina are maintained in a relic shrine in Vadstena abbey, mid Sweden. The origin of the two skulls was assessed first by analysis of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) to confirm a maternal relationship. The results of this analysis displayed several differences between the two individuals, thus supporting an interpretation of the two skulls not being individuals that are maternally related. Because the efficiency of PCR amplification and quantity of DNA suggested a different amount of degradation and possibly a very different age for each of the skulls, an orthogonal procedure, radiocarbon dating, was performed. The radiocarbon dating results suggest an age difference of at least 200 years and neither of the dating results coincides with the period St. Birgitta or her daughter Katarina lived. The relic, thought to originate from St. Birgitta, has an age corresponding to the 13th century (1215–1270 cal AD, 2σ confidence), which is older than expected. Thus, the two different analyses are consistent in questioning the authenticity of either of the human skulls maintained in the Vadstena relic shrine being that of St. Birgitta. Of course there are limitations when interpreting the data of any ancient biological materials and these must be considered for a final decision on the authenticity of the remains.

Sequencing of mtDNA in Shed Hairs: A Retrospective Analysis of Material from Forensic Cases and a Pre-Screening Method

In crime scene investigations, shed hairs are one of the most frequently found types of biological evidence material. DNA analysis of hair can be of great significance in forensic investigations, and the sequencing of the hypervariable regions I (HVI) and II (HVII) of the mitochondrial genome has become a useful tool in this field. This paper describes a retrospective evaluation of the potential of sequence analysis of mitochondrial DNA. We examined evidentiary hair and reference samples obtained from 25 criminal investigations conducted over a ten year period and determined the number of matches and exclusions between samples in the investigation. In total, the study includes the results of 129 samples obtained between 1999 and 2008. Analysis resulted in high quality sequence data from most of the evidentiary hairs, allowing comparison to reference samples. On the basis of matches between mitochondrial DNA sequences from evidentiary hairs and those from reference samples, inclusions were obtained in 16 of the 25 cases (64%). Thus, sequencing of mitochondrial DNA was informative in many cases in this data set. In addition, we conducted an initial evaluation of a strategy for estimating the mitochondrial DNA and nuclear DNA contents of plucked and shed hair samples. The strategy is based on staining both the nuclear DNA and the mitochondria, and may be useful when trying to identify an optimal DNA profiling approach for a given hair sample.

Comparison of DNA polymerases for improved forensic analysis of challenging samples

Inhibitors of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification often present a challenge in forensic investigations of e.g., terrorism, missing persons, sexual assaults and other criminal cases. Such inhibitors may be counteracted by dilution of the DNA extract, using different additives, and selecting an inhibitory resistant DNA polymerase. Additionally, DNA in forensic samples is often present in limited amounts and degraded, requiring special analyses of short nuclear targets or mitochondrial DNA. The present study evaluated the enzymes AmpliTaq Gold, HotStarTaq Plus, KAPA3G Plant, and KAPA2G Robust, with regard to their ability to overcome inhibitory effects. Our data showed that diluting the extracts and adding bovine serum albumin may increase the yield of the PCR product. However, the largest impact was observed when alternative enzymes were utilized, instead of the commonly used AmpliTaq Gold. KAPA2G Robust presented the highest amplification efficiency in the presence of the inhibitor ammonium nitrate. Moreover, the KAPA3G Plant enzyme had the highest efficiency in amplifying degraded DNA from old buried bone material. KAPA3G Plant and KAPA2G Robust may thus be useful for counteracting inhibitors and improving the analysis of challenging samples.

Analysis of Mitochondrial DNA from a Burned, Ninhydrin‐Treated Paper Towel

Contact‐based evidence is likely to have limited quantities of DNA and may yield mixed profiles due to preexisting or contaminating DNA. In a recent arson investigation, a paper towel was collected and used as circumstantial evidence. The paper towel was partially burned and was likely set on fire with flammable liquid. As part of the investigation, the paper towel was treated with ninhydrin to visualize fingerprint evidence. Initial DNA analysis of two swabs was negative for short tandem repeat (STR) markers and revealed a mixture of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Analysis of 13 additional cuttings yielded four more mixed profiles, but also two samples with a common single‐source profile. The single‐source mtDNA profile matched that of the primary suspect in the case. Thus, even if initial mtDNA analysis yields a mixed profile, a sampling strategy involving multiple locations can improve the chance of obtaining valuable single‐source mtDNA profiles from compromised evidence in criminal casework.